6 ms·
Mechanical computer relies on kirigami cubes, not electronics
- bondarchuk 2y agoHave they made even a single working logic gate? The video only shows flipping bits back and forth by direct manipulation. Edit: I am happy to report yes: "Last, we explore the metastructure as simple mechanical logic gates. Figure 8 (C and D) demonstrates the achievement of both “OR” and “AND” logic gate operations by using independent bistability in local elements."
- passwordoops 2y agoThey do in the full paper (not open source & at this time no one's put it on archive): "Mechanical logic gates Last, we explore the metastructure as simple mechanical logic gates. Figure 8 (C and D) demonstrates the achievement of both “OR” and “AND” logic gate operations by using independent bistability in local elements. To facilitate the reading of output information (see more details in fig. S17A and the Supplementary Materials), we use a supported height-adjustable flat plate on the top to cover a small region of the platform. Its initial state is set as an output of “0.” When the plate is even and elevated, it outputs "1," otherwise "0" for the cases of either being tilted or lowered. The configurations of the top plate are determined by the pop-up ("1") or pop-down ("0") motions of three supports bonded to the bistable elements as inputs. A pyramid support denoted as P1 is placed in the center with two other neighboring supports surrounded, e.g., cuboids of S1 and S2 and pyramids of P2 and P3 for the OR and AND logic gate, respectively. Figure 8C and fig. S17B show that when P1 is popped up and fixed, popping-up either S1 or S2 or combined as inputs leads to a stable and evenly elevated plate on the top as an output of "1" for an OR operation, because one point contact at P1 alongside one plane contact at S1 or S2 will render a stable and even surface. For the case of AND logic gate shown in Fig. 8D and fig. S17C, three pyramid that supports Pi are free to pop up or down, providing the point contacts to support the top plate. Only when the plate is supported by three pop-up point contacts, i.e., P1 = P2 = P3 = 1, it will generate a stable and evenly elevated plate as an output of "1" for an AND operation. We note that most previous mechanical logic metastructures are limited to 1D and 2D structural forms (1–3, 11, 19, 20, 26, 29, 41). Our design extends the structural form of the mechanical binary logic computation to a 3D structural form. In Fig. 8 (D and E), we demonstrate the logic operation in only one zone. In particular, given the independent bistability of each local elements, such design principles can be readily applied to multiple zones for conducting a myriad of parallel mechanical binary operations on the same metastructure platform (see details in fig. S18). Moreover, by altering the structural components as schematically illustrated in fig. S19, we can also conduct “NOR” and “NAND” binary logic computations in our designed platform. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado6476 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado6476
- bondarchuk 2y agoThere's a link to the paper in tfa, it's open access.
- beachy 2y agoI believe a NAND gate is required as the base on which all other possible circuits can be built, so they need just to add an inverter for potential turing completeness.
- thih9 2y agoCould be either {NAND}, or {NOR}. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_completeness https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_completeness https://proofwiki.org/wiki/Functionally_Complete_Singleton_Sets https://proofwiki.org/wiki/Functionally_Complete_Singleton_S...
- mtizim 2y agoIt's not, we just use NAND everywhere because they're easier to make with transistors. You can get functional completeness with a NOR instead, or alternatively with some different combinations of other logical operators. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_completeness https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_completeness We even implement AND gates with NANDs in electronics (because they're way simpler), but we might not have to limit ourselves to a single base gate with mechanical computers.
- DrDeadCrash 2y agoI believe an inverter (not gate) is required...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Feathercrown 2y agoYou can route a wire to both inputs of a NAND or NOR gate to create a NOT.
- SanderNL 2y agoWhere do you think the N in NOR and NAND come from?
- ItCouldBeWorse 2y agoHas anyone ever done a society re-bootstrapping from "mechanical computation" back to working chips? As in-a planetwide em-event knocks out all computation- how do we get factories like TSMC back on track? How do we keep food production going? Could we recover from zero, using only this set of mechanical computers and basic instructions
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bondarchuk 2y ago>Has anyone ever done a society re-bootstrapping from "mechanical computation" back to working chips? Thankfully not, since it hasn't been necessary yet... At any rate I would guess mental arithmetic would be much more practical than mechanical computers, and then we could probably skip straight to vacuum tubes and punch cards.
- Teever 2y agoDon't forget about analog computers like mechanical integrators or the anthykra mechanism. Any device that would allow you to automate the production of devices like gears and cam shafts would greatly increase the bootstrapping rate.
- bondarchuk 2y agoA mold is such a device. Doesn't have to be a mechanical computer per se.
