9 ms·
Can Universal Basic Income Transform Society?
- Rucadi 2y agoIt can transform the society into a poor one with shortage of goods.
- VHRanger 2y agoUBI can be mathematically equivalent to any other social welfare system. It's just a question of tax brackets and welfare brackets.
- tgv 2y agoThe term UBI then doesn't mean a guaranteed income, sufficient to live on.
- ghaff 2y agoThat's exactly what the proponents saying it would let people create art and other projects that they don't have time to do today argue for.
- user90131313 2y agoUBI makes 0 sense if one can calculate properly. Almost no nation can be able fund it with current debts they have. It brings cost of Trillions to budget, not possible with more crazy rich tax. It would make rich move. Exc. Norway, Qatar, UAE and maybe few small others. Only possible in these ones because their wealth funds are by far biggest in the world per citizen already.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoA fiscally balanced UBI is simply one where the average taxpayer receives the same amount of UBI as they pay in extra taxes. In the US the average taxpayer makes $40K, and currently pays $6K in taxes, for a net of $34K. If we add a $1K/month UBI, then under a balanced plan that taxpayer would make $52K and pay $18K in taxes for a net of $34K. That's a tax rate of 35% and is obviously feasible since there are lots of people & places with much higher rates. Similar calculations show that a UBI of $3K per month is not feasible. $1K/month won't cover rent in most of the US but it might be possible to live on it if you live in shared housing and eat nothing but rice & beans.
- al_borland 2y agoI don’t understand this. If everyone is getting taxed to the point where they only make $34k, this UBI solution would make everyone poor with no way to work harder, or learn more, to get ahead. This is how black markets to get paid under the table start to form. And if all the UBI is coming from the tax someone pays in, just lower taxes. It would have the same impact without all the extra overhead.
- bryanlarsen 2y ago> . If everyone is getting taxed to the point where they only make $34k Only the average taxpayer gets taxed that amount. It roughly means a 16% tax increase. Somebody making $1M a year would pay $160K extra and get $12K in UBI.
- al_borland 2y agoHow is everyone not worse off under this plan? They are being bled dry by taxes and tossed a couple nickels back as UBI. No one would vote for this. The only people who wouldn’t be worse off are people with no income to start with. I assume they’d get some base level $1k UBI. I think Andrew Yang had the right idea, in the limited amount I heard. Tax the cooperations that are using AI or automation to reduce the need for workers. Their costs are going down, while their profits stay high, so capture that and give it to the people who were displaced. Bleeding the middle class, and people in general, doesn’t make sense.
- spywaregorilla 2y agoThe "B" in UBI demands that the income be sufficient for basic needs and other social welfare systems observably do not provide that unconditionally.
- jltsiren 2y agoThe "B" means that UBI is a welfare system where everyone in the relevant population group receives the same basic income (at least in some technical sense), regardless of their other income. The "U" means that "everyone" gets it. People sometimes distinguish between full and partial basic income, depending on whether the basic income is sufficient to cover most people's basic needs.
- jncfhnb 2y agoDoes that really make sense to you? You’ve identified the connection between basic income and basic needs; and even identified that there’s full basic income and partial basic income; but you think that the “basic” in universal basic income is just a redundant qualifier of the “universal” bit? The B in universal basic income means everyone gets a basic income to cover their basic needs. Obviously.
- jltsiren 2y agoOf course it does. There have been many basic income proposals over the decades, some of them universal and some not. It does not make sense to assume that UBI refers to any specific model. In particular, there are some UBI proposals where the level of the basic income is intentionally too low to cover basic needs. Those proposals aim to dismantle the welfare traps that plague non-basic income models. Once your income grows high enough that you start losing welfare benefits, your effective marginal tax rate can be very high. Rates above 80% are common, and sometimes they rise above 100%.
