5 ms·
Why refrigerators and other kitchen appliances break so easily now
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/SrThf https://archive.ph/SrThf
- sickofparadox 2y agoCheaper materials used inside the appliances, the ability to make materials thinner (saving money and making them more breakable), added complexity, and unnecessary features. An endless spiral of increasing costs from complexity while getting a less useful and dependable product. What a good deal!
- chad1n 2y agoRefrigators now have "software" so you can order Uber and doordash, everything used to build it is cheaper and overal less reliable and the whole structure isn't meant to last. After all, how will manufacturers make money if your refrigerator works for 10-15 years? The whole industry is built around constant (3-5 years) replacement of electronics.
- pokstad 2y agoI don’t think manufacturers are trying to achieve planned obsolescence. Rather I think they are trying to get in on that cheap internet services money they are being left out of. There’s lots of money being left on the table from having a foothold in a consumer’s home.
- taylodl 2y agoIronically, appliance shopping sites and reviews make the problem worse. Many people look at two things: the features list, and the price. They assume the quality is going to be six one way, half a dozen the other. So, your appliance has half the number of features yet only costs $200 less? It's going to get looked over. The internet makes it super easy to look it over.
- fatnoah 2y ago> Refrigators now have "software" so you can order Uber and doordash... I don't plan to buy any new refrigerator until it has full AI capabilities to generate recipes (including visuals) and guidance based on an inspection of the ingredients it contains.
- dsr_ 2y agoI don't want low-rent LLM capabilities. I want a robot chef which can learn my kitchen, pantry and tastes, determine the ripeness of an avocado, and cook omelets and steaks as well as a minimum-wage line cook can. Anybody can shove inventory management and a knapsack solver into a Raspberry Pi, I want real AI and robotics.
- Arrath 2y agoIf we truly insist on shoving AI into my fridge, I just want it to learn my eating habits and monitor the stock levels, pushing an updated grocery list to my phone's notes app that I can pull up at any time and see "expected to run out of milk in 3 days (expires in 1)" or "2 sandwiches worth of salami left if you control your midnight snacking"
- asdff 2y agoHope you can stomach the monthly fee that will demand
- legitster 2y agoThey still make durable appliances - the irony is that they are often the cheapest models. In 2024 you can still buy a new dishwasher with a mechanical dial control that will last you forever. The Maytag Centennial series of washers and driers sell themselves on being simple, robust designs that last forever. Gas appliances are generally have dirt simple mechanisms - they are cheaper and last forever. Part of the problem is that people have insane requirements they demand out of their appliances now - freezers on the bottom but ice makers up top, dishwashers with hidden control panels, washing machines that can do 16 pairs of jeans, etc. The trick is to think like a landlord - there is still a market demand for longevity if you are willing to live with the tradeoffs.
- asdff 2y agoPart of it I think is people end up in lines of work where they have a lot of excess cash. They think, "why not trick out the kitchen I use every day now that I can afford it," and end up with these fridges that can post on instagram with a compressor that breaks in three years. Of course this class of buyer also doesn't care about durability since they can trivially afford maintenance and replacement. The thinking infests the real estate space that targets this class of buyers (increasingly these are all home sales in some markets) that attempts to "keep up with the joneses" gutting walls of dwellings and swapping out the old top of the line stove with the new top of the line stove every time the title changes hands. Who wins? The appliance companies surely. The owners who appreciate the convenience of a sink built into a stove that allows them to fill a pot for pasta water with one less trip to the sink (next decades model will include a drain I am sure but we aren't there yet). And the rest of us bear the costs of real estate priced to get a profit margin on the expenses of these "upgrades" the previous owner's real estate agent prescribed for you, in addition to a diminished supply chain of regular old appliances that work fine for 40 years.
