11 ms·
The great silence: Just 4 in 10k galaxies may host intelligent aliens
- cratermoon 2y agoRecent studies suggest there are 2 trillion galaxies in the observable universe. That works out to roughly 8 billion galaxies with intelligent life. There are untold trillions more galaxies beyond our observable horizon. Intelligence may be scattered sparsely, but there's probably a lot of it in absolute terms. Maybe in some corner of the universe two intelligent civilizations arose in the same galaxy, within a few tens of light years from each other. What is lonelier, having no other intelligence for millions of light years, or knowing there's another civilization tantalizingly close, but still far enough to make the possibility of in-person contact daunting under known laws of physics.
- vessenes 2y agoMy mind goes to: do we want an outside context problem to be our problem or a neighbour’s problem? I choose neighbour’s problem unless they are extremely benign. Like, extremely.
- engineer_22 2y agoThere are intelligent beings on planet earth with language and culture that we have no idea how to communicate with. Roll the in the idea we'll communicate with them with messages encoded in radio waves, and they'll understand, and it sounds hopelessly optimistic.
- babypuncher 2y agoWhat alternative technology do you propose aliens would be using to communicate wirelessly across vast distances? Even if something new is eventually discovered (like Star Trek's "subspace"), it stands to reason that any civilization advanced enough to explore their own solar system would have been using radio long before then.
- itishappy 2y agoWhat makes you assume aliens are communicating wirelessly across vast distances? Earth is home to just one species who've developed wireless communication, and we don't broadcast across astronomical distances if we can help it these days.
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoIf you stay within the realms of physics, there are no great choices. Electromagnetism is the easiest one, other waves or quantum based ideas are hard (physically speaking). It is very probable that electromagnetic waves are what you start with.
- itishappy 2y agoNo arguments here! EM is my career. :) My point is that this limits our search somewhat to just interstellar species, and that's a crazy high bar! The most advanced species we know (us) is still confined to one planet. We'd be difficult to impossible to detect from Alpha Centauri, let alone Andromeda.
- atrus 2y agoThe issue isn't them using radio, it's that it's on top of another encoding. If someone sent you raw radio data, what's it modulated by? Frequency? Phase? Amplitude? A combination of the three? Is it multiplexed with other data? And then, if you magically figure that out, it's not even in a language you speak? If it's even a spoken language! Good luck haha.
- jonfw 2y agoI don't think we would expect to understand any of their radio data, but we might at least be able to recognize that it's alien in nature
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y ago
- Loughla 2y agoWhat beings have language and culture other than human?
- nilamo 2y agoDolphins, ants, most birds, wolves...
- jasonpeacock 2y agoWhales, elephants, birds, octopus, ...
- wahern 2y agoIt all depends on how you define language and culture, and that's before you delve into a host of other unstated assumptions. The whole debate is driven by unstated assumptions, or assumptions and thresholds which are more-or-less pulled out of thin air, notwithstanding any associated quantifications. And these assumptions are constantly in flux. For example, once upon a time "tool use" was considered a unique capability of humans, and from that was derived definitions of intelligence, etc. Well, turns out lots of other animals use tools, at least under that original, somewhat simplistic definition. But what's the significance of that fact--that other animals use tools? Does it mean they're also intelligent, just like humans? People have argued as much, but the "tool use" test was basically pulled out of someone's butt to begin with; the fact we all agree other animals use tools, now, doesn't actually imply much of anything. People draw conclusions where none can be drawn. And people establish presumptions and definitions to fit their preferred conclusions.
- engineer_22 2y ago> People draw conclusions where none can be drawn. And people establish presumptions and definitions to fit their preferred conclusions. In furtherance of my point. We struggle enough with interpersonal communication. Communication with intelligent animals, of which the examples are many and diverse, has to this point been unmanageable.
- vessenes 2y agoThe Drake equations are the most convincing assessment of where we’re at and why that I’ve read — upshot, the fact that nobody is near us is a GREAT sign that we’re likely going to have time to expand out of our solar system before some dominant civ just eats us maybe without even noticing us. That said, so many of these ‘intelligent life’ things have so many baked in assumptions, I’m constantly frustrated: “Must be water based, since that’s what we know,” “Must communicate via radio like we do in ways that we could recognize”, … The assumptions are legion.
- VagabundoP 2y agoExactly, there’s alien and there’s alien alien. We can’t even imagine alien alien.
- bsder 2y ago> “Must be water based, since that’s what we know,” This one is an assumption, but it's a pretty good one. Equilibrium chemistry has a fairly narrow band of energy in which things can be pushed to one side or the other without completely dissociating. A solvent is almost always required as a medium and water is about as "simple" as that gets. Sub-zero chemistries might work, but they would be much slower than water--life might take longer than the age of the universe to evolve. Molten chemistries don't seem to be able to hang together long enough to be reversible. While the "building blocks" of life might be different, given our current knowledge of physics, the probability that the solvent for life is water is likely very high.
