10 ms·
For the first time in more than 150 years, Alberta's electricity is coal free
- kalupa 2y agoNow it's mostly natural gas, instead! With a good chunk of wind, but the current government seems to dislike "renewables"
- dagmx 2y agoYep. The Alberta government has their head stuck in the sand (pun intended) around renewables as they existentially threaten their current economy. They have repeatedly shown that they’d rather double down than try and diversify. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/canadas-alberta-set-ban-renewables-projects-prime-land-report-2024-02-28/ https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/canadas-alberta-set-b...
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoTo boost your point - that is literally what the Alberta government has been doing. They instituted a seven-month renewable's pause to "evaluate" them (evaluating renewables in 2023????), which introduced a lot of investor uncertainty[1]. When the pause was over they introduced rules around preventing wind turbines and solar from being developed in areas to prevent obstruction in "viewscapes"[2]. [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-renewables-pause-moratorium-aeso-foip-1.7196943 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-renewables-pa... [2] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-viewscapes-buffer-zones-renewables-map-1.7145368 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-viewscapes-bu...
- xandrius 2y agoWhich is worse in terms of greenhouse emissions but it's something I guess. Instead of "natural gas", we should just switch to saying methane, which is what that generally is.
- gpm 2y agoNo? Methane produces less than half the CO2 per kwh than coal. Which is still bad, but not worse or as bad. https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- silverquiet 2y agoMethane burned for electricity is better than coal no doubt. But methane that escapes into the atmosphere is way worse than CO2 in the nearish term. And not every extraction company is super thrilled about proper containment.
- mminer237 2y agoA very small percent is not contained though, and even most vented is flared.
- silverquiet 2y agoI am under the impression that methane levels in the atmosphere have spiked significantly in the last decade or two, and the origin is not really understood. Extraction could be one source, but if it's from another source, that could be more bad news as it would mean that some tipping point has possibly been triggered. I'm far from an expert on this though.
- _aavaa_ 2y agoMost of the consciously vented is flared. However, the infrastructure leaks like mad and there have been no incentives incentive for the companies to fix it, it's a cheap invisible gas after all with almost all reporting being self reporting.
- gpm 2y agoReleased methane is 27-30 times worse than released CO2 per unit mass measured over the next 100 years of warming [1]. Burning methane releases 1 CO2 molecule per CH4 molecule (CH4 + 2O2 -> CO2 + 2H2O), or 2.743 it's mass in CO2 [2]. To make up the difference in CO2 you'd have to be losing ~5% of the methane to the atmosphere along the way from extraction to burning. Do you have reason to believe anywhere near that much is lost? "Worse than coal" has set a very low bar for how not-bad methane needs to be. [1] https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/understanding-global-warming-potentials https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/understanding-global-warmin... [2] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=molecular+weight+of+CO2+%2F+molecular+weight+of+methane https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=molecular+weight+of+CO2...
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoWell, it's hard to get someone to hate their source of income.
- nightowl_games 2y agoAs far as I understand it, the whole country is dependent on the tar sands, but the east still hates it.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoIs really not. I don't think there are any numbers justifying narrative, and numbers presented in this thread prove it. The dependency is really just Albertan advertising.
- speed_spread 2y agoCanada's economy is built on primary resource extraction and production in general but would have done fine without the tar sands. Most of the oil money leaves the country; the money that stays mainly fuels self-serving private agendas, pressuring other parts of the economy and stuffing politics. This could have been averted had a solution like Norway's state oil fund been adopted but would have been too socialist a measure for the empire to tolerate.
- nightowl_games 2y agoIs this not the analogous fund? https://edmonton.ctvnews.ca/heritage-fund-reaches-all-time-high-value-of-22-1b-1.6857531 https://edmonton.ctvnews.ca/heritage-fund-reaches-all-time-h...
- bryanlarsen 2y agoTheir current source of income. Alberta has more sun and more wind than any place else in Canada so renewables could be quite profitable to them in the future, but what government cares about anything further out than the next election? Alberta also used to be the only place in Canada where you could just build a solar power plant and hook it up to the grid with minimal red tape so had a massive advantage in terms of number of solar jobs. Also Alberta is next door to BC which has vast sources of hydro-electric power so it could easily trade solar & wind power to BC when the sun is shining and/or the wind is blowing in exchange for hydro power when it isn't.
- snarf21 2y ago“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” - Upton Sinclair
- MisterDizzy 2y agoLet's see how long it takes them to realize they should have gone with the latest nuclear power tech and will eventually be unable to meet demand with anything but coal or nuclear (unless something changes).
