15 ms·
In Math You Have to Remember, In Other Subjects You Can Think About It
- Lockyy 14y agoI experienced the strict setting of sitting in a classroom, facing forwards, listening to the teacher give demonstrations and then answering tens of questions that followed the same pattern. This was from 16-18 and was only a small change from what I had experienced previously. Before that we had at least been allowed to talk to each other, I think because the teacher recognised how needed that is. Once I was studying for my A-levels however I was in a group of people who wanted to learn maths, we had chosen the subject after all. But we were given a teacher who demanded that we were silent, demanded that when we had a problem we asked her and not each other. Except for some students she came to the conclusion that their not understanding was their fault and would just tell them that they should have listened originally, for others it would just take too long to get an answer because the class was overcrowded with students. Twenty-five students at that level is far too many for one teacher. Some students fell behind, and when they decided that instead of doing the parts of the subject they had no chance of understanding they would work on things they did understand to get up to speed, they had less advanced mock papers taken from them and told to do what they were told to do. Students dropped maths, very able students dropped the subject. A lot of people's marks were hurt drastically due to just coming to hate the subject. We knew that discussing things with each other would help us a lot, it was good that I could turn to someone and ask them to explain something right then without having to wait for the single teacher to deal with the five other people who needed help before me. Hence, we did it anyway because it worked and we weren't stupid enough to keep silent just because the teacher told us to, we had to do this to learn, and we had voluntarily chosen the subject to learn. So yes, I completely agree with the argument that the traditional approach is broken and that nobody wins. It's the only thing at that school that I have bad memories of, every other department, even other teachers within the maths department, knew the value of group based learning. A bad teacher using a bad method can ruin peoples view of an entire subject extremely quickly which can lead to disastrous results.
- tomkin 14y ago> Numerous studies over the past thirty years have shown that when people of any age and any ability level are faced with mathematical challenges that arise naturally in a real-world context that has meaning for them, and where the outcome directly matters to them, they rapidly achieve a high level of competence. How high? Typically 98 percent, that's how high. I describe some of those studies in my book The Math Gene (Basic Books, 2000). I also provide an explanation of why those same people, when presented with the very same mathematical challenges in a traditional paper-and-pencil classroom fashion, perform at a lowly 37 percent level. This. I love that this argument is being made. There is this notion among academics that the student should bend to the (fabricated?) stringent regulations on how math is taught or expressed. As a society, we accept the fact that there are those who grasp concepts, learn and develop sensibilities of material in various different ways. For me personally, I found the way that math was taught in school to be completely disconnected with its purpose. There would be times where material was applied, but more often not. No other subject can get away with this. Music - instruments, scale and training. Art - painting, modelling and theory. English – writing, reading & comprehension. Science - hypothesis, experiments, conclusion. Most subjects have an execution factor. How far Jamie has to walk to get 3 bags of milk is not execution, it's practise. This is a gross simplification of a beautiful subject - but this is the point where many get lost: Purpose. For those who absorb material differently, this is where the conversation needs to start.
- tgrass 14y agoPainting, modelling and theory; writing, reading & comprehension. These are practice. Getting your painting into a gallery or your book into the hands of an unobligated reader - that is execution. In Civil Engineering, we ran problem after problem in school. Nothing I do now professionally in civil design resembles the practice I did in school. Which is just to say, execution should be the goal of ALL programs, but none seem to come close. [edit] it's Friday morning and I'm done; any suggestions for a synonym for 'unobligated'?
- tomkin 14y agoI agree that they are practice in some sense, but the end result is valuable immediately. When I was a young student, I would take my painting, science experiment or short story home to show my mom. When I did well in math I showed my grade, not the actual work. Here is where we find perception of activity vs. successful comprehension. Math is not valuable unless it has purpose and if some are not given purpose they will stop investigating it. It's easy to categorize those who have that viewpoint. As someone who found math later in life on my own terms, I can say that it was much more enjoyable than what was being taught as a student. This was foretold in each math class I had in the schools I attended. There was always a "Math is necessary for..." poster on the wall in the classroom, and yet, no other class had a "Art is necessary for..." or "History is necessary for..." poster. We've identified the problem. Now what do we do about it? Language Studies (aside from immersion) also could benefit from being more execution-oriented. For me, 4 years of French class was easily lapped by a month in Quebec.
