3 ms·
NASA indefinitely delays return of Starliner to review propulsion data
- steve1977 2y ago„to an unspecified time in July“ is not really „indefinitely“ Ars Technica.
- rpmisms 2y agoWell, it literally is, since it's not definite. It just doesn't meet the colloquial definition.
- steve1977 2y agoIsn‘t „until end of July“ definite?
- readthenotes1 2y agoNot after all these delays so far
- CoastalCoder 2y agoHow precise would the timing need to be to qualify as definite?
- dylan604 2y agothe article says this capsule is only rated for a 45 day stay. it did not say why only 45 days, but that count down started on June 6. they also did not say what would happen if those days elapse. do they just push it away from the shuttle and let it just become space trash? some sort of auto return on a intentional burn up in atmosphere trajectory?
- disillusioned 2y agoBeyond whatever its rated time remaining, (which usually has to do with weird things like abort system batteries, etc.) there is a _much more pressing issue_ which is that it is _actively leaking a finite supply of helium_ from the myriad thruster leaks, and while it only requires 7 lbs to reenter, they also only have 75 lbs, and are losing more every second.
- asadotzler 2y agoPerhaps my information is outdated, and happy to be updated, but I don't think they're losing anything while docked because the system is valved off. Once they depart, the leaks will begin again.
- rbanffy 2y agoIf Starliner isn't cleared to return live humans, whatever contingency procedures they come up with can still be tested with a payload of station garbage. The ship can be flown remotely and is fully automated. Even if it doesn't bring its crew back (and they wait for the next Dragon) it can still yield a lot of data. And, quite frankly, that it can still operate with all those leaks is a testament to good, robust, design.
- seydor 2y agoit "indefinitely delays", not "delays indefinitely". but i can see the potentiality of clickbait
- oefrha 2y agoJeez this is the third delay already, June 14 -> 18 -> 26 -> ???. I know NASA projects have a tendency of serial delays but didn’t expect that for a live mission. Makes you wonder if there’s an Allan McDonald-like story here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40748371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40748371
- dylan604 2y agoThey need as many delays for the return to match the delays for the launch. Looks like it needed at least one more delay for the launch. oops
- consumer451 2y agoI wonder what the options are if it is decided that Starliner is unsafe to return with human occupants.
- dylan604 2y agoCrew Dragon
- blankx32 2y agoDo they have Dragon suits to fit butch and suni?
- dylan604 2y agoSomeone @musk that question. knowing his ego, he'll have them made. even I would push to have them made just as a big FU to Boeing and take all of the free press about it.
- CamperBob2 2y agoWell, I have solid evidence that the CEO of Boeing molests small woodland creatures, but I'll come up with some way to rescue the stranded kids^H^H^H^Hastronauts. Trust me - Elon Musk
- londons_explore 2y agoThey might decide it's less risk to just return without suits.
- consumer451 2y agoOr maybe they could just send up air and power supply adapters so that their Starliner suits can plug into Dragon? source: wild speculation with no understanding of how difficult or risky that would be
- consumer451 2y ago
- dylan604 2y agoI would love to be a fly on the space station wall to hear what the talk is like between the astronauts.
- richie-guix 2y agoLook up Vladimir Komarov recordings sometimes. Lets hope it doesn't get to that point.
- disillusioned 2y agoWas that the cosmonaut who burned up upon reentry and his last words were basically to the effect of "this piece of shit garbage spacecraft that I told them is going to kill me is going to kill me, Yuri"?
- richie-guix 2y agoIndeed. He knew going up that it will most likely happen and literally demanded an open casket "so everyone will see what they did to me". If you ever come across a bright teenager getting lulled into communism keep this in mind as a very edifying example of the pitfalls of that system. The recordings are chilling. The ones who watch that recording and sort of pause and after a minute double down that the ends justify the means are a lost cause.
- caconym_ 2y agoThe crews of Apollo 1, Challenger, and Columbia might take issue with your implication that glorious American capitalism could never produce similar outcomes.
- nehal3m 2y agoYou're hoping a similar situation doesn't develop under capitalism though? Also, your point of view only makes sense if you're on the receiving end of capitalism. I don't think lithium miners would object to collectively owning the means of production. Disclaimer: I'm a random replyguy dumbass and both of these systems have huge problems. I have no better alternative.
