5 ms·
> How can anyone not see just how impactful it's going to be? Or already is? I can't think of a single recent technology that was so widely adopted by tech and
by ryandrake 2y ago
> How can anyone not see just how impactful it's going to be? Or already is? I can't think of a single recent technology that was so widely adopted by tech and non-tech people alike, immediately integrated into day-to-day experience. The rise of mobile phones and e-commerce in the 90s would be the last time I've seen this happen (I'm not counting smartphones, as those are more of an iteration). Or social media, in purely software space.
You can't know this for certain until you look back on it in retrospect. We did not know mobile phones and e-commerce were going to be huge back in the 90s. We know now, of course, looking back, and the ones who guessed right back then can pat themselves on the back now.
Everyone is guessing. I'll admit it's totally possible LLMs and AI are going to be as earth shattering as its boosters claim it will be, but nobody can know this now with as much certainty as is being written.
- LorenzoBloedow 2y agoI personally attribute this FOMO to so called AI influencers who love "shilling" AGI as something that's as true as 1 + 1 = 2
- llm_trw 2y agoI don't get why people insist this is agi any more than a ship is artificial general swimming. It doesn't matter if it's general, what matters is that its useful. And if you don't find it useful just remember a lot of people in the 00s didn't find google useful either since they already had the yellow pages. I strongly suggest paying for a subscription to either openai or anthropic and learning quickly.
- fragmede 2y agoYou don't even have to do that, just go to http://ChatGPT.com http://ChatGPT.com and type at it. you don't even need to make an account.
- llm_trw 2y agoYou get what you pay for, despite what everyone is saying the 4o gpt model is really bad for long form reasoning. Buy the subscription and use the turbo4 model. After that api credits so you get access to the playground and change the system prompt. It makes a huge difference if you don't want to chat for 10 minutes before you get the result you want.
- okdood64 2y ago> learning quickly. Learning what quickly exactly?
- namaria 2y agoSwimming and 'intelligenting' are definitely not in the same category.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> You can't know this for certain until you look back on it in retrospect. Correct, but the thing is, AI blown up much faster than phones - pretty much a decade in a single year, in comparison. Mobile phones weren't that useful early on, outside of niche cases. Generative AI is already spreading to every facet of peoples' lives, and has even greater bottom-up adoption among regular people, than top-down adoption in business.
- mrbungie 2y agoAny evidence backing up these claims about adoption? I thought the same about adoption (across multiple audiences, not just tech workers and/or young people), was faced with surprising poor knowledge about GenAI when making surveys about it in my company. Maybe investors are asking the same questions right now.
- Workaccount2 2y agoIIRC openai was the fastest growing service by subscriptions of all time.
- PaulHoule 2y agoPew Research asked Americans this March: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/03/26/americans-use-of-chatgpt-is-ticking-up-but-few-trust-its-election-information/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/03/26/americans... 23% said they'd used ChatGPT, 43% said they hadn't, 34% didn't know what it was.
- fragmede 2y agothe article states > The Information recently reported that OpenAI’s revenue is now $3.4B, up from $1.6B in late 2023. and links to https://www.theinformation.com/articles/openais-annualized-revenue-doubles-to-3-4-billion-since-late-2023 https://www.theinformation.com/articles/openais-annualized-r... That's a lot of $20/month subscriptions. it's not all that but that's a lot of money, regardless.
- 2y ago
- doe_eyes 2y ago> We did not know mobile phones and e-commerce were going to be huge back in the 90s. Eh? We did. The whole dot-com boom was predicated on that assumption. And it wasn't wrong. But most of the dot-com investments went sideways. In fact, they imploded hard enough to cause a recession. In the same vein, even if we all agree that AI is fundamentally transformative, it doesn't mean that it's wise to invest money into it right now. It's possible that most or all of these early products and companies will go bust.
- ganoushoreilly 2y agoI think this is the right sentiment. I know a handful of AI startups that have raised 10's to 100's of millions. All of them were crushed with gpt-3 and subsequent models. None of them have any real revenue, have crazy burn rates with their compute spend, and generally haven't proven any value with their AI platforms. Most seem to be working on tech to find a problem rather than the inverse. Funds are throwing money on ideas.. that haven't panned out for years now. I worked with one and they were spending 10's of millions per researcher on AI compute... which makes sense if it's directed but most of the researchers were just running off on their own and the company hoped one would figure something out. Very disorganized for the stacks of cash being spent. Similar things have happened in the Cyber Security field just at a lesser scale. But hey, Nvidia is investing in companies.. to spend money on Nvidia .. infinite money glitch!
- anon-3988 2y agoThat's his point, we _know_ this. People can already use OpenAI as a replacement for Google search and people are already doing this. You might not think this is a good thing yadda yadda go to the library, but we already know that chat bots are here to stay.
- staunton 2y agoThere is a huge spectrum between "here to stay" and "changing everything". On another note, I think if the people arguing here would work out quantitative predictions, they would find that a not insignificant part of the "disagreement" about how big we should expect this to really be is in the framing.
- VirusNewbie 2y ago> I'll admit it's totally possible LLMs and AI are going to be as earth shattering You don't need earth shattering though. The PC revolution was huge because every company got a bit more productive with things like word processors and printing and email. The internet (and then later mobile) was big because every company got a revenue boost, from a small one with online presence to a a huge one for e-commerce to transformative with Netflix and streaming services. Ignoring the more sci-fi claims of AGI or anything, if you just believe that AI is going to make every office worker 10% more productive, surely each company is goign to have to invest in AI, no? Anytime you have an industry that can appeal to every other company, it's going to be big.
- wongarsu 2y agoI wouldn't be surprised if in large companies (say >500 office workers) 10% of all office work becomes redundant. Not in the form of each worker getting 10% more productive, but in form of some roles getting eliminated completely and others losing 80% of their workload.
- VirusNewbie 2y agoWhy? You could make the same argument about PCs or mobile or the Internet?
- fennecfoxy 2y agoThat's been true even for traditionally programmed replacements tho, there are plenty of office out there with a bunch of people banging on excel when everything they do could be automated.
- LouisSayers 2y ago> You can't know this for certain Except AI is already being used by people (like myself) every day as part of their usual work flow - and it's a huge boost in productivity. It's not IF it will make an impact - it IS currently making an impact. We're only just moving past early adopters and we're still in the early stages in terms of tooling. I'm not saying that AI will become sentient and take over humanity, but to think that AI isn't making an impact is to really have your head in the sand at this point.