4 ms·
Montana Has More Cows Than People. Why Are Locals Eating Beef from Brazil?
- ohmyiv 2y agoGift link: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/13/business/montana-meat-old-salt-co-op.html?unlocked_article_code=1.5E0.NRWv.U_aG7xiWxC2z&smid=url-share https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/13/business/montana-meat-old... Archive: https://archive.is/20240613074737/https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/13/business/montana-meat-old-salt-co-op.html https://archive.is/20240613074737/https://www.nytimes.com/20...
- jeffbee 2y agoThe ribeye steak on their site is $25/lb and the USDA national weighted average price for bone-in ribeye is $8.67/lb as of yesterday. That's the reason. No long-form article needed. My nearest independent butcher charges $39/lb for same. There's no question that meat prices at small outlets are far above those of the giant international meat packers.
- throwup238 2y agoYep that was my first thought when I visited their site. Here in SoCal where the cost of living is high, a Costco prime ribeye is $15-20/pound and a ribeye at the Halaal supermarket butcher is $6-10/pound depending on whether it’s a steak or roast. Prime top sirloin is $10/pound at Costco or (ungraded) $6/pound at the supermarket, compared to $18/pound at the Co-op. Most people in Montana can’t afford to eat beef like that unless they get a quarter or half of a cow from a local farmer at a fraction of the price.
- Amezarak 2y agoI've always been interested in what exactly goes into the economics of steak pricing. A whole beef makes a lot of steaks, and obviously the processing cost is not relevant - it all costs the same, which I get my cows they turn into as much steak as possible, then ground beef.
- azinman2 2y agoMarin sun farms sells butchered quarter/half cows for $6-7/lb. So not only is that cheaper the ribeye steak it’s way higher quality too. Unfortunately you’re buying in bulk and freezing.
- Amezarak 2y agoThere's some serious upcharging here in the article. I pay $3.50/lb for all cuts in the southeast from a local farm, grass-fed grass-finished.
- grogenaut 2y agolike a sibling I paid around $4.25 / lb butchered and packed for a grass fed quarter cow in 2023 in Seattle. Farmer just advertises on craigslist and beef is great. you can also find them by asking at the rural meat packer who is selling.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI love the idea of buying local, but am always frustrated with the price. I intuitively want to think that vertically integrating and cutting out several middle men, and selling locally would reduce the price. Especially when I hear so much about distributors gouging farmers. For some reason, this never seems to be the case. Out of curiosity, I checked out the old salt store and they sell Tri tip for $16-20 per lb. I buy tri-tip on sale for $4/lb, and sometimes $3/lb. The interesting bit is that I was recently in Switzerland, where it is common for farms to sell meat and dairy direct to the public. I noticed that the there the farm meat and cheese was 25-50% less than the super market. Taken together, this really leaves me wondering what the difference is between these markets.
- solarpunk 2y agoprocessing. https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2024/january/concentration-in-u-s-meatpacking-industry-and-how-it-affects-competition-and-cattle-prices/ https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2024/january/concentrat...
- s1artibartfast 2y agoLooks to be an interesting article, but I dont understand which side that comes down on or how it fits into the big picture. A big gap between farm price and wholesale would support the idea that farmers could be competitive by cutting them out. Indeed, it sounds like more are because farmers (or feedlots) are creating new processors. Alternatively, if huge processors are hyper efficient, then what is going on in Switzerland? Why could I buy local meat and milk that was half off the market, and even cheaper than the US from farms?
- yuliyp 2y agoThis is just a puff piece for yet another lifestyle/marketing-based luxury food service that you see advertised all over the place. They're trying to sell their meat as a luxury item at luxury prices, shipping it in small parcels across the country vs the economies of scale of the larger industry. Works for wealthy people, impractical to participate in for everyone else.
- everybodyknows 2y agoThe Times eats it up. Consider this: > In the next five years, Old Salt’s goal is to sell meat to 10,000 families around the country each year, up from around 800 now. It won’t be easy: Americans are used to purchasing ground chuck from the grocery store, not from a website. But of course only locals can buy ground beef from Old Salt's website, by picking it at the company's refrigerators, for obvious reasons. Though the web site nicely obfuscates this: https://www.oldsaltco-op.com/collections/fresh-cuts-ground/products/ground-beef https://www.oldsaltco-op.com/collections/fresh-cuts-ground/p...
- jlund-molfese 2y agoThe headline and some of the supporting quotes talk about eating locally-produced beef in Montana and the environmental benefits. But then, apparently, the entire point of the company is to ship meat around the country in a copycat fashion, primarily outside of Montana, contributing to CO2 and plastic emissions? The story doesn’t make any sense.
- buescher 2y agoBecause they're poor. Same reason people in Idaho eat Oregon potatoes.
- beefnugs 2y agoGlobalism hurts everyone except capitalists. Western canada has a ton of high quality trees. So furniture companies should move to this place, buy cheap input materials, create local economy, add value in a healthy way, and profit properly. Instead locals trying to do anything are killed by global pricing and it destroys businesses. It costs thousands of dollars more than it should just to make a CRATE to ship anything else. Absolute the opposite of proper sustainable economy
- alister 2y ago> Why Are Locals Eating Beef From Brazil? To directly answer the question in the headline, it seems that almost all locally produced beef in Montana becomes an “anonymous commodity crisscrossing the country”, so the origin of the product you get at the supermarket is a sampling of the overall U.S. market, and Montana beef is only 1% of that. And Brazilian beef is more than 1% of the U.S. market, so Montanans are more likely eating Brazilian beef.
- electrodank 2y ago[flagged]
- ldehaan 2y ago[dead]
- tomohawk 2y agoPart of it is the EPA and other federal regulators treating small companies the same as the 4 oligopolists. https://nwmpa.com/epa-impact-statement/ https://nwmpa.com/epa-impact-statement/ We buy 1/2 a carcass worth of beef at a time from a small local place, and the cost is a lot better than costco. But we're worried at the immense pressure small shops like that are now under due to the enormous compliance costs for regulations that make little sense for the scale of work they do.