- angdis 14y agoI recently picked up my neice's high school alegbra book and the "mile wide inch deep" problem is plainly evident: way too much clutter and convolving of topics. When I helped her with some problems sets, it became apparent that the teacher had been drilling the students with rigid mechanized approaches to solving different types of problems. Actual THINKING about the problem at hand and gaining intuitive grasp of graphing and relationships seems to be completely ignored in the teaching. Very sad indeed.
- jasim 14y agoThis captures the problem with mathematical education well enough: > When Boaler would visit a class being taught in a Railside-like fashion and ask students what they were working on, they would describe the problem and how they were trying to solve it. When she asked the same questions of students being taught the traditional way, they would generally tell them what page of the book they were on. When she asked them, "But what are you actually doing?" they would answer "Oh, I'm doing number 3." [p.98] The typical math education relies a lot on rote learning (just take a look at the cheatsheets here: http://tutorial.math.lamar.edu/cheat_table.aspx http://tutorial.math.lamar.edu/cheat_table.aspx). There are a lot of equations you just have to remember by heart to be able to be productive in solving the typical textbook problems. For a high-school student who does not have any insight on the beauty of mathematics, this is a huge turn off. They leave school with the impression that this is a cold hard subject with perfect proofs that you have to learn by rote, and nothing more. No one talks about why Math is beautiful. The most positive thing about Math I've heard from people is that it is the best subject to get a perfect score. The arts are subjective and there is no perfectly right answer, but Math, if you know how to solve these types of problems without missing a sign or a bracket here or there, you get a 100/100. The problem, I think, is because we teach the results of hundreds of years of evolution of Maths. For example, most courses on Calculus start teaching it by talking about Limits, and from there moves onto Differentiation. Integration is considered to be the 'advanced' part of Calculus. It was very recently that I discovered Apostle's textbook on Calculus (students of universities who use that text are lucky) where he treats Integration first - because that is the right historical order in which Calculus evolved. I could appreciate it a lot more when I understood what kind of problems were Newton and Leibniz trying to solve when they came up with the formalized notion of Calculus. Calculus was described by them using the concept of 'infinitesimals', not through Limits. Limits was a clever abstraction that was evolved later to better explain Calculus and keep it consistent. But when we start teaching students Calculus with Limits, show them the perfect way where Limits can be used to find the differentials of trigonometric functions, they do not know this background. For them, there is no moment of 'awe'. They are not even shown a glimpse of the amazing intellectual pursuit that was behind this fantastic subject. All you see are a bunch of equations, some proofs that are mathematically perfect, and you just learn them by rote. The typical Math education needs to focus more on the evolution of the subject, the pains faced by mathematicians (or physicists!) to which they came up with these solutions. The logical gaps in new ideas and how they were filled later. Let the students understand that this is not a 'perfect' subject. There were human beings who faced real problems who came up with these solutions. Even better, let them understand that some of the things they learn was the result an intellectual pastime for these mathematicians. It was imperfect, and there was joy when mathematicians brought it closer to perfection. With the advent of computers, most of the evaluation criteria used in High School Math is becoming redundant. Moving from one step to another without making careless mistakes is priority number one now. If we reduce the importance on that manual aspect of the typical Math problem solving, and instead focus on teaching the more interesting, insightful things about Math, the students will go away with a totally different idea about Maths. Like programming, it becomes a universe of abstractions where your curiosity drives you to learn more.
- CurtMonash 14y agoI was generally regarded as math prodigy. I got my first algebra book when I was 4 years old, and mastered the material quickly. I eventually got a mathematics PhD from Harvard when I was 19 years old. Traditional mathematics classrooms contributed very little to that learning, except for the portion of a university education directed toward mathematics major. And I even have my doubts about that part. Meanwhile, the best bit of math teaching I've ever done may have come when I was helping my stepdaughter with her algebra homework. I noticed her applying on over-specific rule to a class of formula simplification problems. So I deliberately changed the problem she was working on to one where the bogus rule didn't apply ... :) I've come to believe that for students of all levels, the most important part of mathematics education is when you coach them through problem-solving. Yes, the formalities are wonderfully powerful and fun, at least to my taste. But they should be a last resort, whether for solving a problem or checking the soundness of a result. Formalities-first is exactly the wrong way to approach things, for math users and math teachers alike.