- ggm 2y agoWhat would anyone have NASA do? Surely in the circumstances what they are doing, is the BATNA pending more information? In the end, turning the crew into long duration stayers until a dragon capsule and suits to fit can turn up, or negotiate with the Russians may be a better outcome than repeating engineer fear of losing face a la "o" ring decision logic.
- m3kw9 2y agoDid they bring a set of parachutes?
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoActual article/official release: https://blogs.nasa.gov/spacestation/2024/06/21/nasa-boeing-adjust-timeline-for-starliner-return/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/spacestation/2024/06/21/nasa-boeing-a...
- mshockwave 2y agocould somebody ELI5 what is happening to this program? delays after delays, and now they might need to send another spacecraft to bring people back. It will be hilarious if that turns out to be a SpaceX Dragon.
- JPLeRouzic 2y ago> "It will be hilarious if that turns out to be a SpaceX Dragon" Or a Soyouz
- rbanffy 2y agoThat would be an epic egg on NASA and Boeing's faces. Therefore, it'll never happen.
- mppm 2y agoEverybody involved with the NASA manned space program seems to only care about their slice of The Budget nowadays, with actual mission requirements being a distant second priority. This results in a patchwork of bad design decisions and a weird mix of obsolete and yet-to-be developed technologies. This further results in endless delays and extremely low launch volume, which means you basically learn operations anew for every launch, and achieving anything resembling reliability becomes essentially impossible. Which brings us to this situation, where the Starliner was given the go-ahead out of budgetary desperation, despite having many known reliability problems. For a longer and more colorful version of this argument with sources, see [1]. [1]: https://idlewords.com/2024/5/the_lunacy_of_artemis.htm https://idlewords.com/2024/5/the_lunacy_of_artemis.htm
- chgs 2y agoIt will certainly be dragon. What will be hilarious is if starship collects the starliner capsule in a couple of years and returns it to earth.
- rbanffy 2y agoI think they might fill it with garbage and let Boeing attempt an unmanned landing. All the issues are in the service module - the capsule itself is OK.
- jb1991 2y agoThat’s a large delay for Starliner. But a small delay for mankind.
- SkyMarshal 2y agoI wonder if these Starliner problems are symptoms of the same short-term, bottom-line, corner-cutting in Boeing's airline assembly lines. Given it seems to have come from the top, has it infected the space operations too?
- bitcharmer 2y agoIt sure does look like it
- jalapenos 2y agoIf all you know is MBA crap, how can you suddenly switch on engineering acumen when you've driven it out?
- bell-cot 2y agoPlausible...but if Short-Term Bottom Line is your top priority for hiring and promoting managers, for years - then don't expect either your engineers or engineering culture to be much good.
- bell-cot 2y agoHmm... - Starliner's current showstoppers all seem to be in its Service Module's propulsion systems - Relatively little delta-V is needed to deorbit from the space station - Rocket Labs has been zealously developing several "as a service" versions of their Photon satellite bus/kickstage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_Lab_Photon#Photon_versions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_Lab_Photon#Photon_versi... SO: Could Rocket Labs quickly launch a "space tug" Photon, capable of replacing the Starliner Service Module's propulsion system well-enough for the undocking and controlled de-orbiting? Hard to imagine NASA allowing that with a manned Starliner. But is there any current capability to handle "dead" spacecraft near the ISS? Docking ports are very limited, and "drifting nearby" can be damned dangerous in orbit.
- tim333 2y agoThe "space tug" thing sounds complicated. I imagine if they don't feel the Starliner is safe they could send it to earth without anyone on board and send the SpaceX Dragon to get the astronauts.
- bell-cot 2y agoYes, the space tug idea would be bleeding-edge. But if Starliner does not have a working propulsion system, then they can't send it anywhere.
- multimoon 2y agoI’m going to laugh pretty hard if we have to send up a SpaceX rocket to grab them.
- dsq 2y agoOr if the Russians offer to rescue them...
- weebull 2y agoI don't understand the planning around "lifeboats" and the ISS. I thought that there was always an extra Soyuz capsule docked in case people are stranded on the ISS. Yet, it's never been used and it's never discussed as an option. Even with Columbia and after, the discussion was always around sending a second shuttle up if the backflip inspection found a damaged heat shield. Maybe that's more understandable given the number of people involved on the Shuttle. Still... What's the purpose of having that lifeboat there if it's never considered?
- ceejayoz 2y agoIt’s there as a “evacuate the station right now” contingency. Fire on the station or something like that. There’s plenty of supplies to take time to work up a better plan in this sort of scenario that doesn’t use the lifeboat.