6 ms·
Bananas Don't Taste Like They Used To. Here's Why
- bhjgjy 2y ago[flagged]
- onychomys 2y agoTitle of this entry needs a (2023) after it.
- PhasmaFelis 2y agoI doubt bananas have changed much in the last 15 months.
- financetechbro 2y agoYou can never be too sure.
- timetraveller26 2y agoWhat has js done
- DoctorDabadedoo 2y agoNothing, but buckle up, we need to refactor our stack again.
- adamredwoods 2y agoI'm eager to try blue bananas! I hear they are great.
- Propelloni 2y agoYou mean this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Banana https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Banana I kid, I kid.
- fuzztester 2y agoalmost exactly opposite in a geographical sense, is the Rub' al Khali (The Empty Quarter): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rub%27_al_Khali https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rub%27_al_Khali i don't kid. it's huge, and mainly empty. I first read about it in an English children's novel about Arabia, as a kid.
- Propelloni 2y agoAmazing! Thank you for the link.
- fuzztester 2y agoDe nada. Punno intendedo. ;)
- simonblack 2y agohttps://archive.is/THgjP https://archive.is/THgjP
- simonblack 2y agoI recently bought a batch of six bananas from a local farmer's market - they were very fresh and very green and smaller, having just been picked. I let them ripen at home over the next 3 days. They tasted very much better than my usual rather tasteless supermarket-bought bananas. I'm going to try the exercise again tomorrow to check whether this was a one-off or not. After reading the article, I'm going to check with the grower whether or not these were Cavendish bananas which are the norm around this banana-growing area, or something else.
- christkv 2y agoMight be dwarf Cavendish which is what they grow on the Canary Islands in Spain. It's abut 1/2 the size of the full Cavendish and to me taste slightly better.
- simonblack 2y agoWent back to the market this morning: Those bananas were dwarf Cavendish. And the farmer said " .. and we don't treat them with (ethylene) gas."
- fuzztester 2y agoit is not a one-off. this is commonly done in India. in fact people even put a branch of bananas into a steel storage drum full of raw rice to help them to ripen. I don't know the science behind it.
- simonblack 2y agoRipening fruit/veges give off ethylene oxide which causes further ripening. If you trap that ethylene oxide by putting the fruit or veges in a closed plastic bag, they will ripen even faster. Here in the tropics fruit ripens very quickly (chemical reactions proceed faster with increased temperature). I try to slow that down by keeping the stuff cold in the fridge. (But the fridge traps the EtO anyway!)
- 2y ago
- ramonreyes 2y ago[flagged]
- kombookcha 2y agoI have been very curious to try a Gros Michel after learning that the common artifical banana flavor is supposed to taste like them, not like the post-Panama Disease bananas. I wonder how it is that we keep using this heirloom banana flavoring even after everyone's assumptions about what a proper banana tastes like changed.
- mentalfist 2y agoDeveloping new artificial flavors is very expensive, is the explanation I've heard.
- upon_drumhead 2y agoI fell in love with Apple Bananas in Hawaii. Highly recommend. https://hawaiiancrown.com/apple-bananas/ https://hawaiiancrown.com/apple-bananas/
- actionfromafar 2y agoI'm afraid I will love Hawaii itself too much if I go there to visit. :)
- fuzztester 2y agothat Hotel Hawaii song ... "you can never leave" :) https://genius.com/Eagles-hotel-california-lyrics https://genius.com/Eagles-hotel-california-lyrics
- fuzztester 2y agomy god, the number of insane downvoters on hn. they even downvote you for an innocuous comment like mine above. I can only guess that they are losers or haters or retards or are hurting heavily for some reason, so they feel the need to strike out blindly, to get some kind of pathetic relief from whatever it is that they are hurting from. it could be job loss, or lack of money, no SO, etc. See Maslow.
- AlexeyBelov 2y agoI think you're way out of line. It's you who appears deranged over some downvotes. Why are you reaching so far into the "why" and assigning those users very strange and hurtful characteristics? "Insane", "retards", "haters", "no money and no love in their life". Are you sure the reasons can't be simpler? What do the HN guidelines say on the topic? PS: I don't have the ability to downvote anything in case you think I'm your mortal enemy / hater / retard.
- fuzztester 2y agohmm. maybe you're right. it's just that it seems to me that is senseless of these people to downvote comments for what seems like no good reason at all. and like I said somewhere else here recently, why can't they make a reply comment, saying what they think is wrong with my comment, if they disagree - as you just did. I can't tell, by a downvote, whether they just disapprove, or actually disagree. and if they disagree, it would be helpful if they said why. downvoting seems like the lazy option in the case of disagreement. but yes, you really cannot change people. either they have some good reason for doing it, which I don't understand, or they just are that way. anyway I am getting tired of doing it, so maybe I'll take your advice and just ignore it from now on. thanks for your feedback.
- pengaru 2y agoPSA: unripe bananas are medicinal, if you struggle with a "sensitive GI tract" I highly recommend trying to eat an at least slightly green banana every morning.
- amelius 2y ago> Unripe bananas contain mostly starch, which makes up 70–80% of their dry weight. Much of that starch is resistant starch, which is not digested in the small intestine. For that reason, it's often classified as dietary fiber. However, bananas lose their starch as they ripen. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/green-bananas-good-or-bad https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/green-bananas-good-or-b...