- kenjackson 14y agoI'm interested in how you mastered algebra at 4. Were you already strong at arithmetic when you got the algebra book (and algebra was just a continuation of your already acceleratd progress) or was algebra just very intuitive and the start of a great math career?
- yaks_hairbrush 14y agoCan't speak for OP, but I started learning algebra at 5. It happened that I really liked playing with calculators at age 2-3, and that helped give me an extremely solid mental arithmetic foundation. Essentially, the special thing about me probably wasn't some super-human neural circuitry for understanding math. It was the fact that I was wired, somehow, to enjoy playing with a calculator. I had more arithmetic practice by age 4 than most kids have by age 11.
- prezjordan 14y agoI feel like I can relate to this (a little). I'm no prodigy, but even as a young kid (6 or 7) I would write down algebra problems all day and solve them. I did a ton of mental math, too, writing down several dozen 2-digit numbers and adding them all in my head. Haven't really thought about that in a long time. Playing with a calculator also got me into programming (TI-Basic on the TI-83 in middle school).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jere 14y ago>In an international survey conducted in 2003, students from forty countries were asked whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement: "When I study math, I try to learn the answers to the problems off by heart." Is "off by heart" really a well known phrase in 40 countries? I'm from the US and this question really confused me (even though I'm aware of the phrase "by heart").
- lurker14 14y agoIt is in the non-rebellious parts of the British Empire :-) https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=I+try+to+learn+the+answers+to+the+problems+off+by+heart https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=I+try+to+learn+the+ans...
- xyzzyz 14y agoThey obviously didn't ask this question in English in all these countries.
- pessimizer 14y agoI'm all about physical metaphors being used to teach math - instead of handing someone an equation and saying that the equation is what the concept being taught is, it's easier to remember the physical metaphor that the concept is like, and then to see how the equation describes both the concept and the metaphor. More of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Where_Mathematics_Comes_From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Where_Mathematics_Comes_From
- RockofStrength 14y agoI'm a big fan of that approach. Betterexplained.com uses the method.
- jere 14y ago>In Math You Have to Remember, In Other Subjects You Can Think About It This title/quotation is quite depressing, since the student has it totally backwards. Math and any field with mathematical roots are the only things you can think about and figure out. I can't count the number of times I walked into an EE test unprepared and was able to work out some formula, which I hadn't memorized, from other principles. Most of my history/english/social studies consisted of rote memorization of facts, dates, and obscure words. I'm still flabbergasted on why the SAT has middle school level math problems while also testing you on an intractable memorization problem: vocabulary. [update: apparently, analogies have been removed from the SAT. thanks, nickbarnwell]
- nickbarnwell 14y ago> Most of my history/english/social studies consisted of rote memorization of facts, dates, and obscure words. I'm still flabbergasted on why the SAT has middle school level math problems while also testing you on an intractable memorization problem: vocabulary. As someone who still has the SATs fresh in mind, vocabulary is actually a very small, and very easy, portion of the exam. It's a subcomponent of the Critical Reading section, which largely concerns itself with drawing conclusions from a given text. Anyone even moderately well-read should be capable of acing CR, and it was a not unusual occurence at my gymnasium (~5 out of 15 students in my year managed 800s, IIRC)
- jere 14y agoIt's been about a decade since I took mine. Apparently, they got rid of analogies, which is what I was thinking of: >In 2005, the test was changed again, largely in response to criticism by the University of California system.[32] Because of issues concerning ambiguous questions, especially analogies, certain types of questions were eliminated (the analogies from the verbal and quantitative comparisons from the Math section). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAT#2005_changes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAT#2005_changes That sounds like a great change. Each analogy required you to know 4 words (at least one of which would be rather obscure). I read quite a bit in grade school (still proud of myself for seemingly being 1 out of only 3 students who read the required 750 page John Adams over a summer), yet suffered miserably during this section.
- jwingy 14y agoAs someone who was taught the 'traditional' way of mathematics, can someone give a few pointers of de-programming myself from the traditional way that I was taught? (Although maybe it won't be so hard since I feel like I've forgotten quite a bit) Someone already recommended this for calculus which looks pretty promising: http://www.gutenberg.org/files/33283/33283-pdf.pdf http://www.gutenberg.org/files/33283/33283-pdf.pdf
- maxerickson 14y agoYou probably don't need to deprogram anything. A problem that you are motivated to solve is a good idea. Because it provides clear motivation. If such a thing isn't forthcoming, maybe think of understanding the concepts as the problem to solve (which is pretty wishy-washy, but it is likely going to be a difficult task if it isn't providing any satisfaction).