- doubled112 2y agoDishwashers with hidden control panels? Seems pretty low on the list considering the number of people I know who can't get theirs to keep water inside. I have to load mine just right or it'll throw a ton of water on the floor. Once I figured out where stuff has to go I can make it work, but I don't feel like I should need to. I know a guy with a pan under the door as a drip tray just in case. This isn't wear or an old seal, they have been like this since new. They aren't fancy by any means.
- Jsebast24 2y agoLet's say you have these two options: buy a $4,000 fridge that can last 20 years or a $1,000 fridge that lasts 5 years. Think about it. With the $1,000/5 yrs option you'll get one new modern fridge every 5 years (add a bit more $ for inflation), or 4 brand-new in a 20 yrs period. If you go with the $4,000 option, you'll be stuck with the same equipment for 20 years.
- woodruffw 2y agoSerious question: what "must-have" technology has been added to fridges in the last 5 (or even 10) years? It's hard for me to imagine even wanting to upgrade that often. I could see upgrading for significant energy savings, but it seems like that's already mostly been picked bare. (I rent, and I have what seems like a pretty modern fridge. The only real innovation I can discern between it and my childhood home's 20+ year old fridge is that it beeps when it's been left open for more than a minute.)
- rmbyrro 2y agoI think they've gotten more energy efficient over the years
- woodruffw 2y agoI think I addressed that. I would definitely buy a 2000s fridge over a 1970s one. But energy efficiency improvements appear to be largely stagnant since the mid-2000s[1]. [1]: https://appliance-standards.org/blog/how-your-refrigerator-has-kept-its-cool-over-40-years-efficiency-improvements https://appliance-standards.org/blog/how-your-refrigerator-h...
- Arainach 2y agoMy refrigerator is the one appliance in my house I haven't had to replace yet, but depending on the age and your budget there are a number of nice features including: * Better organization - pull out can drawers or exterior-facing small doors so you don't need to expose the whole contents of the fridge to warm air just to grab a can of soda or the ketchup * Water and ice dispensers - not brand new tech but I've owned plenty of fridges without them (even bought one such fridge within the last 10 years) and much prefer to have them. * More temperature zones * Better internal organization * Significantly better energy efficiency * Reduced noise I don't want to have to replace appliances (or cars, or most anything) every 5 years, so I'm glad there are a range of options, but there do continue to be quality of life improvements.
- dmitrygr 2y agoSeek out "commercial" grade appliances, pay ~2x, they last forever and often come with actual warranties in the 10-year range
- asdff 2y agoA lot of them are more noisy, consume more energy, and emit a good deal more heat with the assumption you have a pro kitchen vent setup. The sort of appliances everyone had in the 90s were basically end game already. They still work today after all with pretty routine repair jobs should anything happen (probably won't).
- iamthepieman 2y agoMaybe. Commercial anything often has subtly different use cases that are not advertised or shown since they are implicit in an industry. Commercial kitchen appliances have rock solid frames, bases, enclosures but wearable parts might be no better than anywhere else since it might be assumed they are being replaced every year. Completely different example I encountered recently. A bike tech told me the highest end components need constant adjustment and maintenance since tey are made of such lightweight materials. Totally fine if you've got a dedicated maintenance tech on your racing team. Pain in the ass if you're a weekend warrior.
- sitkack 2y agoYou often want to go for the "Toyota Corolla" or the Timex. Something mass market that has had a low amount of needless churn in the design. The scale at which these products are sold is staggering, they can't have returns, the backscatter would swamp the company.
- fwungy 2y agoAnyone can build a bridge that will stand. It takes an engineer to build a bridge that will barely stand. A second of life beyond the warranty period is profit that the manufacturer can hold on to rather than give to the consumer. With microprocessors and new materials you can cut the edge closer and closer. Who cares if you destroy the brand's reputation, the executives and PE will be gone before that matters.