- seafoamteal 2y agoSouth India has a pretty diverse collection of banana species, even from my limited experience. You have red bananas; plantains; and these very small (some are about the length of a finger) and delicate yellow bananas known locally as Yelakki, among others.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thisislife2 2y agoAt This Banana Farm, the Bunches Grow in 430 Shapes and Sizes - https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/how-many-kinds-bananas-are-there https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/how-many-kinds-bananas...
- fuzztester 2y agothe small one you mention may be what is called karpooravalli in Tamil. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-English-name-for-the-Karpooravalli-banana https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-English-name-for-the-Karpo... commonly available in South India. then there is the hill banana, also small like the one above. grows in the Palani Hills in Western Tamil Nadu, at least. maybe in other hilly places too. it may be the same as the above one. not sure. one of the best banana varieties for flavour, not just sweetness, is the nendran or nendrapazham, grown in Kerala, and maybe in western Tamilnadu. it's slightly larger than, and looks different from, the common banana. the outer surface is somewhat ridged, like a ridge gourd. it can be eaten either raw or cooked. very different taste from the common banana. considered a delicacy. https://specialtyproduce.com/produce/Nendran_Bananas_23405.php https://specialtyproduce.com/produce/Nendran_Bananas_23405.p...
- lofaszvanitt 2y agoOh jesus this author also has the Tolstoy virus.
- thih9 2y agoThe title is click baity, here is the paragraph answering the question: > This is precisely what happened in the early to mid-20th century. Panama disease, a wilt-causing fungus, evolved to attack one Gros Michel banana tree. It was then able to infect all the Gros Michel banana trees which were planted in close quarters with one another on these massive banana plantations. Only by switching the crop to a new banana that American consumers would like [-Cavendish] —one that was similar to the Gros Michel in color and shape, but was genetically distinct from it—could the banana industry save itself from collapsing. In the process, though, we lost the better banana.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Aardwolf 2y agoThe Canary Islands produce some good bananas, they're a bit smaller but sweeter
- DonHopkins 2y agoIt's easy to underestimate the enormous magnitude of the worldwide problem of monocropping, but the banana helps illustrate the scale.
- Heston 2y agoThai bananas taste at least 3 times as good as regular Cavendish. A much stronger fruity flavor
- sersi 2y agoIf you ever try bananas from Philippines, the Latundan is great. In general, once you taste how good all the different bananas can be, you'll never want to just go back to the Cavendish which is mostly boring.
- rob74 2y agoI assume that bananas that ripen naturally also taste better than those picked green, shipped halfway across the world and then ripened in ripening chambers? I tried various bananas in South America, but not a naturally ripened Cavendish, so I can't say for sure, but I know that this is the case for tomatoes.
- YeGoblynQueenne 2y agoYeah, tomatoes only taste of tomato in the heart of summer, and even then you better be in a place that produces them rather than one that imports them. I'm guessing that's because tomatoes are fruit and fruit always tastes better when it's in season. For instance, I wonder if I've ever known the true taste of ripe mango. I have eaten plenty of mangoes, but I only ever eat them in the UK, where they're imported. I suspect that they taste very differently (as in much better) if you pick them from a tree in the right season. I bet South-East Asians in the UK must turn their noses up to the local mango supply, like I do with, well, most veg really.
- YeGoblynQueenne 2y ago>> Consumers these days expect year-round availability of a product, which is consistent every time a person buys it, eats it, and cooks with it. It's like a fairy tale witch cursed us all for our greed: you will have any food you like any time you like it, but it will taste bland and boring and you will long for a taste you have never known. That's why people get so protective of their food culture, even their food habits (like meat-eaters getting up in arms when they hear from vegans). It's because if we leave food completely at the hands of big food, we'll all end up eating food that it is just nutritious enough to keep us from starving and just good enough to eat to keep us from all going mad.
- noja 2y ago> Consumers these days expect year-round availability of a product, which is consistent every time a person buys it, eats it, and cooks with it. I am a consumer and do not expect year-round availability of fruit and vegetables.
- nakeru 2y ago"I don't fit in a generalisation therefore that generalisation is not true". At the same time, not sure we have the data to back up the original argument. Personal anecdata? People around do expect to find everything all year round, and they get mad if they don't.
- blueflow 2y ago"personal anecdata" or not, what he is saying is market demand. If you offer cavendish that taste like mashed potatoes, you won't see that persons money. Mine neither. Fact.
- outime 2y agoWhat are you supposed to say if you read a statement that includes you in a group you don't belong? That's why it's important to be more precise instead of saying "customers" in general.
- supermatt 2y agoAs an aside - Europes largest producer of bananas is... Iceland.
- tweetle_beetle 2y agoThe article doesn't go far enough back in time to flesh out quite how absurd the Cavendish story is as a tale of exploitation. After centuries of generational wealth transfer in the Cavendish family, it was developed by gardeners working for a Duke who was sent some as a gift from the recently invaded colony of Mauritius (the British overthrowing previous French colonists). They were grown in the middle of England in the largest greenhouse in the world (heated by 8 coal fired furnaces requiring so much fuel that a small railway was installed). It sat a few minutes walk from a house (one of 8 the Duke inherited), literally covered in gold so it would look nice during sunsets. The bananas won a horticultural prize in London and were then shipped off around the world - setting the scene for where the article picks up.
- oicu812 2y agoThe Freakonomics podcast [1] did a whole episode on this topic. It's one of the more fascinating episodes in my opinion, and I can't eat a banana now without thinking about the Gros Michel. [1] https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-most-interesting-fruit-in-the-world-ep-375/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-most-interesting-fruit-...