- fferen 14y agoIf you can code, Project Euler is really good. Particularly the problems past #100; those tend to concentrate more on mathematical insights than programming ones. It's what kindled my interest in math in high school.
- eru 14y agoYes, but Project Euler merely gives you a stimulus to go out and research, and a test to apply your new skills. They are not so much a tool on their to acquire the skills. E.g. learning about dynamic programming will simplify at least half of all Project Euler problems. But it would be rather harder than necessary to try and come up with all the generalities of dynamic programming just from personal attempts at solving Project Euler problems.
- eru 14y agoRead `The Pleasure of Counting'. It's an excellent mathemical book for teenagers written by an actual mathematician and a gentle but real introduction to real mathematics. No dumbing down.
- mistercow 14y agoThe substance of the article seems good, but why was it necessary to mention that it was a female high school student? Is her lack of a penis somehow involved with this discussion?
- jere 14y agoUh... perhaps since we have huge gender gaps in STEM fields, such a quotation by a female high school student is especially alarming?
- mistercow 14y agoWell, if the author had tied that point into the article in some way, that would be fine. But he didn't.
- amcintyre 14y agoAs mistercow says, it would have been a good idea to explain that. That detail just hanging there with no explanation caused me to pause as well, because I've encountered some mathematicians (not people I've worked with, just visiting professors and such) that felt the need to tell stories about person X, who was in some way not as clueful as they'd expected, "and by the way she was a woman." I'm not in any way suggesting that the article author (Devlin) is like that, just that I would personally try not to make a statement like that without proactively making it clear that I'm not "that guy."
- vlad 14y agoMy favorite part about the benefits of learning to solve problems rather than memorizing skills for a particular section of a book at a time: > When they had been at school, their social class, as determined by their parents' jobs, were the same at both schools. But eight years later, the young adults from Phoenix Park were working in more highly skilled or professional jobs than the Amber Hill adults... 65 percent of the Phoenix Park adults were in jobs more professional than their parents, compared with 23 percent of Amber Hill adults. In fact, 52 percent of Amber Hill adults were in less professional jobs than their parents, compared with only 15 percent of the Phoenix Park graduates... Students at the school that that taught problem solving rather than memorization continued math education in college because they enjoyed it, leading 65% of them to get better jobs than their parents at only 24 years old. On the other hand, the majority of students at the traditional high school avoided math in college, and chose "less professional" jobs than their parents at 24. Over their lifespans, I can only imagine the disparity increased... > Which statement would give you more pleasure? "Because of good teaching, my child scored 79% on her last math test," or "Because of good teaching, my child has a much better job and leads a far more interesting and rewarding life than me." The author mentions that even the best students at traditional schools had trouble on tests since they practiced the skill-of-the-day on assignments, leading me to believe they would show remarkable improvement on standardized testing in a new curriculum. Maybe the author believes that testing students after-the-fact is not as good a use of taxpayer money as providing resources and education for teachers to change the curriculum would be.
- barrkel 14y agoFor context here: Phoenix Park was predominantly working class, while Amber Hill was predominantly "affluent". In this context, the results sound a lot like reversion the mean.
- lurker14 14y ago" In Math You Have to Remember, In Other Subjects You Can Think About It" Most math geniuses I know (including however much of a genius I am) know the exact opposite! Other subjects are memorizing facts; you can noodle through math problems using logic. In fact, much of our success in other subjects is in weaseling through multiple-guess tests using mathematical logic!
- colanderman 14y agoYou should read the article instead of responding to the title, which is in fact a quote by a student about the current state of education in the US.
- learc83 14y agoI was helping my 9th grade step brother with his math homework, and I've noticed his math classes are no longer divided into subjects they way they where when I was there 10 years ago (algebra, geometry, algebra II, trig/precalc, calculus, discrete math) His math book jumped around so much, that one week he was working on probability, the next basic geometry, and the next simple factoring. It looked exactly like someone wrote a whirlwind study guide that covered just enough to pass some very specific standardized test.