- vundercind 2y agoChemistry’s the limiting factor for most of it. You’ll need a lot of energy for complex life. The list of things that can naturally provide enough without having extremely-hostile side effects is pretty much limited to stars, and then only if you get really lucky in a whole bunch of ways. Then you need to turn that into chemical energy to actually do anything with it. That’s gonna turn useful chemicals from the environment into waste you can no longer use. If you’re lucky the waste is chemically useful, and if something can evolve to use it, maybe it can turn it back into what you need (happened with oxygen). If the waste isn’t useful, you better hope your planet’s recycling it somehow. Ideally with some kind system that adjusts with a feedback-loop so it doesn’t limit your growth too much. Our one example sure looks extremely fragile, in that if you mess with any of several things a little bit, you might still get life, but it’ll cyclically wipe itself out, or never be able to harvest enough energy to support complex life, or any number of other problems that end in not seeing intelligence arise.
- saomcomrad56 2y agoSounds like more than enough
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dyauspitr 2y agoImagine if we are the only life in the universe. A million years from now we will have seeded life across multiple galaxies if we’re still around. What a crazy life that would be.
- cgriswald 2y agoIf we left today, instantaneously at the speed of light, it would still be another 1.5 million years before we arrived at the nearest galaxy.
- knowitnone 2y agoaccording to relativity, if we could travel at the speed of light, we would arrive instantaneously. you're thinking about it from the observer point of view.
- dgrin91 2y agoOur nearest galaxy is only ~25k light years away (Canis Major)
- dyauspitr 2y agoYeah but the people traveling would barely have aged.
- postalrat 2y agoProbably already happened.
- OutOfHere 2y agoThe article is not about life, but about intelligent life. It says so right in the title. I do not consider humans to be particularly intelligent, as they can't even come together to address global threats like climate change that could mean the difference between a universe with intelligent life versus a universe that's barren. To address the risk, we first have to acknowledge this universal risk.
- cosmotic 2y agoWhy not say 1 in 2.5k?
- moralestapia 2y agoNice! That's billions of them, then.
- Ekaros 2y agoAn other aspect I have been thinking is fraction of planets that have sufficient metal richness for life or advanced civilizations in first place. So you could have intelligent life that just doesn't get advanced due to lack of resources...
- exe34 2y agowater worlds - easy to evolve life, much harder to evolve technology.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- topspin 2y agoGiven the number of galaxies, this ratio means "intelligent aliens" are common.
- TheBlight 2y agoIt seems like application of the Copernican principle should be the default and the burden is on others to show that the Earth and its observers are somehow extraordinary.
- kcplate 2y agoIntelligent life isn’t even common on the one planet where we know it exists. You have maybe a dozen species that could go beyond their basal instincts out of millions of forms of life and only a single species has the intelligence to make itself known outside the biosphere. Life might be common, but “intelligent” life? That seems to be exceedingly rare.
- kachapopopow 2y agoSo basically, aliens are all around us? Just very very far away.
- TheBlight 2y ago"Just very very far away." Many of them have probably had ample time to travel the galaxy.
- yobid20 2y agoThey are already here.
- marmaduke 2y agoC'mon, call it dark forest already
- fuzzythinker 2y agoPoor title, 4 in 10k is in the low side of estimate. "by plugging this value into the Drake equation, Stern and Gerya arrive at a value for the number of extraterrestrial civilizations as somewhere between 0.0004 and 20,000". EDIT: If we take a number near the middle, say 1, we have ~1 per galaxy. Near the high side, we have ~10k per galaxy.
- ant6n 2y agoHey that's us! We're like a terrestrial civilization inside a galaxy!
- effed3 2y agoOr maybe actually this is a measure of the fact we are still quite deaf (and blind) about what is, in wide sense, life, not event about intelligent one. Plate tectonics, water and dry land are really necessary? And some intelligent beings will radio-shout everywhere? Maybe they not know radio, and still are intelligent, or know the radio and being even more intelligent do not use it...
- lukan 2y agoThe assumption here is, plate tectonics are required for intelligent life. Which is an interesting theory, but not much more I think. We don't even know what is required for the formation of life at all.
- yabatopia 2y agoA fingerprint is unique. A snowflake is unique. But for some reason we find it difficult to face the possibility that intelligent life - on planet earth - is in a similar way unique.
- tconfrey 2y agoI've often wondered how important the tides are to the migration of fish onto land and our subsequent evolution. Our moon's relative size is another earthly anomaly and without the moon tides would be solar driven and pretty minimal (AFAIK).
- OutOfHere 2y agoIf we are alone or among the very few in the universe, this makes it all the more important for us to shed selfish behaviors and come together to resolve global threats such as climate change and many others. Yet, we continue in the opposite direction, treating life in the universe as disposable.
- TheLoafOfBread 2y agoThat means lot of space for Human race to expand in.