4 ms·
This brings up a very prevalent false dichotomy and some interesting psychological issues that are holding back software development. The false dichotomy is th
by ilaksh 14y ago
This brings up a very prevalent false dichotomy and some interesting psychological issues that are holding back software development.
The false dichotomy is the idea that you can have either well engineered and powerful systems that are complex and difficult to program, or you can have poorly engineered, simple systems that are easy to program.
There is a conflict here which is a little bit like the inherent opposition of technology and business (most people aren't aware of this issue either, of course, but that's a whole other comment for people to dismiss). The tools which make software development easier and more efficient, both for experienced professionals as well as for beginners, also make software development more accessible, reduce the amount of traditional programming being done and therefore mean it requires less programming skill to accomplish the same thing.
This means that as new, more powerful programming tools appear, you can actually be fairly sure that the programmers who have only used those tools have less experience than programmers who use older, less powerful tools. Even worse, since everyone knows the tools are easier to use, there is a social dynamic and pressure warning programmers off of them: its basically cheating.
Many programmers are still acting like calligraphers in an area where the printing press has just recently been introduced. What self-respecting calligrapher uses a machine to print text? Its not even calligraphy.
I had to stop using Visual Basic anything just because I knew people would judge me as being a lesser programmer if I took advantage of the easier and more productive tool.
Peer pressure, pretty much at the level of 12-year-olds, is the main thing holding back deployment and advancement of technology in all aspects of our 'society'.
- sedev 14y agoI argue that Silicon Valley startup culture's existence and profitability disproves the point you're attempting to make here. Haven't we all read pg's "Beating the Averages"? Haven't we all heard a hundred startup founders say "I used the tool that was closest to hand, and customers didn't care what I used as long as my service met their needs"? Haven't we all seen the companies with printing presses handily beating the calligraphers both in the Iron Age assembler-versus-C contest and the modern contest of web startups with FOSS stacks beating companies burdened with compiled languages and expensive licenses? Peer pressure is certainly not zero - but hackers are pragmatists. If the tool really was easier and made a coder more productive, they'd be making money with it and that would be its reputation right there. The thing you call "cheating" is celebrated and encouraged. Better tools improve the whole community. >>> "I had to stop using Visual Basic anything just because I knew people would judge me as being a lesser programmer if I took advantage of the easier and more productive tool." This says far, far more about you than about the people around you.
- route66 14y ago>>> This says far, far more about you than about the people around you. Not necessarily. In my MS past I also had to defend my VB.Net experience in interviews, being perceived as a low-threshold toy language. And peer pressure matters in your network: how much reach-out would you get, as self described VB wizard or a SQL master? Fashion rules, as PL topics on HN show regularly. A PL survey [1] was linked from an article some hours ago; it shows interesting answers: just compare the language list of "I know many people who use this language" to "I would use this language on my resumee" That said, of course you are right: If you stay out of the fashion circuit and produce some value with tools you know, then nothing else matters... [1] http://www.eecs.berkeley.edu/~lmeyerov/projects/socioplt/viz/rank.html http://www.eecs.berkeley.edu/~lmeyerov/projects/socioplt/viz...
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>This says far, far more about you than about the people around you. Are you sure about that? On HN it's very easy to find an attitude in the comments and article selection that if you even use C#, you're just an enterprise boiler plate programmer that sucks. The "Leaving .NET" stories typically easily make the front page. In fact this article made it twice on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1719277 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1719277 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2005867 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2005867 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2370022 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2370022 And another ~100 articles and thousand comments which I don't have the time to link. You should go read some of these articles and comments. Sites like StackOverflow, Newegg, Plentyoffish show that many of these commenters are wrong, but each to their own biases.