- zmoazeni 14y agoPersonally, I would have preferred a breadth-first approach to mathematics when I was in school. All of those concepts are related, but it's very difficult to make those connections when you are "only learning [algebra|geometry|etc]" in isolation. Edit: related http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/03/math-for-programmers.html http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/03/math-for-programmers...
- learc83 14y agoThis definitely isn't some kind of holistic approach to math. It's basically just here memorize this probability forumla, and the algorithm for multiplying two brackets together, because that's what you're getting tested on at the end of the year. I could understand if it was something like showing how bracket multplication works by adding in an example from geometry like this http://math1sfun.wordpress.com/category/algebra/expanding-brackets/ http://math1sfun.wordpress.com/category/algebra/expanding-br... But it's nothing like that at all.
- rsanchez1 14y agoIt is still split up that way, but I think that is for more advanced students. For students not focusing on math, they may just make a text that generalizes on many topics without focusing on a specific subject.
- learc83 14y ago>It is still split up that way, but I think that is for more advanced students. He's in honors math, i.e., the most advanced math available for his grade level.
- tokenadult 14y agoThanks for the many interesting comments. I'll reply jointly here to a few of the comments, and invite further discussion on some points made in the submitted article that I'm curious about. From a top-level comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4084559 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4084559 As someone who was taught the 'traditional' way of mathematics, can someone give a few pointers of de-programming myself from the traditional way that I was taught? (Although maybe it won't be so hard since I feel like I've forgotten quite a bit) From a second-level comment, which has already received some helpful replies: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4084426 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4084426 After Vector Calc, I wanted to go back to the fundamentals, to understand instead of remembering. There is a FAQ page on the Epsilon Camp site http://www.epsiloncamp.org/FAQ.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/FAQ.php that includes some Frequently Asked Questions articles about learning mathematics for deeper understanding. The FAQ article "Problems versus Exercises" http://www.epsiloncamp.org/faq/faq_1.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/faq/faq_1.php relates to what kind of work to set for yourself to build deeper understanding, and the FAQ article "Learning Mathematics" http://www.epsiloncamp.org/faq/faq_3.php http://www.epsiloncamp.org/faq/faq_3.php points to writings by various mathematicians, including the book Numbers and Geometry by John Stillwell, about how to appreciate mathematics as a deep, connected subject. The submitted article mentioned "Numerous studies over the past thirty years have shown that when people of any age and any ability level are faced with mathematical challenges that arise naturally in a real-world context that has meaning for them, and where the outcome directly matters to them, they rapidly achieve a high level of competence. How high? Typically 98 percent, that's how high. I describe some of those studies in my book The Math Gene (Basic Books, 2000)." The most striking example of this that I remember from a news report was a Wall Street Journal series in the 1990s that followed two young men in an inner city ghetto, one who was a good high school student and the other who was a street criminal. The street criminal usually skipped high school, but happened to show up the day students could take one of the major standardized tests (probably the PSAT, if I remember correctly). The street criminal, who sold illegal drugs among other activities, scored just as well on the test as the more regularly attending student who had learned most of his mathematics from school lessons. That's a rather stark illustration of what's missing in school lessons for children who don't have an outside-of-school environment for learning mathematics. http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf The article also says that many students say, "You have to be willing to accept that sometimes things don't look like - they don't see that you should do them. Like they have a point. But you have to accept them." I wonder how that relates to the quotation attributed to John von Neumann, http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann "Young man, in mathematics you don't understand things. You just get used to them." And from a third-level comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4084865 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4084865 I experience math (and programming) quite differently than learning a language or painting: Once I grasp a concept, I can use it. Before that, it's mostly useless to me. I ask, because when I studied mathematics in school, I had a drive to understand the general principles first before I launched into working on my homework, while some of my classmates were successful--at least in the context of school--by working on the homework and DEVELOPING some level of understanding as they tried to figure out answers for the homework. (I was in a "tracked" mathematics class, taking algebra in eighth grade in an era when most Americans took algebra in tenth grade, if at all, and most of my classmates had parents who were engineers or medical doctors and could ask their parents for help at home if the school lessons were confusing, as they often were.) I also have a very strongly visual