16 ms·
Traffic noise hurts children's brains
- globular-toast 2y ago> "The guidelines don't [mention] fluctuations and peaks. Every time there is a noise peak, it is a distraction which can affect children's attention [span] and working memory," This is the worst part, I think. Rail and aircraft are at least predictable and, presumably, no louder than they have to be. But all it takes is one asshole with a loud car or motorbike and hundreds or even thousands of people are disturbed. Why are these bastards allowed to continue with ever louder motors? How do people live with it? Do they not realise that it could be quiet? This is something we could choose to have quite easily.
- rustcleaner 2y agoMy proposed fix is to make speeding ticket funds NOT EVER go to local governments, pass vehicle noise limits comparable to last decade's new vehicles stock (with fat paycheck busting fines), pass every cop a handheld combination laser range finder/parabolic decibel meter/video camera enforcement device/"gun," and make the fines go totally to local government. 3rd time or intentional over-100 decibel should be crusher (with no loan discharge) for the car and five years in the clink for felony disturbing the peace. No more loud fucklechucks! :^)
- rustcleaner 2y agoOh and motorcycles at full rev must be made as quiet as a VW TDI. Thank Harley Davidson and his customers!
- erikaww 2y agoWhy the crusher? Just repo it or take all the expensive parts out. Then give that money to schools or use it to fund putting out cameras to automate traffic enforcement
- ehnto 2y agoGovernment run chopshops is what you are suggesting. The incentives are all bad, it would get exploited even if the profit goes to a school, because the middlemen still get paid. Kickbacks to cops getting cars into the workshop. I don't disagree with the general sentiment mind you. I think tarketing specific cars will do little, given even a regulation following car is still very impactful across a range of issues.
- erikaww 2y agoThere sounds like a simple fix: have the city run the full stack (including towing). Ideally most cars flowing in would be from automated enforcement. Regulation will only work with strong enforcement. By taking such aggressive actions, we can also elicit information on shops doing illegal work and have the police shut their businesses down.
- shiroiushi 2y agoI don't like the idea of destroying stuff (except aftermarket noise-making parts). How about sticking the car on a boat and shipping it to some other country and donating it there? No one profits.
- ZoomerCretin 2y agoWhy should speeding ticket funds not go to local governments? Noise may be damaging, but to a much lower degree than a violent death by car crash which speed limits reduce.
- Dylan16807 2y agoBecause it causes really bad incentives. Sometimes including making roads more dangerous with speed changes!
- ehnto 2y agoRoads are never less safe by reducing the speed, except in the case that the road design didn't also change to accompany the reduction. If you slow down a 60mph road to 20mph you need to signal with the design, that it's not safe to go fast here. Reduce the lanes, width, remove the demarking areas etc.
- Dylan16807 2y agoI don't mean the whole road, I mean segments. The speed changes while driving on it, not compared to what it was months or years ago. And then, yes, not using the design to signal the speed changes. If they're even in charge of that.
- rustcleaner 2y agoJust want to incentivize switching from radar gun to sound gun. Local departments are who principally enforce this, and taking away a reliable speeding revenue source should hunger their budgets up a bit for the noise enforcement. I'm sure laser speed acquisition could be added.
- idunnoman1222 2y agoYeah that will be popular
- ChainOfFools 2y agogot my vote! Except maybe the jail part, but I know you're probably being a little bit hyperbolic
- rustcleaner 2y agoI lived over 15 years in a house on a 2x2 lane. Speeding deaths doubling would cause less social harm than the hundreds of thousands (at least) suffering mental issues from constant vehicle noise. All the opportunity costs.
- spinach 2y agoAlso why are lawn mowers so loud and not made to be quieter in some way? Why does everyone need to cut their lawn in the first place?
- idunnoman1222 2y agoElectric lawn mowers exist
- ChainOfFools 2y agoUnfortunately idiots who will run the mower over their own cord, or absent minded who consistently forget to plug the thing in to charge it, also exist. And more neutrally there is a certain laudable economy in not throwing away a perfectly functional lawn mower just because it's become a relative nuisance as the options around that have become better over time. The lawn mower equivalent of wanting to drive a car until the wheels fall off because why trash a perfectly functional car when so many people don't even have that. Finally there are other people who actually enjoy the petty power thrill that comes with being able to make all of their neighbors endure the harsh grating drone of a 2 stroke engine, the kind of person who doesn't see the problem with suggesting other people should wear earplugs in their own homes when he's mowing his lawn, (there's a number of this type in this very comment section doing the same for cars) and because there is a flimsy but historically normalized justification for it -before electric mowers appeared on the market, everyone else with lawns to cut had to be equally guilty of making a comparable racket willing or not- they get away with it as there's no straightforward legal argument that isolates exactly why what they're doing is a net harm to the quality of life of all their neighbors.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y ago> Why does everyone need to cut their lawn in the first place? Because they want to? It's amazing how informative and insightful the HN crowd can be, however as most of the crowd seems to live in large cities there is intolerance to rural living.
