7 ms·
Singapore doubles down on lab-grown meat as Silicon Valley backs off
- ImHereToVote 2y agoCan someone explain how lab grown meat releases less greenhouse gasses? Seems like much more energy inefficient than the old fashion way. Are there any figures available that go into the thermodynamics of it all?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 2y agoNobody talks about the thermodynamics because right now it's terrible (also why the economics is terrible - nobody can get anywhere the $3/kg of chicken breast). However, theoretically lab grown meat could be a big win on the thermodynamics front, and whoever solves that will have a far easier time getting the economics working too.
- arrobbiato 2y agoThe idea is that cows, and all the infrastructure around raising them, are a huge source of greenhouse gasses, while just cultivating cow meat eliminates everything not directly related to producing a hamburger. More recent studies [1] cast doubt on that and even suggest as you do that cell-cultured meat may be more environmentally damaging, not less. [1] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.04.21.537778v1.full https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.04.21.537778v1....
- energy123 2y agoCan you condense the argument for us? Why can't the supply chain be decarbonised?
- arrobbiato 2y agoOne of the main factors: generating the growth media for the cells is by no means carbon-free, and some of the ingredients are very very carbon intensive to produce.
- energy123 2y agoDo you mean energy intensive or carbon intensive?
- arrobbiato 2y agoCarbon intensive. Most of them are agriculturally sourced, and fossil fuels/feedstocks are not likely to be widely replaced in agriculture for several decades, at least.
- kibwen 2y agoWhen talking about beef specifically, the problem is that cows produce a disproportionate amount of methane, which is a disproportionately powerful greenhouse gas. If you don't want to give up meat but do want to make a dent in your emissions, even just eating pork or chicken instead is an improvement. There might be ways to reduce the emissions of cows in the future (different feeds, gut biome interventions, bioengineering), but right now these are science fiction. As for the energy inputs themselves, the notion of grass-fed beef often gets trotted out as a way to make beef more eco-friendly, but in practice this mostly amounts to greenwashing. Most beef is not grass-fed, and most places in the world that raise cows are not suited to pure grass feeding. And then there's the land use aspect. When we're clearcutting the Amazon in order to satisfy the world's demand for beef, we've fucked up.
- klipt 2y ago> There might be ways to reduce the emissions of cows in the future (different feeds, gut biome interventions, bioengineering), but right now these are science fiction. I thought there's already research showing that seaweed in the cow's diet drastically reduces methane emissions.
- coryrc 2y agoYes, just 2% of diet as seaweed essentially eliminates methane emissions. But there's no price on methane emissions for the farmer so no incentive to do so.
- raverbashing 2y agoI wonder if anyone tried to capture methane produced in this way
- ryanjshaw 2y ago> cows produce a disproportionate amount of methane, which is a disproportionately powerful greenhouse gas. Can somebody explain run through these quickly, I'm not sure which parts are wrong and how much they're wrong: 1. the constituents in the methane came from the food the cows eat? 2. the food got it from the atmosphere? 3. cows don't increase methane constantly, rather it's the marginal volume of feed required to sustain every new cow on the planet less the ones slaughtered? I.e. the growth in new supply? 4. Eliminating cows raised for meat would stop the increase in methane due to increase in supply and it would result in a one-off net reduction in atmospheric methane in time proportional to what cows were releasing, assuming the food continues to grow? 5. What happens when the food the cows are no longer eating dies, does anything get released then?
- MattGaiser 2y agoOne of the larger issues is the methane byproduct, i.e. they fart. It isn’t just about energy.
- coryrc 2y agoBurps, actually. Even harder to capture if you were going to try.
- dvh 2y agoI think the end goal is control of food production: 1. Introduce artificial meat that only large corporations can make 2. Ban natural meat as artificial alternative exists 3. Jack up the prices and profit
- llamaimperative 2y agoThat’s actually super hilarious given the conglomeration that has occurred already anyway. Turns out you can just skip both the incredible engineering problem of lab grown meat and the incredible political problem of “banning meat” and even people who are apparently paranoid about corporate/government control will just go right along with it.
- spamizbad 2y agoMost of the meat consumed in the US already comes from a large corporation. 99% of it is factory farmed. Source: https://ourworldindata.org/how-many-animals-are-factory-farmed https://ourworldindata.org/how-many-animals-are-factory-farm...
- energy123 2y agoReality is the opposite with the agriculture and beef lobbies influencing government and cultured meat facing outright bans
- 123yawaworht456 2y agohowever, agriculture and beef lobbies don't demand a ban on small farms and individual cattle raising.
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[flagged]
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[dead]
- 2y ago
- mytailorisrich 2y agoI think it's more an issue of resources rather than raw energy. If this can be produced using much less space, locally to consumers, and using clean energy then it's a net gain. What I'm interested in is where do the raw materials come from? I suppose this needs a number of "ingredients", including proteins, that must be sourced from somewhere.
