8 ms·
Microsoft makes Copilot less useful on new Copilot Plus PCs
- whywhywhywhy 2y ago> Microsoft says it will be able to “more agilely develop and optimize” the Copilot experience as a result of these changes Can't help but see this as anything other than "The team working on it doesn't know how to code native applications on our OS"
- Rinzler89 2y agoJudging by the modern Windows apps, that seems true as most of them (ClipChamp, Weather, News, etc) are just web apps with an Edge wrapper similar to Electron apps. I'd get it if they were meant to be cross platform apps, but they're not. Crazy they couldn't have bothered to write native windows apps in .NET/C# for something that's obviously meant to be Windows exclusive. The community writes way better Windows apps (Sumatra, Notepad++, etc) than Microsoft does internally. Microsoft has no cohesive product vision for the OS and just seems to let various groups slap random low quality shit to the OS, based on some internal power struggles their managers win in the org I assume. It's ironic that low quality slop like those and ads ship by default with the OS, but the truly useful and high quality utilities they write like PowerToys, do not. They lost the plot on their core audience after Windows 7 and sloppy implementations of "AI" like Copilot+ and Recall won't bring them back, on the contrary, it convinces people to GTFO to Linux ASAP.
- mathverse 2y agoIt's absolutely crazy they dont have an internal toolkit a la QT that allows them to create performant multiplatform apps. It's really mind boggling. Even their OneDrive uses just QT.
- neonsunset 2y agoThey do, there is just no top-down initiative that says "use WinUI with C# or lose your job, make sure to throw out React Native and WebView2 by the end of this quarter". That would at least cover Windows. Or they could force everyone adopt MAUI internally instead, despite its flaws (if you dogfood something heavily, bugs get fixed fast). I find it funny that, unlike OneDrive, iCloud desktop client uses WinUI. But I'm not holding my breath and think that whoever could make this reality was pushed out of the relevant teams or the org as a whole by the time W11 shipped - just look how they killed great OneNote UWP variant. Salvaging the situation would be an improbable miracle.
- pjmlp 2y agoIn this regard, as already discussed before, it what saddens me that Apple and Google are more willing to double down on their UI stacks, Android and iDevices, than Microsoft. If one of them was at the steering wheel of Longhorn, it would most likely been shipped with its .NET based architecture, improved in later releases, and everyone that wasn't into it, could have looked for a job elsewhere.
- victor106 2y agoabout WinUI from https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/winui/ https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/winui/ > At this time, there are two generations of WinUI: WinUI 2 for UWP and WinUI in the Windows App SDK (WinUI 3). While both can be used in production-ready apps on Windows 10 and later, each have different development targets. In the Microsoft land it's always utterly confusing to get started. You are always left guessing what choice to make.
- neonsunset 2y agoSeems pretty straightforward to just follow these? https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/winui/winui3/desktop-winui3-app-with-basic-interop https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/winui/winui3/... (not very pretty) https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/windows-dotnet-maui/walkthrough-first-app https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/apps/windows-dotne... (better) In either case, my comment did not concern regular users but MSFT themselves.
- vitorgrs 2y agoAs far I know, OneDrive doesn't use QT anymore on Windows. It's web iirc (the ui part) + WinUI.
- skywhopper 2y agoI suspect they forgot the value of internal training on their own platform’s tech and they just hire folks from outside and let them run wild, and all they know how to do is React, so that’s basically what we get.
- bromuro 2y agoThere was a time they were pushing React for building Windows apps - wasn’t Skype moved to React after their aquisition?
- the_snooze 2y ago>It's ironic that low quality slop like those and ads ship by default with the OS... it convinces people to GTFO to Linux ASAP. It certainly convinced me. Steam Proton runs pretty much all the games I enjoy (mainly indies), and I can quarantine Windows in a VM for MS Office, as well as keep a full Windows installation on a separate disk if I really need it (rarely). The crap that's made its way into mainline Windows makes me feel like my computer isn't serving me anymore.
- hotstickyballs 2y agoWindows development is death
- kotaKat 2y agoI'll take it. It makes it easier for me to fully gut out of my system if it's a few links to a crappy PWA instead of being fully hooked into the OS.
- joenot443 2y agoMy understanding is that it takes orders of magnitude longer to develop native Windows applications than it does to develop webapps. I think that your suspicion is right and that some PM along the way was able to make the business case that we could ship 75% of the product using 10% of the engineering resources. It's a drag, though, because as everyone will immediately see, having a shortcut on your keyboard to open glorified GPT-4 isn't really a killer feature.
- usef- 2y ago> takes orders of magnitude longer to develop native Windows applications than it does to develop webapps. That seems extremely far-fetched to me. If it's for economic reasons, I think it's more likely related to availability of developers with webapp experience vs native experience.