- akira2501 2y agoFrom the Barcelona study linked in the article: "Conclusions We observed that exposure to road traffic noise at school, but not at home, was associated with slower development of working memory, complex working memory, and attention in schoolchildren over 1 year. Associations with noise fluctuation indicators were more evident than with average noise levels in classrooms." So, at the very least, the title of the original article does not seem justified. In fact the whole article comes off like a bad internet argument, tons of links that aren't understood, and the whole thing is designed to reach a pretermined conclusion, which is, of course: "Car-free zones The best way to protect children from excessive noise is by reducing traffic around schools, says Foraster. " I mean. Why not just sound proof class rooms? Seems way easier than entirely reengineering traffic in a dense urban environment. This really feels like "think of the kids!" now applied to traffic.
- rustcleaner 2y agoYou just know this is sponsored Walkable City™ SEO-slop.
- lovethevoid 2y agoBecause it’s not just class rooms, although those are places you want them to be at their peak. It’s just the easiest to consistently test. Additionally, with how severely under funded education is, you’re not going to get much effective sound proofing. Most classrooms can’t even afford regular maintenance.
- xnyan 2y ago>We observed that exposure to road traffic noise at school, but not at home, was associated with slower development of working memory, complex working memory, and attention in schoolchildren over 1 year Pretend I'm dumb, why is this not a bad thing? >Why not just sound proof class rooms? Seems way easier than entirely reengineering traffic in a dense urban environment. I see it completely the other way. Reductions in the maximum allowed speed in the direct area around the school to archive the target noise maximum would be far more efficient than sound mitigation for the school.
- 2y ago
- t-writescode 2y agoTwo of the best parts, to me, about electric cars are: 1) lower pollution where people live, so you can go for runs and such without breathing in a bunch of noxious gas 2) how much quieter inner city walking will become. It can’t come fast enough!
- fire_lake 2y agoBig improvements, but keep in mind that air and tyre resistance are the loudest aspects of driving at even moderate speeds.
- alan-hn 2y agoAnd that pollution of tire degradation is one of the biggest sources of particles from cars
- guntars 2y agoDon’t forget the brakes. When the rotors get worn down, where did they go?
- MVissers 2y agoNot a big issue with evs, most use regenerative breaking.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoAs do hybrids! Even mild hybrids like those new pickups
- shiroiushi 2y agoThe rotors aren't the problem, the pads are. Rotors are just cast iron, and they wear very slowly compared to the pads.
- georgeburdell 2y ago
- oopsallmagic 2y agoAdult brains, too. I appreciate the study, but this is one of those "yes, obviously" situations for anyone who has ever been outside amongst cars.
- whythrowshade 2y ago[flagged]
- ZoomerCretin 2y agoIt's one of those "yes, obviously" situations that are surprisingly controversial if you mention it in conversation. There are a lot of people (likely the already heavily hearing-damaged) that have zero problem with road noise and are very dismissive of any and all noise concerns.
- brnt 2y agoAt soms point I realized people who think noise sensitivity is ridiculous are always either old, partied a lot or are hard of hearing through other means. Yeah, of course problems you don't have seem silly. At least, for the minimally empathetic.
- yieldcrv 2y agoThat’s the best result for a study
- james4k 2y agoWe already know pollution from cars increases childhood asthma, and I imagine those pollutants could affect brain development as well. Edit: Also I would be curious to know how dog barks affect children's brains. Of all the environmental noise, dogs are often the loudest and most jarring, anecdotally.
- erikaww 2y agoDogs barking cannot be worse than cars, especially compensators with the pop pop pop engines or tires screeching. Live right by a doggy daycare and several busy arterials
- james4k 2y agoOn average I agree. Dog noise doesn't carry nearly as far. But if you're neighbors with noisy dogs, it's probably at the top of your mind.
- dagw 2y agoright by a doggy daycare Doggy daycares are generally run by people who love dogs and know how to work with them and make them behave. The problem dogs are the ones owned by people who don't care how they behave and just leave them outside and ignore them.