- arrobbiato 2y agoCell-cultured meat industry veteran (and dropout) here. If Singaporean companies are able to make a viable business out of cell-cultured meat, that would be fantastic, and a boon to the world. Some skepticism is warranted, though. It's very difficult to do this at scale, and that's regardless of unit price. Cultivating the meat that sells at a mass-market price is the real challenge and one I wouldn't bet on anytime soon, not even by 2030. The technical challenges are too many to list here, some of which are not public knowledge. Besides, the once-touted environmental advantages have turned out to be marginal at best. One way this business might make sense would be to sell boutique cell-cultured "specialty" meats, like scallops, veal, and wooly mammoth (yes, it's been seriously considered). They're not nearly as price-sensitive, and the scale is smaller. Here's hoping we can ease the burden on endangered populations and mitigate the inherent cruelty of some of those industries with cell-cultured alternatives.
- contingencies 2y agoSingapore is a follower. Whatever they're in to happened elsewhere 2 years before. More broadly, it's not really about cell-cultured meat. It's about producing any kind of protein whatsoever which can be ingratiated in to the food supply chain anywhere. The huge success in culturally normalizing the consumption of 'beef balls' and similar '<highly processed, derivative, nominal protein identity> balls' in markets like Thailand to my critical eye largely stem from the beef ball factories of Shantou in Guangdong. Make no mistake: those people are making bank selling total bunk for real bucks. Poverty will be the driver. Economically, it's hard to pass up plants. They've literally evolved over millions of years to produce the goods using almost nothing in resource terms. Somehow the world just needs to learn to love Indian food and stop expecting protein and lipid dense meals.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 39896880 2y ago> The formulation of its new product uses just 3% cultivated chicken in order to sell at a lower price point so more people can try it, he said So it’s 97% normal chicken, but 3% cultured? That doesn’t seem too interesting.
- re 2y agoNo, the rest is plant-based (wheat- and soy-based protein), like traditional vegan meat alternatives. https://www.goodmeat.co/butchery https://www.goodmeat.co/butchery
- briandear 2y ago[flagged]
- sega_sai 2y agoWhat are you specifically denying ? 1) the increase in temperature on the planet 2) the danger from increase temperature? 3) the human origin of temperature increase? Enlighten us with motivation why you think a ton of studies on each of this items is wrong.
- oopsallmagic 2y agoOr even the fifth-grade science project you can do. Fill a soda bottle with air, a soda bottle with CO2, put them in the sun, then measure their internal temperature. You can do it with your kids in an afternoon.
- jnovek 2y ago[flagged]
- leptons 2y agoYou had the hottest year on record last year. You're in for the hottest summer ever this year, and next year will also be the hottest on record, and the one after that - maybe when it's 132F outside you'll realize something's wrong?
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[flagged]
- oopsallmagic 2y ago[dead]
- benzible 2y agoSee https://thecounter.org/lab-grown-cultivated-meat-cost-at-scale/ https://thecounter.org/lab-grown-cultivated-meat-cost-at-sca... for a thorough exploration of why lab grown meat will never happen... > Humbird likened the process of researching the report to encountering an impenetrable “Wall of No”—his term for the barriers in thermodynamics, cell metabolism, bioreactor design, ingredient costs, facility construction, and other factors that will need to be overcome before cultivated protein can be produced cheaply enough to displace traditional meat. > “And it’s a fractal no,” he told me. “You see the big no, but every big no is made up of a hundred little nos.” I've posted this comment before, but the linked article is relevant to every story about lab-grown meat as the entire concept is a fantasy, or less charitably, a scam.
- dekken_ 2y agoall we need to do is break the second law of thermodynamics, what's the big deal?
- vikramkr 2y agoLast I checked the cow doesn't have a problem producing steak and thermodynamics applies to that too so not sure what the argument is here
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dekken_ 2y agoRuminants are actually very efficient protein generating machines. They (like us) have been evolving under thermodynamic pressures for millions of years, I would like us to be able to not have to produce them to have high quality protein/fat/etc, but I haven't seen anything to say it's remotely possible.
- vikramkr 2y agoWe only sequenced the first cow genome 15 years ago and plenty of plants and fungi produce high quality protein/fat/etc - it's not like we're starting from scratch the whole point of bioengineering is that we can cheat using stuff nature figured out for us. It's certainly not scientifically impossible. In the zero interest rate hype cycle over the past couple years plenty of startups convinced themselves that they could totally make it work with cell culture and stupid expensive bioreactors and media and stuff since that was the only tech that was 'ready' even though at best all you can get is an overpriced lean meat only replacement for ground beef, and this article seems to take for given that this approach === meatless meat. I think it's useful to keep the questions of 'are these tech bros going to figure out how to make producing meat in class 8 cleanrooms viable' and 'are bioengineered animal-free meat replacements going to happen in the next few decades' seperate
- pedalpete 2y agoMany of the cultured meat companies are going about this the wrong way from an economic standpoint. They often try to make the new chicken nugget, a low cost mass produced food that may seem easy to replicate, because it is already so processed. This is were Vow, and a few others are going the high-end, foods that haven't really existed before, with their Japanese Quail Parfait. Similar to how Tesla started with the roadster, and then went to the S, 3, Y, etc etc. Imagine creating a cultured cavier or foie gras. Sold in small quantities to those who want the experience, social signaling, and opportunity to make a small difference. The companies won't make money on these items, but they can cover a higher percentage of their cost, and learn how to scale. Then move into less rare, but still coveted foods, etc etc
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Imagine creating a cultured cavier or foie gras We already have these and they’re delicious. I’m unconvinced kaviar has a market. But your core point, that these firms should go high and trade replicating for expanding, is correct.
