3 ms·
They may not be future underwater loans. Buyers are speculating on a distressed asset someone is willing to let go at a discount. Might be worth nothing, but al
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
They may not be future underwater loans. Buyers are speculating on a distressed asset someone is willing to let go at a discount. Might be worth nothing, but also might be worth something. Banks have more stringent regulatory requirements with regards to these loans than speculators.
From the piece:
> For investors, the attraction of snapping up discounted commercial real estate loans is that the loans could be worth a lot more if the industry recovers in the next few years. And in the worst-case scenario, the buyers get to take possession of a building at a discounted price after a foreclosure.
“Buy when there is blood in the streets” — Baron Rothschild
- jaggederest 2y agoAs I've learned sometimes businesses are unable to properly value something that, intuitively, has a clear nonzero value. Classic example would be selling something with an ongoing royalty of e.g. 10% of future profit.
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoThe UK has huge swathes of empty commercial property. The book value of the property is related to prospective rental income. It is - bizarrely - sometimes more profitable for owners and investors to maintain the fiction of high rental value without any income than to drop the rental value to something realistic and take a realised loss. Even if that's generating real income. I would guess it's the same in the US. This leans suspiciously towards subprime-all-over-again, where the nominal value and security of investments is being wildly overstated. At some point it's going to have be unwound, which will create some interesting readjustments.
- jaggederest 2y agoYeah I think the world collectively needs mark-to-market rules for real estate quite urgently. This "we will give you 6 months free rent but never lower the rent rate" scam is pretty toxic.
- kryptiskt 2y agoTaking possession of the real estate might not even be the worst case scenario for the buyer of the loans, it might be their plan A all along.
- creer 2y ago> Might be worth nothing In the US it's more or less impossible for the loans to be worth "nothing". They are usually secured by the property itself. But the loan itself is worth less if it's in default, rather than not quite yet in default. So it can be a better deal for a bank to sell it away now rather than later.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThese investments should have immediate positive value at the right price, but there are potential edge cases that are catastrophic to such a speculative play (maybe have to tear the building down, future dispute wrt claim, etc). Unlikely, but possible.
- crznp 2y agoIt doesn't seem wildly unlikely: there is a fundamental shift in how office spaces work. But the other side is possible too: even if the loans had a guaranteed long term value (like SVB's bonds), they could be an issue in the short term. More so if getting the value out of the loan requires both time and effort (eg: legal costs).
- creer 2y agoYes, and we do hear sometimes of a massive pile of taxes due, coming with the building.
- TuringNYC 2y ago>> In the US it's more or less impossible for the loans to be worth "nothing". Totally disagree. A loan can absolutely be worth nothing, especially if it is a 2nd/subordinated lien. Imagine you buy a house for $1000 with $800 borrowed ($700 first lien, $100 second lien.) If the home goes down in value 30%, the second lien is worthless. The administrative and legal cost of recovering the second lien may be greater than the recoverable value of the second lien, which in this case is $0.
- timr 2y agoYou're describing a situation where the second lien is underwater. This is not itself the value of the loan. Just in the obvious case, if the borrower continues to pay, the lien is worth the future value of its cashflows. Not everyone who goes underwater on a loan simply stops paying. In the US, even loans in default tend to have some value, because speculators are willing to buy the debt and attempt collection.
- fnordpiglet 2y agoYea this is a crucial point. The capital reserve requirements since the financial crisis on these assets is crazy high for a systemically important institution. Offloading to a less regulated entity would significantly improve the value of the position.