3 ms·
Compared to what? Even remotely comparable solutions drawing less power either cost something like $5-10 per megabyte (Inmarsat L-band, i.e. BGAN, Iridium Certu
by lxgr 2y ago
Compared to what? Even remotely comparable solutions drawing less power either cost something like $5-10 per megabyte (Inmarsat L-band, i.e. BGAN, Iridium Certus) or require even more power (Inmarsat Ka-band) and still cost something like 50 cent per megabyte! Monthly plans start at several hundred dollars, and terminals start in the low 4 to medium 5 digit ranges.
If you can live without Internet when backpacking, enjoy the outdoors! If you need it for whatever reason, this just cut the cost per megabyte by about 95% and the cost for the terminal by 99%. You'll probably also not hate LEO latencies compared to GEO.
- devit 2y agoCompared to being in LTE coverage and only needing a smartphone with 2-3W power draw (around 10% of the Starlink Mini).
- clarkmcc 2y agoThat’s like comparing apples to oranges though. This was never meant to be used in situations where you have a smartphone and LTE service.
- lxgr 2y agoWhat makes you think you need satellite communications when there's (working) LTE? Obviously that's not the use case, just like you don't need fixed Starlink when there's (working) gigabit fiber available.
- devit 2y agoI mean ideally (for Internet access purposes) one would have worldwide LTE coverage via cell towers and just use smartphones; the Starlink system is an alternative to that, so it makes sense to compare it. From an individual perspective, if you want Internet access and don't have to be in a specific place, the current alternative to Starlink is to simply limit your wilderness living to places with or near areas of cell phone coverage (which potentially results in tradeoffs, of course).
- grecy 2y ago> I mean ideally (for Internet access purposes) one would have worldwide LTE coverage via cell towers As someone that has explored a lot of Australia, Alaska, Yukon, Africa and South America, I'm having trouble parsing your statement. I've driven more than 1,000 miles for 10 days with absolutely nothing. No town. No people. No cars. Nothing. I've canoed for 15 days well over 3,000 miles from the nearest town, road, building or electricity. The idea you could cover the globe in LTE cell towers is unfathomable.
- lxgr 2y agoAbsolutely. I think living in a densely populated area, it can be hard to get a perspective for how big and largely empty the world actually is – and that's just land (and coastal seas, as far as LTE/5G reaches). The remaining 70% are ocean, and people sometimes go there too! Some densely traveled oceans actually do have LTE coverage, e.g. parts of the north sea, since it has existing infrastructure in the form of wind parks that make adding a base station fairly easy, but that's the absolute exception, globally. A single direct-to-cell satellite can cover a circular area measured in hundreds or thousands of kilometers. Due to the Earth's curvature, that's simply not feasible using terrestrial base stations.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoI don't think any of those are remotely common for recreational backpack hikers. Garmin inreach maybe, because it covers the two essentials this group actually wants of "check in with family" and "call for help." It would really surprise me if backpackers switch to this en masse, or if having it enabled anyone to start backpacking who currently can't because of this need being unmet. It'll probably get used on boats, where people actually do kinda want to watch netflix at night and don't have to personally carry every gram every day. The current options are very expensive and power hungry. And probably a bunch of other outwardly similar but culturally distinct groups that could use it. Remote wilderness hunters, ice fishers, who work out of a seasonal camp but otherwise are pretty cut off.
- hammock 2y agoGreat use case examples. The marketing bit is "fits in a backpack" but really it's "fits in a base camp duffel/dry bag." People with a boat, sled, overlanding vehicle etc this is great
- lxgr 2y agoNot every backpack is used for backpacking! I use mine largely for the not-so-exciting trek to the office :)
- hammock 2y agoThe point was the use case is better for people who are not traveling by foot
- lxgr 2y agoDefinitely! But Starlink doesn't market it towards those people. Their page simply says "fits a backpack". In fact, they almost don't do any marketing at all, and they probably don't need to, given how far ahead their service is at this point.
- devit 2y ago
- hammock 2y agoCompared to Garmin inReach Mini.. 3.5 ounces, 35 hours battery life and less than half the price all-in. Don't get me wrong, this is cool and emerging tech, and I support it (I pray it doesn't ruin the wilderness). Just saying there IS a comparison
- sambazi 2y agothis is iridium though. i suppose there is an internet overlay, but it probably isn't pretty (or fast)
- lxgr 2y agoInReach and similar devices use Iridium SBD, which is more like text messaging than an actual internet connection. Iridium does offer voice and data services too, but terminals for that are significantly larger and draw more power, and the price per megabyte might bring tears to your eyes for recreational use. (Iridium Certus gets you 88 kbps at around $5/MB, and devices start at around $1500.)
- lxgr 2y agoThe InReach Mini is an amazing satellite messenger, but does not in any way provide Internet access.