15 ms·
Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars
- aftbit 2y agoEww it is not the car's job to enforce speed limits. More nanny state nonsense.
- ghaff 2y agoA number of years back I had a rental car (in Arizona possibly) that had a speed limiter that was at the speed limit--or just above--as I recall and it was incredibly annoying.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoWhat was annoying about it?
- brink 2y agoNobody drives exactly the speed limit - except apparently Europeans now.
- OnlyMortal 2y agoEU.
- lolinder 2y agoNot OP, but I can hazard some guesses: * Very few people drive the speed limit, so you're now stuck at being the slowest car on the road. (This will still be a problem under this law because new vehicles are the only ones affected.) * Inaccurate/out of date speed limits. * Impossible to pass anyone on a two lane road. * Having the car take over control is very disorienting for a skilled driver who expects the machine to function as an extension of their body. See the number of people who prefer manual transmission and who eschew cruise control.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoThe first doesn't really win any sympathy from me lol. People should drive the speed limit, and I have no sympathy for people who tell me about getting pulled over by cops
- galdosdi 2y agoNo, OTHER people, not the driver. He's saying OTHER PEOPLE drive over the limit, and OTHER PEOPLE are NOT in your control, so "haveing no sympathy" is irrelevant here. You have no sympathy for me when i find myself driving amongst others who drive above the limit? Their speeds are not in my control. Only mine is. And if the limiter prevents me from going the same speeds as everyone around me, I will be constantly passed and in greater danger of wrecking. Do you even have a drivers' license? You evince very little familiarity with practical every day driving. If you are a driver, how many years experience in which countries? It would help us gauge the relevance of your comments -- different countries have different driving cultures.
- novagameco 2y ago> You have no sympathy for me when i find myself driving amongst others who drive above the limit? I also often find myself driving among other people who speed. I stay to the right with the OTHER drivers who are following the law. I always drive the speed limit and it's never a problem for me. Many states' laws require this, anyway (faster traffic to the left, slower traffic to the right).
- galdosdi 2y agoYes, I stay to the right too unless passing or exiting to the left, etc, for the reasons you said and others too (the right lane has a shoulder next to it, increasing options in an emergency) Still gets you passed a lot if you're unnecessarily slow though. If the prevailing speed is a speed I feel unsafe going, then sure, I'll accept the passing. But if the prevailing speed feels safe -- it might just be 5 MPH over the limit, or the limit might be unnecessarily low -- of course I will just go the prevailing speed, to maximize safety. What kind of a fool would do otherwise, just to satisfy an imaginary policeman in his head?
- cheeseomlit 2y agoNobody follows the speed limit that closely, in the US at least. If my car was hard-capped at the posted limit I'd have a mile-long line of honking tailgaters behind me in no time
- Zigurd 2y agoOnly until speed-limited cars reach a critical mass.
- novagameco 2y agoIf you hog the left lane, sure. I follow the posted speed limit and it's never a problem for me
- nradov 2y agoYou never drive on two-lane rural roads? Getting stuck behind a slow vehicle is torture.
- novagameco 2y agothey usually allow passing at specified points
- lolinder 2y agoWhich are often few, far between, and quite short. If there's any kind of traffic coming the opposite way you can miss your chance over and over again.
- oneepic 2y agoI would have to guess you can't speed up to pass another vehicle (think bus or truck, or maybe a dangerous situation) and then you will piss off anyone in the fast lane who does not have these limiters.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoCant speak to europe, but in the US you're not supposed to speed up past the speed limit to pass someone, that's illegal. We also don't have "fast lanes" (ie like how the autobahn has sections with no speed limit), we only have passing lanes, but the speed limit still applies in the passing lane. You're not supposed to stay in the left lane for very long
- zamadatix 2y agoFast lane probably meant left/passing lane, not unrestricted roads. That you're not supposed to stay in them long is part of why people speed up to pass, otherwise it takes a minute seconds to gain 60 feet on that semi going just under. Speaking to the US as a whole on traffic law is hard to do. E.g. in Washington it is absolutely legal to exceed the speed limit to pass someone on the highway, in California it isn't. In California it's illegal to sit in the fast lane, in Minnesota it's not. In Minnesota you can turn right on certain reds, in DC you can't.
