10 ms·
The EU should be the heat-pump pioneer
- dtx1 2y agoWe tried to do this by law in germany and it almost ended in a civil war.
- uniqueuid 2y agoThat's an overstatement. Also, people routinely rebel against the introduction of change, but soon become accustomed to it. For quite over a year, heat pumps have made up over 50% of new installs [1]. I don't think it's useful to focus too much on short-term pains here. [1] https://www.bdew.de/service/daten-und-grafiken/entwicklung-beheizungsstruktur-baugenehmigungen/ https://www.bdew.de/service/daten-und-grafiken/entwicklung-b...
- OKRainbowKid 2y agoAnd now, the leader of the opposition is attending heat pump PR events, after vehemently opposing the governments plans to promote heat pumps, claiming they were uneconomical. However, the damage is done.
- croes 2y agoPartially because of articles from a certain German newspaper which admitted they don't understand how heat pumps work.
- Maakuth 2y agoAre heat pumps economical heating sources in Germany? Power there seems very expensive and natgas cheap. No wonder if there's pushback if you have to do expensive renovation and you don't even end up with lower operational expenses.
- kuschku 2y agoHeatpumps can be powered by natgas as well. Heat pumps are just a compressor and a heating element for a defrost cycle. Gas powered compressors are relatively common, e.g. in camping trailer refrigerators. Also, even with Germany's relatively expensive electricity, heat pumps are economical after 15-20 years, which is good enough.
- Maakuth 2y agoWhile that's technically correct (the best kind of correct!), I doubt a lot of natgas heatpumps are being installed in homes at the moment. I suppose the real economics are going to be better, as you probably need to make gas more expensive by carbon trade or something in order to decarbonise. And electrical power should be very cheap.
- MarkCole 2y agoIt really depends on a lot of factors. For example if you have solar, how well insulated your house is, etc. I am currently renovating a house in Germany and had a quote for a heat pump system and a quote for a central gas heating system. The heat pump system was quoted at 66.000€, it would however be reduced by 24.750€ to 41.250€ as the government is currently giving a subsidy for these systems. The Gas system was quoted at around 18.000€. Both of the quotes included removing the old Oil Heating system and disposing of it. The Gas System included the price of connecting to the cities gas supply. I went with the Gas System, as not only the install would be cheaper, the running cost would also be substantially cheaper. Some electricity providers have a seperate tariff for heat pumps that is marginally cheaper. However even then my calculation was that a Heat Pump would only have a comparable running cost if I also invested in a large Solar install on the Roof.
- kuschku 2y agoAnd yet, like all the issues the conservatives rally against, once the law actually came into force, everyone stopped caring about it and now heatpumps are standard.
- blitzar 2y agoThe track record of the German people going to war over something is not great. They were probably on the wrong side (again) on this one.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 4ad 2y agoYep, they should be, and now they are anything but. In Austria at least getting AC installed in any urban environment is de facto impossible. There is no law against it, but you need various approvals from multiple parties that you will simply not get. Moreover, Austrians are very against AC in general for various reasons. I am trying to get AC installed and these are some of the responses I got: > Air the room properly, wrap a damp towel around yourself and get on with it. With energy prices like these, that's just throwing money out the window, not to mention the environmental impact. > I don't think it's bad yet. It's important to keep busy when it's hot, not to moan "it's so hot" and do nothing. Get used to the fact that it's getting hotter every year. Wear more clothes in the cold season. Get used to warmer clothes. Try to do more for the environment. Drive less, throw rubbish in the bin instead - don't get lazy, vote for parties that tackle the climate crisis and don't deny it. > I just sit around in my underwear and sweat, I prefer it. I can't even...
- debesyla 2y agoWhat kind of permits are required? Are AC installation also a problem for new buildings too?
- 4ad 2y agoIn fact it's even more of a problem for new buildings. For old buildings you can complain that the building is unsafe to live in without AC, but new buildings are required to be livable (<26C) without air conditioning, so it's very easy to get a blanket rejection for this very reason alone. Of course even though new buildings should be livable without AC, this is not true in practice. I live in a new building and right now I have 33C indoors inside my apartment. But some bureaucrat signed that it's 26C certified so who am I to complain!
- Gare 2y agoWow, ridiculous. In Croatia almost every condo built in the last 20 years has AC already pre-installed (or at least conduits and installation location prepared).
- 2y ago
- cpach 2y agohttps://archive.ph/EqHsG https://archive.ph/EqHsG
- xbmcuser 2y agoIts a long studied management theory that most companies in the lead in trying to protect its current profitable product ie cash cow hesitate in innovating as it would destroy their current products market share. This results in competitors coming from behind and out innovating them and stealing market share. This is what is happening to Europe and it's manufacturing industries
- rapsey 2y agoI mean a ton of heat pumps are being installed. New houses tend to have heat pumps. The problem is with old houses who already have a heating system installed, it is crazy to overhaul to a heat pump as the cost is not even close to being sensible.
