5 ms·
US blocks British court from British territory
- karol 2y agoMy guess is, this only scratches the surface of what goes in various military bases and research establishments around the world.
- cturner 2y agoThis is a beat-up. The US has a lease on the territory, and it is their prerogative to control access. The British would not have let Chinese lawmakers into Kowloon during the lease. The US would not let Cuban lawmakers into Guantánamo Bay, also leased.
- throwaway4good 2y ago“Leased”
- throwaway4good 2y agoHow can anyone think that Hong Kong new territories and Guantanamo, which were areas essentially taken by force and then had a dubious leasing agreement painted over them, is the same situation as an agreement between two formal allies?
- defrost 2y agoLikely because: Between 1968 and 1973, the Chagossian (Îlois) inhabitants were forcibly expelled from Diego Garcia by the UK Government so that a joint US/UK military base could be established on the island. Many were deported to Mauritius and the Seychelles, following which the United States built the large Naval Support Facility Diego Garcia, which has been in continuous operation since then. In 2019, this action and continued British administration of the archipelago were deemed illegal by the International Court of Justice in The Hague, a ruling the United Nations General Assembly supported. In 2023, Human Rights Watch condemned the action as a crime against humanity.
- PeterHolzwarth 2y agoAn important detail to add to that, to ensure a complete picture is created of the situation, is that originally the atol was uninhabited. The French created a colony there of 60 or so people and slaves.
- defrost 2y agoIt was uninhabited in 1519, over 500 years in the past. In the interest of completeness both Great Britain and North America were also once uninhabited.
- eesmith 2y agoUmm, "people and slaves"? Do you really consider slaves to not be people? Also, originally Iceland was uninhabited. The Norse created a colony there of - as you put it - "people and slaves". That equivalent history surely does not affect the legal status of the descendants of those people now living in Iceland. Why should it affect the people now living in the BIOT?
- sociorealist 2y ago[flagged]
- fmajid 2y agoPretty much the same situation as Guantanamo Bay in Cuba.
- bell-cot 2y agoThis sounds like a prime example for arguing that our current international legal system is broken. The "territory" in question is a tiny, isolated island - which is a US/UK military base. The people are refugees from a vastly larger island, a thousand-ish miles away. Doubtless the military folks would prefer that civilian authorities quietly take the refugees off their hands, and away from their tiny island base. But Because Laws, nothing sane is allowed to happen. And meanwhile, the Britain's just-elected new PM, with a massive majority in the new Parliament, started his legal career as a human rights lawyer.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoAnything is allowed to happen in reality. The situation is the result of who wants or does not want to do what.
- bell-cot 2y agoTechnically, yes. But when the legal system is working well, this kind of indefinite-prisoners-in-limbo crap does not happen.
- ndsipa_pomu 2y ago> And meanwhile, the Britain's just-elected new PM, with a massive majority in the new Parliament, started his legal career as a human rights lawyer. I don't think that Starmer can do much for this situation even if it was on his list of priorities. Even if he declared the island(s) to be free from UK occupation, then the U.S. would still be blocking non-military people from accessing it.
- bell-cot 2y agoI'd say that Starmer could do quite a bit...but unless he found a particularly clever solution, the political cost would be too high. Leaving the bottom line the same, either way.
- ndsipa_pomu 2y ago
- e-t-u 2y agoUN decided couple of years ago that Diego Garcia is a part of Mauritius. Check the official UN map.
- csomar 2y agoThat's the "international" law order for you. Some people will still use these words with a straight face.
- cies 2y ago"rules based international order" (just as BS as "protecting democracy")
- snovv_crash 2y agoPossession is nine tenths of ownership.
- j16sdiz 2y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/28/un-court-rejects-uk-claim-to-chagos-islands-in-favour-of-mauritius https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/28/un-court-rejec... > The Foreign Office stressed it had not been a party to the maritime court proceedings and so was under no requirement to comply with the ruling. International law, ugh?
- account42 2y agoThe UN also thinks that Taiwan is part of China so I would not be to quick to follow their judgement.
- moomin 2y agoIn short: UK has no place there, US has no place there. A whole bunch of refugees probably do have a place there but no-one cares about them. Also crimes are probably being committed over and above what I’ve just described. In other words: situation normal in the Chagos Islands.
- etothepii 2y agoWhy does UK have no place there? The islands were uninhabited when settled by the French and following a peace treaty with France were transferred to the UK.