- novagameco 2y agoIn my state, it's illegal to go over the speed limit at any point, for any reason. If you want to pass someone, you do so in the left lane, at the speed limit, and then move back over to the middle/right lane. And you best believe you'll get pulled over
- isatty 2y agoAnd what state is that? I do know that some states are over zealous about this but two vehicles driving next to each other slowing gaining on another to overtake is also creating a dangerous road situation. This is taught when you take your written test in CA. Trucks don’t really have a choice which is why it’s normal for them to do so even on a two lane highway.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Swizec 2y agoMy experience of learning to drive in Europe is that there are roads where the speed limit is 90kph but any non-local sane person will drive 60kph (most mountain roads) and there are roads where the limit is 130kph but regular traffic flows at 140kph and many people cruise (safely) at 150kph. The people actually doing 130kph on the left lane (trucks go 90 on the right) can be a safety hazard. And like others have said, the laws actually say "speed limit unless passing". Because passing is dangerous and should be done as quickly as possible.
- ghaff 2y agoBasically it kept cutting out right around the speed limit (may have been 5mph over) on the highway. It wasn't "smart" just an absolute limit. (I think wherever I was had a relatively high speed limit for the time--maybe 70--so it was probably some standard governor setting which was sort of unreasonable for where I was, but a long time ago.)
- richwater 2y agoJust another data point for the eventual "EU social credit score"
- cm2187 2y agoAnd another nail in the coffin of the EU. Annoying your voters, great way to salvage your sinking popularity.
- richwater 2y agoI don't understand the downvotes. The surveillance potential of this is _massive_ and dystopian.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoPeople life authoritarianism when it’s “their side” doing it.
- gambiting 2y agoThis is one example of legislation that mandates fantasy tech that doesn't exist. You'd think that something as simple as speed limiter should be very easy to implement, and it couldn't be further from the truth - watch any review of a car with this tech and every reviewer will complain that it's not the presence of the system that's the problem, it's the fact that it constantly gets the speed limit wrong. Either reading the wrong signs(from parallel streets or signs which have been vandalized and moved facing the wrong way, or literally just reading the speed incorrectly) or getting the GPS speed wrong, or when on a private road defaulting to 20mph so beeping at you when driving in your own driveway. Generally personally I actually think this is a potentially good thing - but the implementation is universally flawed, across every brand, every model. Now the selling point is whether the car has a shortcut button on the dash to disable this system.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoAgreed that the general case is hard to solve. I think you could at least make a case for solving a simpler problem. What's the highest legal speed limit in the country in which the car was sold? Set a global speed limit to that.
- kodt 2y agoThis could make it impossible or dangerous to pass in many situations where it may be necessary to temporarily exceed the speed limit.
- CalRobert 2y agoWhile it can be overridden, hopefully this saves many lives. We limit speeds on scooters and e bikes so cars are only fair
- lacy_tinpot 2y agoI'm almost certain that the Autobahn is inside the EU and it's famous for the very thing this law supposedly limits.
- gambiting 2y agoAnd on the derestricted section of the autobahn it will do nothing, given that there is no speed limit.
- gambiting 2y agoWe don't limit the speed of ebikes - we limit the point at which the electric motor cuts off, but there's nothing stopping you from just pedalling faster.
- CalRobert 2y ago
- seydor 2y agoIs there actual data that these make driving safe?
- croes 2y agoHardly because they didn't exist widespread before. Speed limits on the other hand are proven to reduce accidents.
- kbolino 2y ago> Speed limits on the other hand are proven to reduce accidents. There have been speed limits on every road in the US for over half a century; how did they conduct a controlled study?