- jncfhnb 2y agoUsing your logic then, what’s the difference between a universal income and a universal basic income? There doesn’t seem to be any. You seem to have confused yourself into thinking that since you could run a “universal partial basic income” scheme that the definition of the term UBI must refer to a general framework that can accommodate this. But that is semantically backwards. UBI is universal full basic income. Partial UBI is a different thing. It’s like saying you can do a 360 flip and then doing a “partial 360” where you turn 180 degrees. “Full basic” means it meets your basic needs. It means basic. Binary. “Partial Universal Basic Income” equates to “Universal Not Basic Income”.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoSo, it's just a question of Congress passing the right rules and not messing it up? That's not very reassuring...
- hellojesus 2y agoAll gov welfare leads to the conclusion of the GP.
- actionfromafar 2y agoAn objection I seldom see but I think is important to consider: wouldn't it take us that much closer to "bread and circuses" i.e. that the State can even more easily buy (quite literally) favours from a subdued population. In a way we are already there, but UBI would really short-circuit the loop.
- loudmax 2y agoThis is among the most frequent objections to UBI that I see. This is a legitimate concern, but we shouldn't blow it out of proportion. Just because there's a danger in pursuing a policy to it's logical extreme doesn't mean society shouldn't practice it in moderation.
- ziggyzecat 2y agojust make it conditional: 21 hours of study and/or social work/field work per week. - high school style tests, milestones and road maps to test study progress, good for citizen science but can be any subject, fugees start easy with the ABC - social work including agriculture & farms, where the first year or two can count towards apprenticeship if combined with studies solves low wages short-, mid-, long-term, increases buying power, creates jobs and tons of admin, org, bureaucracy work for those who dig it :) make it enough to afford rent and healthy food and some culture per week. in Germany, that would be 1350 - 1500 per month, which is covered already, but the conditions are nonsense and lax.
- criddell 2y agoWhat problem are you trying to solve with those conditions?
- ziggyzecat 2y ago- increase of brain power - smarter future voters - increasing participation in productive and constructive society - more voices and more discussion - eliminating the bias and discrimination against people who receive basic income - eliminating small scale opportunities to lazycheat - eliminate the continued rise of the currently too easily abused right leaning parts of the population - ... it will take time, of course
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- VHRanger 2y agoConditional social benefits are always a nightmare in practice. Look at the rules to qualify for that high school style test or prove that you actually achieve the milestone. Assume they will be implemented by the most incompetent of bureaucrats (eg. months to get an appointment, buggy Oracle software). Assume they will be implemented by the most nightmarish of your political opponents. Look for instance on rules for identification for voters in the southern USA. In theory that makes sense! In practice it's cynically implemented to systematically prevent certain demographics from voting. The main advantage of UBI in practice is that it's no questions asked. Anything else about it can be replicated by fiddling with tax and welfare bracket numbers.
- jakelazaroff 2y agoI feel like treating UBI as a panacea has actually hindered its adoption, giving critics plenty of ammunition in the form of implementations that don’t quite live up to their proponents’ loftiest ambitions. Can UBI transform society? Probably not! But why is that the bar? It can just be boring form of welfare that makes a lot of people’s lives easier. That’s still a good thing worth doing.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dgfitz 2y agoI don’t think anyone on welfare would say their lives are easy.
- micromacrofoot 2y ago*easier than not having it
- dimitrios1 2y agoActually, it's worse than that right now for many on welfare, as they face the "benefits cliff". Inflation is rampant and some low wage earners are getting modest increases to keep up with inflation, but this increase is subsequently pinching their benefits.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoso... if would be better for them if they never had those benefits how?
- dimitrios1 2y agoThis has been debated ad nasuem in America since at least the 60s. It depends on your philosophy both economic and political.
- freddealmeida 2y ago[flagged]
- incomingpain 2y ago[flagged]
- exabrial 2y ago[flagged]
- CalRobert 2y agoAnnoyingly, the basic income pilot described in this article is not universal, and only helps people who could already afford to be artists. I'm sure the people working behind the counter in your local chipper would've liked to avail of it but they don't qualify as working "artists". But being Ireland, I can't imagine they'd ever implement it without an enormous means test.
- slackfan 2y agoBetteridge's law of headlines strikes, per usual.
