4 ms·
Is there somewhere where a government created scarcity of licenses actually works? The only things I can think of is resource specific activities (e.g. hunting
by protomyth 14y ago
Is there somewhere where a government created scarcity of licenses actually works? The only things I can think of is resource specific activities (e.g. hunting licenses).
- crazygringo 14y agoWell it makes sense to limit the number of NYC cabs -- except for the hour of handoff (~5pm) and in particular neighborhoods at night (Theater District, Greenwich Village, etc.), the number of cabs seems pretty good. If anyone could drive a cab, the profession might only barely pay a living wage, as each driver would get less passengers, and you'd get a race to the bottom -- and the streets would be more congested too. To me, the biggest question with taxis is scheduling and demand -- how to get extra cabs to the places/times people need to take cabs from, and the fact that this isn't really compatible with people who want to drive a cab on a predictable block schedule.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gruseom 14y ago"If anyone could drive a cab, the profession might only barely pay a living wage" According to the article, it hardly does that now: shortly after the most recent fare raise in 2006 [...] an independent consulting company found that drivers’ take-home pay for a 12-hour shift averaged $158. (Last year the NYTWA calculated it at $96.) By all accounts, it’s slipped since. So, something around $10 per hour. I don't think that drivers' quality of life is motivating this policy.
- jacobolus 14y agoBasically, all the surplus that was supposed to go to drivers via the license restriction has instead been sucked off by a rent-seeking financier class.
- gruseom 14y agoOne small healthy sign is that the terms "rent-seeking" and "financialization" seem now to have entered the lexicon.
- jrockway 14y agoTo me, the biggest question with taxis is scheduling and demand -- how to get extra cabs to the places/times people need to take cabs from, and the fact that this isn't really compatible with people who want to drive a cab on a predictable block schedule. I agree. I've never successfully gotten a cab to take me to LGA, for example. (Someone is getting them, though, because I've never not gotten a cab from LGA.) The distribution throughout the city is also strangely uneven. I used to live a 6th/27th and even at 3 am on a Tuesday, 6th Ave. was densely packed with cabs. But over in Brooklyn Heights where I live now, I think I've seen a cab once or twice. The one time I took a cab in Brooklyn, I had to explain to the driver how to get to a major through street. (The explanation was: "I never leave Manhattan.") Overall, it doesn't work very well, and 99.99% of the time I take the train. Much cheaper anyway.
- dandelany 14y ago> I agree. I've never successfully gotten a cab to take me to LGA You probably already know this, but always get in the cab first (if possible), then tell them you're going to LGA. Cabbies aren't allowed to turn down a fare in city limits once you're already in the cab. If they protest, snap a photo of their badge # and tell them you know the law - most will give up and take you where you want to go. It's a pain in the ass, but you gotta do it sometimes.
- jrockway 14y agoYeah. Now that I live in the city, I am perfectly comfortable saving $35 and just take the bus. Slow, but I'd just be reading my book in the terminal anyway.
- rg 14y ago"If anyone could drive a cab, the profession might only barely pay a living wage, ..." That isn't the case in London, widely thought to have the best taxi service in the world. There, anyone can pass a demanding standard examination and having done so can drive a cab. Anyone can build a vehicle that meets a standard inspection, and once passed that vehicle can be used as a cab. No limit on the number of drivers, no limit on the number of taxis, both inspected but not limited. The result is that different drivers work different convenient hours, some full time and some part time, with larger numbers of cabs available at rush hours and other times of heavy demand. All the drivers know how to drive well, all the taxis are clean and in perfect shape, and there's always one available when you need it. This is what makes it truly possible to live better in central London without a car than with one. All the schemes to forbid more competitors simply hand profits to taxi operators and produce poor service for taxi users. As usual, government regulations are captured by the regulated industry to exclude competitors.
- gruseom 14y agoa demanding standard examination This test is legendary. There was an interesting study done on the brains of the drivers who pass it: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2011/12/08/acquiring-the-knowledge-changes-the-brains-of-london-cab-drivers/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2011/12/0...
- andyjsong 14y agoI wonder if GPS has downplayed the role of having to memorize the streets of London.
- 1123581321 14y agoGood question. It has not changed because of that. Drivers are supposed to be able to immediately choose routes without consulting any kind of map.
- ams6110 14y ago
- te_chris 14y agoI'm pretty sure in auckland anyone can drive a cab. Seems to work.
- A1kmm 14y agoAuckland has a different system to the medallion system, but still has restrictions: * The driver needs to have an endorsement on their drivers' license allowing them to operate a small passenger service vehicle. To get this, they need to pass a 'fit and proper person test' (which disqualifies many people with past convictions) and have completed a course. * The driver needs to be employed by an approved passenger service. It currently costs NZ$449.80 to apply to start a new one - the laws about when the government must grant them are here, http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1998/0110/latest/DLM434609.html and there are no direct limitations on the number of taxis.