7 ms·
McDonald's is ending its drive-thru AI test
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoFuck McDonald's and their unhealthy, climate change-promoting, antibiotic resistance increasing, and single-use garbage non-food. RIP Morgan Spurlock
- Bluestein 2y ago[flagged]
- raverbashing 2y agoLet me guess: minimum effort implementation combined with heavy accents and people who can't be bothered to enunciate Sounds like a recipe for a failed project
- aenis 2y agoThe price of errors is too high, I'd imagine. I see this everywhere in my own domain - AI stuff is super easy to demo and prototype, but running in production in scenarios where errors are not cheap is a recipe for disasters. We are currently only pushing it where the existing process involving people is ridden with imperfections -- and AI can do no worse or better, but still not perfect.
- kachapopopow 2y agoMost likely because they will replace it with the openai based one that has been getting popular.
- consp 2y agoLooking at the state of most drive though electronics this is pointless and won't matter. Keeping that system working is already difficult enough with a highly adaptable human at the other end of the line which can interpret your order with a broken microphone, bad language skills, a loud motor interfering and in any weather. And openai cannot handle the "please drive though to the first booth" if all else fails. On another anecdotal note completely off-topic: I wonder how it would interpret a horse, back in the days when I worked at the local McD we had plenty of them going though the drivethough.
- jagged-chisel 2y ago> I wonder how it would interpret a horse... Surely you don't intend to imply that the horse is ordering. Give that, there are all manner of sensors to detect the presence of an automobile or horse in the drive through and notify staff or the AI that someone wants to place an order. My understanding is that this is a solved problem. Staff get an alert/announcement chime or recording about someone waiting because the electronics detected something. Why a horse would pose a challenge is a mystery to me. Sure, there are some devices that will work less effectively as sensors for a horse than a car, but your particular franchise just adapts to the correct sensors for its traffic.
- consp 2y ago> Surely you don't intend to imply that the horse is ordering. Haha no (should have explained), but riders are too high to be heard due to the directional microphones installed and you only effectively hear the horse. Same for very high seated cars (though I suspect this might be different in the US). Trucks are too tall and would hit the building so they are not a consideration for the one I worked at. As you said, a simple alert system might work to solve this.
- imglorp 2y agoThis might be a case where a kiosk touchscreen is better. I've used them in-store. It's not a bad system, plus you would pay there instead of "pull up to the first window". Plus a touchscreen works for hearing impaired people.
- Waterluvian 2y agoThe only time I dislike these kiosks is when they’re inexplicably laggy and horrible to trigger interactions. How does that happen?! It’s at least 2008.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoI’ve found using my knuckle helps immensely. Still slow, but touches register more consistently.
- lozf 2y agoAnd you don't then use that knuckle to pick up food, and eat with. Much cleaner.
- yetihehe 2y agoBecause they wait for corporate server half the world away logging every click through crappy 2g connection before they can advance to next screen. How I know? I made some telemetric devices working on 2g connections, trying to optimise the hell out of it (other hardware vendors look at you funny when you tell them that your devices use only 2MB/month). Minimum response time was about 1.5s, 20s was still pretty normal.
- Severian 2y agoThe biggest challenge to this is weather. Do you really want to roll down your window and get soaked in a rainstorm to pick a #1 with a diet coke? Most drive-thrus I've ever seen (Ohio, US) have zero cover and you are completely exposed to whatever mother nature wants to throw at you. Even the service window itself may have a tiny 24" awning that barely helps. In fact in my experience during rain it makes it worse as you get runoff right on top of the vehicle since they don't have rain gutters.
- infecto 2y agoMakes sense. I think the technology will get there but there are most likely too many unknown variables in the ordering process. McD would rather you order through the app for pickup.
- GaggiX 2y agoI remember seeing a video from WSJ about the drive-thru AI chatbot from https://presto.com/ https://presto.com/ being used in a fastfood restaurant, to be honest it works quite well, I wonder if McDonald's will switch to them. The service is already being used by Checkers, Hardee’s, Carl’s Jr. and Taco Johns.
- YounoYouno 2y ago> But the company did not dismiss the prospect of drive-thru AI, suggesting that McDonald’s plans to find a new partner for its automated order taking efforts. Yeah, it's ending the current partnership, not the imminent doom of fully automated restaurants.