- mikeyouse 2y agoBecause speed limits change and it's easy to measure the before/after impact in terms of the number and the severity of accidents as the average speed in an area changes. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4989038/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4989038/
- kbolino 2y agoTwo major confounders for this argument are the raising of national speed limits from the 1970s to the 1990s, during which time traffic accident and fatality rates went down significantly, and the post-COVID bump in traffic accident and fatality rates, during which time, for the most part, no speed limits went up. Without a control, there can be no confidence in the claimed causal link. Moreover, "speed limit" vs "no speed limit" is not the same question as "lower speed limit" vs "higher speed limit". People often behave in non-intuitive ways, which is part of why studies are conducted in the first place.
- mikeyouse 2y agoThat’s a pretty silly line of thought.. there’s absolutely no need for a “no speed limit” control when speed limits already are just chopping off the higher end of the bell curve of speed distributions. And clearly there are other causes of accidents and other ways to reduce fatalities (antilock brakes and seatbelts for the period you mentioned) but it’s actually pretty straightforward to assess speed’s influence on accident rates and injuries as shown by the dozens of studies that have found a direct causal relationship. It’s not as if there’s some possibility of a discontinuity where no speed limits means everyone drives slower… especially if you know how speed limits are set in the first place.
- teraflop 2y agoSeems misleading for the headline to call this a "speed limiter", since depending on the implementation it either doesn't affect the car's speed at all, or slows it down in an immediately overrideable way. So there is no actual limit on the car's speed.
- throw_a_grenade 2y agoFrom TFA: “The EU regulations permit a system that can use [...], or a speed control function in which the speed of the vehicle will be gradually reduced.” Sounds a hell lot like an actual limiter.
- itishappy 2y ago> "Even in the case of speed control function, where the car speed will be automatically gently reduced, the system can be smoothly overridden by the driver by pressing the accelerator pedal a little bit deeper," the European Commission adds.
- floren 2y agoLeaving aside the myriad political & economic implications of this, my VW's navigation quite frequently thinks I'm on a different road, or it misses a speed limit sign, etc. It's bad enough when it jerks the wheel a little because it got confused by an off-ramp, or slams on the brakes in the parking lot because someone is walking a mere 30 yards behind me, but boy if my car started dropping speed to 35 because it confused the freeway with the frontage road I'd be pretty mad.
- angrygoat 2y agoMy car has this stuff in it too (BYD Dolphin) and it's a mixed bag. I find the "watch out, car/object moving into your path" stuff really useful – here in Australia, driving in the bush, it's picked up roos I'd likely have missed otherwise. It whinges if it thinks I'm speeding, but it's often totally wrong on the speed limit: reading the wrong signs, holding a lower limit when I've turned onto a road with a higher limit. I find the alerts extremely distracting, and unfortunately they use the same sound as alerts I might want to know about. It also makes that same sound every time it reads a new sign. And then it feels the need to claim I'm speeding all over again, even if the limit hasn't changed. I turn it off most times I get in the car, although there's no shortcut for it, so it's just a constant annoyance: the car won't remember the setting.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoPlease oh please add them to German cars sold to USA too. I would really enjoy watching all the BMWs and Mercedes going the speed limit all the time instead of flying past me with plate obscuring devices and never seeing any consequences
- alfalfasprout 2y agoThis isn't a problem if you just stay in the right lane.
- anunes 2y agoYeah, if only a pedestrian or a cyclist or a regular person who isn't out of their mind would "stay in the right lane" and let me go vrooom vrooom, then we would be satisfied! /s
- nunez 2y agoNo, it's a problem if you're in the right lane. I spent years trying to do this (Houston, TX). You'll get tailgated, and you'll _also_ deal with the drivers that cross four lanes of traffic to hit that exit.