- darkr 2y agoThis. The cost of installing and upgrading a big old drafty Victorian house to a COP 4+ efficiency where the running costs actually beat oil/gas would have a break even point way past the end of my lifetime.
- valenterry 2y agoNope, it's very simple. Just don't try to heat up water to heat the house. Use an aircon. In fact, their efficiency is even better. 4+ is already standard, 5+ is good and there are even models that go beyond 6. Only problem can be if you have a lot of tiny rooms - in that case it's expensive to install everything.
- darkr 2y agoThose figures are for the unit itself. It takes a lot less energy to heat air than it does to heat water, but water retains heat for much longer. What matters is the SCOP for the system as a whole. In a traditional Victorian house with a fireplace in every room, radiant heat will provide far greater efficiency than a forced air system, in which all of that warm air will literally go straight up the chimney.
- valenterry 2y ago> Those figures are for the unit itself. No. > What matters is the SCOP for the system as a whole. That's exactly what my numbers are. They are the efficiencies for moving the heat-energy from the outside air into the inside air, assuming constant 20 degrees celcius indoor temperature and a specifically weighted outdoor temperature (there are multiple types of SCOPs, depending on the climate-zone and I was refering to the moderate one as it is present in most of middle Europe). Whether you transfer the heat from the outside air (or some other medium) into the indoor air or into the indoor water does not matter - except that for the latter, you will need to consider that the water has to still transfer the heat to the indoor air, so you need to know how hot the water will have to be to calculate the SCOP correctly for your house. > In a traditional Victorian house with a fireplace in every room, radiant heat will provide far greater efficiency than a forced air system, in which all of that warm air will literally go straight up the chimney. What kind of "efficiency" are you even talking about? Can you please provide a definition and some example calculation? Otherwise it's meaningless to discuss.
- BiteCode_dev 2y agoYeah but there is heavy resistance. My mother won't install a heat pump because she claims she doesn't want to be dependent on electricity. She likes the idea that if it goes down, she can still heat her home. It is irrational because her gas burner needs electricity to run anyway, and if electricity shuts down, she lights a wood fire, which she could have as an alternative to the heat pump. Humans have religion-like behavior in every aspect of their life, not just God-related things. If you haven't heard about the French pushback against the linky, a smart electricity meter, google it. You will have a good overview of what can go wrong if we force the issue on people.
- nottorp 2y agoGas burners use little enough electricity that you can get an UPS for them though.
- BiteCode_dev 2y agoIndeed. Hence the religious aspect. She doesn't care about making sense. She cares about her stance on electricity heating.
- nottorp 2y agoThe point is you can plug it into an UPS and get 12 hours of heating without electricity working...
- epanchin 2y agoWe get a lot of power cuts. I have a UPS on the pump for my kerosene fired heating. We also have an aga which uses no power, just kerosene. I’m putting in underfloor heating powered with an air source heat pump, but leaving the boiler and radiators in place for midwinter and power cuts.
- BiteCode_dev 2y agoYou see, that's the rational approach: you got a problem, you find a solution. Most people don't do that. "I heard that..." "I believe that..." Is mostly the source of their decision making. Forcing heat pump on people will make them react like you are stealing from them. Because you are: you are stealing their ability to choose. But they choose badly.
- kkfx 2y agoHeat pumps prices here keep going UP, not down. The very same machine cost more after few years. There is no chance to keep up such conversion at these rates. I'm one of the few who have built a new home, all electric main car included, and yes even friends and parents told me it's a mistake, it will cost much more heating and cooling or it's even impossible to heat and so on. There is much resistance but the real point are prices. Similarly to BEVs. In other places prices drop, that's why sales goes up, here they do the opposite and that's why sales goes down.
- yyy888sss 2y agoPioneer? Nearly every home in the US already uses heat-pumps: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/technology-adoption-by-households-in-the-united-states?country=~Home+air+conditioning https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/technology-adoption-by-ho... In cold climates many people still use gas heating because its cheaper, making electricity cheaper would be the only realistic way to increase heat-pump usage in winter.
- blitzar 2y agoPractically every house in the world has more one (or more) ... a refrigerator.
- robertlagrant 2y agoYep. And quite a few have air conditioning as well.
- tordrt 2y agoWe don't use gas much for heating in northern Europe. At least not in Scandinavia, Iceland and Finland (Maybe Denmark is a small exception). Norway is also Europe's biggest gas exporter. I don't think gas heating is noticeably cheaper than heat pumps, but smaller upfront costs.