- throwaway22032 2y agoThe fundamental problem that I see with UBI is that it basically means that we are just paying people to be passive consumers of resources. It'll always be a hard sell as a result. People want their neighbours to pull their weight. Even if it's just sweeping the street, painting their fence, whatever. Paying people to sit about watching TV is never going to work.
- olalonde 2y agoIf it's just the bare minimum to survive (e.g. food + roof), there's still quite a lot of self-interested incentive to pull your weight. Of course, some people would be satisfied with the bare minimum but my guess is it wouldn't be a large percentage of the population.
- hellojesus 2y agoNot only do you steal from working people to give to tv watchers, you also structurally shift the market by forcing all jobs to pay more than the baseline minimum wage, which means that all would-be workers that cannot provide more than $x in value to an employer would never be hired. This tends to impact unskilled workers, who tend to need experience to increase the value they can offer employers.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoI think you have it backwards. Let's say somebody is making $1K/month from UBI. They might take a job that pays $1/hour because the difference between $1K/month and $1160/month is very significant. And there'd be no reason to stop jobs from paying $1/hour because everybody already gets UBI.
- exitb 2y agoThat's a quite horrible outcome though. It basically means that this persons income is paid by fellow workers who happened to be more fortunate, so that the business owner can have an almost free workforce.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoCan we just give everyone food, healthcare, and a place to live?
- newsclues 2y agoDo farmers just give away food? Do doctors give away healthcare? Do trade people who build houses do so for free?
- petesergeant 2y agoThe government provides many services already, and the cost of provision is not free, and they pay the providers of these things
- imgabe 2y agoThis is not limitless. The government gets money by collecting taxes. In order to collect taxes, there have to be people doing paid work to collect taxes from. If the government takes over doing all the things that people currently get paid to do by engaging in commerce, then where is the government going to collect taxes from? Without collecting taxes, how is the government going to compensate all the workers providing the free food and healthcare?
- micromacrofoot 2y agoThis is a bit of a naive perspective, the military is massive in the US and they contract with hundreds of private companies and create thousands of jobs. Rolling things into taxes and government services doesn't make jobs and money disappear. It's not a perfect system by any means, but there's no question of availability when it comes to national defense priorities... in fact there's a massive abundance and it feels like we sell arms to half the planet. We can do the same for healthcare.
- imgabe 2y agoIt goes from net revenue to net loss. If the government pays $100 billion in defense contracts they are necessarily collecting less than that in taxes from the employee income. Spending $100 billion to collect $30 billion in taxes is not sustainable. It's not naive, it's simple arithmetic. The money has to come from somewhere.
- olalonde 2y agoThe problem is getting political support for it. I'd be in favor of if it could be done without increasing government spending (aka by massively reducing/eliminating other government programs). Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to resonate well with progressive voters.
- RegnisGnaw 2y agoIt can't be done without massively increasing government spending, the numbers doesn't even add up.
- olalonde 2y agoIf you're thinking of a UBI that allows people to live a comfortable life without working, yeah that doesn't seem possible. But if you're thinking of a UBI that prevents homelessness and hunger, it seems possible. Let's say we set the bare minimum at 1000$ per month. That gives us 1000$ * 260,000,000 adults * 12 months ~= 3 trillion$ per year. That's around half of the federal government spending for 2023. I know 1000$ doesn't seem like a lot but if you live in a low density area with roommate(s) and eat a lot of rice[0], it's do-able. Of course, living in a costly area wouldn't be possible for people who solely survive on UBI. The UBI could even be upped to 1,500$ and still leave government with 1.5 trillion to spend. [0] https://efficiencyiseverything.com/calorie-per-dollar-list/ https://efficiencyiseverything.com/calorie-per-dollar-list/
- zoky 2y agoThe thing I’ve never understood about UBI is how it wouldn’t immediately be counteracted by inflation. Money is like water or electricity; its only ability to do work is when it flows. Just like a water wheel can’t do any work without a river flow, or a motor can’t do any work with a potential difference, money is useless when everyone always just has the same amount. It is only the transfer of money from one entity to another that causes work to be done. The difference between 9V and 12V is 3V. The difference between 12V and 15V is still 3V. The amount of work you can do is the same, but the bar to entry is higher. So somebody explain to me, when everyone gets the same baseline amount of money, how that does anything but raise the baseline?
