3 ms·
Tesla parental controls keep teenage lead feet in check
- ajross 2y agoI'm a Tesla-owning parent whose first child will be receiving their license in a few months. And... this is cute, but I think most of its value is in marketing via press hits like this (which push "High Tech Gadget-filled Supercar" narrative). Actual driving safety is a boring and fairly well-understood problem. And if a kid can get in trouble in the family minivan or crossover (and they absolutely can) they can in a settings-crippled Model S too. As far as real policy goes: he'll be driving the 12-year-old minivan primarily for the first year or so. Not because of genuine safety concerns (he's actually a pretty cautious kid) but just because new drivers get in a lot of wrecks and we'd rather that happen in the car that's cheaper to fix and easier to replace.
- Taek 2y agoEvery kid is different. In highschool I had plenty of friends that would be way more dangerous (to themselves and others) in a fast car than in a speed limited car. Does that make the car safe? Well, in relative terms, yes it does. Probably 100x less likely to cause fatality for specific kids. Not yours maybe, but a lot of them. Parents usually know if that's their kid or not. There are plenty of signs.
- ajross 2y ago> Probably 100x less likely to cause fatality for specific kids. FWIW, that's ridiculous. If a popular car showed a 100x increase in fatalities for some common demographic, that would show up in the data. Sites like HN would be away in "Teen Boy Killer" Tesla articles. It's not. I won't speak to the anecdata, clearly some kids want to drive fast. But speed on regular roads is limited by the roads, not the car. A Corolla or Outback is no less capable of reaching those speeds, its just takes 3-4 seconds longer to do it. That's the kind of delta that, sure, might show up in the data if you look hard (it's a solid hypothesis), but 100x is nonsense.
- _mlbt 2y agoA wreck in the old minivan is financially less expensive, but isn’t the Tesla much safer for your child in the event of an accident? I can replace my car with insurance, but I can’t replace my kid. https://www.tesla.com/VehicleSafetyReport https://www.tesla.com/VehicleSafetyReport
- ajross 2y agoIncrementally. EV's with their very low c.g. and high mass are indeed really safe, but frankly so are minivans. If the choice was the Model Y or a 1970's Jeep or whatever, then the calculus might be different. I don't sweat that stuff, it's the same logic that keeps kids in booster seats long after their friends are riding shotgun.
- throwway120385 2y agoIn a lot of cases adding your child as a primary driver to a very expensive car will significantly increase the cost of the insurance. My brother quadrupled my father's insurance price, for instance, because he was a teenager. Most people can't afford to just eat the increased monthly, so they have to balance the need to have their kid be functional in the real world with the need to make sure their kid is "safe." A lot of older vehicles are still fairly safe in common accidents, as "older" in many cases means driver and passenger airbags, seat belts, crumple zones, and so on. I think the most you can say here is that you can afford to have your kid drive the Tesla. Many people can't. I could make some points about how the NHTSA values occupant safety over the safety of people in other cars but that's a totally different discussion.
- FireBeyond 2y agoThese stats are garbage though, and there have been so many analyses of the statistical and logical flaws in Tesla's reporting that there's no way that it's not at least knowingly misleading, at this point. That being said, Teslas ARE safe vehicles. They are regularly in the top tier for IIHS safety reports. I don't mean to decry that. But that particular page has issues.
- itishappy 2y agoI definitely took my minivan unintentionally off-road once or twice, but I drove a lot more responsibly in it that I would have in a Hellcat because it lacked the performance to do anything else. A Model S is a unique vehicle, it has more than enough power to get you out of a lot of traditionally sticky situations and (in my admittedly limited experience) its drivers know this and drive like it. I guess I'm saying that if I had a kid I'd prefer them to learn the capabilities of a more average car before moving on to a sports car. Habits are a safety feature.
- snapcaster 2y ago>it has more than enough power to get you out of a lot of traditionally sticky situations what does this mean? I'm thinking you're saying you can easily flee the police pursuing you but I'm guessing I just misunderstood
- itishappy 2y agoLOL, not what I meant! An example of what I mean is merging next to an 18 wheeler. In most cars including my ol' minivan that takes a somewhat concerted effort. Pick a slot, match speed, communicate intent. A Tesla (or any sports car, really) doesn't need to do any of that. You can just lay on the accelerator because you can reasonably assume that you'll always be able to outmaneuver the other vehicle, and drivers often do. I don't blame them, it's way more fun that way. My argument is that a big part of learning to drive is building understanding and empathy for the other inhabitants of the road, and sports cars don't do a good job of this.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoI actually strongly disagree. My first accident occurred because I accidentally spun the wheels on a rainy night while trying to get to highways speeds. This was an SUV we used for towing. Rear wheel drive with lots of power. I wasn’t messing around or driving recklessly, I just put too much power in poor conditions and I downshift broke the tires free. Since either was rear wheel drive, we fish tailed into the ditch. It would have been nearly impossible for me to do that in a minivan. Even if I could have gotten enough power out, the front wheels would have broken loose in a much more predictable and recoverable manner.