- ZoomerCretin 2y ago> There will be four ways in which ISA systems will work to slow the vehicle down, and it will be up to the manufacturers to pick which one they want to use. The EU regulations permit a system that can use a cascaded acoustic warning, a cascaded vibrating warning, an accelerator pedal with haptic feedback, or a speed control function in which the speed of the vehicle will be gradually reduced. > "Even in the case of speed control function, where the car speed will be automatically gently reduced, the system can be smoothly overridden by the driver by pressing the accelerator pedal a little bit deeper," the European Commission adds. So not speed limiters, but speed warners. Still, given that ebikes and escooters have been limited by legislation to 20-25mph, it only made sense to do the same for the much more obviously dangerous vehicles on the road. I hope we can do the same in the US, or at least make your car annoy you when you speed the way it annoys you when you don't have your seatbelt on.
- knallfrosch 2y agoYou pin the "disable speed warner" to your infotainment favorites and click it once when starting the car. With wireless-phone-as-key, keyless ignition and automatic transmissions, drivers of modern cars who disable the speed warner this way still do less than people driving older cars. The current effect on race drivers is small. It's about the cultural shift towards respecting speed limits and forcing car manufacturers to implement reliable speed recognition tech. Once that in place, the time will be ready to switch to speed limiters.
- bowmessage 2y agoHopefully the EU's right to repair allows consumers to fix their cars by removing this malware.
- croes 2y agoIf you have relatives who got killed by a speeder you may think differently.
- gambiting 2y agoGiven that the tech doesn't actually work reliably I'd remove it even without any intention to speed. It's the same reason why I keep lane keeping assistance off in my car - not because I disagree with the idea, but because the implementation is so bad it's actively dangerous.
- ars 2y agoThe slight speed increase that ordinary people do does not kill people. We aren't talking about people going freeway speed in a residential area.
- Thorrez 2y agoIncreasing speed increases the chance that someone will die in a crash if it happens, and also increases the chance that a crash will happen. Check out these graphs: https://safety.fhwa.dot.gov/speedmgt/ref_mats/fhwasa1304/Resources3/08%20-%20The%20Relation%20Between%20Speed%20and%20Crashes.pdf https://safety.fhwa.dot.gov/speedmgt/ref_mats/fhwasa1304/Res...
- Symbiote 2y agoThe "normal" speeding in residential areas absolutely does increase the chance of death and injury in a collision with a pedestrian or cyclist. K = m v² That energy increases with the square of the speed, and has to go somewhere (person's body) in a collision.
- 2y ago
- peppermint_gum 2y ago>There will be four ways in which ISA systems will work to slow the vehicle down, and it will be up to the manufacturers to pick which one they want to use. The EU regulations permit a system that can use a cascaded acoustic warning, a cascaded vibrating warning, an accelerator pedal with haptic feedback, or a speed control function in which the speed of the vehicle will be gradually reduced. This is more like a "speed warner" than a "speed limiter".
- dyauspitr 2y agoA cascading vibration warning sounds like it would make going fast feel more exciting.
- seattle_spring 2y agoLike a Rumble Pak[1] for your car! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumble_Pak https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumble_Pak
- prions 2y agoBit funny how the article states that the systems are unobtrusive as to be essentially useless, which ignores the fact that these systems are defanged to appease entitled speeders. Governments around the world impose various requirements on vehicle speeds, most notably ebikes being capped at 20mph for "safety reasons". Meanwhile private cars can travel at over 100mph for no apparent reason other than to not upset drivers at the expense of everyone else on the road.
- robertlagrant 2y agoEbikes go where bikes go, that's why. They can mingle with pedestrians. They don't require a licence to operate.
- prions 2y agoClass B and C mopeds in NYC are speed limited and require a license and registration
- robertlagrant 2y agoCan you explain your point?
- prions 2y agoMopeds can only operate on streets, they cant go in bikelanes or sidewalks. They are subject to the same restrictions as cars (licensure, registration) except that they uniquely have a speed limit Not having a speed limit is unique only to private car ownership
- robertlagrant 2y agoNo, you've got it backwards. NYC categorises mopeds by top speed, where class A don't have a speed limit. As a secondary issue, you're claiming an NYC rule (that you've misconstrued) is evidence of pro-car rules worldwide, and also you're omitting motorbikes (and class A mopeds) even in NYC. The NYC classification allow relaxations of rules for class B and C mopeds. No helmet required for class C. No inspections required for B or C. These are pro-moped rules. It seem really unobjective to see them as evidence of pro-car thinking.
