11 ms·
Mystery as 4k-year-old axe-heads sent to museum
- INTPenis 2y agoProbably found in someone's back garden, or they would have sent an equally anonymous note on where they were found. Prison is a harsh deterrent to most people.
- c-linkage 2y agoMy head-cannon is that both sets of artifacts reported in the story were sent in by the same person. The dude just loves metal detecting and he won't be stopped! And it's better to preserve the finds anonymously rather than face stiff penalties. EDIT: Shout-Out for metal detecting in the UK: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detectorists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detectorists
- blowski 2y agoPart of it was filmed where I live, and there has been a huge increase in the number of "detectorists" out in the fields.
- fnordian_slip 2y ago"The dude just loves metal detecting and he won't be stopped!" As someone who used to be in that field, I never understood why people don't do any research before getting into metal detecting. It should be obvious after even a tiny bit of reading about it that most finds are mostly useless without the context in which they were deposited. This context is usually completely destroyed by digging without knowledge of how to properly document it (that's why so many archaeologists kind of hate Schliemann, even though it has been 150 years). And on top of that most laypeople don't even properly record the location of the find. But many people, once they have started, seem to develop a sort of identity around it, and from that point on, most are impervious to new information. I've often heard that "these greedy archaeologists / government officials want to take what's rightfully mine" or "they don't appreciate me, I'm just trying to preserve history". It's generally either total ignorance or "I didn't want to get fined" that lead to situations like the article. The latter is the same reason shady companies don't record where they disposed of chemicals in the woods, but somehow it's okay for you? Because you have convinced yourself you are "preserving history" by removing a bronze axehead from a location that has preserved it for over 2000 years? It's truly a shame. There are of course some who work with local archaeologists, have received a bit of training and know how to dig and document, and when to stop digging, but from what I've seen, they are a tiny minority. And even many of them do more harm than good. Some archeologists only work with them because they know that these people would dig or loot without them otherwise, and destroy much more in the process. But they can't say that openly, because in today's climate of anti -intellectualism, this would be seen as "ivory tower behaviour", and even more people would go detecting completely unsupervised. Just like rolling coal and the like, some people just really don't like being told what to do, no matter the disparity in knowledge about the subject. Sorry about the rant, it's just all rather frustrating sometimes. In my country, the laws surrounding excavations are so stupid that no-one is happy with them, but archaeologists don't have a lobby of course, so we'll just have to live with the status quo.
- Aurornis 2y ago> It's generally either total ignorance or "I didn't want to get fined" that lead to situations like the article. The latter is the same reason shady companies don't record where they disposed of chemicals in the woods, but somehow it's okay for you? Because you have convinced yourself you are "preserving history" by removing a bronze axehead from a location that has preserved it for over 2000 years? You’re heaping a lot of assumptions on to people who do metal detecting. What makes you so confident that these people went out with the goal of finding and destroying archaeological sites with their metal detector? Finding archaeological artifacts is an extremely rare edge case in metal detecting. I doubt these people had any idea they were digging up valuable artifacts until they were completely out. > It's generally either total ignorance or "I didn't want to get fined" that lead to situations like the article When the fine is on the order of a decent annual income, it should come as no surprise that people don’t want to get fined. It should also come as no surprise that anyone who discovers any artifacts like this would be highly incentivized to hide their origin. I don’t know what you expect. For someone to generously turn their probably accidental finding in and pay a massive amount of money for the privilege?
- rozab 2y agoI've heard a bit about metal detecting in the UK from a relative who is into it. I assume the laws aren't too far off how it works in Ireland. I know that finding hoards of 1000+ year old coins is completely par for the course and is really the goal of the exercise. It may be different in the new world where ancient metal is uncommon, but that's how it works here. Groups like the one my relative is in get special permission to search on building sites before they lay the foundations. I believe the developers are obliged to allow this. Destruction of the archeological context isn't such a concern there because the site is being destroyed anyway, but detectorists are still legally obliged to report any treasures to the authorities and can be forced to sell them to a museum. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/feb/18/change-to-uk-treasure-law-will-keep-more-artefacts-in-museums https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/feb/18/change-to-uk...
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- pbj1968 2y ago$60,000 fine… who can imagine why these were anonymously donated… probably dug them up in his backyard
- bitshiftfaced 2y agoWhich on top of the fine, I imagine they wouldn't be thrilled to have a digging operation right by their house. The anonymous packages make perfect sense.
- esel2k 2y agoWe don’t want that people use metal detectors to find archeological material but we want to find archeological material and know everything about it. Maybe there is a way to deal with it? With licenses/permits including training and a ban on reselling?
- voidUpdate 2y agoI assume there is a kind of permit system, given the "unless you have written permission from the government" part
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoYou can apply for a permit - you usually only will get one for a specific area if you are an archaeologist associated with a university or a museum or something apparently. The law is intended specifically to prevent random people digging up stuff and causing damage to historic sites.
- lazide 2y ago‘When metal detectors are outlawed, only outlaws will have metal detectors’?