- mihaaly 2y agoA bridge over a narrow stream, just to be precise.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pvg 2y agoRecent related big thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39449713 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39449713
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pokstad 2y agoNo mention of efficiency regulations causing manufacturers to make devices use less power and water? This has been a huge factor with front loading HE washing machines becoming essentially disposable products. I’m sure it affects other energy hungry appliances like refrigerators being made more cheaply.
- etrautmann 2y agoIt’s not obvious to me why those regulations would lead to poorly made products.
- pokstad 2y agoThe article mentions the switch from analog and mechanical parts to digital and electric equivalents that break more. Part of the reason for doing that is energy efficiency.
- Brian_K_White 2y agoIt's obvious to me. There are many ways in which a robust, reliable, or strong thing is less efficient. It's a basic fundamental trade-off in everything everywhere, like security vs convenience, like form vs function. A reliable motor that will run forever has big solid castings, big heavy windings (meaning fewer turns in the same volume), and no electronics at all, nor brushes. That means a shaded pole synchronous motor. An efficient motor has thin windings with a lot more turns in the same volume, and light weight rotor construction that can start/stop with less inertia, ,driven by dc power and pwm electronics. The electronic motor is a lot more efficient but has 100x more parts, dies from some part failure 100x more frequently and lasts a fraction as long. A reliable boiler is made out of a thick mass of cast iron with thick walls and not much surface area, and so is an inefficient heat exchanger. An efficient heat exchanger is paper thin sheets of stainless steel and lots of closely packed fins or folds or tubes for more surface area, which burns through or corrodes through or clogs up in a couple years, and cost a lot more to make. An efficient ice engine has a turbo, a reliable engine does not. The very definition of the word efficient usually means less overhead in some form in most contexts, which means running closer to the failure point, which means failing sooner. It's a kind of truism in that sense where the very meaning of the word efficient can be reworded to literally mean less reliable, not because that just happens to be an associated consequence, but because it literally means less overhead, less excess capacity, less redundancy, etc.
- bookofjoe 2y agoFWIW my 1995 Whirlpool refrigerator cost $499 new and will celebrate its 30th anniversary — without service — in less than a year. Works perfectly, just like when I bought it. I wouldn't accept a free top-of-the-line Bosch or Miele in exchange for it. Food is cold, what more do I need? My GE Electric Oven was installed when my house was built in 1967, which makes it 57 years old. It still works perfectly, calibration spot-on. Full disclosure: one of the four burners is inoperative. I can live with that forever.
- jasonpeacock 2y ago$499 in 1995 is equivalent to $1,030 today, that's not as cheap as it sounds.
- bookofjoe 2y agoAs I recall, it was the cheapest one on display at Best Buy.
- hollerith 2y agoWhen it does need repairing, good luck finding parts for it.
- bookofjoe 2y agoNo worries. At that age it would insane to try to fix it. A new one every 30 years? I can live with that.
- bookofjoe 2y agoFrom the original article: >And even if you want to repair rather than replace, you might not be able to do so easily. When it comes to electronic components, “the pace of change is so fast that a company will make something one year, and in two years down the line, they don’t make that component,” says Michael Pecht, a distinguished professor of mechanical engineering at the University of Maryland. “They’re making the next generation and that new component may not fit the old one.”
- 2y ago
- fallinghawks 2y agoSeveral of my appliances are in the 20-25 year range and have started to fail. In the last 3 years I've needed a new water heater, dishwasher, and clothes washer, fingers crossed for all. Maintenance (draining the WH every year or two, cleaning the washer filter every few months) is a must. I replaced a switch and the belt inside the clothes dryer (21) and just replaced the heating element in the oven (23) - hope to keep them going as long as I can.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoTalk of 35-year-old refrigerators. Throw them away! Their efficiency is abysmal.
- DrinkWater 2y agoI do work for a company that makes household appliances. Let’s just say, this is a very complex problem and people are aware of it. But it’s not easy to solve. Technological progress, customer psychology, geopolitical questions, market positioning and branding are things you need to consider.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- josefritzishere 2y ago[flagged]