- gruturo 2y agoThis is terrifying. I routinely cross a bridge with a 30ton weight limit, which my car mistakes for a 30km/h speed limit sign. I would cause an average of 2 accidents per month if I suddenly slowed from 70 to 30 and the people behind me weren't paying attention. The technology is _not_ there and this won't save lives, potentially it will cause deaths. (Yes I read the article, this is initially only "for the driver's information" and not (yet) a hard limit.... but it's the first step in a very wrong direction)
- shortrounddev2 2y agoThis uses GPS data, not optical recognition
- gwbas1c 2y agoFrom TFA: > Cars have been able to figure out when they're speeding for a while, thanks to GPS as well as traffic sign recognition
- Tade0 2y agoThis is going to lead to some backpedaling. On one stretch of ring road (120km/h limit) my car consistently catches 80km/h signs set up for the exit roads.
- gwbas1c 2y agoWhich, IMO, is one of the reasons why I think speed-limit based speed limiters are a poor idea now. (I didn't mention much in my other post at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40919908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40919908) Personally, I think this (speed-limit aware speed limiters) are going to trigger Congress to either fast-track legislation to disable them. Specifically, once the general public is aware of what's going on, they will stop buying new cars and car manufacturers will push on Congress. I also think the legislation was written by someone who is very naive about engineering. What I remember is they tolerate a 10% error rate. If 10% of the cars are going too slow during rush hour, it's just going to create a major traffic jam.
- gfna 2y agoWell this is going to be interesting if they rely on GPS. Possibly due to gps jamming by our neighbour country i have had to disable the feature where the car tries to predict the road ahead and suddenly brakes on the motorway because it thinks it is on a side road 10s of kilometers away.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zombiwoof 2y agoAbout time. Why have rules for cars if they can’t be enforced
- baggy_trough 2y agoOur accursed state senator Wiener is trying to bring the same thing to California.
- rsingel 2y agoLove it and love Wiener. One of the most effective legislators in California. Speed limiters/governors are way past due and will save lives and help make streets more liveable
- alfalfasprout 2y agoGlad I left California. You guys can keep your limiters.
- baggy_trough 2y agoNot something or someone I'm a fan of, to put it mildly.
- christkv 2y agoI swear i remember my old TomTom device having something like this built in but maybe im remembering wrong.
- Lammy 2y agoI am going to hold on to my 2013 car for as long as possible. Fuck this future where everything “““needs””” to spy on me and everywhere I go.
- oaththrowaway 2y agoEven my 2013 has OnStar. I gotta figure out how to kill that as well
- mikeyouse 2y agoAFAIK - pre-2015 OnStar used 2G cellular radios which no longer work since we shutdown that cellular network a few years ago. You can check your VIN here to verify but I don't think you have anything to worry about: https://activate.onstar.com/en-US https://activate.onstar.com/en-US
- HenryBemis 2y agoExpect that soon enough they will ask people to put some colored sticker in their car, depending on the age of the car, the technology of the engine, and then you won't be allowed to drive "here" or "there" or you will need a super expensive "pollution-pass".
- uyzstvqs 2y agoRooted cars will be a thing soon enough. If that doesn't work for you, consult your local Amish community for transportation options.
- alright2565 2y agoThis is wonderful. Even if it's just a warning, I'd expect this to significantly reduce traffic injury & death.
- EricE 2y agoObligatory https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RvV3nn_de2k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RvV3nn_de2k
- tremarley 2y agoRules like this m, mandated by unelected officials are one of the reasons millions of people in the UK voted for Brexit.