- coreypreston 2y agoYou're cramming an analogy into your point. Systems like economy and people dont fit into an electrical diagram.
- zoky 2y agoAm I? I don’t think so. Please describe for me a situation where the simple possession of money, absent any potential for that money to flow, causes work to happen. If you can, you’ve described nothing less than perpetual motion.
- derdi 2y agoThe simple possession of money by a hungry person causes that money to flow by encouraging the person to spend the money on food. That causes work to happen at the food producers. Maybe even so much more work that they're willing to hire additional hungry people to do that work.
- fgdorais 2y agoUniversal Basic Water would be a great achievement!
- al_borland 2y agoI’ve had the same question. We saw this, to some degree with the stimulus checks during the pandemic. Initially people got all this money and reports were that savings rates had never been higher… but most of the world was also shut down. As things opened up, or people simply got bored at home, what did we see? People spent everything they were given, and more. Personal debt is now at an all time high, and we’ve seen a bunch of inflation (for various reasons). Most people are in a worse place now. Financial literacy is extremely important. Giving more money to people who don’t know how to handle money, allows them to dig bigger holes. That said, everyone’s investments and 401ks are reliant on this reckless spending to keep returns high.
- imgabe 2y ago> Today, as artificial intelligence (AI) learns from the collective intellectual and creative output of humans and uses this to dispossess workers of their livelihoods, Has anyone actually lost their job to AI yet? At best it helps some workers do their jobs faster as many innovations in the past have. Historically, this increases the amount of work expected to coincide with the capacity for doing work. For example, CAD software replaced hand drafting. This didn't remove jobs, clients just expected things to be designed faster and in greater detail than they were before. Maybe before we start patting ourselves on the back and handing out free money we should have a concrete example of an AI doing actual useful work without any human intervention.
- tempfile 2y agoAre you arguing that technology never forces people out of their jobs? Note that even if the total number of jobs stays fixed, it doesn't follow that the same people are doing them. They might end up doing something better, or something much worse, or just die and get replaced by a new generation with different skills. There are many examples from history going in either direction.
- imgabe 2y agoThe total number of jobs increases. Logically, it has to. Population increases. There are more people now than there were in the past and there is not massive unemployment, so there must be more jobs than there were before.
- tempfile 2y agoWhat does that have to do with my comment? I said: > Note that even if the total number of jobs stays fixed, it doesn't follow that the same people are doing them.
- RegnisGnaw 2y agoThe major issue I have with all the UBI studies is that it ends. If you know that UBI ends in say 2 years or 3 years, your actions will be different if it is a true UBI. That skews any of the results of people's behavior.
- glitchc 2y agoNo. The universal in UBI is key, it means everyone gets the same basic amount, no matter how rich (reframing on purpose to make a point). No one wants to give rich people more money, not even those who conceived of the plan. When people start talking about UBI, they are really talking about a guaranteed minimum income. And that's effectively welfare, which we already have. So it becomes mainly a discussion about reducing barriers to access welfare.
- petesergeant 2y agoWhy is it key? What does it being truly universal unlock that being means tested does not?
- derdi 2y ago> When people start talking about UBI, they are really talking about a guaranteed minimum income. No. A guaranteed minimum income means that you can make 500 Euros scrubbing toilets, and welfare bureaucracy will top that up to 1000 Euros after "means testing". A UBI means that you get 1000 Euros from the government without bureaucracy. If you so wish, you can earn additional income by scrubbing toilets. > No one wants to give rich people more money, not even those who conceived of the plan. There's nothing wrong with giving the rich 1000 Euros like everyone else, as long as tax rates are adjusted so that they effectively give the 1000 Euros back. This zero-sum effect may seem silly, but it's a simple implementation without any additional bureaucracy.
