3 ms·
Love stuff like this. Years ago I lived in an apartment building where the main entrance was controlled by an analog phone system with an extra pair of wires.
by kelnos 2y ago
Love stuff like this. Years ago I lived in an apartment building where the main entrance was controlled by an analog phone system with an extra pair of wires. All the handsets in the unit were connected to a speaker/microphone outside the door (directly; there was no enable/disable when your unit was or was not getting buzzed), and there was an extra pair of wires for activating the door unlock.
I wanted to give my partner (and houseguests) the ability to come and go as they pleased without having to give them a building key (I only had one spare key provided by my landlord, and it was expensive to replace if lost). I bought a relay and grabbed an old Raspberry Pi, hooked the relay to the Pi's GPIO pins, and opened up the intercom phone and found the wires that activated the door unlock. Wrote a little HTTP server in python that would enable the GPIO pins for 10 seconds to unlock the door, and wired that up to my home automation system (openHAB). I got a Twilio phone number, and set it up so it would respond to particular PIN codes from specific phone numbers. When I was hosting someone for a weekend, I'd generate a random 8-digit PIN code and add that and their phone number to a config file on the Pi.
At the time I hadn't realized there were smart relays; otherwise this maybe would have required less work. This was 6 years or so ago, though, so maybe they weren't really a thing back then.
- pimlottc 2y agoYou added your own automated control to your shared apartment buildings main gate? And your landlord agreed to this? I mean, I hope you got their permission…
- ssl-3 2y agoWould it have been different if they'd put stuck a Switchbot on there to push the button on the intercom instead of wiring in their own relay, and thus leaving the wiring intact? Why, or why not? Or, perhaps absurdly: Would it have been different if they'd hired someone to (at least in part) hang out and push the button on command, instead?
- hunter2_ 2y agoI don't think the hired help is any more absurd, given that the primary perceived problem would be the increased likelihood that a bad actor exploits the system. I think that's what would keep a landlord up at night far more than an impermanent modification to the real property. Either way, it removes the resident's own judgement from the request/response cycle. But then again, so does the resident handing out copies of keys, which has a very different but still substantial attack surface. No matter what, the main gate still keeps out random people who aren't sophisticated in their attack, which is all it ever did in the first place, so there's really not much going on here.
- ssl-3 2y agoThat was the basis of my (rather open) question: Whether the primary perceived problem would be the increased potential for bad actors to do bad things, or whether the primary perceived problem would be the fact that a tenant modified the wiring inside of their own unit. I agree that bad actors are the worst concern, since bypassing a switch with a relay on a low-voltage circuit is about as non-invasive as wiring mods can ever get. So. Assuming that there aren't purely-technical failure modes that can results in an improperly-closed relay, we can ask: Does having per-user codes and a wired-in relay result in a worse security scenario for the building than lending the [singular] spare key to a friend does? Sure, it's easy enough to give someone else instructions and a code, while it can be hard to copy [some] keys. But it's also easy to disable a code when that visitor has left or is no longer welcome (and thus also disable all copies of that code), whereas it is hard to disable a copy of a key. And OP went a step further than mere codes by also validating inbound phone numbers, as a form of 2FA. This second factor is also possible to duplicate by a bad actor, but we're well into the realm of requiring some sophistication (or brazen theft) for that to happen. (All said, based on the description I think they did pretty good with their hack.)
- pimlottc 2y agoOn my initial reading, it sounded like they had modified the wiring on the gate itself, which would be more alarming. Now that you mention it, it does sound like they might have instead accessed wiring within their own unit. I’m used to access systems that just dial out to residents’ phone numbers, so when they talked about accessing the intercom wired to the gate, I assumed they were talking about the public call box at the gate itself.
- p51-remorse 2y agoTrust me - landlords have bigger things to worry about than details of the security stance of a guy who knows enough EE and SW to pull this off. They mostly worry about the guy two doors down who thought Breaking Bad looked really cool and just bought a chemistry book.
- pcchristie 2y agoI think I have the same phone system and have been meaning to do something similar for years. Do you have any of your work documented/published anywhere? I think the Nuki [1] exists for this purpose by the way, I stumbled upon it when trying to work out how I'd do what you seem to have done! [1] https://nuki.io/en/opener/ https://nuki.io/en/opener/