- defrost 2y agoBrief history: Diego Garcia is an island of the British Indian Ocean Territory, a disputed overseas territory of the United Kingdom also claimed by Mauritius. It is a militarised atoll just south of the equator in the central Indian Ocean, and the largest of the 60 small islands of the Chagos Archipelago. Portuguese sailors under Pedro Mascarenhas were the first Europeans to discover the island, finding it uninhabited in 1512. After a 1786 British colony failed, the French began using the island as a leper colony and, starting in 1793, coconut cultivation by enslaved labor. It was transferred to British rule after the Napoleonic Wars. It was one of the "Dependencies" of the British Colony of Mauritius until the Chagos Islands were detached for inclusion in the newly created British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) in 1965. More recently: Between 1968 and 1973, the Chagossian (Îlois) inhabitants were forcibly expelled from Diego Garcia by the UK Government so that a joint US/UK military base could be established on the island. In 2023, Human Rights Watch condemned the action as a crime against humanity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diego_Garcia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diego_Garcia
- PeterHolzwarth 2y agoKey is that: "The Chagos Archipelago was uninhabited when first visited by European explorers, and remained that way until the French established a small colony on the island of Diego Garcia, composed of 50–60 men and "a complement of slaves"." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsion_of_the_Chagossians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsion_of_the_Chagossians
- meheleventyone 2y agoThe comment you're replying to mentions that.
- cies 2y ago"In 2023, Human Rights Watch condemned the action as a crime against humanity." Yet the BBC fails to mention this in their 2024 article, instead they use this language to describe the event: "Britain took control of the Chagos Islands"
- brabel 2y ago
- fmajid 2y agoIn the 19th Century, the U.K. (and France, the US and others) militarily defeated China and imposed humiliating “unequal treaties” on it. Nowadays the US does the same to the U.K., e.g. an extradition treaty that gives US citizens far more leeway to fight extradition than the other way round. The occupation of Diego Garcia is just another example of the U.K. being America’s poodle.
- cies 2y agoSee how sneaky the language being used is crafted to not put blame on the UK: "Britain took control of the Chagos Islands, of which Diego Garcia is part, from its then colony, Mauritius, in 1965. It went on to evict its population of more than 1,000 people to make way for the military base." -- BBC They "took control" (sound quite nice) and "evicted" (probably also the nicest word they could find). The intend is also clear: kick out the natives to make a military base in a place of the world far from their home-island. See how this language changes when Russia "takes control" of the Donbas. At least Russia claims to step up to rescue the Russian population of Ukraine that lives in a bordering region that Russia controlled not too long ago. Hence I consider the BBC to be tax paid UK state propaganda, not much better or worse than RT.com in Russia.
- beardyw 2y agoWhataboutism
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoI respond instead of reflexively downvoting. This is not an argument. And even if that one line could be considered one, it is lazy and does not address the point OP is making.
- beardyw 2y agoLaunching an attack on the authors of the article rather than joining the discussion about the topic appears to be a diversionary tactic.
- blibble 2y agothere weren't any natives as the islands were uninhabited when European explorers first encountered them
- cies 2y agoAt some point no humans existed on earth. But when the UK "took control" (a.k.a. invaded) there were inhabitants that apparently had to be "evicted" (a.k.a. expelled or forcefully kicked out). I believe the people that inhabit a place should have some say in their future.
- jmclnx 2y ago2036 ? With Climate Change, I doubt that island even support a military base on it then.
- maxglute 2y agoAlways interesting to see how people try to spin Diego Garcia vs PRC in SCS. Chagos/Diego Garcia case another reason why US will never ratify UNCLOS. Reminder there's now actual ITLOS ruling (as in official UN) against UK vs Mauritius. Also reminder that there is no actual formal ruling (as in ITLOS/ICJ) against PRC for SCS - PCA PH vs PRC is not formal UNCLOS case since PRC not subject to optional arbituation clause - hence ITLOS has no formal position on the case. PCA has the legal status of a high school essay. Post ITLOS Chagos ruling, UK (by connection US) is now worse violator of UNCLOS/international law than PRC in SCS... as in actual UN international law, not make believe rules-based-order law. Extra spicy drama now US/UK can't even maintain the rule-based-order wank between friends.
- onemoresoop 2y ago[flagged] by CIA?