approach to grappling with mathematical problems. So when I first learned algebra, which was presented to me as a bunch of "Do this to the equation, and then do this" with little rationale, I found that very dissatisfying. Later in the school year, we learned about coordinate graphing of systems of equations in the Cartesian plane, and I remember thinking, "Why didn't you tell me this in the first place?" For historical reasons, and perhaps for reasons of what most learners consider most easy, usually purely procedural algebra for solving systems of two equations in two unknowns has been taught in school before graphing systems of equations in the coordinate plane. But for some learners, it would be easier and more accessible to reverse that order. What do you think about the issue of students working first according to instructions, to DEVELOP understanding a la the von Neumann quotation, versus getting the "big picture," perhaps explicitly visually, before working on problems. I'll comment also that the approach taken to learning mathematics in school in most of the newly industrialized countries of east Asia and southeast Asia is plainly superior to the United States approach for at least two reasons: 1) the school textbooks in those countries explicitly encourage students to THINK about why a procedure will or will not work, and about how many different ways there might be to solve a problem, and 2) the school textbooks show multiple representations of most mathematical concepts, building from "concrete to pictorial to abstract" as in the Singapore Primary Mathematics series http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_US_Ed_s/39.htm http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_US_Ed_s/39.... and the follow-up New Elementary Mathematics series http://www.singaporemath.com/New_Elementary_Math_s/47.htm http://www.singaporemath.com/New_Elementary_Math_s/47.htm which interleave arithmetic, number theory, geometry, and algebra in increasing depth and interconnection throughout all grade levels.
- jkn 14y agoParents whose own math education was more traditional believe [...] that the presence of weaker students [in mixed ability groups] will drag down the better ones. These parents are so wrong. Nothing makes you better at math than to explain what you have understood, well what you think you have understood, to other students. It's a challenging exercise that will benefit the brightest (except for pretentious asses I guess).
- Mon_Ouie 14y agoThis reminds me of one of the math teachers I had, who used a technique I found quite interesting and effective compared to how other teachers taught us about new concepts. He would rarely come up with some theorem, ask us to solve a few exercises, and go on to the next chapter. When he wanted to introduce a new concept, he'd usually ask us to solve an equation or a more concrete probleme (I can remember something like the fence problem mentioned in the article, which was used to introduce us to finding the maximal output of a 2nd degree expression). After that, we would either find a solution through some struggle — and then try to figure out a more efficient approach — or we'd stumble on a problem by trying to use approaches we'd been taught before — and therefore try to find a better way to represent the problem. On an amusing sidenote, while we were each working individually, he'd walk around in the class, looking at what we were doing, and crossing out with a red marker pen mistakes we'd made.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- prezjordan 14y agoIs this satire? I think this is completely backwards. You can intuit math, you can't intuit the king of England during the 1400s, or what the word "defenestrate" means (well I guess you can if you know a bit of French or Latin). Everybody forms their own way of doing mathematics through the mind, but vocabulary and history are simply memorization.
- dllthomas 14y agoThe title is a (depressing) quote from a student who apparently didn't understand enough math to understand the problem with their position.
- danibx 14y agoWhere can I learn about math notation and how to read math symbols expressions? Many times I find some articule that explain some idea using math symbols. And I can understand nothing. This week I was looking for a method to calculate the distance between two geolocation coordinates. Át. First the article used math symbols to explain and I could understand nothing. I didnt even know how to Google that "enigma". But a few lines below there was the same algorithm, but This time it was written in Javascript. And it was very easy and simple to understand. How to learn "math syntax and grammar"?
- roryokane 14y agoGood question. Some resources I found: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Table_of_mathematical_symbols http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Table_of_mathematical_symbols. It is more of a reference than a tutorial. It also includes only symbols, not other features of notation such as division lines and superscript/subscript. http://mathoverflow.net/questions/33152/is-there-a-reference-containing-standard-mathematical-notations http://mathoverflow.net/questions/33152/is-there-a-reference.... Someone with a similar, more specific question, looking for a dictionary of what to name variables. Nobody found any such dictionary. http://www.alcyone.com/max/reference/maths/notation.html http://www.alcyone.com/max/reference/maths/notation.html. A decently large list of notations. But it doesn’t have, for instance, the notation of calculus, and you must run a web search yourself to learn more about what a listed notation means. Hopefully in conjunction these resources will help. But it’s too bad that there isn’t anything quite like what you’re looking for; I would be curious to read such a tutorial, too.
