4 ms·
Why do people look for unknown causes of obesity when there are so many obvious known causes? We aren't lacking an explanation!
by IshKebab 2y ago
Why do people look for unknown causes of obesity when there are so many obvious known causes? We aren't lacking an explanation!
- AmericanChopper 2y agoI think there are two reasons for that. The first is just many people don’t like to take accountability for themselves, so they look for other things to blame. There’s now enough obese people in the population for this delusions to get a lot of mainstream acceptance. The other is that doctors know they can’t actually get their patients to do the necessary lifestyle changes, so their interventions tend to revolve around the assumption that the patients will happily lifestyle themselves to death.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoLifestyle is definitely a problem to an extent, but people didn't just all decide to be lazy at once. The environment and culture changed.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoCulture is just the sum of the things people decide to do, so I’d question whether there’s any real distinction between the things you’re saying here. People who lead obese lifestyles can simply decide to lead a more healthy lifestyle. Why many people don’t make this decision, and what caused these lifestyle choices to be so widely adopted in the first place are interesting questions. But lifestyle choices are the totality of the problem.
- 7bit 2y ago> People who lead obese lifestyles can simply decide to lead a more healthy lifestyle. This is a greatly simplified POV and also incorrect. Lifestyle is influenced by a lot of things that are not merely choices. Stress, depressions, addictions (sugar is highly addictive), trauma, your social environment. Saying that someone can simply choose a healthy lifestyle is like saying someone can simply choose not to be depressed or addicted.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoThese things can influence the choices people choose to make, but they cannot make those choices for them. You’re simple stating the shared delusion of obese people who can’t confront accountability. None of the factors you’ve mentioned require anybody to have a donut and a milkshake for breakfast every morning. They might make somebody more likely to make that terrible decision, but it’s still a decision only they are accountable for.
- 7bit 2y ago> You’re simple stating the shared delusion of obese people who can’t confront accountability. None of the factors you’ve mentioned require anybody to have a donut and a milkshake for breakfast every morning. I'm not saying that. I'm merely saying that things aren't so easy as you make them out to be. Read my post again.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoYour claim is very explicitly that people are unable to make healthy lifestyle choices. This claim is complete nonsense. Posting a list of vague reasons why people may choose to make unhealthy choices doesn’t support your central claim in any way.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoNo, they're not. If a problem is systemic in its existence, then it has a systemic cause. Looking at it as an individual problem is fine for yourself, but if you want to fix it for a society, you have to look at the systemic cause instead.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoThe main problem here is that millions of people somehow convinced themselves that they’re not responsible for their own lifestyle choices. Which is certainly a systemic problem worth investigating. If people want to stop being obese though, there is no substitute for lifestyle changes
- TulliusCicero 2y agoPeople weren't extra responsible before, it was that their diet and exercise patterns were healthier even without them particularly trying. Getting stuck on individual responsibility as a route to society-wide change is a smooth road to failure.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoYour ruminations about how they problem can or cannot be solved are not relevant to what is causing the problem. Individual lifestyle choices are what causes obesity, this is a plainly obvious fact that a lot of people are in a complete state of delusion about. What caused this massive shift in culture is a seperate question, that you will find plenty of other people eager to debate with you. How to solve the problem this has created is again another seperate question. But I would suggest that problems caused by individual choices have very few (and very unsatisfying) solutions, other than personal responsibility. Which all tend to require denying people their liberties (like the way you might put a person in jail if they refuse to stop choosing to commit crimes).
- TulliusCicero 2y ago> Your ruminations about how they problem can or cannot be solved are not relevant to what is causing the problem. It is, you just don't want to admit it. People didn't all individually decide to change their lifestyle, their lifestyle changed due to their environmental conditions changing. People aren't fully rational actors, but they are responsive actors.
- benoliver999 2y agoI am a fat guy and I can explain why I am fat - I eat too much food and don't do enough exercise. Guest what happened when I ate less food? Lost weight
- theshrike79 2y agoIt's not just less or more food. Calorie density matters, as does taste. Yes, one can lose weight by drinking some Soylent Green mush with the exact correct caloric count and macros for steady healthy weight loss. You know what else that person will lose? All happiness and the will to live =) Some people really are just "food is fuel" and don't care what stuff tastes like, others (like me) actually get enjoyment from eating food, different foods on every day. This is why there isn't a one size fits all solution to weight loss. Even "calories in calories out" is a bit hazy, because not every single calorie in the food is consumed with 100% efficiency - it depends on your gut bacteria, which we know way too little about.
- Sirizarry 2y agoNah dude it really is as easy as eat less = lose weight. In all cases if you reduce your food consumption you will eventually weigh less this is thermodynamics 101. Nobody has to drink Soylent green mush or even just salads. Just eat less. And maybe go for a run here and there that helps too.
- trealira 2y agoI agree. Some people don't realize how many calories some of the things they regularly consume have, though, and I think that's why many have trouble losing weight, which is why it's important to track your calorie consumption when trying to lose weight.
- theshrike79 2y agoPeople have different gut/intestinal flora which affects the amount of calories digested from different foods. There are actual studies on this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10368799/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10368799/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8291023/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8291023/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7463616/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7463616/ We all know that one person who can eat literally anything and is still fit and that one person who sees an ad for ice cream and gains 5 pounds (hyperbole of course). According to these studies it's the difference in gut microbiota that's the difference here.
- rich_sasha 2y agoEuropean obesity rates are also growing, but are much lower than US. Contrary to anecdotes, most people in Europe are also pretty sedentary, don't cycle to work and don't do sport (there's probably more active people in Europe than US). We probably walk a bit more but there can't be that much in it. So I'm still baffled at that difference.
- IshKebab 2y agoHave you been to the US? It's mostly the food. The bread aisle in American supermarkets smells of sugar. For real. Very weird. Also... yeah we are pretty sedentary in Europe but it's another level in America. In many parts of US cities there are literally no pavements so you can't walk even if you wanted to. I can't think of anywhere in Europe like that.
- moltar 2y agoWhat I noticed in south Europe at least is that food in small quick restaurants is cheaper and way better quality than fast food. It naturally forces people to make good choices. For example, in Portugal a McDonald’s meal is about €12. Meanwhile you can get a meal of fish or meat, mashed potatoes and some veggies plus Coke Zero in a glass bottle for €8.50. Or a plate of rice, good quality salad (not a token one) and quarter chicken plus a coffee for €7.50.