4 ms·
You cannot make money off of people who are starving.
by WalterBright 2y ago
You cannot make money off of people who are starving.
- eat_veggies 2y agoYou can force starving people into unfair arrangements where the choice is between getting screwed or dying of hunger. You can use the existence of starving people as a threat to keep your work force in line. Sometimes it's not even the starving people that you're making money off of, but their minerals and land. There are a lot of ways to profit from suffering. And sometimes it's not even about profit—it can just feel so good to have an Other to oppress.
- WalterBright 2y ago> You can force starving people into unfair arrangements where the choice is between getting screwed or dying of hunger. History shows us that if you want to force starving people to work for you, you also need to shoot the people who refuse. See the Soviet gulags, and the Nazi slave labor camps.
- eat_veggies 2y agoIndeed the arrangement is violent and enforced with terrible violence, and in no way is this incompatible with profits.
- WalterBright 2y ago[flagged]
- mandmandam 2y agoHow does this account keep managing to make every thread on HN into 'communism bad' without getting flagged? Tell me your secrets Walter.
- WalterBright 2y ago> make every thread on HN Only in response to posts that extol the virtues of collectivism and/or how bad freedom is. It's a dirty job, but someone has to do it :-) > Tell me your secrets Walter Too bad it seems to be a secret that free markets are far more successful. My dad was a finance professor at a college in his later years. He said students would tell him from time to time that they had never heard of a case for free markets before. Isn't that amazing for people that lived their whole life in a free market country? I remember one person complained to me that I was "ramming freedom down his throat!" It boggles the mind. Note that I don't attack or berate people. Only ideas. dang knows about me. You can ask him.
- mandmandam 2y agoI'm sure your "dirty job" makes sense to you, and it's clear you even feel very righteous about it. Be that as it may, ideological crusades such as this are explicitly disallowed on here. "Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That tramples curiosity." Dang has been very clear on that, many times - whatever he "knows about you". You really think it's "impossible" for a corporation with Star Trek replicator tech to profit from starving people? ... And that was the right time to fight "the virtues of collectivism"? You are trampling curiousity, and have admitted as much, and now you really ought to consider giving it a rest.
- Jensson 2y ago> Be that as it may, ideological crusades such as this are explicitly disallowed on here. "Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That tramples curiosity." That goes for both sides, every time someone repeats the meme "capitalism bad!" they are perpetuating their own crusade, at that time the gloves are off and it is free to engage with them. You can see it in this thread where people started out by trash talking capitalism, at that point it is ok to go and defend capitalism according to HN guidelines even if you do it in every thread where people start attacking capitalism. Its those who start attacking capitalism everywhere that needs to stop if this happens too often, since they are almost always the instigators.
- BSDobelix 2y ago>History shows us that slave labor cannot compete with free labor. History shows us that you can build Pyramids and the Chinese wall with slave labor, probably not affordable with "free labor". But maybe we should also look at "modern slavery" that is "free labor" but without any chance to get another job or get reported to the police. >it's about forcible slave labor, forced with guns and whips. Worked incredible well for Belgium, and works incredible well for every warlord in west-Africa...and for us (>bloody< cheap raw-materials for our phones) I know what you want to say with it, forcing specialized people with whips isn't going to give you good results in the long run, however if you just need their joules it's shockingly effective.
- defrost 2y ago> History shows us Does it? Contrary to popular belief, it wasn’t slaves who built the pyramids. We know this because archaeologists have located the remains of a purpose-built village for the thousands of workers who built the famous Giza pyramids, nearly 4,500 years ago. https://www.sciencefocus.com/science/were-the-egyptian-pyramids-built-by-slaves https://www.sciencefocus.com/science/were-the-egyptian-pyram... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_ancient_Egypt#Great_Pyramids_not_built_by_slaves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_ancient_Egypt#Great...
- BSDobelix 2y agoYes, maybe the slaves did the less "worthy" jobs: >Slaves were a constant presence in ancient Egypt. Starting with the Old Kingdom (2613 - 2181 BC), slaves took on different roles. Some became soldiers, others scribes. https://www.worldatlas.com/ancient-world/were-slaves-used-to-build-the-pyramids-debunking-a-long-standing-myth.html https://www.worldatlas.com/ancient-world/were-slaves-used-to... >Does it? Yes it does, or do you have another argument against the Chinese wall or Belgium for example? Do you really want to argue against the fact that slaves did (and do) the hardest, most back-breaking jobs?
