4 ms·
What is ZIRP, and how did it impact the startup world? [video]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 2y agoMeanwhile in the previous episode they were pushing startups to jump on the LLM hype-wagon or risk being left behind. YC seems to be focusing more on whatever the buzzword topic that is trending amongst the Twitter monoculture. Rather than educating founders on more fundamental topics such as how to get from 0-1, how to hire, fostering positive culture etc. For which there is still such little content on.
- devnullbrain 2y agoIf you think LLMs are overhyped, the rational move is to start an LLM company, since it's practically the only way to obtain shares to sell.
- kimixa 2y agoIf you think LLMs are overhyped, you likely expect a bubble burst when the "Emperor has no clothes!" moment happens - so it's rational to avoid the risk of being stuck holding the bag when that happens.
- lokar 2y agoPure money stuff. He has said if you think something is over valued, short it. If you think the VC startup industry is overvalued the best way to do that is to start (and sell to VC) a startup. Enter adam neumann.
- skybrian 2y agoNo, shorting is different; it's borrowing something you might not be able to pay back. WeWork was signing leases - borrowing real estate. They went bankrupt from not being able to pay for it. This isn't the same as selling shares to VC's. Equity isn't debt.
- lokar 2y agoYes, his point in the newsletter is that if you want to short something you can’t borrow, then you should (cynically) make more of it.
- AlexErrant 2y agoThey deleted a lot (all?) of the negative comments on that video too, hah. At one point this was their advice: > We see this so commonly at YC that we have a term for it. It's called a "Solution In Search of a Problem," or a SISP. And these are usually not great, because usually, you never actually find the problem. You're much better off starting with a problem, and then looking for solutions. https://www.ycombinator.com/library/8g-how-to-get-startup-ideas https://www.ycombinator.com/library/8g-how-to-get-startup-id... Very few people have a problem that AI can currently solve. It might not _stay_ that way... but man I wonder what kind of moat a startup could build when they're just wrappers around foundation models.
- gfourfour 2y agoI think wrapper companies could do very well if AI does end up becoming having an impact near on the order of the internet or smartphones, which it may never. A product that incorporates a foundation model could still require solving a hard engineering problem separately from the training and provision of said model. Someone who could, say, provide a reliable filter for copyrighted content from an LLM is providing real value and has a tangible moat.
- jgalt212 2y agospeaking of the LLM hype-wagon or risk being left behind conundrum, is anyone surprised that Michael Saylor hasn't sold all his BTC, and used the proceeds to buy graphics cards?
- PheonixPharts 2y ago> Rather than educating founders on more fundamental topics such as how to get from 0-1, how to hire, fostering positive culture etc. My experience is that none of these things actually matter anymore. I wish they did, but my experience has been that getting any of these things right in today's environment is in the best case inconsequential to success and in the worse an actual determent. I've worked at horrifically toxic startup cultures, but it never seemed to hurt them getting funding from outside teams that didn't care in the slightest how healthy the org was or even the product was even remotely good for customers. I've worked at companies that literally did not know how they were every going to make a profit IPO, then continue to fail to figure this out and changed their strategy to shrug-your-shoulder-and-wait-for-the-return-of-zirp, with no observable consequences on their stock price or investor support for years. Maybe this will eventually catch up to them, but so far they've been quite successful burning a dollar to make $0.70. I've worked at companies that hired hundreds of completely useless data scientist, filled management with toxic management consultants, driven out all the serious talent they had... with again, no real consequences. And all of the companies I've known that checked all of your bullet points? Well they've mostly stayed small, saw revenue decline, and eventually start falling apart. All of the best companies I've worked for ended up having to get rid of all the things that made them good in order to appease investors and keep growing. I wish that we lived in a world where your advice was correct, but I haven't seen any evidence that that is the world we actually inhabit.
- dang 2y agoI don't know about Twitter but I do know that what YC focuses on is founders. If most of the startups are working in some area, it's because that's what founders want to work on. Maybe there's some link between the kind of founders that YC looks to fund, and the sort of things such founders want to work on, but as far as I know YC isn't pushing them in that direction.
- threeseed 2y agoHave often heard that YC picks the "best" founders and lets them work on whatever. Which is interesting given that the last two batches had 90+% of founders being young and from SF. So either international founders should quit running startups because they will never be great. Which is insulting. Or YC is being a bit flexible with the truth and they do have a clear investment thesis.