- _mlbt 2y agoAs a father of an about to be 16 year old, this is a very welcome and potentially life saving feature. I was already considering a Tesla for my next vehicle, but this makes it all the more appealing.
- mentos 2y agoMy only hesitation with this if there is a life saving reason to go faster. Maybe a simpler solution is to just send notifications when the car exceeds certain limits?
- mbg721 2y ago...At which point the panicky parent needs to have enough restraint to sit and stew and get the story later, rather than immediately phoning a teenager who's driving fast in a life-saving situation.
- jerlam 2y agoSometimes it is better for kids (and adults) to make mistakes and get the proper punishment, than to prevent them from making mistakes at all. It gets a little greyer when the mistake can lead to death or permanent injury though.
- xattt 2y agoA delta-V limit would be “constant” in that the teenager would build it into their mental model of how a car drives, and take it into account if/when exceptional circumstances do occur. The greater risk comes from the car spinning out of control from a standstill because of enthusiastic acceleration. As for safety, it’s not often we need to outrun a pyroclastic cloud/tornado/airplane crashing into your path.
- 39896880 2y agoWhat is an example of a life saving reason to go faster? What are the chances of that situation happening vs a situation where the young driver will exceed the speed limit and cause injury?
- matheweis 2y agoAsked for this 5 years ago, nice to see it finally implemented! https://x.com/matheweis/status/1109106624612859904 https://x.com/matheweis/status/1109106624612859904
- MBCook 2y agoFord has had this ability on many of their cars for years. It’s called MyKey. You can program a keyfob so the car has various limits and safety features can’t be disabled. Seems like a nice system. I was surprised I’d never heard about it until I bought a Ford and found it in the manual. I wonder if any other manufacturers have something similar. https://www.ford.com/support/how-tos/keys-and-locks/mykey/mykey/ https://www.ford.com/support/how-tos/keys-and-locks/mykey/my...
- fred_is_fred 2y agoVolvo has this: https://www.media.volvocars.com/us/en-us/media/pressreleases/268578/every-volvo-model-now-comes-with-a-112mph-speed-limit-and-care-key https://www.media.volvocars.com/us/en-us/media/pressreleases...
- cmcaleer 2y agoWhere I qualified, there’s a mandatory speed limit of 45mph on all roads (even motorways) a year after qualifying. When I was finally free of this I had absolutely zero respect for why speed can be dangerous and how. The rules had created the incredibly dangerous combination of experience driving but no experience driving at speed, and teenager brain. Shackles off, I drove at 60mph on country roads. It was always fine! Just like when I did 45mph everywhere! Until it rained, and at a tight corner I nearly wrapped myself around a tree. I didn’t fully appreciate the speeds I was going to be doing because I never was trained at them. I had no idea how it actually felt and how to understand when I could use speed and when I could lay off, because the limit was there. It was so suffocating that I never really experienced understeer or circumstances where I was in danger, because the mollycoddled experience hid me from understanding what those dangers are and how to anticipate and prevent them. Limiting speed is an answer, but I don’t really think it’s a good answer. The most dangerous crashes (rural) will still happen and be easily fatal at 70mph. Trainee pilots will get put in dangerous feeling situations all the time; the instructor can put the plane into a stall or a dive - a terrifying situation that you should never put yourself in in the first place - and teach you how to recover. I always thought driving instruction could do with something like that, because while learning to recover a plane is a lesson in and of itself, experiencing that sinking feeling and imagining it in circumstances where you’re under less control is a crucial lesson and disincentive. Instead, youths experience that lesson when they see a rapidly approaching tree or brick wall instead of a tire wall.
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoPersonally, I think it's way too easy to get a license in the USA. In many states, driver's ed isn't even mandatory, so people get taught by their parents, which leads to massive gaps in education and in many cases, incorrect driving habits getting passed down between generations. For example, a friend of mine had his mom tell him to just stay in the left lane on the highway if his exit isn't coming up, training him to be a passing lane camper. Not only should driver's ed be mandatory, but it should include a LOT more hands-on driving in bad situations, not to mention make them do something like an emergency stop test in both dry and wet conditions so they can understand the increased stopping distance and potential loss of control when slamming the brakes on water. I'd even like them make drivers do a basic slalom course in both a small sedan or hatchback and a large SUV so they can possibly get an appreciation for different handling. My local raceway has a car control course for training people how to control a skid [0]. I think this kind of training should be a mandatory part of earning a license. [0] https://www.prodrive.net/car-control-and-defensive-driving-course https://www.prodrive.net/car-control-and-defensive-driving-c...