8 ms·
Vigorous Exercise, Cognitive Decline, and High Blood Pressure
- throwawaysleep 2y agoThey really need to work on exercise in a pill so that it can matter for public health purposes.
- peter_retief 2y agoI think the positive effects for physical exercise in cognition and hypertension are fairly well known. There are other factors like alcohol consumption and stress have high correlation on the downside as well. I have a family history of alzheimer's and have hypertension so have a personal interest in looking after my mental health. What I can recommend from personal experience is: 1) Regular exercise with a routine designed by a fitness trainer. 2) No alcohol, moderation is not an option 3) Manage your stress, some repetitive tasks I find useful, like household chores
- data-ottawa 2y agoIn your experience why is alcohol moderation not enough; Is it that the effects of a little are still significant, or that it still lives room for abuse?
- peter_retief 2y agoI found the effects of low consumption significant.
- tuyiown 2y agoGiven the focus on hypertension, I'd venture that because alcohol always increases tension, so you have to ban it if you what to avoid any kind of tension peaks.
- old_bayes 2y agoJesus, you manage stress by doing chores?
- peter_retief 2y agoGive it a try you may be surprised. It is about attitude rather than the actual task.
- noufalibrahim 2y agoYes. When a task doesn't require concentrated mental effort, it can be quite relaxing. The hands take on a life of their own and the mind can relax. Pressing clothes, shining shoes etc. An old school hobby that I think served the same purpose was whittling. I do something like that from time to time and it has a very calming effect.
- District5524 2y ago"The greatest among you will be your servant. For those who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted." (Obviously, I'm neither Jesus nor the OP).
- grape_surgeon 2y agoWhy is this so ridiculous? Cleaning can be meditative. Just zone out
- ramblerman 2y agoIf you find chores stressful how do you handle a high stakes situation?
- m_kos 2y agoI had a highly-educated, very intelligent girlfriend once. She loved cleaning the toilet. She said it relaxed her and she enjoyed seeing the results of her work immediately.
- keiferski 2y agoI am no expert on the public health system and so I'm more than willing to be educated/corrected here, but I have the following impression: There is more money to be made by stakeholders treating health problems than there is in preventing them. And so there is a lot more money and effort invested in developing pharmaceutical and treatment solutions than there is in preventing the problems they treat – even though that would be far, far better for society as a whole. Alternatively/additionally, the stakeholders that make money treating things (insurance companies, hospitals, etc.) are simply larger and better capitalized than those that make money preventing health problems (gyms, health food stores, etc.) The biggest gym or fitness company in the world is probably minuscule in comparison to the average medical company. The only wrinkle in my understanding here is that as far as I know, insurance rates are lower for healthy people, and thus doctors(?) are somewhat incentivized to have healthier patients. Is there a market-based solution to this? And if so, what would it look like? Tax breaks for gyms? More lobbying from Big Gym?
- throwawaysleep 2y agoThe barrier to exercise isn’t money in most cases. It is that exercise is misery. Exercise sucks. I am overweight. I much prefer Ozempic (and pay a substantial premium for it) vs lifestyle change. So do millions of other Americans who are shelling out for it. You would basically need to economically torture fat people to the point that exercise is less horrible than your incentives. I’m paying 8K a year to avoid exercise.
- danielbln 2y agoIt's a shame that exercise is linked to misery for so many people, because it doesn't have to be miserable. Hell, it's so so much easier to stick with it if it isn't miserable. I always tell new runners to slow down, like ridiculously slow, laughably slow. If it feels like the lung is burning and you want to vomit, oh that is wayyyyy too fast. Keep it slow and steady and maybe only ever so slightly uncomfortable, then allow your body to adapt and ride that feeling until you're all of the sudden exercising much harder but without feeling like you do. I posit that exercise does not have to feel terrible to work, and that it can be turned into something that feels maybe a little bit uncomfortable during, but really nice after.
- pif 2y agoIf you want slimmer people, invest in hunger-stopping pills. Have a lettuce satiate you like two ham and cheese baguettes, and the obesity problem will disappear overnight.
- keiferski 2y agoIsn’t that pretty much what Ozempic does?
- pif 2y agoI don't know this Ozempic. If people take it for at most a few years, then yes, it may do what I described. On the other end, if people are supposed to take it for life, then it does surely not!
- thefz 2y agoExercise has benefits that span far beyond weight loss, like the article you clearly haven't opened states. In fact, in many cases it's not even necessary for weight loss alone, as controlling the caloric input is enough.
- pif 2y ago> Exercise has benefits that span far beyond weight loss, Don't you think that slimmer people are more inclined to enjoy exercising?
- thefz 2y agoDefine slim? Many "skinnyfat" (no muscle, no fat) people don't like to move, and there are lots of muscular people that enjoy exercising. Is that a function of bodyfat percentage? I doubt so as well. Ideal BF% in men goes from 8 to 20%, when I see lots of people above 20% in the trails or running/cycling around. Besides, if the goal is weight loss, that can be achieved with caloric restriction and zero minutes of cardio. It's thermodynamics. Move for the sake of it, not for weight loss.
