3 ms·
My personal experience with "smart" thermostats is that my electric bill went up. By "smart" I just mean programmable. I had settings for morning, daytime (nob
by SoftTalker 2y ago
My personal experience with "smart" thermostats is that my electric bill went up.
By "smart" I just mean programmable. I had settings for morning, daytime (nobody home), evening, and night. It makes no sense but my total costs went up. This was years ago, so I don't remember exactly what temps I had set for the different times of day. Now I just set the A/C at 76 and leave it there.
- IneffablePigeon 2y agoWith heat pumps (like AC) and condensing boilers, it is often more efficient to run for longer and slower as long as that makes your appliance run more efficiently (lower flow temperatures for heating, higher for cooling). Requires the system to support modulation though.
- otherme123 2y agoLet me paint you a scenario where this is possible: you leave home at 9 AM, and the A/C stops. The house slowly gets hot, maybe 95°F. You plan to arrive at 9 PM, so you program the A/C to get the house to 76°F, which the thing thinks it can do in 1 hour at full blast. But the energy price between 8 PM and 9 PM is the highest of all day: you just programmed the A/C to the worst. Instead, now you leave it keeping 76°F, and the thing can do it working at 10%. You consume more energy at the end of the day, but the consumption is spreaded through the cheapest hours in the middle of the day, and only a small fraction of it is consumed in the expensive hours from 6 to 10 PM. This is how freezers work, cooling intermitently as the thermostate goes off limits. I would test if it is worthy money wise, not energy wise, to put the A/C at full blast in the cheapest hours. Say from 4 to 6 PM (the cheapest here in Spain), to get the house as cold as possible, and then try to play with A/C at maybe 5% letting it rise until reaching 76°F at 9 PM.
- baby_souffle 2y ago> I would test if it is worthy money wise, not energy wise, to put the A/C at full blast in the cheapest hours. Say from 4 to 6 PM (the cheapest here in Spain), to get the house as cold as possible, and then try to play with A/C at maybe 5% letting it rise until reaching 76°F at 9 PM. Depending on how big the house is and how well insulated it is, it very well may make for a big thermal battery and this would work well. If small and/or poorly insulated or drafty then this will not work well.
- catlikesshrimp 2y agoIsn't it less expensive and more ecofriendly to turn on the AC when you are actually there? Dumber would be smarter. Not to mention, you can be late, or early, or not arrive for the whole night.
- petre 2y agoNot always because it depends on many factors such as demand energy pricing. The house also has heat inertia, meaning it could take hours to reach a ceratin temperature, so you'd have to turn on the AC hours in advance before you arrive home.
- Scoundreller 2y agoCool thing is I don’t care about the temperature of the solid mass inside of where I am, just the air really. I know when I turn on the A/C in my office, it’s not going to cool the concrete wall/floors/ceiling much in the 8h I’m there before I shut it off for the day. And that’s fine.
- petre 2y agoThe solid mass inside the building, the walls and floors heat the air and the AC is working harder to keep up. Also exposed glass to direct sunshine that creates a greenhouse effect.
- kelnos 2y agoEco-friendly, possibly, buy cheaper? Maybe not. It depends on when you arrive home. If you arrive home during peak hours when your utility prices are higher, it can be cheaper to run the a/c earlier, while you're not home, to at least get the temperature down into the rough ballpark of where you want it, and then maintain that temperature into the peak hours. Even the eco-friendly bit isn't always clear, depending on your equipment. It might use less energy overall to maintain your desired temperature 24/7, even when you aren't there. Your particular equipment may run less efficiently if it has to go on full blast for an extended period of time to do a large temperature change when you first get home.
- amluto 2y agoAn A/C may also operate rather more efficiently when it’s modulated down than when it’s running at full blast.
- roenxi 2y ago> It makes no sense but my total costs went up. Due to inflation, the expected state is your costs will go up, even in the case of a small improvement in energy use. A number of western countries also seem to be in a state of energy crisis that could explain the price going up beyond inflation. So that is less informative than it could be. Did you see your real energy use rise?
- petre 2y ago> It makes no sense but my total costs went up It does make sense if you were scewing around with the temperature values in excess of 2°C, because the HVAC would work harder to reestablish a new steady state. Most houses have thermal mass and heat inertia and sometimes it takes hours to reach a new temperature set point, the HVAC working at full load to do so. It depends on many factors and it's not easy to optimize without logging the temperatures, the operating cycles of the HVAC and understanding the whole process.
- nottorp 2y agoIs there any defined way to do the math on this? I haven't been able to find even specific case examples showing which consumes less energy: turning down heating/ac when no one's home or just keeping it on constantly. I'm sure it's pretty complicated because buildings vary, but someone who understands heat transfer should be able to do it at least for a few ideal spherical cows... > daytime (nobody home) But that's so last century :) We WFH now.