- skywhopper 2y agoWhich they could easily solve if they invested in training new hires on their own internal tech, but I suspect that’s long been cut to the bone. So if you can only rely on what skills people have when they join, you’re going to dilute any proprietary tech you have.
- joenot443 2y agoIt's precisely for economic reasons, hiring a qualified team being the long tail here. I assure you guys that it's much, much easier finding a team of decent web devs than a team of decent Windows devs. Is that really so far-fetched?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- usef- 2y agoI assume you're right, but it's still quite absurd. Apple has recently released applications written natively in WinUI (iCloud for Windows). So Apple can more easily hire/train WinUI developers than Microsoft? I'd accept the "difficulty" excuse from a company like Walmart. But we're talking about a (relatively) small number of built-in mini applications here, inside a tech-specialised company that created, maintains and presumably promotes this native framework.
- ChrisLTD 2y agoThe old sidebar experience was also a web view, so I don’t think anything has meaningfully changed except for the delivery mechanism.
- cageface 2y agoDesktop software APIs are in a generally dire state right now. SwiftUI on Mac also feels like a neglected stepchild. After evaluating a bunch of them I was somewhat astonished to conclude that Flutter was the best option, at least for my purposes.
- vitorgrs 2y agoIf only they knew how to build web apps. Like, I honestly hate web apps. But there is some that is really good, like the new Threads.net app... Meanwhile, MSFT web apps are horrible. They kill native apps, like Mail and classic Outlook, and are replacing with the horrible new Web Outlook. Copilot on Android is also horrible, Bing, etc. They don't know how to build web apps either.
- Havoc 2y agoSeems a bit odd to phrasing it that way. MS scaled things back because of public outcry
- rty32 2y ago[flagged]
- KoolKat23 2y agoScaled back is an understatement, may as well have shipped with a link to the chatgpt app download website.
- simion314 2y ago>MS scaled things back because of public outcry Not related, AI feature would be accepted if M$ would not upload the data to their cloud and implement the stuff safely (the stuff was super unsafe) My assumption is that id did not work as they imagined, maybe you coudl use it by saying "Open Resolution Settings" but it would fail when you change "Resolution" with "Network" os soemthing else because of the giant mess in Windows. Though from my experience the Assistant in Android is also useless to open the correct Setting screen and I still have to hunt the setting I need manually.
- mtmail 2y agoYou're thinking of "Recall", that feature was supposed to be part of the "Copilot+" PCs. The article doesn't talk about Recall.
- dmurray 2y agoCould have been an Onion article. What next, every two years Microsoft announces a new keyboard where the only change is that some "useless" keys have been removed to make way for a bigger Copilot key?
- QuarterReptile 2y agoPresumably this is a reference to the actual Onion article announcing the macbook clickwheel: https://www.theonion.com/apple-introduces-revolutionary-new-laptop-with-no-keybo-1819594761 https://www.theonion.com/apple-introduces-revolutionary-new-...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- freehorse 2y agoThey do not give an explanation but one can only imagine _what could have gotten wrong_ with giving some LLM admin access to the OS of a computer and changing settings through that. Maybe M$ should fix their horrible windows settings UX which is a mesh of windows XP/7/10/11/whatever instead.
- fire_lake 2y agoBlows my mind that Microsoft did not allocate resources to basic UX issues with Windows.
- pjmlp 2y agoThe way WinUI 3.0, WinAppSDK have progressed since Project Reunion announcement in 2020, is quite telling how resource contrained those teams are. 4 years later, still no designer, C++/WinRT will never have a VS tooling experience like C++/CX (and is actually in maintenaince), plenty of UWP features that are still missing from WinUI 3.0, Native AOT on .NET 9 might finally catch up to .NET Native, map component is now backed by a Webview2 and Bing maps,...
- StableAlkyne 2y ago> _what could have gotten wrong_ with giving some LLM admin access to the OS of a computer and changing settings through that. This is my biggest gripe with the MS Edge chatbot - it's cool I can just use Bing Chat with just a click, but holy hell I do not want it to have the ability to change my browser settings. The only time it has ever changed my settings has been when it misinterpreted what I was prompting
- Rohansi 2y agoThe latest Windows 11 is actually in a good state now for settings. Still took them unreasonably long to get here but I haven't needed to go into the old control panel in a long time.
- Rinzler89 2y agoSame. Windows 11 control panel feels now complete to me, way better than the Windows 10 one which had me always reaching out to the legacy control panel.
- the_snooze 2y agoIt really shows that Microsoft doesn't hold themselves up to a high standard. They make all this noise about AI PCs and a new (!!!) Copilot key, only to deliver... not much. Where are the adults in the room who have the guts to say "let's have a cohesive story and do this the right way?" I suspect they think their customers are so dumb that they'll be wowed by the same Malibu Stacy doll with a new hat (!!!).