- hellojesus 2y agoThey rich would have to give more back than the 1k they take. Otherwise the program wouldn't be funded for those that give back less than 1k.
- derdi 2y agoSure. There is no magic source of free money. My point was that, even if there were a magic source of free money for the UBI, "don't give money to the rich" would still be implemented in the most simple way as "do give money to the rich, then get it back".
- vaidhy 2y agoMost of the arguments seem to be that UBI will reduce labor participation. That seems logically correct, but why is it morally correct? In US (and in western countries), we have the capitalists benefit from the increase in productivity and the working people penalized. Maybe, it is time for the pendulum to swing the other way? Why should the the wealth generated by the society not go to the society (instead of a few wealthy people, as it happens today)? For all the arguments about how it can increase the cost of labor, I would say so what? The profits of the corporation can go down a lot and go to people who make it work.
- soco 2y agoOh no, think of the billionaires...
- benmw333 2y agoWhy do you want to control the lives of others?
- hellojesus 2y agoNot sure which way this post is arguing, but in my anti-UBI opinion, providing UBI does control the lives of others primarily by stealing from productive members to give to unproductive ones. I have no problem if people want to personally finance folks to not work via private charity, but when it becomes a government program, you are definitionally controlling everyone.
- antisthenes 2y agoBecause control over lives of others is what makes a well functioning society. This is something that every single anarchist/libertarian is incapable of understanding, despite living in the developed part of the world. It's just not personal control but institutional control.
- bdw5204 2y agoUBI makes most sense as a targeted way to increase wages by removing some people from the workforce. It would be very good for society, for example, if we paid parents to stay home with the kids instead of sending the kids to day care and to homeschool their kids instead of sending the kids to school. We'd also benefit by paying creatives and scientists so they can pursue their calling without having to work a day job in the patent office like Einstein was infamously forced to and without having to work for a university where there are perverse incentives that discourage the most important work in favor of what is most likely to lead to publications and to governmental/corporate grants. Of course UBI is only part of a plan to control the labor supply and thus drive up wages. We also need to preserve child labor laws, lower the retirement age (60 or maybe even 50 would be reasonable), tax outsourcing instead of subsidizing it and restrict the sort of immigration that takes our jobs instead of creating new jobs. In the case of immigration, that's why green cards for college graduates are preferable to guest worker visas because highly skilled immigrants seem to be disproportionately entrepreneurial but only if their immigration status isn't tied to a job. Prosperity for all rather than maximizing GDP needs to be the goal of economic policy. The issue with most UBI proposals is that their supporters seem to have no understanding of economics and no bigger plan to achieve any real policy objective. So their proposals would just cause inflation unless corporations were able to automate away almost all jobs. In which case we'd basically have an imperial Roman style economy where most of the population is dependent upon the government for bread and circuses while a few accumulate great wealth from the machines (in the case of Rome, humans who had the misfortune to be born as "machines") that run everything. I don't think that's really the kind of future we should want.
- DaleNeumann 2y agoUBI in effect would clean the most degenerate and ignored few in society while at the same time liberating the masses from aimless drudgery. It will inject cash into the consumer market and lower risk to seeking credit. I see it as the ultimate form of capitalism when everyone has a means to acquire goods and services at a mutually agreed upon standard. I also see it as the only option to avert a cataclysmic economic event when we all get layed off and replaced by robots. Read this article from McMaster about UBI in action in the Province of Ontario, it is short and clears up many pre conceived notions against such a program. https://macsphere.mcmaster.ca/bitstream/11375/28173/1/southern-ontarios-basic-income-experience.pdf https://macsphere.mcmaster.ca/bitstream/11375/28173/1/southe...
- swayvil 2y agoOur scientific revolution was based upon a hundred idle wealthy individuals who chose science as their preferred toy. UBI could make that happen again.
- wakawaka28 2y agoIt can transform society all right. Into a ghetto, most likely...
- AwaAwa 2y agoOh it absolutely will. For the worse. When you get something for nothing, you better believe that productivity will plunge. Even a cursory glance at history will show this to be true. Argentina is a great example, of 'something for nothing'.