- galdosdi 2y agoOr, just add speed bumps, curves, narrowings in the road, etc, to naturally bring the speed down. Then it works on everyone, whether they have the nanny tech or not, and you avoid the difficult problem of determining the speed limit accurately 100% of the time across every segment of road everywhere. This is kind of like the (apocryphal) "NASA spent millions on a pen that would work without gravity; russians just used pencil" parable.
- DoingIsLearning 2y agoNot sure why you are getting downvoted. Urban design is a much more effective approach to saving lives (a large fraction of speeding deaths are pedestrians) with the bonus of giving large areas of the city back to pedestrians. "Traffic calming" is a well established evidence based field. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_calming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_calming
- galdosdi 2y agoEspecially considering the top 5 threads on this article are all complaining about how speed limiting and speed limit recognition technology sucks. That's why I thought this was the most logical response.
- stavros 2y agoLeaving aside the concerns about the tech not working well, I'm really not a fan of this pre-crime stuff. This feels very Big Brother, where someone (or some system) is watching over you so you don't break any laws. Things like this lead to cultural ossification and are a nightmare scenario for me.
- umvi 2y agoOne possible future includes one or more of: - AI guns that won't shoot at other people, only authorized in-season animals. - AI keyboards that won't let you type "hate speech" - AI browsers that only let you visit approved, legal sites. - AI smartphones that contact the police if you are breaking curfew, trespassing, recording unauthorized (copyrighted) public or audio, etc.
- stavros 2y agoYou don't need AI for the browser thing, stuff is already blocked at the DNS level.
- novagameco 2y ago> - AI guns that won't shoot at other people, only authorized in-season animals. That sounds like a legitimately good idea, why would you need a gun that shoots people
- its_ethan 2y ago> why would you need a gun that shoots people Resisting the urge to be snarky, self defense is a legitimate answer. You may not live somewhere where it's common (or you may not frequently feel unsafe) but wanting the ability to have a weapon to defend yourself (or more commonly to show that you have the ability to defend yourself) from any assailant is a very real thing for people both in the US and around the world. There are plenty of women with restraining orders against men who would do them harm who would very much suffer consequences, and be made much more afraid for their safety, if it weren't for "guns that shoot people".
- drusepth 2y agoSeems like a net positive change to me, assuming the tech doesn't succumb to some of the FUD takes here (and/or can be improved over time...). I've had family killed by speeders. I've had friends and family permanently maimed and disabled by speeders. For people who think speed limits are just a suggestion or don't always apply, I can see how this would be "annoying". But the point of speed limits are for driving safety -- something humans are notably absolutely terrible at as a species. Anything that enforces them a bit better than the limited (and tbh flawed) resource of just traffic stops is an improvement in my book.
- avalys 2y agoThe problem with automated enforcement of laws like this, is that the laws were not written for 100% automatic enforcement. Everyone who has ever followed a car driving 5 mph below the speed limit on a two-lane road knows that it is basically impossible to ever pass them while staying under the speed limit. Legally, that's what you're supposed to do, but everyone - the police, the legislators, the courts, and drivers - understands that in practice it's acceptable to exceed the speed limit a bit when making a pass. This is just one of countless areas in which the law is not actually written with the expectation of being enforced 100% of the time.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thiht 2y ago> everyone - the police, the legislators, the courts, and drivers - understands that in practice it's acceptable to exceed the speed limit a bit when making a pass Not in France. When passing a car, you MUST stay below the speed limit. The only exception would be an immediate danger, like for example if you follow someone visibly drunk. Wanting to pass someone because they drive 5kmh below the speed limit is not an immediate danger, just be patient, you’ll be late by 5 minutes at most. Speed limits are laws, not suggestions.
- lolinder 2y ago> Speed limits are laws, not suggestions. This depends a lot on where you live. In much of the US the speed limit only gets enforced at 10mph above the speed limit, which means that 5 under without good reason is actually hazardous—you're actively impeding traffic that wants to be going ~13mph faster than you are.