- WalterBright 2y agoSlave labor can indeed accomplish things, but it cannot compete with free labor.
- TaylorAlexander 2y agoThis is false. You can create conditions where their only real choice is to work for you. And since they’re starving, they’ll work for very low wages. You sell the product of their labor and collect the surplus value created by their work.
- WalterBright 2y ago[flagged]
- defrost 2y agoThe majority of the Chinese immigrants were male, many having left wives, mothers, sisters, daughters, and future spouses at home in China. Foreign miner taxes in California, often aimed squarely at Chinese immigrants, prevented them from staking mining claims, which in turn forced them to look for opportunities elsewhere. The CPRR hired an initial group of 50 Chinese workers that in short time dispelled the negative assumptions held by some CPRR managers. They fostered a reputation of strength, efficiency, and reliability. More Chinese workers would be hired and they held a variety of jobs: laborers, foremen, contractors, masons, carpenters, cooks, teamsters, interpreters, and medical professionals. Even so, racial inequalities persisted. Chinese workers were paid an average of 30% less than their white counterparts. They were segregated in work camps and had to pay for their own lodging, food, supplies, and equipment. The disparity came to a head on June 24th, 1867, when all Chinese railroad workers from Cisco to Truckee, California, a 30 miles section of track, stopped work. https://www.nps.gov/gosp/learn/historyculture/chinese-labor-and-the-iron-road.htm https://www.nps.gov/gosp/learn/historyculture/chinese-labor-... Confrontation, Threats -- and a Bloodless Resolution After a week's worth of lean rations had settled upon the men, Charles Crocker returned to the work camps. He dictated the options as he saw them: wages and hours were immutable. If the hungry Chinese workers returned to work immediately they would only be fined, but if they continued on strike they would not get paid for the whole month of June. Motivated by malnutrition, most men agreed to return to work https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/tcrr-chinese-workers-strike/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/tcrr-ch... Numerous other examples in colonial history.
- tsimionescu 2y agoIf they're literally at the point of starvation, maybe true - though famines often happen when people simply can't get access to food, even if they have the resources to buy it. So, bringing food to a starving area is unlikely to be bad for business. However, the more important point is that you can surely make money off of people by becoming their only source of food/money - i.e. they would starve without you, so they accept whatever trickle of resources you deign to assign. This is extraordinarily common throughout history, coupled with a threat of violence that all states use.
- WalterBright 2y ago> the more important point is that you can surely make money off of people by becoming their only source of food/money If you the only source, there is a reason for that, usually because you are shooting people who try to leave. I'll cite a counter for you. The US was the first country in the world to eliminate the specter of famine (around 1800). Free labor was the distinguishing ingredient, not slave labor. (The slaves at the time were used to primarily farm cotton and tobacco.) The average height of Americans increased dramatically throughout the 19th century. Scores of millions of Americans arrived in America as paupers and moved into the middle class. The economic machine of America was fueled by free labor, not starving people.
- eat_veggies 2y agoSlavery created the wealth that made industrialization in the north possible, and was the basis of the economic machine that you speak of. You've reduced slavery to a parenthetical. Where do you think the cotton and tobacco went? Where do you think the money came from? Where do you think it got spent? https://www.vox.com/identities/2019/8/16/20806069/slavery-economy-capitalism-violence-cotton-edward-baptist https://www.vox.com/identities/2019/8/16/20806069/slavery-ec...
- WalterBright 2y agoHere's why that's wrong. When the Confederacy seceded, the economy of the South slid into ruin. The economy of the North thrived. The Rebel army was barefoot, because Southern industry could not even make shoes. The reason that Lee was in Gettysburg was to loot the shoe factory at nearby Harrisburg. Where were the industries in the South? Where were the industries in South America? Why did the South secede to protect their economy from the North? > was the basis of the economic machine that you speak of The Civil War destroyed what there was of the Southern wealth, literally burning it to the ground. "made the South its most prosperous region" That's just nonsense. Take a look at contemporary photos and paintings of the North and South before 1865, and you'll see the stark difference in prosperity. Railroads latticed the North, far outstripping mileage in the South.
- imtringued 2y agoCapital is most valuable when demand exceeds supply (producer surplus).
- superb_dev 2y agoIt doesn’t matter, people are starving.