5 ms·
Coffee: Never Surprise Your Customers
- usernamed7 2y agoThe price jump from $1 to $2 feels exploitive, even if it's not. Even removing the surprise element, 100% is too big of a price jump for any product to make. You could correct for the surprise aspect, but the change itself is still problematic. Communicating the change ahead of time (given it's popularity and cost difference) would be the most prudent. But in the end, I think they actually found a better approach: for regulars, the coffee is often free. Because they also bought other things, and helped reinforce the customer community and predictable revenue. In services, grandfathering is a great way to rollout changes to pricing. But it doesn't work for companies with very little growth/where everyone is a regular.
- SoftTalker 2y agoFor something like that, any price change is going to be a nuisance. Any jump less than another whole dollar now means you have to deal with change. I usually have some cash on me but I go out of my way to not carry a pocketful of coins. Yet jumping to $2 is a 100% increase and that feels like a lot. Probably better to stay with $1 and just treat it as a loss leader that gets customers coming back. See for example the $1.50 Hot Dog combo at Costco, which has stayed at that price for decades. They aren't making any money on it but customers have come to appreciate it and it nurtures loyalty.
- xethos 2y ago> [Costco] aren't making any money on it Perhaps not the point you were trying to make, but they almost certainly are. Per the cofounder and (in 2018), CEO, Craig Jelenik: > we [Costco] took it over and started manufacturing our hot dogs. We keep it at $1.50 and make enough money to get a fair return. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/costco-founder-kill-hotdogs/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/costco-founder-kill-hotdog...
- SoftTalker 2y agoOK. Hot dog, bun, drink cup, and soft drink. Straws, napkins, plate or paper wrap, condiments. Labor to serve the customers, and clean up after them. Floor space taken up by the eating area. Cost of storing the raw ingredients, and the kitchen equipment to prepare the food. I'll grant it's possible they are making a profit, but note he doesn't say they are making a profit, he says they are making a "fair return." They could be losing money. Either way, in the scope of their store operations, it's not consequential on that basis. They do it to make customers happy. It generates good will. That is the "fair return."
- joshmanders 2y agoIt's a since the dawn of time understanding that happy customers are loyal customers. But for some reason so many companies get greedy and ruin that loyalty for short term profit gains that decimate their long term profit.
- coding123 2y agoNew people get hired and want to make their mark.
- ncr100 2y agoPutting imbalance into the system, extracting resources.
- paulddraper 2y agoInteresting. Any case studies in particular come to mind? Where a profitable company increased its profits, via actions that later lost customers and profits? (The historical cases that come to mind for me of are companies that were already in the red, trying to turn it around.)
- Zenzero 2y agoCostco could easily triple their cost of their hotdogs and still be cheaper than everyone else. They don't because they know it would be foolishly destructive to their reputation in the long term.
- katbyte 2y agoThey also faced pressure during the pandemic to increase their margins like other companies were doing to price gouge. But of course that would do the same to their rep and is not where they make there money. Iirc 80% of profits are from memberships
- paulddraper 2y agoSo that's an example of business making the right long-term decision.
- coding123 2y agoIt was (is again) this gas stations Costco hotdog
- Tempest1981 2y agoDo you need to be a Costco member to eat at the food court? I thought "no", which means they are still making profit on their food alone.
- jjj123 2y agoYou need a membership to get through the door, right?
- titanomachy 2y agoAt the Costcos I’ve been to the restaurant is outside the members-only area.
- jogjayr 2y agoI haven't seen outdoor food courts in Ontario Canada. But you don't need a membership to go to the pharmacy, and I'm sure they'd let you in for free for the food court. In California, in addition to the pharmacy, there was no membership required for buying alcohol.
- ezschemi 2y agoNo, you don’t. If you know someone with a Costco membership and they buy you a gift card, you can get in with that. Even if the gift card is only for $10 or $20 and you want to buy things worth more than that, you still get the membership prices and pay the difference by credit card.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoHere in Calgary, you don't need a membership for the food court, pharmacy, eye clinic, or customer service. Customer service would be where you would sign up for a membership anyway Or liquor stores I think.
- 2y ago
- zug_zug 2y agoI guess this is why most places change prices more gradually. If they made it 1.10 for 3 months then 1.20 for 3 months etc I bet people would have dealt (assuming it's still the cheapest coffee around).
- veunes 2y agoTo maintain customer loyalty and minimize backlash
- sciencesama 2y agoAnd this is happening with vmware ansible and terraform !!
- pindab0ter 2y agoWhat's happening with them, for someone out of the loop apparently?
- ldx1024 2y agoThis article trips my BS meter for a made up story to illustrate a point. Of course that says nothing about whether the point it is making is valid or not.
- Alifatisk 2y agoIsn’t there a name for such thing? I have a vague memory of someone in HN mentioning a word which describes such scenario, where someone is making up a story to backup their point.
- markx2 2y ago(UK) My local pub would charge me £1.10 for a pint of Lime & Soda water. The local pub had an expensive makeover They now charge double for exactly the same drink, and IF I go in I have to be sure to say "No Ice" If I go in .. my patronage has dropped through the floor.
- justabaldguy 2y agoLoved this article, thank you for sharing.
- jpl56 2y agoTwitch is doing this too ($5 to $6 price increase). As soon as I received the information email, I immediately canceled my subscriptions and removed my payment method. I'll keep helping my content creators through their Youtube channel instead.