- thiht 2y ago> 5 under without good reason is actually hazardous No it's not. It's annoying, not hazardous. > you're actively impeding traffic that wants to be going ~13mph faster than you are. You DON'T break speed limits because the guy behind you wants to break speed limits. That's a terrible reason to break a speed limit. And if you're the guy breaking speed limit and pressuring the drivers in front of you to do the same, you're actually the hazardous one.
- mglz 2y agoNormally I am a big fan of the EU but this is crap legislation. If you want to stop speeding, just do what France is doing: Frequent speed cameras and high fines. It is very rare to encounter somebody speeding there.
- gwbas1c 2y agoHonestly, I think it makes more sense to start with limiting cars somewhere around 90-110MPH; IE, the fastest that anyone would ever drive on a public road. Where I live, speed limits are routinely set artificially low due to a cultural belief that rules are meant to be broken. IE, if the safest speed is 75MPH, then the speed limit is set to 55MPH because everyone will break the rule. If the limit was really 75MPH, then everyone would drive faster. I do think we need frank discussions about what is a safe speed to drive, and the general public's tolerance for risk, before "speed limit aware" limiters are commonplace. Otherwise, these just smell like a scheme from an "enthusiastic rule follower" to try force unneeded rules when these rules don't need to exist.
- ryandrake 2y ago> Otherwise, these just smell like a scheme from an "enthusiastic rule follower" to try force unneeded rules when these rules don't need to exist. Also, a lot of these "enthusiastic rule follower" lawmakers who push for these things are really only interested in making other people follow the rules. They will find a way to exempt themselves.
- akira2501 2y ago> then the speed limit is set to 55MPH The speed limit is set to 55MPH because the road services vehicles that weigh 600lbs all the way up to 80,000lbs. "Safe speed" is not a single universal number for a given stretch of road. The laws even acknowledge this, as if the weather is extremely unfavorable, you can be pulled over for driving _at_ the speed limit as it will be declared "unsafe speed under given conditions." This doesn't even approach things like construction zones, traffic accidents and other roadway hazards that can't be flagged in a way for the automated system to recognize correctly.
- gwbas1c 2y ago> because the road services vehicles that weigh 600lbs all the way up to 80,000lbs The laws recognize that those vehicles are different. Where I live those vehicles are only allowed to drive in the right two lanes. There's already a federal push to have speed limiters in vehicles like that and it is getting a lot of pushback: https://www.freightwaves.com/news/fmcsa-delays-speed-limiter-rule-to-may-2025 https://www.freightwaves.com/news/fmcsa-delays-speed-limiter... Again, That's why I said it's important to have a frank discussion about the general public's tolerance for risk. Otherwise, whatever authority is pushing for speed limiters under the claim of "safety" is just unintentionally taking an authoritarian approach.
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40880764 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40880764
- barryrandall 2y ago"The objective is to protect Europeans against traffic accidents, poor air quality and climate change, empower them with new mobility solutions that match their changing needs, and defend the competitiveness of European industry," Do speed limiters, as proposed, meaningfully contribute to achieving those objectives?
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoWhen the issue is supported by random claims that no one cares to check, why can’t the solution?
- Gare 2y agoWell, all that mandatory tech does make the cars more expensive...
- throw_a_grenade 2y agoThis system is already in use for lorries, which are hard limited (like the last option described in TFA — engine loses power if driver attepts to accelerate beyond the limit). It's an absolute hell for other users of the road, because they're hard limited to 100 km/h, even on roads where the legal limit is higher. Now the problem is, no two vehicles have exactly the same limit, it varies a noticeable amount, so inevitably one lorry driver will attempt to overtake another one — with speed difference below 1 km/h, at about 100 km/h where legal limit is 140 km/h. It takes about 2 min and usually causes 2-3 km "jams" on motorways.
- eschneider 2y agoI'm curious what the Venn diagram of folks who think this is a hard problem and folks who thing self driving is doable looks like.