- count 2y agoMicrosoft has never had a cohesive story, they've had a cohesive brand. From 'Windows' to '.NET' to 'Azure' to 'CoPilot', it's always been about slamming the new buzzword trademark onto everything, regardless of it's relation to the prior thing with similar name.
- asp_hornet 2y agoI was impressed how quickly they were able to dilute their copilot brand. A new personal record
- wkat4242 2y agoYeah like when they branded Skype on everything and we had to do a whole campaign to educate our users that Lync is now Skype but nothing has actually changed and it's not actually compatible with the real Skype in any way, it's just empty vacuous branding crap. I really hate dealing with Microsoft. Now with the CoPilot 365 stuff they're selling us something like it's the best thing in the world when really it's only a barely beta quality product that really shouldn't have made it to market yet.
- kemotep 2y agoThe fact that Co-Pilot 365 is unable to directly search or reference current Microsoft documentation on their Learn site or any of the support articles and just tells you to go look that up yourself is annoying. I understand the major selling point is it’s ability to search through your emails, team messages, meeting notes/transcripts, and SharePoint/OneDrive documents for information is not as useful as it could be because I can’t get it to find me information in my OneNote doc without giving it the documents and even then it usually just tells me to ask the person who last edited the file.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pjmlp 2y agoThe irony of decisions like this, is while WinUI 3.0 team still tries to sell WinUI as the framework for delightful Windows experiences, the remaining business units keep shipping Web stuff instead.
- StableAlkyne 2y agoWhatever happened to dogfooding? I remember they were pretty famous for having it as a hard policy a couple decades ago
- pjmlp 2y agoIt died when Windows 8 came to be, I would say, not even Office was that keen in adopting WinRT. Additionally, I think Microsoft "Developer, Developer, Developer" culture on Windows side, is kind of gone, as many key people went elsewhere, and got replaced by a newer generation without Windows development culture. So now we get UNIX conventions all over the place, and teams that rather ship React Native and Webviews, instead of proper native frameworks.
- vitorgrs 2y agoNo, it died on Windows 11. On Windows 10 everything MSFT developed was UWP. They were basically banned to use anything else. The only thing that used old frameworks, were... old "legacy" components.And the old legacy components barely had updates because they avoid to touch. WinUI (in part) was even born because of this. They already had internal XAML controls (DEPControls) for all their apps, and they decided to open-source and named WinUI. And then later they also wanted to open-source the UWP XAML stack and decouple from Windows updates, and that became WinUI 3.0. Even on 11 launch, there was an attempt to continue with this effort, but well, it's Microsoft... they rewrote taskbar to be UWP (not WInUI 3!), because well, WinUI 3 was (and is) worse than UWP. On other apps, they didn't wanted to rewrite from scratch, because then you would break compat (File Explorer Shell extensions, context menu... etc), so they had a great idea to just mix old UI with WinUI! So you have WinUI on Notepad, File Explorer, Paint, etc, but not in the entire of it. So they were trying to make things more consistent (and WinUI), and it only got worse because mixing the two added too much complexity, WinUI 3 is slower than UWP, etc. So they started going web. Also because of budget reasons.
- ChrisLTD 2y agoMy guess is that Microsoft collected telemetry that showed no one used Copilot to control Windows, so it got the axe.
- nortonsdad 2y agoNaw, the message there would be they need to shove it in the users face more aggressive and turn it on automatically with updates. Telemetry mainly is used to identify the applications users have fled to and still use and target them from the next round of crapping things up.
- dencam 2y agoThis is a lie, I am sure they have a backdoor.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- skywhopper 2y agoSo the MS AI experience is basically the same as that offered by Logitech with its AI mouse button that also just pulls up an LLM chat window.
- exitzer0 2y agoThese new PCs/chips are about more than just co-pilot. They are also the first series of chips with Pluton. https://gabrielsieben.tech/2022/07/25/the-power-of-microsoft-pluton-2/ https://gabrielsieben.tech/2022/07/25/the-power-of-microsoft... Pluton should be absolutely TERRIFYING to anyone informed on Microsoft's security story.
- a1o 2y agoThis new DRM functionality is terrifying indeed, I am really sad this is happening, it's the end of general purpose computers.
- lovethevoid 2y agoAfter reading through, that link does the opposite of what you intend, I now have no issue with Pluton.
- borg16 2y agothis is what happens when the leadership wants you to ship something "good enough" out the door in a fear to not fall behind in whatever race they have conjured up in their minds. this product on some levels, when looked at in isolation, feels as useless as did Rabbit's R1. However, Microsoft is a ginormous corporation, and hence can keep on throwing releases like these at the wall hoping something stick. The leaders will never learn, and I am sure, despite all the good points raised in this article, this release will be or is already being celebrated as a success within the internal circles.
- nancyp 2y agoWhat is Microsofts contribution to AI? Investment in OpenAI and marketing. Satya inherited Azure, lost opportunity in mobile, crapped windows, so he held on to AI bandwagon.