- GoblinSlayer 2y agoIME the loudest are bikes and metro (inside). There's an occasional mustang, but bikes are still louder.
- obruchez 2y agoMotorcycles are absolutely the worst. Even when they drive as slow as possible, to make less noise, they're still noisier than some cars. This is insane. And what's frustrating is that this is considered a feature, not a bug. I don't know how we can get out of that particular culture. I'm not sure electric motorcycles would help at all.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThis feels like a study with many confounding factors.
- brikym 2y agoIt may not be noise causing all these things. It could be tyre dust or fumes or lack of exercise from driving everywhere or anxiety from being hit by a car. It still points a big finger at car culture being bad.
- idunnoman1222 2y agoNot really, probably rich kids have schools that are quieter
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoProbably? I don't know about that, there are many "rich kids" in manhattan, one of the noisiest places in the US.
- idunnoman1222 2y agoYeah, those ones are probably loopy in particular because the city is polluted
- DangitBobby 2y agoThe article starts with the story of a public school next to a subway line that has measurably lower test scores for children in parts of the school where the noise of the subway is higher. Imagine my surprise when the CTA at the end was about removing car traffic noise! I guess "cities too fucking loud for healthy child development" doesn't exactly match the current cultural zeitgeist. Not particularly surprising to find yet another HN comments section talking about how cars are evil, though.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoDid anyone read the article or is this just turning into /r/fuckcars? The first 3 paragraphs are about SUBWAY cars (aka public transportation) being too loud. The article also talks about other forms of transportation being too loud.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- majormajor 2y agoSo beyond "make the schools themselves" quieter, some analysis of "traffic noise where the kids live" vs "non-traffic noise" would be useful here. There is a lot in the article about negative effects of all sorts of unwanted noise. But it seems like it would be just as easy to go to "this is why we need well-built schools and well-insulated cars and big parking lots and sprawling low-density housing so the kids can have quiet at home too" as to "get rid of cars" from this.
- ehnto 2y agoWhat non traffic noise? I am struggling to come up with a single thing that could be consistently as loud as a road and actually be likely near a school. Whereas cars are made basically mandatory, so will always be near schools.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoDid anyone read the article or is this just turning into /r/fuckcars? The first 3 paragraphs are about SUBWAY cars (aka public transportation) being too loud. The article also talks about other forms of transportation being too loud.
- ehnto 2y agoI'm focussing on cars because they are the far more likely culprit. Few cities in American even have a metro, so it's the less wide spread issue.
- schmookeeg 2y agoI wonder how soon we'll be charging those "crackle map" exhaust hoonigans with assault on the un-thought-of children.
- ChainOfFools 2y agoNot soon enough, and even though I'm a parent frankly it's for my own sanity as much as for that of my kids. I have no sympathy, in fact negative sympathy shading into election year issue territory, for the small but growing minority who feel entitled to make all us living in a quarter mile radius of their incredibly irrelevant presense get rudely disrupted by their deliberately obnoxious ear-splitting noise machine, _inside our own homes_ when trying to take a nap, have a conversation, read a story or do anything at a normal indoor volume. Why is society decided to accept this Behavior in a way that they would never accept, say, someone marching down the street tossing firecrackers into the air at all hours of the day? The answer is simply that it's too impractical to catch and penalize people who get a petty sadistic power thrill out of their consequence-free enshittification the ambient public space. I welcome the growing use of noise maps as evaluation layers in the real estate and rental markets, only by putting hard numbers on the degradation of value that this causes, particularly for homeowners, will any measures with actual teeth be implemented to push back on it.