- seydor 2y agoIt might be more prudent to mandate self-driving
- masterj 2y agoHacker News: This is absurd! The tech doesn't exist! Reality: It's existed for years, and has already been successfully tested in pilots https://www.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/027-23/mayor-adams-results-successful-pilot-program-reduce-speeding-hard-braking-in https://www.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/027-23/mayor-ad... Sometimes you should try looking at the real world instead of trying to assume from first principles.
- Zigurd 2y agoAt about 1.4 million annually, and roughly half are people not in cars, it's only surprising cars and speeds are not more closely regulated. Instead, vehicle makers are allowed to raise the hood line on trucks because it's macho. Which causes more death and worse injury.
- skrebbel 2y agoI’d hate for this to become mandatory but at the same time you’ll pry my Ford’s slightly intelligent speed limiter from my cold dead hands. If this change in law means that somehow cars become better at reading speed limit signs (radio signals on roads or sth? maintained by the people who put up the signs? no idea but this gives it a mandate), then I’m only going to love it more. Though if they make it obligatory to turn on and/or annoying, i’m going to be angry. That shit is going to only make Audi drivers more frustrated than they already are.
- 8xeh 2y agoPlease make speed limit signs broadcast speeds by radio! That would be incredible. If the road noise outside my house gets too loud, I can transmit a lower speed limit instead of turning up my TV.
- morgunkorn 2y agoWe're driving a Tesla Model 3 refresh 2024, and it has the speed nag at every start up. It also has a lot of wrong speeds for portions of roads around our place. Sometimes it's temporary speed limits that were set during road construction and then never went away, sometimes it doesn't understand that you left a type of road and went onto another one with a different default speed limit, it's pretty infuriating. And that's a car that has cameras all around, onboard image analysis software and permanent internet connection. I can't imagine how that'd even work in cars with less capabilities.
- monort 2y agoThis law makes an intelligent speed limiter mandatory to be present in a car, but it does not currently require it to be activated. The software for road sign recognition is currently of poor quality, making a mandatory system impractical. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=PI_COM:Ares(2021)2243084 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=PI_...
- randerson 2y agoThis might be effective if all existing cars on the road were somehow retrofitted with speed limiters. But what we'll see instead is an even more dangerous combination of people in older cars (the majority of cars) speeding while people in newer cars are causing a dangerous speed differential in the flow of traffic. Not to mention the economic impact this could have on on new car sales when people decide en masse that they'll just hold onto their old cars without limits for longer.
- CodeWriter23 2y agoNext step: frustrated by variances between acutal and reckoned speed limits, consumers demand the limit is returned by an authoritative government API. Of course, authentication will be required to prevent abuse Next next step: speed API uses social credit score as an input and imposes lower limit for those disfavored by credit system
- hofo 2y ago> Starting in 2022 all newly introduced car models in the EU have had Intelligent Speed Assist (ISA) installed, but now all new vehicles must feature them. Huh? What’s the difference between “installed” and “featured“ here?
- grujicd 2y agoI think the difference is between "only new models" and "all new vehicles". So previously you could buy a new car, just model from a year or two ago without this tech. Now these cars can't be sold any more.
- penguin_booze 2y ago2024 must be the year of the speed limits (cue: Year of the <animal> in Chinese calendar), or something is in the waters. Right now, in the UK, there's an enthusiastic drive to convert roads to 20mph. And now this, from the EU.
- gnicholas 2y agoIt seems understood that people typically go about 5-10 MPH over the limit. I assume that speed limits are set with the knowledge that this is common. If technology like this becomes widespread and results in the actual speeds more closely matching the posted limits, will the speed limits eventually be increased, since it was always understood that people could safely drive a bit faster than the old posted speeds? Secondly, I remember hearing that some car companies calibrate their speedometers to be a bit conservative (reporting a higher speed than is actually being driven), in part so they aren't sued by customers who get tickets. If different cars show different speeds, what will this do to the flow of traffic? Will everyone end up going as slow as the most heavily down-calibrated vehicles?