- micro_cam 14y agoAs a mathematician who made the jump to software I feel that, while there is certainly room for improvement in math education, methods based too much on intuition and feel are a hugh step backwards. Math is about thinking abstractly. To do it at the level required by modern science, data analysis and engineering you need to be able to focus on the abstract symbols, equations and rules that govern them without relying on an intuition for underling objects. For example, no one has valid intuition for fluid turbulence, n dimensional manifold theory or complicated probability distributions, so great leeps in understanding these are made by people who have an intuition for how equations behave and rigorously show that it is valid. Real world applications are often only found after the fact. I think that they key to a good math education is not just showing students real world application but teaching them to find beauty and pleasure in abstract symbolic reasoning and the rigors of proof.
- TreyS 14y ago"As someone who was taught the 'traditional' way of mathematics, can someone give a few pointers of de-programming myself from the traditional way that I was taught." I tutor high school students in math and breaking the memorization, process based approach to math is usually pretty difficult. The biggest thing is to absolutely avoid memorizing or even looking at formulas. Instead, try and look at things graphically. A lot of formulas seem confusing and unintuitive but if you look at it on a graph, it makes a lot more sense. A basic example is something like the distance formulas. Students often say "Gah I can never remember the distance formula. I need to memorize it before the test" because d = sqrt( (x1 - x2)^2 + (y1 - y2)^2 ) seems complex and confusing. But if you draw a right triangle, it's apparent that the distance formula is just finding the hypotenuse. In a nutshell, focus on the why's and not the how's.
- atpaino 14y agoAs an undergrad math major, I've just recently run into this problem as I begin to take graduate level math courses. In the past (i.e. through high school math and basic calculus) I have always had a deeper understanding of the math going on such that I didn't really need to memorize many formulas or rules because I could always "reinvent" them (at least the simpler ones such as cos^2(x) + sin^2(x)=1) if I needed them. I have found this level of understanding far more difficult to attain recently. For example, this past semester I took a linear algebra course. Whenever I am given a definition or property, I typically try to prove/justify it to myself or at least figure out why it is interesting. I found in my linear algebra course that this was very difficult to do, since there were so many definitions that just seemed to be "dropped in", unexplained by the professor. Thus, I found myself memorizing formulas and theorems instead of having the deep understanding of them I was used to. I may have gone off on a little bit of a tangent, seeing as this article relates more to basic mathematics, but I think the underlying problem is the same. I'm not really sure what the solution is in my case, but I would guess that if my professor were to devote more time to explaining the usefulness of some of the more abstract concepts (such as eigenvalues) I would probably feel more comfortable with the subject.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoI did very poorly in math throughout high school (and mediocre in college). I still am not that great, but I feel I have a far deeper understanding than your average college or high school "A" student. It has nothing to do with how smart I am. It has everything to do with the fact that I have been using math in "real world" (ok, virtual world) problems for the last decade. You absolutely cannot "teach" math (beyond the elementary level) and expect students to fully understand how it works. Memorizing equations is not understanding. You must learn math, the hard way. Give a student a relevant problem, and tell them to solve it. Don't tell them how to solve it, let them derive the solution on their own. It might take weeks in some cases, but I guarantee they will have a much better understanding and increase their general problem-solving ability in all of mathematics.
- mahmud 14y ago(Shrink the size of math text books. No reason why an algebra or trig text needs to be 900 pages, each page in primary colors)
- OrionTheDog 14y agoWell I was not happy with the plug and chug approach to calculus so I wrote a book that uses a more intuitive geometric approach (at last it is intuitive to me) and put it all online for free at http://www.thegistofcalculus.com http://www.thegistofcalculus.com but nobody cares to read it so I guess people are actually fine with just memorizing everything. It is only about 50 pages and explains the meat & potatoes of the math class.
- krakensden 14y ago> The other, less common scene appears much more chaotic. Groups of students sit around circular tables discussing how to solve a particular problem, or standing at the whiteboard arguing about the best way to proceed. The teacher moves around the room talking with the different groups in turn, making suggestions as to how to proceed, or pointing out possible errors in a particular line of reasoning the students are following. Occasionally, the teacher will call the entire group to order and ask one group to explain their solution to the rest of the class, or to give a short, mini-lecture about a particular concept or method I had some classes that did this. In was invariably even less useful than "please memorize this formula", simply because of the social pressures.