- stctw 2y agoI am with you 100%. Imagine, if you would, that you lived in an apartment, and that you spent $2,000 on a stereo system, and that you turned up the volume so high that people in vehicles, driving by on the nearby street, could feel the sound waves inside their vehicles from a quarter-mile away. What would happen if you did that? Well, obviously, someone would call the police, and they would bang on your door, and they would warn or cite you, and you'd have to pay a fine or appear in court. On top of that, you'd probably get an angry call from your landlord, and if you ever did it again, you'd probably be evicted. It would be absurdly anti-social behavior that's prohibited by existing laws and ordinances. But, somehow, as you said, society tolerates the very same behavior when the source is inside a vehicle rolling around on wheels. And yet, if you think about it, as that vehicles rolls from one end of town to another, down busy streets, past residences and businesses and hospitals, the number of people needlessly antagonized and harmed by the noise must number in the thousands each day. "But it's only for a few seconds," the other side will say. And yet it happens over, and over, and over again, tens of times a day, day after day, waking people up too early in the morning, disturbing them while they live and work at home, and keeping them up at night. And the purpose of this noise? Is it a necessary by-product of the vehicle's natural purpose? Of course not. The purpose is solely, completely, 100%, and only, self-aggrandizement of the operator; to intentionally antagonize innocent strangers who can't even be seen by the antagonist. If anyone doubts this, one should look at a few advertisements offering these audio systems for sale. "DISTURB YOUR NEIGHBORS" is a common theme, even an explicit one. The noise is entirely artificial, with no reasonable, ethical, or moral purpose. To derive pleasure from the mere intuition that someone, somewhere is being antagonized by one's own actions is surely a sociopathic, anti-social, anti-societal behavior. We hear the cries to legalize some drugs because "they don't harm anyone but the user," but where are the cries to de-legalize this widely harmful behavior? Well, FWIW, I've been told by local cops that the behavior is already illegal in my area, but when they've cited offenders, their cases have been dismissed by local judges, so now they don't bother. Why? Who knows, but when I consider the local businesses that sell these stereo systems, I can only imagine their reaction to a campaign to "lower the boom" by ticketing offenders, and I wonder what influence they may have on local government. Put that together with increased violence in general, and the increased risk of a confrontation at any traffic stop, and I can imagine that cops consider carefully whether to initiate one for various behaviors. And we hear these cries to make people live closer together, in smaller dwellings. No, I want to be further apart, with more buffer. I am very careful not to impose my by-products on my neighbors, but not all of them are so considerate. /rant (I so rarely see like-minded people talking about this issue)
- LightHugger 2y agoI drove through a school the other day. The school was actually part of a 6 lane highway, like, it was built over it, the highway kinda formed a tunnel through a piece of one of the school buildings which flanked both sides of the roadway. Not really sure what's up with that, but holy fuck did i feel bad for those kids. Just one of those things that makes you go "the fuck is wrong with this country (it was in the US)".
- tssva 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MichaelRo 2y agoI might be overly sensitive to car noise but I find revving engines extremely annoying. Fortunately (and by choice) I live in a relatively low traffic area, so at least at night it's got almost no traffic, but during the day it's got enough of it to force me to shut close the thermopane windows and doors AND turn on an electric fan heater without the heat, so the low frequency white noise it makes masks the occasional roaring of the car engine passing by. Also it's not like all the cars, most cars pass by with their engine on idle so they make little noise. Every now and then (which by law of statistics translates to always, eventually after some time), some idiot accelerates aggressively when their clutch is disengaged, resulting in the engine squealing like a demented stuck pig and me almost getting a seizure out of stress. And then there's the occasional SUV with tank tracks instead of tires (figuratively speaking, they have tires suitable for climbing muddy hills, not cruising through residential areas) which zooms around at 80Km/h, in this case can't hear the engine because the darn tracks make so much noise you can hear them from several blocks away. Hate. Cars. Also an unpopular opinion which will 100% guarantee I get fiercely downvoted: "they" should make gas prices not 10-20% but 4x - 8x higher. So the vast majority of the idiots would have to take the public transportation system instead of the current standard of 3 cars for a family of two and sitting in traffic for 90 minutes to make what would otherwise be a 20-30 minutes transit. Differential price for individual (luxury) transportation.
- ptman 2y agoHate cars, but especially car noise. I find it fucking insane that we require quiet EVs to make engine noise. Drop the speed furthe instead. And people need to learn to watch for pedestrians. And pedestrians need to watch for cars, maybe get rid of the (noise cancelling) headphones
- pmg101 2y agoI agree with you about the disappointment. However I do also think EVs creep up on people and the stats bear this out - 3x more pedestrian collisions in urban areas EVs vs ICE. The moment of maximum surprise for me is when a silent and stationary vehicle suddenly moves. I think EVs should have to clear their throats before moving forward.
- simonebrunozzi 2y agoIn 2021 I decided to move from San Francisco to Venice, Italy - where obviously there are no cars. People walk a lot more. The level of noise in this city is by far the weakest compared even to a small village town, because of lack of cars. I love it here. It's only anecdotal, but I am sure that this positively affect many things in my life, including my stress levels and the quality of my sleep.
- dddw 2y agoThat it is a walking/boating city is exactly what is so great about it. It's a great place to simply walk and get lost in the smaller streets until you find a grand canal. It surely has grown on me.