- slackfan 2y agoMan, I've missed classic Slashdot-style "didn't read TFA".
- blowski 2y agoAt a guess, a landowner doesn't want archaeologists forcing their way in to dig up their garden and place restrictions on future works on the property.
- anotherhue 2y agoProbably. If only there were some way to align the incentives. Oh well.
- HPsquared 2y agoPaying a "bounty" for artefacts seems the obvious one. If they're so valuable and all.
- jordanb 2y agoIt's the opposite of what they want. Artifacts in isolation are not very useful to archeologists. They want them "in situ". For instance, digging up a graveside and pulling all the artifacts out, without extensively documenting every inch of what was found at the graveside even uninteresting things like arranged rocks, destroys the context that might have yielded insights about burial customs. Archeologists prefer everything to be left alone undisturbed, and generally the idea is you only go looking for artifacts when trying to answer a specific question, or if the site is going to be destroyed anyway for construction. From their perspective treasure hunters are going out there and destroying the record of history.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- carlosjobim 2y agoI see this repeated here in the comments, but it doesn't make much sense to me. The site will still be there to be dug by professional archeologists. Pulling up a few artifacts do not destroy it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chairmanwow1 2y agoYeah this is what a $60k fine gets you. It’s a silly law to try and prevent metal detecting.
- lukan 2y agoIt rather gets you usually nothing at all as it all stays underground and it is rare for somelne to anonymously donate while gaining nothing from it.
- RichardLake 2y agoMy understanding is that the context in which the pieces are found is of enormous import to archaeology. It would be better to one site done properly with the rest in the ground than lose the context from a larger number of sites when the artefacts donated anonymously.
- fnordian_slip 2y agoYour understanding is correct, though I believe that you, jordanb and me are tilting at windmills (as most commenters seem to think the laws are insane without even trying to understand the dynamics behind them). The allure of the fantasy of a real life treasure hunt is too strong compared to the boring reality of field work and research :)
- lukan 2y agoBut do you understand, that most people are not deeply fascinated by archeology to just let some people dig up their yard or make them wait unspecified time for their new home to be build for some years without proper compensation? I am deeply fascinated by archeology, but I do think it is insane expecting this of people who do not share my fascination. And the result is likely, most artifacts and sites get lost.
- actionfromafar 2y ago
- nasvay_factory 2y agowhat a chad! just finds a really old thing and sends it to a local museum anonymously. i would've done the same.
- rdtsc 2y ago> Those convicted of the offence can face a fine ranging to more than €63,000 (£53,000). They can also be sentenced to up to three months in prison > However, appealing to the sender to get back in touch, staff said information about the discovery of the axe-heads would be "treated with the utmost confidentiality and used solely to verify the find location and its circumstances". Says the current administration until someone else replaces them or someone eager to see justice served from the law enforcement forces them to disclose their source.
- elzbardico 2y agoActually, in most countries, the public agents are forced to pursue persecution whenever they are aware of a "crime", not doing so is usually defined in most countries legal statutes as the crime of "prevarication". So, unless a formal procedured issues a legal valid document granting immunity, I hope this guy/gal keeps quiet.
- Suppafly 2y ago>Actually, in most countries, the public agents are forced to pursue persecution whenever they are aware of a "crime" Source?
- rdtsc 2y agoNo gp, but I know of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandated_reporter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandated_reporter in US. It’s for abuse so we’re not talking about a few old axes. But such a thing as a concept does exist.
- Suppafly 2y agoSo no evidence any sort of law exists then.
- rdtsc 2y ago> So no evidence any sort of law exists then. The link I showed mentions this: > If a mandated reporter fails to report, they can be subject to civil penalty, criminal prosecution, or both. Not sure how subject to criminal prosecution would work without a law. So that's good enough for me. Do I want to dig through the legal docs today to quote the exact paragraphs for all the US states or other countries? Nah, maybe some other time.
- 23B1 2y agoThe cognitive dissonance on display. The nanny state is allergic to common sense.
- neontomo 2y agois there no way to verify where the package was sent from? not the address, but the specific post office that handled it?
- bell-cot 2y ago> It is illegal to use a metal detector to search for archaeological objects anywhere in the Republic of Ireland, unless you have written permission from the government. So if you were (say) digging some footings for your new garden shed, found the items, and didn't much trust law enforcement - but were, in abstract, a patriotic sort, who wanted to do the right thing... True story: A friend of mine was digging foundations for a new shed in the back yard of a house he owned - and discovered human bones. Police got involved, and it was a big, big PITA. Even though experts from the local university pronounced "the remains were buried over a century ago; the victim appears to have died of infectious disease". And my friend had bought the house (from an unrelated party) just a few decades prior. And the house had been used as a hospital a century or so earlier, when "bury the paupers in the back yard" could easily be tiny-hospital SOP during an epidemic.
- janpmz 2y agoI wonder how they know the axe-heads are 4k years old. Carbon dating tells them how old the material is, but how do they know when the head was formed into an axe? The same goes for cave paintings. They can date how old the paint is, but how do they know when it was painted?
