3 ms·
you seem to be saying that they are using two separate kernels, one for the bootloader and one for the final boot target the title text says 'Loaded by the EFI
by kragen 2y ago
you seem to be saying that they are using two separate kernels, one for the bootloader and one for the final boot target
the title text says 'Loaded by the EFI stub on UEFI, and packed into a unified kernel image (UKI), the kernel, initramfs, and kernel command line, contain everything they need to reach the final boot target' which sounds like they're not talking about using two separate kernels, one for the bootloader and one for the final boot target, but rather only one single kernel. possibly that is not the case because the actual information is hidden in a video i haven't watched
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40909165 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40909165 seems to confirm that they are indeed not saying what you thought
edit: they're proposing both configurations
- samatman 2y ago> It's just that the bootloader is itself using the Linux kernel This sentence does not say "the bootloader is itself another, separate, Linux kernel", so I'm not seeing him saying what you're saying he seems to be saying.
- kragen 2y agoalthough you stated your comment less aggressively, you don't have nmstoker's excuse of possible ignorance; you must have already known what i said in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40911469 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40911469
- comex 2y agoI watched the video. They have two different configurations, one where there’s only one kernel, one where there are indeed two separate kernels with one kexec’ing to the other.
- kragen 2y agothank you for your sacrifice and for the resulting correction to my error
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nmstoker 2y ago>> you seem to be saying that they are using two separate kernels, one for the bootloader and one for the final boot target This doesn't make sense. There's nothing in the post you responded to which could realistically be interpreted as making that point. And there haven't been any edits, which might have explained your confusion.
- kragen 2y agothe comment says 'they are proposing a bootloader, which can still let you modify the cmdline, (...) the bootloader is itself using the Linux kernel' possibly you don't know this, but in order to run a kernel with a modified command line, the bootloader-kernel would need to run a second kernel, for example using kexec; linux doesn't have a useful way to modify the command line of the running kernel. that's why i interpreted the comment as saying that they are proposing using two separate kernels. in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40910796 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40910796 comex clarifies that they are in fact proposing using two separate kernels; the reason i was confused is that that's not the only configuration they're proposing
- nmstoker 2y agoWhat I know or don't know is irrelevant, because what matters is that your statement rests of bringing in external knowledge/assumptions, so it's clearly not what the commenter is saying (alone).
- mlvljr 2y ago[dead]
- Dylan16807 2y agoUsing external knowledge to interpret the meaning of sentences is how every communication works.
- nmstoker 2y ago
- thom 2y agoTo be clear: the win here is that there's no longer duplicated (or worse - less capable and outdated) code to do the same things in both the bootloader and the kernel, however the two versions of that code might be deployed.