5 ms·
I wonder if this "Desktop" version will have the ALL CAPS menu titles. Their rational for that in the regular version iirc is that it fits with metro better fo
by jlgreco 14y ago
I wonder if this "Desktop" version will have the ALL CAPS menu titles. Their rational for that in the regular version iirc is that it fits with metro better for some reason.
It would be strange to make a non-metro version of Visual Studio have those menus with that rational, but it would also be weird to have two versions of Visual Studio, one with capped menus and the other without.
- nlawalker 14y agoVS is not a Metro app: All versions of Visual Studio run on the desktop - what this article is referring to is a free version of VS with the capability to create desktop apps, which was removed from the free version of VS2012 that was already announced. The all-caps menus are part of the Metro "design language," which is related to but separate from actual Metro applications that run within the new non-desktop interface. Additionally, it's already been revealed that there will be a setting to return the menus to regular capitalization, and it can be done in the beta via a registry key.
- ryanmolden 14y agoNot true (to my knowledge) it hasn't been stated there will be any such exposed setting (to my knowledge, if I am wrong feel free to cite sources). There is a reg key switch, but there are lots of reg key switches in VS. Edit: As drivebyacct2 points out below I am wrong, it HAS in fact been officially stated. I don't see any attribution on the blog entry, but I suspect I know who wrote it and it is an official Microsoft blog, so that is a public announcement. Done and done.
- jlgreco 14y agoI have seen speculation here on HN that it would be a setting, and maybe even that they would change the default. Only speculation though.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoGeez, it was posted yesterday. http://blogs.msdn.com/b/visualstudio/archive/2012/06/05/a-design-with-all-caps.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/visualstudio/archive/2012/06/05/a-de... >That said, we will enable you to customize the casing, and we are exploring options for how to expose that choice. We will post again once we’ve settled on a final approach to be available in RTM.
- ryanmolden 14y agoYay! I stand corrected. Sorry, I hadn't seen that. I don't tend to keep up on the blog as I have had negative experience in trying to interact with customers via the comment section before (and reading the comments in general) :) In my experience such interaction generally takes the form (some hyperbole for humorous effect): Customer: You are incompetent because you made decision X. Me: We made decision X for the following reasons (enumerate things that weighed in on the decision). Customer: You are worse than Hitler and need to die.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoWell the comments there are more or less that, which is sad to see. I like that the VS team (and many teams it seems) are responding well to public feedback and making smart decisions that can make everyone happy. It's just sad to see people can't respect the VS team's default decision, even when they agree to expose it as a setting. That's users for you.
- pbz 14y agoOf course interactions like this are childish and unproductive. However, I feel that these are symptoms of being ignored. When people feel that the VS side has their fingers in their ears, one needs to yell louder to be heard. Claiming to paying attention to feedback when clearly not doing so is also quite frustrating. A counter-example is how ScottGu handles situations like this -- or used to, nowadays he doesn't seem to have that much free time. When one posts about a problem on his blog he gets personally involved and assigns somebody to get it fixed. On the other side, one thousand people ask for the same thing and they're being ignored. Do you see my point?
- jlgreco 14y ago"VS is not a Metro app: All versions of Visual Studio run on the desktop" That was my understanding. I guess I expressed myself poorly. I was wondering why a piece of software that is apparently explicitly for 'Desktop' (as in creating things for it) would sacrifice sensibility for the sake of any Metro concepts. I don't know, the entirety of it is weird to me, so maybe this makes more sense to somebody who understands the reasoning behind everything else about windows 8.
- ryanmolden 14y agoAs a member of the VS team (but not one who is in charge of making these decisions) I can't comment in any official capacity. I can say I am not a fan of the ALL CAPS menus, but, strangely enough, my personal opinion doesn't drive decisions in a multi-million dollar product unit :). I will however just leave this here: http://www.richard-banks.org/2012/06/how-to-prevent-visual-studio-2012-all.html http://www.richard-banks.org/2012/06/how-to-prevent-visual-s.... This is of course not officially supported and my being a VS team member does not imply a contract for this registry key to exist for all time or on any specific SKU.
- tseabrooks 14y agoWow, that all caps menu is ugly. I hadn't seen that before. As the only person I can talk to working on VS team.. I hold you personally responsible. "Fix It!"
- ryanmolden 14y agoFeedback was given in that general direction before the public release. I guess it goes to show that while our feedback was viewed as...less than representative, they (UX)got the general idea when the public feedback was...mostly identical :) NOTE: The previous rambling statement was in regards to general UX treatment in the Beta/RC timeframes, not on the ALL CAPS menus in particular, but feedback has definetly been given (by myself and others, internal and external) on that topic. They certainly are aware of the feedback.
- barrkel 14y agoI'm very surprised to learn that all caps menus were intentional. I thought it was for some other reason - maybe something along the lines of what we at Borland called "egging", i.e. using odd international characters to test for internationalization errors; in other words, maybe it was testing for UI spacing or something.
- pbz 14y agoWhat I find strange (not sure how true) is what I hear from random MS employees that customer feedback is more valuable, or weighs more, than the feedback from MS employees. To me, this shows a low level of trust from management in their own employees' ability to gauge the market. Another thing I can't wrap my mind around is how can it be possible to have one thousand of your customers yelling at you they don't like something -- that can be easily changed -- and have the management respond with "Oh well, we're still going to do what we want. What ya gonna do about it?!"
- CurtHagenlocher 14y agoJudging by the screenshots here (http://www.theverge.com/microsoft/2012/2/9/2787365/microsoft-office-15-unveiled http://www.theverge.com/microsoft/2012/2/9/2787365/microsoft...), this is being done for "compatibility" with Office 15. (I don't know anyone inside Microsoft who likes the all caps, but at least Office apps have only 5 to 7 top-level menus.)
- aninteger 14y agoWhat's really really interesting to me is that they've removed the ribbon from the menu system. I'm happy about this, but I know a lot of people loved the ribbon UI. Or at least it appears that way from the screenshots in your link.
- CurtHagenlocher 14y agoIt has always been possible to hide the ribbon. When you click on the top-level menu, it reappears.