3 ms·
the comment says 'they are proposing a bootloader, which can still let you modify the cmdline, (...) the bootloader is itself using the Linux kernel' possibly
by kragen 2y ago
the comment says 'they are proposing a bootloader, which can still let you modify the cmdline, (...) the bootloader is itself using the Linux kernel'
possibly you don't know this, but in order to run a kernel with a modified command line, the bootloader-kernel would need to run a second kernel, for example using kexec; linux doesn't have a useful way to modify the command line of the running kernel. that's why i interpreted the comment as saying that they are proposing using two separate kernels. in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40910796 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40910796 comex clarifies that they are in fact proposing using two separate kernels; the reason i was confused is that that's not the only configuration they're proposing
- nmstoker 2y agoWhat I know or don't know is irrelevant, because what matters is that your statement rests of bringing in external knowledge/assumptions, so it's clearly not what the commenter is saying (alone).
- mlvljr 2y ago[dead]
- Dylan16807 2y agoUsing external knowledge to interpret the meaning of sentences is how every communication works.
- nmstoker 2y agoIndeed, but accusing someone of saying something based on unstated external knowledge/assumptions is the original problem here. They just needed to say words to the effect of "taken with point X what you say implies Y" and it would be fine and much less accusatory.
- Dylan16807 2y agoI don't find "it sounds like you're saying" on a rather neutral technical topic to be very accusatory, personally.
- nmstoker 2y agoFair point. I should perhaps have said putting words in someone's mouth. Anyway far too much on this side point, I'll bow out here.