- 2y ago
- isaacfrond 2y agoLet's do it one more time. Correlation != Causation Could the causation conceivably run the other direction? People with beginning dementia exercise less? Yes, that is quite conceivable actually. Could there be a common cause explaining both? Yes, if you are in good health, with good genes, a good job, leisure time and money, then probably you are the type of person who'll live longer, sport more, and be cognitively healthy for a longer time. It doesn't mean the causality runs in the other direction. In other words, this study shows what we all know. The 'good' people have all the good stuff. But what we want to know, will an intervention that causes people to exercise more do any good?
- gwd 2y ago> Baseline self-reported frequency of VPA was categorized into low VPA (<1 session/week), and high VPA (≥1 session/week). So yeah, this is a mere correlational study, and a self-reported one at that. So technically, it could even be that people who think they exercise harder have better health outcomes.
- drited 2y agoYes methodology here seems suspect. Also: Activity levels were self reported. Could just be that early stages of dementia cause individuals to forget - either that they exercised or to exercise or to report.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 2y ago>Let's do it one more time. Correlation != Causation No, please let's not. This almost automatic HN reaction to every research is the lowest tier of facile dismissal.
- thefz 2y agoSometimes I wonder if commenters in this forum will do anything to try to disprove that exercise is good for health.
- 2y ago
- zarzavat 2y agoSomewhat unrelated but is there any SOTA for what “vigorous cardiovascular exercise” should be to optimize benefits? Should I just exercise flat out and try to sustain that as long as I can, or is there a level of vigorous exertion below flat out that leads to better results because of the longer duration?
- phoebos 2y agoIt was self-assessed: > When we say ‘vigorous’ we mean activities that make you sweat, increase your heart rate or increase your breathing. Please think about vigorous activities that you may have done at home or at places of work other than your home, as well as vigorous recreational activities or conditioning exercises. Please think over the last year and indicate how often you participate in vigorous activities.
- 082349872349872 2y agoYou're overthinking it. Do you stop afterwards and catch your breath? It was vigorous. Bonus if you broke a sweat. There's no need to be more qualitative than that for most folk (a "suboptimal" schedule consistently applied being vastly preferable to an "optimal" one inconsistently), but if you absolutely insist on getting quantitative, see: https://pacompendium.com https://pacompendium.com [in particular, see https://pacompendium.com/sexual-activity/ https://pacompendium.com/sexual-activity/ : a light pash might be twice as much activity as just sitting on the couch, while "scaring the horses" can be six times]
- garspin 2y agoGoogle 'polarized training'. It's 80% really slow conversational pace jogging, and 20% really hard, struggle to breath flat out sprinting. Just avoid the intermediate jogging that's comfortable, but unproductive.
- sebnun 2y agoHIIT fits the bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_interval_training https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_interval_traini...
- personalityson 2y ago"Scientists researching possible candidates for treating Alzheimer's disease found exercise outperformed all tested drugs for the ability to reverse dysregulated gene expression." https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-22179-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-22179-z "High fitness in middle age reduces the chance of dementia by ninety percent" https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/03/180315101805.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/03/180315101805.h...
- nabla9 2y agoDifference is just 5.8 per 1000 person-years. The effect size is very modest. You spend more time in exercising than increase your lifespan. The metaphor is literal, you are running from death and disease, and death is running faster. What we need is review studies ranking lifestyle and health regimes by their effect size and combined effect sizes. Almost certainly combining two effective regimes increases the life- and healthspan more than their sum. Whatever you do, the effect likely is probably just 5 years of healthspan (relative to your generation). Wild guess: Body weight, proper nutrition, exercise, no stress, no smoking or alcohol and controlling inflammation in the body other ways, like dental hygiene[1] is the best you can do. [1]: Patients with periodontitis have a doubled risk of stroke already before age 50 https://www.helsinki.fi/en/news/brain/patients-periodontitis-have-doubled-risk-stroke-already-age-50 https://www.helsinki.fi/en/news/brain/patients-periodontitis...
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoLiving longer but less fit is no prize. It's also misery to shuffle around and wheeze through every minute of your life. Exercise improves sleep, improves cognitive function and make tasks easier and more enjoyable. Everything about your life improves. I bicycle, and I enjoy it. It is one of the reasons I want to live longer.
- nabla9 2y agoGood for you. But this is not about you. I feel the same, but this is not about me. For people who read this and don't exercise, may not feel it enjoyable, it's often uphill all the time. They don't like exercise. Maybe being just thin and losing weight would be better, or doing non-vigorous exercise. We don't have much information. We make stories going off the tangent on some studies.
- pengaru 2y agoEverybody feels better when healthy, and worse when sick. Viewing this topic purely through years of life extension is severely flawed.
- 2y ago
- sgt101 2y agoI have only had a quick look, but I think that this is suss because of the VPA definition. The authors could show us the data vs. response to the questionnaire, in particular the columns for folks doing >5 episodes of high intensity exercise per week... but they don't and instead simply show the categories >1per week and <1 per week. This smells bad.
- Samanthabontle 2y ago[flagged]