3 ms·
[flagged]
by CamperBob2 2y ago
[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- crote 2y agoYes, because the company has something to gain by lying. If Wikipedia cites a newspaper article which brought to light that the company has been poisoning the local water supply, should that section be removed just because the company's founder says differently?
- CamperBob2 2y agoNo, but someone else can use a "reliable source" (whatever that means) or an authoritative primary source to add that information. Personally, I want a resource that values primary sources, not one that censors them. The world isn't short on hard drive space (and deletionism didn't make sense back when it was, either.) I would prefer that an article about XYZ Co. is edited by the former CEO of XYZ Co., rather than by someone who knows nothing about XYZ Co., but whose opinion regarding "reliable sources" is informed by their biases regarding the "social structure of capitalism."
- dessimus 2y ago> I would prefer that an article about XYZ Co. is edited by the former CEO of XYZ Co. Even a former CEO would keep secrets. The next corporation's board is not going to hire a CEO that will knowingly be frank on Wikipedia about a former company.
- CamperBob2 2y agoNote that he didn't say anything about the information the CEO tried to add/remove/edit, just that the edit was "historical" in nature and epistemically unacceptable based on its source. It might not have involved a secret plot to dilute the company's baby formula with methanol, it might have been as innocent (and as objective) as their date of formation or ownership structure. We simply don't know. There's a lot we don't know because somebody like this didn't approve of where the information came from. Somewhere a homeowner's association is missing a lawn committee chair.
- arp242 2y agoOf course not, but no one is saying that we should always uncritically accept what a company says. That's just boring black/white nonsense. Obviously people involved in a topic have a conflict of interest and their edits should be viewed with the appropriate amount of trepidation (if they should even be editing at all). This, however, has nothing to do with capitalism. It's a very odd swipe to include. And it really does depend on the specifics of what they wanted to change. People with a conflict of interest try to make poor edits all the time, but there's also tons of uncited or poorly cited stuff on Wikipedia that can be hard to change if one particularly difficult editor stands in the way for whatever reason (possibly due to their own opposing conflict of interest). A whole-sale dismissal of their complaint without any information about the specifics at all is just flat-out wrong. This is exactly the sort of behaviour are complain about.
- jjmarr 2y agoSpeaking as someone who edits frequently, the "social structure of capitalism" argument is a bad way to put it, but the general point that employees/leadership aren't reliable sources is true. Virtually every company has a direct financial incentive to prevent negative information about them from spreading widely and to add positive information of dubious relevance. The way Wikipedia deals with this is the policy commonly abbreviated as WP:ABOUTSELF [1], which allows to cite companies for information about themselves in the following situations. > Self-published and questionable sources may be used as sources of information about themselves, usually in articles about themselves or their activities, without the self-published source requirement that they are established experts in the field, so long as: >> The material is neither unduly self-serving nor an exceptional claim; >> It does not involve claims about third parties; >> It does not involve claims about events not directly related to the source; >> There is no reasonable doubt as to its authenticity; and >> The article is not based primarily on such sources. If you want to "begin to argue with someone who holds an opinion like this", the first step is probably to clarify what the policy really is. Personally, I think this is a fair compromise between a maximalist approach (anything influenced by capitalism = bad) and the idea that companies are 100% authoritative on their own history. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Verifiability#Self-published_or_questionable_sources_as_sources_on_themselves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Verifiability#Self-p...
- defrost 2y agoIt's interesting to me that no specific mention is made in [1] of Company X material released by Company X to the stock exchange that lists them. In the case of minerals and energy listing specifically there are steep penalties for releasing information known to be false and for not correcting information by a following release at the earliest oppotunity. Annual reports, quarterlies, board positions, major share holdings, assets, new grounds, technical report summaries, reserve|resource estimates etc are all "self published" but can be assumed to be accurate and backed by third party accountants, third party assessors, etc if pressed.
- jjmarr 2y agoIn my opinion, that kind of material would fall under that rule, but I can't find enough discussions to tell you if they should be treated as especially reliable. The closest thing to a discussion on stock exchange filings was in 2012 on SEC filings (which also have legal penalties for dishonesty) where editors made the points you did: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_120#EDGAR%2FSEC_filing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Not...
- davidgerard 2y agoWikipedia editor and admin here. I am one of the people who deals with the mountains of commercial editing, on the spectrum from PR to spam. Wikipedia deals with a firehose of this nonsense. I can assure you that prima facie rejecting edits from company sources with a glaring conflict of interest is the obviously correct move, both with a moment's thought and in practice. If you bounce this hard off the mere words "social structure of capitalism", then you come across as trying way too hard not to understand fairly straightforward and obvious things.