3 ms·
Ok, next experiment. Imagine you took a brain and replaced one neuron by a transistor (or gate) that performs the exact same function as the neuron. Now repla
by amelius 2y ago
Ok, next experiment.
Imagine you took a brain and replaced one neuron by a transistor (or gate) that performs the exact same function as the neuron.
Now replace more and more neurons until all neurons are now transistors.
Would the resulting being be conscious and experience qualia, like the original did? If not, at what point was there a notable change?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus
- vundercind 2y agoThe same function, down to quantum and gravity et c effects on everything around it, and accepting and reacting to same? Yeah probably, but we’re back to having to “run” this on the same arrangement of actual matter as the original. [edit] there’s an obvious attack on this, but I’ll go ahead and note my position on it: the whole premise that we can do any of this without just using actual matter the ordinary way is so far into magical territory that we might as well ask “what if lephuchans simulated it?” or “what if god imagined the simulation?”—well ok, sure, I guess if magic is involved that could work, but what’s the point of even considering it? “What if a miracle occurred?” isn’t a rebuttal to the position that consciousness as we know it likely can’t be simulated by simulating physics, because you can rebut anything with it. Its admission to a discussion is the same as giving up on figuring out anything.
- mistermann 2y ago> there’s an obvious attack on this, but I’ll go ahead and note my position on it: the whole premise that we can do any of this without just using actual matter the ordinary way is so far into magical territory that we might as well ask “what if lephuchans simulated it?” or “what if god imagined the simulation?”—well ok, sure, I guess if magic is involved that could work, but what’s the point of even considering it? That's one of the main points of using a thought experiment: by declaring axioms explicitly, by fiat ("true" by definition), it prevents the mind from taking advantage of thought terminating get out of jail free cards like this, it forces people to argue their point.
- strogonoff 2y agoYou can’t replace a body cell by cell, and you can’t know if it’d ever going to be possible. To just assume it certainly would is the same wild kind of extrapolation from past scientific progress as assuming we would be able to resist gravity or clip through walls would be in earlier times. There are natural laws that you don’t know about. That should be a hint about the issues with naive monistic materialism.