3 ms·
> "annually producing several thousand litres of fuel." That's maybe 10 liters a day. Seems low for the size of the installation. A liter of gasoline is about
by Animats 2y ago
> "annually producing several thousand litres of fuel."
That's maybe 10 liters a day. Seems low for the size of the installation.
A liter of gasoline is about 10KWh. So if this thing gets 5 hours a day of full sunlight, it's putting out 2KW. That's like 5 standard solar panels.
Either I'm calculating this wrong or this is insanely inefficient.
- wolfi1 2y agoit is insanely inefficient. whereelse I read you need 3 liters of gasoline to produce 1 liter of synfuel
- ChuckMcM 2y agoWhat is your measure of efficiency? I ask because the cost of sunlight is nominally zero so 10kWh/$0 is a really big number :-). Note that the article said that as a thermal plant it operates 24/7 by storing heat in a high thermal mass fluid. Another shot at this is Terraform Industries (https://terraformindustries.com/ https://terraformindustries.com/) which is doing something similar with direct PV -> Fuel (rather than using CSP) The "magic bean", the "trick", the "secret sauce" here is that there are huge swathes of land that are currently both high sunlight receivers and not used (can't farm them, no one wants to live there, think deserts) That could be used to crank out liquid fuel that has no issue being losslessly transported over long distances and for applications that are unlikely to run on batteries any time soon. Making fuel for those by taking CO2 out of the atmosphere is a double win.
- roenxi 2y agoThe plant is physically quite large; the sunlight might be free but capital and deprecation will influence that ratio. Although if they can do this economically then good. I have a soft-spot for any solar farm that can be made to look a bit like a flower.
- chii 2y ago> sunlight is nominally zero the investment into the panels is not free though. But i do agree - converting electricity into fuels is great, but only if said electricity does not have another use and would've been wasted otherwise.
- h0l0cube 2y agoThe capex in something, the opex is neglible, but the opportunity cost doesn't make sense until energy prices go very low or negative is some permanent fashion, or both fuel costs are very high and the switching to alternatives costs too much, or is even infeasible (e.g., air and space transport, shipping, steel production). A premium might make sense for specialist operators who want 'carbon neutral fuel', and have customers willing to pay for it.
- jfengel 2y agoA fossil fuel tax would capture the externality that's currently not accounted for, and shift the viability of a project like this. All that's needed is the desire to avert much larger costs in the future. Or in other words, an absolute impossibility.
- kaliqt 2y agoThat's a very bad idea.
- herewulf 2y ago> Making fuel for those by taking CO2 out of the atmosphere is a double win. It's just a single win because the CO2 is going right back into the atmosphere as the fuel is used (carbon neutral, not carbon negative). Still, a win is better than the loss that extracted fuels amount to.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zemvpferreira 2y agoI agree but you could still argue that any economic incentive to develop better carbon capture is another win. If captured fuel gets lots of use, maybe it will become cheap enough to manufacture that we will do so purely for environmental reasons.
- beojan 2y agoYou don't have to use all the fuel produced. Presumably some could be used to make plastics and everything else we make from oil. You could also bury some.
- Scaevolus 2y agoCarbon-neutral combustion is a win over carbon-positive combustion of extracted coal/oil/gas.
- hnaccount_rng 2y agoIt's not entirely clear, that we can use e.g. deserts "for free". Changing the albedo of significant amounts of surface can have far reaching consequences. And unlike already populated areas (were this already happened), we don't really know what will happen there (probably until we try)
- spookie 2y agoThis is a good point. Urban areas are responsible in part for "global warming", just by their albedo. [1] [1] https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-31558-z https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-31558-z
- jfengel 2y ago"In part" means 0.00107°C over the next century. That's less than a thousandth of the overall rise. So it's really not the top priority. Even assuming this technology increases it by a factor of 10 it's a massive net gain to displace fossil fuels.
- dmurray 2y agoThis is a cool project, but it's fair to say that 10 litres of petrol a day isn't sufficient scale to be described as "THE WORLD’S first industrial plant using solar heat to make fuels". It's a research prototype.
- conradev 2y agoMy measure of efficiency would at least incorporate capex It takes a non-zero amount of energy to build all of that energy-capturing equipment – question is, how much?
- ChuckMcM 2y agoSure, if you're doing a TCO analysis you figure out a deprecation schedule for your physical plant and your OpEx for the day to day operations. Of course the CapEx for "one" versus the CapEx per instance for "one thousand" will be quite different. Also how much site prep is needed, how much can be built offsite in a factory setting Etc. So a full economic analysis would incorporate all of that. Then price that against the price of fuel with the carbon and environmental externalities priced in, sure. That would give you a solid set of reasoning to say whether these systems are worse, similar to, or better than existing systems. If you wait for all of that to be in place (versus risking capital today that might have been used for other things) then you risk dying from those aforementioned externalities of 'business as usual' (aka the do nothing hypothesis). John was, in my reading, defining "efficiency" to be turning the solar power available as electricity in the surface area of the plant into liquid fuel. And my response to that is always that the solar energy was going to hit that patch of ground anyway, and if you don't have the infrastructure to move it to where it is needed "right now" or store it, then its wasted. California is, today, having days where Solar and/or Wind generation is discarded because there are no customers demanding it. At some point (hopefully soon) we'll get better at dealing with this situation, and converting that "extra" power into syngas is a good use for it.
- almostnormal 2y ago> That's maybe 10 liters a day. Seems low for the size of the installation. A liter of gasoline is about 10KWh. So if this thing gets 5 hours a day of full sunlight, it's putting out 2KW. That's like 5 standard solar panels. > Either I'm calculating this wrong or this is insanely inefficient. With your numbers: 10 l/day * 10 kWh/l / 5 h/day = 20 kW
- Animats 2y agoRight. That's better. But there's more mirror area there than even 50 standard solar panels.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- herewulf 2y agoIt's a pilot plant. Its purpose is to develop, test, and demonstrate the technology. If successful then they can follow through with plans to build bigger plants that run at full capacity. They won't get the funding for the latter step without the former step first.
- swiftcoder 2y agoIt's a small-scale prototype of a much larger plant: > Synhelion already has plans to build a much larger plant in Spain in 2025 that will ramp production up to around 1,000 t/y. And beyond that, its ambition is to be manufacturing 1m t/y within a decade