- KingOfCoders 2y agoFrom the artists biography.
- freeone3000 2y agoWhen your error bars are a few hundred years or so, the few weeks between “making paint” and “using paint” isn’t terribly relevant.
- thaumasiotes 2y agoWell, we can safely rule out the idea that a cave painting was made with thousand-year-old paint. It's more difficult to rule out the idea that a thousand-year-old painting was restored with usable paint.
- Zitrax 2y agoI don't think you can date the axe-heads from the material? I assume they date based on objects found nearby and the technique used to make them. Which is also why knowing the exact location is important.
- nu11ptr 2y agoWow, I can't imagine why the person sent these anonymously, lol. Them to Sender: "Where did you get these from? It is very important!" Them to Public: "We want to remind everyone that metal detecting for something like this is illegal and will be fined!" Also Them to Sender: "Oh...err...but we won't apply that to you!" wink wink
- thomasdeleeuw 2y agoAlso, the museum hardly has any say in prosecution.
- Connector2542 2y ago> It is illegal to use a metal detector to search for archaeological objects anywhere in the Republic of Ireland, unless you have written permission from the government. > Those convicted of the offence can face a fine ranging to more than €63,000 (£53,000). No wonder they donated anonymously, what an insane law.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoYup. I believe the term, here is "hoist with his own petard," to quote an Englishman (or Dane) of some repute.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- lawlessone 2y agook but... >The letter stated that the axe-heads were discovered in County Westmeath using a metal detector. >The museum explained those "severe penalties" are in place because unauthorised metal detecting can cause "serious damage to Ireland’s archaeological heritage
- justinclift 2y ago"But PULEEEEAASE tell us who you are and where you found these! We pinky swear we'll ignore the law and you won't get in trouble." Good luck with that.
- inglor_cz 2y agoIt would be a lot more reassuring if they just fined the culprit 1 EUR and closed the case. Most European countries don't allow a judged case ("res iudicata") to be reopened unless new serious material evidence comes to light, and many not even then.
- lawlessone 2y ago
- Workaccount2 2y agoIt looks to me that if the museum really wants all the details, they will have to pay $60k (or $60k x 2?) in order to get them.
- meroes 2y agoThere we go. Put your money where your mouth is
- eggy 2y agoThe law says it is illegal "to use a detection device to search for archaeological objects anywhere within the State or its territorial seas; without the prior written consent of the Minister for Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht" What if you are searching for gold, lost items, underground cables, or other, and you stumble upon an archaeological object? You were not hunting those objects, so I would say you were within the law. What you do with the fortuitous find is another matter (IANAL). My brother and I were the first to buy a house in our immediate family. My Uncle Vic was the first to say you never really own your house or land. You pay property taxes after you have paid off your house. Your land can be taken with little compensation in some matters, etc. I can see why you would be happy and worried at the same time discovering artifacts whether you were looking for them or not.
- actionfromafar 2y agoI don't know Irish law, but there are usually excemptions for other activities, like cables etc. In that case, you'd report your finding to relevant authorities.
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoSo using them for searching for cables/pipes or lost items is “allowed, sort of” - you can readily buy metal detectors in Ireland for these purposes. Prospecting for gold, on the other hand, is a legally thorny subject in Ireland. Finds above a couple of grams have to be reported and handed in. If you happen to “stumble across” historical artefacts on your land you are meant to stop doing whatever caused you to find them (eg construction), report it, and then wait forever while archaeologists eventually show up and spend ages poring over the find to ensure you don’t destroy anything of historic value.
- flerchin 2y agoA classic example of a 2nd order effect.
- PenguinCoder 2y agoIf real life was a movie, I'd say those likely contain some ancient poison or virus that out ancestors used against alien invasion, and won against. They're surfaced now as a plot device for when we get invaded again (soon) and we find out our only hope is recreating that exact poison. Timely...
- myspeed 2y agoIt can be also a smuggled item from elsewhere.
- elzbardico 2y agoIt is a really stupid law, and I hope the object finder don't fall in the trap of revealling her/his identity before a formal waiver of criminal persecution is issued by the competent authorities.
- Aardwolf 2y ago> It is illegal to use a metal detector to search for archaeological objects anywhere in the Republic of Ireland, unless you have written permission from the government. What if you use it to search for non-archaeological objects, but then accidentally find one? Not surprising they receive anonymous donations without information if they treat finders like that.
- egberts1 2y agoScrew the crying pleas of museums and archeologists for more locale information, for with an oppressive law with HUGE disincentive to self-report accidental finds of seemingly archeological object that can knock out a good portion of your own precious land usage, there is nothing to be gained by outing yourself. Now, if there were ample of compensations, then it becomes tenable and possibly fairer. You should pass on this brand of British & Wales “presumptive justice” until they treat their citizen (as well as their jailed subpostmasters) better.
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoThis isn’t Britain or Wales. RoI is not part of the UK.