- moogly 2y agoYeah; gas is big largely in Germany, and even moreso in the Netherlands since they historically had an enormous gas field in Groningen.
- j1elo 2y agoThere's a saying that I've been hearing since being a kid, that heat pump sucks because it's just instantaneous heat but as soon as you turn it off, the heat disappears in an instant. Based on my experience, it's true. As for the other people. it must be true too, because the norm in my southern country is to have installed proper radiators all around the house. Family, friends, formal visits, I wouldn't be able to name even once in my life that I've been at someone's main place during winter without its proper radiator installation. And when it is turned off, the whole building is warm, not only the air in the living areas, so the place stays warm for a long time. So heat pumps exist but just as a "not very good" alternative, relegated for things like small secondary homes at the beach (where it doesn't get too cold anyway). EDIT- I was thinking about the aircon that on winter can be switched to output warm air. But reading replies I'm now learning that heatpump doesn't necessarily always mean air, but radiators could also be used!
- goralph 2y ago100% agree. I find the "passive" heating options like radiators or floor heating much more comfortable than being blasted by hot air from above.
- qalmakka 2y agoYou can have floor heating with heat pumps, too. Just heat up the water to a lower temperature (~40C) for longer. It's still way more efficient than burning gas.
- 2y ago
- darkr 2y agoAnother issue with heat pump rollout, at least in the UK is a severe lack of qualified heating engineers with a basic understanding of thermodynamic principles. Thus you get plumbers with experience installing gas boilers, resulting in poorly specified and installed systems that provide nowhere near the efficiency that they should reach. This then leads people to say “heat pumps don’t work” or “heat pumps are expensive to run”, which only feeds into the whole anti net-zero rhetoric.
- blitzar 2y ago> plumbers with experience installing gas boilers > without a basic understanding of thermodynamic principles. that when you have them come quote say “heat pumps don’t work” or “heat pumps are expensive to run”
- tyho 2y ago> This then leads people to say “heat pumps don’t work” or “heat pumps are expensive to run”, which only feeds into the whole anti net-zero rhetoric. Tell me, what is the average SCOP of heat pumps in the UK and what is the ratio between the price of electricity and gas?
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoArticle on this phenomenon, sometimes called the "spark gap": https://www.lowcarbonhub.org/p/spark-gap/ https://www.lowcarbonhub.org/p/spark-gap/ The UK is worst in Europe and has been as high as 4.7x recently, more than the average Heat Pump can overcome.
- darkr 2y agoIt would only need to be 4.7 to beat a gas/oil system that is 100% efficient. In reality, a very good gas based system that is well specified and installed might reach 80% as a whole. Most UK gas/oil heating systems are significantly lower.
- tankenmate 2y agoAccording to the Heat Geek (in the UK) their minimum is 3.5 and their current average is 4.4. I saw a video[0] they did with Urban Plumbers and they visited a new build (well insulated) where the SCOP was 2.2. The main reason it was so low was the heat pump was over specced (by almost 4 times!) and the pump was cycling constantly. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r70Pt6roE0o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r70Pt6roE0o
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- klabb3 2y agoCan this really be solved without proper insulation? I’m from a cold place with excellent insulation, and everywhere else I’ve been in the world, it subjectively feels like the heat is disappearing half an hour after turning off the heat source. This includes places that gets near freezing cold in winter. Like trying to empty a leaking boat with a bucket.
- dghughes 2y agoWindows are the worst. I'm constantly telling my mom to lock the windows in winter. They are meant to be locked. If not you can feel the heat escaping it's so cold next to the window. One was even up a few mm! Mom grew up on a farm in the 1950s in a big farm house that thing leaked air. It was so cold they used to put a heated brick in their beds to warm it before bedtime.
- reustle 2y agoIf it was wood fired, it was likely designed to leak air. I was somewhat surprised to learn that the steam heating all over NYC was designed to be used with the windows open.
- rkwasny 2y agoI don't quite get why we insist on air/ground<->water systems, instead of just using aircon and heating the indoor air directly?
- dghughes 2y agoHeat pumps move heat they don't make it. Air source heat pumps are at least 300% to 400% more efficient than just electrical resistance heat. Ground-source heat pumps are even more efficient. All you do is use a bit of electricity to power a pump and some fluid to move heat around no need to burn things. Even better if the power comes from solar, wind, hydro, nuclear.
- phicoh 2y agoI'm not an expert, by dry air has a very low heat capacity. So you get a house with cold walls, floor and roof. And the dry warm air is rather ineffective in transferring heat to the walls, floors, etc. In contrast, if you have underfloor heating, you have a relatively large surface filled with warm water that heats up the floor. And then you have an even bigger surface that transfers heat to the rest of the house. In the end the house is more easy to heat because it doesn't depend on an airflow to reach all parts the house.