- dang 2y agoI haven't heard anyone at YC claim to "pick the best"—that feels like it's been reworded to sound more arrogant. The point is that YC focuses mostly on founding teams in deciding who to fund, and having funded them, focuses on supporting them in doing what they want to do.
- hdivider 2y agoMy view: look at most of the real problems we face today. They require solutions consisting of: 1) Engineering (what software folks call hardware), especially cross-functional engineering across several fields, such as chemical and electrical. 2) Software, typically including applications of ML. 3) R&D. Research And Development, folks. The thing investors don't want you to do. Those types of companies will almost never come out of venture capital. They start with a small founder investment (what VCs tell us is called 'bootstrapping'), significantly supported by federal government grants and contracts (the best source of funding for true R&D), and then product development and commercialization. The ZIRP-era of pure software, VC-driven type of technology entrepreneurship tries to skip all the way to the end, scale beyond all bounds, and exit big and fast. No wonder we're experiencing groupthink, and why the Bay Area is hollowing out: in this form of technology entrepreneurship, there is no deep economic basis for growth. In short: technology entrepreneurs should take on technology risk. That means raising capital late, not early, because investors will always be skittish about R&D and longer timeframes. And it means following your own vision first and foremost, rather than letting venture capitalists define how you see the world. Investors are not where the action is. It is founders and early employees who built the likes of Sony, Qualcomm, General Atomics -- each of these, a real technology company.
- rohansingh 2y agoYou captured some of the ideas that have been swimming around in my brain for a little while and really crystallized them. Couldn't agree more.
- steveBK123 2y agoYeah I think in a generation we will look back at the ZIRP era and be bewildered by how little we got out of it. Hard physical engineering R&D, physical infrastructure improvements, mass transit, high speed rail, etc? No. We got B2B SaaS apps. If ZIRP wasn't the era we could fund such long payoff projects, then when will there ever be a possibility?
- no_wizard 2y agoFor some of this, it shouldn't be private capital (such as infrastructure improvements) funding it, it should be public funds. The venture capital model is not a good fit for that, simply based on the evidence available, IE the distinct lack of funding for non-software solutions in the space. SpaceX is a wonderful example of this as well. Elon Musk funded SpaceX, then investors followed much later, mostly due to StarLink and its potential, I imagine. We need better government funding and we definitely need to re-evaulate how grants are structured, the funding tends to be very narrowly specified that you can't solve adjacent problems with the funding as it would be a violation of the terms of the grant. That sort of thing needs to be better accounted for and it isn't today, at least not always.
- dools 2y agoZIRP stands for Zero Interest Rate Policy. BTW it's also the only sensible monetary policy in an economy that issues its own currency on a floating exchange rate. Paying interest on reserves or bonds is solely a policy choice and acts as a transfer payment (ie. welfare) for the rich.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoThat's a very contentious position. I understand that it's a commonly held view among MMT proponents, with whom I mostly agree, but I don't think they have paid enough attention to the importance of interest rates in deflating debt-fueled asset bubbles.
- dools 2y agoI don't know if I can say that I speak for MMT proponents generally but in his lecture on stabilising an unstable economy[1] Wray puts forward a series of very simple regulatory changes that would avoid those types of problems. In other words, regulatory oversight is a better tool for managing those types of bubbles than monetary policy. Mosler also talks about interest rate policy in his debate with Murphy[2] and has a long career in finance in both a public and private capacity. I don't think you could say he hasn't paid enough attention to anything to do with interest rates! [1] Lectures 6 & 7 in this series https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFf95BVx9Qw&list=PLYvSXI9SKGf2lIno6TI0r_PbLX_cpAwuu&index=7&t=39s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFf95BVx9Qw&list=PLYvSXI9SKG... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUTLCDBONok&t=5347s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUTLCDBONok&t=5347s
- jgalt212 2y agoit's a nice theory, but there's no practice or experiments to back up the theory.
- dools 2y agoJapan had an asset bubble that monetarists blamed on their lack of action to tighten the money market by increasing interest rates. Their economy tanked and they switched to ZIRP in the late 90s and have been there more or less ever since, with no runaway inflation or asset bubbles. So at best you could say that the impact of monetary policy on inflation and GDP is indeterminate, however it is more likely than not going to be inflationary because increasing interest rates increases net financial assets in the private sector by increasing transfer payments to rich people.