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoI'm wondering what scenario you're considering that natural gas won't suffice but coal will. Alberta is celebrating simply transitioning from one fossil fuel to another, slightly cleaner burning, one. They are certainly still struggling with renewables when they are needed the most, such as -35 at 7PM, long after the sun has gone down and the wind turbine's hydraulics are too cold to function safely and all our furnaces are running and everyone is cooking and doing laundry. This is also when nuclear isn't a great solution, as it's a huge spike in demand.
- adrianN 2y agoWhy would you let your hydraulics freeze?
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoSorry, I did some research, it's not just hydraulics, but at below -30 materials experience significant changes in strength and many become brittle and prone to breaking, demanding that they be shut down. My mechanic father has a saying - badly maintained stuff breaks down at -30 C, but everything can break at -40 C.
- adrianN 2y agoWell, then you'd better choose materials that are appropriate for the location. There are wind turbines in Antarctica. It's just a matter of engineering. https://www.fastcompany.com/90429887/sustainable-living-lessons-from-antarcticas-first-zero-emission-research-station https://www.fastcompany.com/90429887/sustainable-living-less...
- 2y ago
- photochemsyn 2y agoAlberta's tar sands are even dirtier than coal - because large amounts of natural gas are required to convert the tar sands into syncrude, which is like a crude oil that requires more refining to produce gasoline, diesel and jet fuel from it. The residue from tar sands refining is petcoke, which gets burned in regional power plants and exported overseas: https://skepticalscience.com/legal-fight-leave-dirtiest-fossil-fuels-in-ground.html https://skepticalscience.com/legal-fight-leave-dirtiest-foss... Since the coke is being exported to India and China for consumption in power plants there, there's zero change in the amount of fossil CO2 being pumped into the atmosphere, so any effort to promote this as 'cleaning up the tar sands' is just fossil industry greenwashing. https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news-and-insights/latest-market-news/2469505-canadian-coke-exports-rise https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news-and-insights/latest-marke...
- nightowl_games 2y agoAs far as I understand it, Canada's economy is wholly dependent on the tar sands.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoAlberta. Ontario and even Quebec and maybe BC actually have industry.
- soperj 2y agoBC has Coal as it's number 1 export, and logging a close second.
- mthoms 2y ago“Almost all of the thermal coal Canada produces comes from coal mines in Alberta and is exported, mainly to Asia, from ports in B.C.” https://globalnews.ca/news/10392382/canada-coal-exports/ https://globalnews.ca/news/10392382/canada-coal-exports/
- JamesCoyne 2y agoAlberta is somewhat unique within Canada, with electricity trading on a market operated by AESO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alberta_Electric_System_Operator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alberta_Electric_System_Operat...
- exacube 2y agoDoesn't Ontario's IESO also do this?
- bryanlarsen 2y agoNot really. Talking to energy producers, it's a lot easier to add new generation in Alberta than it is in Ontario.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoElectricityMaps zone CA-AB: https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/CA-AB?wind=false&solar=false https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/CA-AB?wind=false&solar=... Total fossil gas generation capacity is ~12.7GW. Seems straightforward to replace with solar, wind, batteries, and interconnects with neighboring grids. Wind and Solar Potential resource: https://www.pembina.org/pub/wind-solar-alberta https://www.pembina.org/pub/wind-solar-alberta
- tonyarkles 2y agoIf you're curious, you can actually see the real-time stats for what's going on in Alberta: http://ets.aeso.ca/ets_web/ip/Market/Reports/CSDReportServlet http://ets.aeso.ca/ets_web/ip/Market/Reports/CSDReportServle.... There's lots of solar and wind installed but wind right now isn't producing much at all. Solar's doing decent though!
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThanks for sharing that resource! ElectricityMaps parses it [1] for showing real time data as well as creating a data source for carbon intensity estimation models. Alberta has the most favorable wind and solar resources in Canada (citation in my root comment), so solving for the remaining fossil gas generation should occur in due time simply out of economics [2]. [1] https://github.com/electricitymaps/electricitymaps-contrib/blob/master/parsers/CA_AB.py https://github.com/electricitymaps/electricitymaps-contrib/b... [2] https://archive.is/2024.06.24-223854/https://www.economist.com/interactive/essay/2024/06/20/solar-power-is-going-to-be-huge https://archive.is/2024.06.24-223854/https://www.economist.c...