- pedalpete 2y agoI think there is a key difference between cultured caviar, and kaviar (by which I'm assuming you mean imitation caviar, not the swedish fish roe spread). A high priced cultured caviar isn't just trying to be a replacement for the expense of real caviar. In fact, as I'm suggesting it (which you are agreeing with) is that because it does not harm fish in the process, it can be priced higher. This can't be done with imitation caviar, whose entire purpose for being is cheaper. Though, it is in some ways a marketing move. It's not quite the difference between fake leather and vegan leather, but it isn't that far off.
- netsharc 2y ago"Do you like the foie gras?" "Is it artificial?" "Of course." I feel like the superrich don't really care about their CO2 costs, in fact, the more wasteful, maybe the better the social signal. But I guess there are different categories of superrich.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- DrNosferatu 2y agoAlways heard cell cultured meats don’t scale to industrial size.
- TheDudeMan 2y agoMaybe that's true with today's technology. But that stuff tends to improve, especially if you invest money/research.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoOne would so assume, but I saw a statement that whole classes of medications(?) seen as promising in the 90s were a no go because of the exact same fundamental bioreactor scaling issues. I’ll try to find the reference.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoNot the original reference I was thinking of, but close enough: https://thecounter.org/lab-grown-cultivated-meat-cost-at-scale/amp/ https://thecounter.org/lab-grown-cultivated-meat-cost-at-sca...
- stefantalpalaru 2y ago[dead]
- ralusek 2y agoI have had a somewhat dystopian idea (on the surface level) that is actually much more humane than our current systems. Why don't we work, via CRISPR or aggressive evolution, to get to the point where something like a cow is much closer to a meat worm? Imagine if we could get the brain down to something where it's basically like a mollusk, to remove most of the ethical issues with slaughtering something as sentient as a cow or a pig. Then imagine if we could breed away the legs and such, and get this thing to the point that it's just a long tube of the most tender cuts of meat. Whole worm of ribeye and fillet. And it can just be suspended in a factory, hundreds of meat worms high, with food being pumped in their mouth, and excrement being swept up. Again, sounds insane, but I want my meatworm future.
- ralusek 2y agoI know lots of problems with lab grown meats are that: 1.) they have no immune system and are therefore incredibly finicky when it comes to infection. meat worms can still have an immune system 2.) they don't produce the necessary hormones for growth. meat worms can still produce hormones 3.) hard to get the proteins and fats to grow together. meat worms would absolutely love to be fat
- Panzer04 2y agoIt sounds like a decent idea. It doesn't really resolve the problems with calories in vs calories out, though (ie. by and large you still need just as much feed). It also might not be cheaper - lots of meat agriculture largely leaves the animals to themselves before slaughter, which this obviously wouldnt be capable of. You're also proposing a fairly massive genetic engineering project to get to that point too - I suspect there are many other problems on the chopping block that would be possible if/when we're capable of making those kinds of changes to organisms. The idea does solve the moral qualms (if we ignore the squickiness of creating an artifical being in a much degraded state from its origin)
- keiferski 2y agoThis is a pretty interesting philosophical question, and I think it basically boils down to whether you are fundamentally a positivist or not. Meaning that if we remove the sensory organs of a being (I.e., remove its ability to feel pain) that means it loses any ethical value. If you agree with this viewpoint, then the idea of “beef worms” or “chicken fruit” makes sense. But if you question positivism and think that beings have another form of value that isn’t merely the sum of their sensory impressions, it gets much more complex.
- sovietmudkipz 2y agoThe best thing about traditional meat is the evolved immune system and kidneys.
- aziaziazi 2y agoCan you elaborate on the immune system ? Doesn’t heat destroy every celles responsible for the immune system ?
- a_c 2y agoI think we are re-inventing the wheel of using biochemical process to grow protein. Current meats have millions of years of evolution. Sure the types eaten most are not bred out of efficiency. Why don't we choose other starting points, possibly insect, e.g. grasshopper or maggot and grow them in the lab?
- aziaziazi 2y agoI like the idea to start with the most efficient specie but other animals/vegetable we eat are in fact already very bred out for efficiency. So much that some very efficient ranchs choose to slaughter babies caws at birth because they are “milk bred” male or “meat bred” female and not economically viable.
- mynameisnoone 2y agoMeanwhile, in Florida: the beef protection racket bans it. Recall what happened to Oprah in 1996 when she dared to express an opinion about beef during the global mad cow scare.[0] And, also the existence of beef libel laws in multiple states. The cultured meat industry needs better lobbyists or the beef industry is going to squish them. 0. https://www.texastribune.org/2018/01/10/time-oprah-winfrey-beefed-texas-cattle-industry/ https://www.texastribune.org/2018/01/10/time-oprah-winfrey-b...