- ethbr1 2y ago> ending its partnership with IBM on automated order-taking without an expansion Aka some IBM b-team screwed up yet another implementation, but the contract language prevents McDonald's from saying so.
- Drakim 2y agoIt's kinda wild how frequent screw-ups like this with companies like IBM and Oracle are and that companies never learn.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoReading the comment above from noen, it seems McDonalds sabotaged the project as part of a plan for an acquisition. When reading the article I also jumped to conclusion it was IBM's problem. But then thought it sounded an awful like McDonalds was 'hinting' that it was IBM's problem while not being able to say so. So kind of a reverse stab. McDonalds is acting like there is contract language saying they can't say what happened, and subtly making it seem like it was IBM when really McDonalds is saying: "It was IBM but we can't say because of contracts, wink wink, but really we were a horrible customer and wrecked the project and trying to spin this onto the vendor".
- noen 2y agoI worked on this project at my former employer for nearly 8 months. We worked as a good faith partner with McDonald’s, only to find out eight months in that McDonald’s had never had any intention of working with us and we’re only using us as a negotiating tactic for the acquisition they eventually made for this technology. I learned two things from this project. Our team built a complete English language model for every possible permutation of ordering every menu item. No LLMs, no gpt required. The hilarious part is that McDonald’s stopped responding to our team and abandoned the project only about a month before we were going to tell them that it was not technically feasible to do it scale. The problem is not bad AI nor a lack of data. The problem is all of the real world interface challenges, keeping speakers and microphones working outdoors across many different climates and weather conditions, and temperatures and humidity is incredibly expensive. And on top of that, the hardware needed per store at the edge and the permanent network infrastructure required to keep everything running makes the whole system substantially more expensive than just having a single human being running drive-through even have much higher wages than minimum wage. So McDonald’s never got this conclusion from us and instead spent several billion more dollars and another six years of R&D to come to the same conclusion. My other take away from this project was that I will never give McDonald’s another dollar of my money. Working with over 200 fortune 500 companies in my career McDonald’s is far away the most evil heartless and ruthless company I’ve ever dealt with. They don’t care about their customers, their users, their franchisees or their employees. The only thing they care about at all is their stock price.
- astronads 2y agoPlease share more about this!
- tehwebguy 2y agoThanks for sharing, everything makes sense except this: > The problem is all of the real world interface challenges, keeping speakers and microphones working outdoors across many different climates and weather conditions, and temperatures and humidity is incredibly expensive. I thought this was a solved problem already, by McDonald’s in fact?
- 2y ago
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- spacecadet 2y agoWhat a play by McDonalds, sell the team to recoup the risk, sign some initial extension to make it feel worth it to IBM, then pull the rug. IBM nothing changes...
- matthewfelgate 2y agoIs America living in the past? Here in the UK I always use the McDonalds app and either order for pickup or delivery to my car or table inside the restaurant.
- JohnFen 2y agoYou can do that in the US, too, if you want.
- Slyfox33 2y agoNo? You've been able to do that here for a decade.
- LegitShady 2y agoi dont install apps from food companies on my phone. Some have already been caught collecting the data nefariously. The reason they have the app is to steal your data. Before mcdonalds had their summer drink and ice cream cone specials for everyone, now you have to use the app, so they can take your data. A lot of people just opt out.
- matthewfelgate 2y agoYes. Well that's up to you.
- LegitShady 2y agoYes.
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40701868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40701868
- say_it_as_it_is 2y agoNobody ever gets fired for choosing I... oh.
- xcavier 2y agoIn addition to the environmental issues, surely a wide disparity in dialects and speech patterns must have played a role? ML/NLP models largely be trained on clear, precise - and predictable - English language must struggle when you add in an accent, slang usage and age/geo-specific language choice?
- exsomet 2y agoI don’t have any actual data to inform my feelings (I’m sure it wouldn’t be hard to find), but any time this stuff comes up I have to wonder about the economics of building out the AI, instrumenting a store, building or buying/licensing software for the customers to interface with, the compute, bandwidth, etc… Versus paying some kid $7 an hour to hit buttons on a screen. As uninformed as I may be here, my gut says that it doesn’t make a lot of sense.