- generic92034 2y agoHonest question: Is it clear that wind really could not produce more electricity right now? Depending on the way producers are chosen and the net is "congested" the wind farms might just not be allowed to contribute.
- DowagerDave 2y ago
- neonate 2y agohttps://archive.md/sEZIL https://archive.md/sEZIL
- softfalcon 2y agoHey folks, I live in Alberta. This isn't as big of a win as you all think it is. We replaced coal burning with natural gas and gasoline burning power generation. For those who will say, "but Alberta has wind and solar!" please know that our current premiere (similar to a governor) is actively attacking all of our renewable energy investments. Her name is Danielle Smith and she's quite literally a former oil and gas lobbyist. The only reason this is being touted is because big oil in Alberta is happy we've switched over to burning their carbon emitter of choice. Take that into account when you read this feel good piece about Alberta being "coal free".
- nemomarx 2y agoHow much is natgas? I Do think it's still better than coal in terms of emissions and particulates and such.
- xxpor 2y agoActual gasoline? Unless you're talking about super-isolated northern communities on generators [which should still be using diesel rather than gasoline], that seems... insane.
- Symbiote 2y agoAs posted elsewhere anyway, Alberta doesn't have any oil-fired power stations: https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/CA-AB https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/CA-AB
- softfalcon 2y agoThey fire up gasoline generators when the load is high as a back-up to natural gas generation. There have been periods of rolling brown outs due to high industrial demand where I live. I know people in the industry and also watch the local news where they report that the gasoline backups have been activated and the brown outs should stop. Can confirm, they sometimes burn gasoline for power generation.
- jes5199 2y agoI'll still count it. Natgas is much cleaner than coal. And economics will eventually force their hand as solar costs continue to fall
- chollida1 2y agoIt is frustrating as someone who lives in Canada and has spend so much money to remove coal that India and China have said FU to the world and increased their coal usage. I guess given that those two countries are keeping Russia afloat by buying their oil it shouldn't be a surprise, but its still disappointing to see those countries choosing the path they did.
- Waterluvian 2y agoAs a Canadian it’s hard for me to be upset given we still emit far more carbon per capita than China or India.
- brailsafe 2y agoI suppose there could be worse problems though. According to Bloomberg, as of a few years ago there were more people in India who didn't have access to electricity at all than live in all of Canada, and not insignificant portion of our population is of recent Indian descent. This source reports ~10% of their population https://www.iea.org/reports/sdg7-data-and-projections/access-to-electricity https://www.iea.org/reports/sdg7-data-and-projections/access... As a Canadian (but not Albertan) I've never had direct access to the residual economic effects of oil resources, or the slight tax offset that comes with having no Provincial Sales Tax, aside from general gov redistribution. I've never not had electricity, and I've never not had renewable electricity, which is quite remarkable.
- azinman2 2y agoBut would that be true if Canada had 1 billion people?
- rootusrootus 2y agoIIRC most people's carbon emissions come from transportation, electricity, heat. My guess is the efficiency of scale at ~40M is within spitting distance of what it would be at 1B. So it ought to scale linearly, for the most part?
- bastien2 2y agoUnfortunately they did it by switching to natural gas instead of the massive sustainable buildout they needed. Good job on reducing thorium and uranium emissions, at least.
- Gibbon1 2y agoOther hand when talking about functional operation. Solar, Wind plus Nat Gas works well together. Where Solar, Wind plus Coal doesn't. It's technically easy to shutdown, restart, and take Nat Gas plants in and out of standby to make up for shortfalls in solar and wind production. Where you can't do that with coal and nuclear for both technical and economic reasons.
- DowagerDave 2y agoNote: even though this is published by a large and pretty well respected newspaper it's an op-ed piece from a left-leaning environmental organization (which should be obvious if you read it). Dropping coal is pretty different from dropping fossil fuels, especially right now when natural gas is dirt cheap. It's also debatable if Alberta currently needs any more solar or wind; what we definitely need is storage for these generative sources. The other components of industrial use and transportation are probably more effective targets for big wins than getting gas out of the electricity grid.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoDue to its abundant wind & solar, Alberta could easily get to ~70% renewable generation without any storage. So until Alberta hits that 70% mark, investing in a dollar on wind or solar generation will provide far more fiscal and decarbonization return than investing that dollar in storage. Similar, investing a dollar in wind & solar will pay itself back very quickly. Investing that dollar into transport or industrial decarbonization will have a much longer return.