- hypercube33 2y agoReading this thread I feel like I'm alive in the Star Trek universe. yesterday an article about warp drive, now discussing rebooting society after a global event and optical computers... interesting
- abound 2y agoCollapseOS [1] comes to mind, but that's more about bootstrapping simple chips for directing power as opposed to rebooting society, but one could argue that the two go hand in hand. [1] http://collapseos.org/ http://collapseos.org/
- passwordoops 2y agoLink to the paper (sorry it's not open source!): https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado6476 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado6476
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 2y agoWhat are use cases of this? High radiation or otherwise extreme environments?
- bigbacaloa 2y ago[dead]
- snailmailman 2y agoOn Venus, the air corrodes any electronics incredibly quickly. Making it a difficult environment for spacecraft. With a mechanical solution, the parts can hopefully be more durable, as electrical conductivity could stop being a requirement.
- novaRom 2y agoI think similar approaches might be useful in micro-electromechanical systems (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MEMS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MEMS)
- hughlett 2y agoGo Pack!
- weakfish 2y agoinsert wolf hand sign It’s very neat to see an NC State article on here
- brotchie 2y agoNeal Stephenson’s The Diamond Age IRL
- grondilu 2y ago> Mechanical computers are computers that operate using mechanical components rather than electronic ones. For anyone who's excited about mechanical computers, perhaps it is worth reminding that an electron is about a thousand times lighter than a nucleon. Therefore, it's probably fair to say that mechanical computers will always be more energy consuming than electronic ones, because they fundamentally need to move atoms around to operate.
- jes5199 2y agosure, but how many electrons do we typically move around as a single signal
- dekhn 2y agoFew, if any; instead, it's typically the propagation of an electromagnetic wave that transmits a signal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_electricity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_electricity
- pyinstallwoes 2y agowhat is the electromagnetic wave made of, what's the substrate it is composed of and moving through?
- dekhn 2y agoThe wave is electromagnetic energy passing through a waveguide (typically copper) mediated by electrons. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waveguide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waveguide
- reaperman 2y ago“Few”, yes. But definitely some. I don’t think you can have propagation of EM wave through a conduit without at least pushing one electron into the conduit and removing one electron from the other side of the conduit.
- theturtle32 2y agoKinda reminds me of QAM
- tombert 2y agoIf I ever become a billionaire, I am going to have an entire big room in my house dedicated to pre-electric computers. It's amazing how much stuff got borderline-trivial once the transistor became ubiquitous, and stuff like The Writer Automaton has always been something that has utterly fascinated me.
- eks391 2y agoIf I ever happen upon a large fortune, I'd gladly give it to you if you used it for this and let me play with all the computers until I knew how they work. I studied mechanical engineering, and work in other fields now. Although I see and understand their importance to society, I am always fascinated by manipulation of mechanical principles to reach an objective.
- wayeq 2y ago“Second, this proof-of-concept work focused on binary computing functions with a cube being either pushed up or pushed down – it’s either a 1 or a 0. But we think there is potential here for more complex computing, with data being conveyed by how high a given cube has been pushed up. We’ve shown within this proof-of-concept system that cubes can have five or more different states. Theoretically, that means a given cube can convey not only a 1 or a 0, but also a 2, 3 or 4.” Is this trying to straddle the line between analog and digital computing? Because it sounds like they are describing a crippled analog computer system.
- kens 2y agoSome existing digital storage uses multiple levels beyond 0 and 1 for improved density. For instance, the 8087 floating-point coprocessor used a ROM with four levels to store its microcode with two bits per transistor, as a regular ROM was too big for the die. Flash memory uses multi-level cells with up to 4 bits per cell.
- hetman 2y agoDigital doesn't mean binary. A digital system must simply occupy a fixed number of levels, rather than the contiguous values of an analogue system. Binary systems, with 1 and 0, just happen to be one example of that. There's plenty of non-binary schemes used in modern digital systems though. Modern NAND flash is one instance, for example QLC SSD drives store 16 distinct levels per storage cell (allowing each to encode the equivalent of 4-bits of data). Another example is 64-QAM, a modulation scheme used in a variety of places, including 802.11n Wi-Fi and Digital Terrestrial television (among others), which forms symbols out of two out of phase sinusoids, each of which can take up to 8 amplitude levels. And even electronic computers haven't always been binary, one of the early Soviet computers was ternary, relying on 3 digits rather than the more familiar 2, to do all of its core computing functions.
- samuelec 2y agoMaybe a silly question, are those computers suitable for harsh environments such as in a rover on Venus?
- retrac 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automaton_Rover_for_Extreme_Environments https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automaton_Rover_for_Extreme_... there was a NASA design study that examined that question re: mechanical computers I rather like the idea of rotating retroreflectors read by laser from orbit to send data back.