5 ms·
72% of U.S. high school teachers say cellphone distraction is a major problem
- themerone 2y agoSo 28% of high schools ban phones or is this a 10th dentist thing?
- klyrs 2y agoNo, the other 28% were paying attention and teaching instead of fucking around with a survey on their phone.
- fuzzfactor 2y agoI would think at some schools, the other 28% were on Facebook or Tiktok themsleves.
- klyrs 2y agoYou missed my insinuation that 72% were distracted by their phones...
- fuzzfactor 2y agoI guess it goes without saying more than I thought. And that makes 100% ;)
- rhelz 2y agoHeck, Cellphone distraction is a major problem for me, and I haven't been in a classroom since the Clinton era.
- jackvalentine 2y agoRight? I have a 1 year old kid and are really careful not to use my phone in front of him and it is an _eye opener_ how much willpower that takes.
- adamnemecek 2y agoClassroom is a distraction from internet use.
- bookofjoe 2y agoQuote of the day
- datavirtue 2y agoSome schools have already banned phones and everyone loves the result. The wave is coming.
- StressedDev 2y agoI doubt everyone loves the result. I am a lot of the students are not thrilled about giving up their phones.
- Gigachad 2y agoPhones were banned in my highschool (~10 years ago). You didn't "give up" your phone, you just couldn't take it out. Taking your phone out during class usually resulted in having it put on the teachers desk until the end of class so it wasn't a major punishment but also you couldn't sit there scrolling facebook all day. Not sure why HN acts like this kind of rule is impossible when its already extremely common in schools.
- nytesky 2y agoThe whole problem is that phones are disruptive by nature, but teachers having to police students (and it’s more than one, on many days) and it’s a huge chunk and disruption to instruction time. 10 years ago you were messaging/posting; now it’s all video streams with hidden wireless headphones. I feel like taking a phone until the end of school year might have impact, that used to be a policy when I was kid, but granted kids weren’t walking around with $1000 doodads so different economics. The 30% who say it’s not a problem just assume the kids on their phones are a lost cause and just write them off.
- Gigachad 2y agoGuess it depends on how unruly the school is. It never seemed that disruptive for teachers to police from my perspective, but no one argued with it. It wasn’t the end of the world to lose your phone for an hour. Phones have been banned in private schools in Australia for ages, and just recently the government put the same rules in for public schools. So it’s not exactly a radical idea to ban them today.
- Spivak 2y agoThis survey suffers from the nothing at stake problem of assessing severity. You can't just ask it in a vacuum because it doesn't actually reveal any preference. I would bet my hat that if you asked teachers to rank the problems in their field cellphones would be consistently near the bottom. And "I would rather you fix these 18 things first" is not what anyone would call major. Forty years ago I bet you could get "passing notes distraction" is a major problem. There was a whole generation that could text one handed in their pockets and they turned out fine. They're adults with real jobs now. re: but smartphones are different, in this essay...
- mlyle 2y agoIMO the top 3 issues right now: 1. student mental health, 2. academic integrity, and 3. direct distraction from cellphones and game devices. And #1 or #2 are directly tied to cellphones, too: not to say that reducing cellphone use will eliminate them, but it will certainly help. And I expect other dividends from reducing cellphone use: the students who are addicted to short-form content have shockingly small attention spans.
- themerone 2y agoI hear more complaints from teachers about funding, pay, and parents.
- mlyle 2y agoI teach in a private school; none of the things you mention frequently impact my ability to be successful in a classroom. Sure, I'd like to be paid more, and I'd like easier interactions with parents. Or to live in a culture that prioritized education a bit more.
- Aeolun 2y agoI’m inclined towards just banning cellphones in schools. For 70% of the students this will be enough to ensure they don’t use one (number made up based on experience of recalcitrant kids in my classes)
- KingMachiavelli 2y agoA ban on cell phones would make doing homework a lot more difficult. It's far easier to have textbooks on your phone than carrying them around all day. Almost impossible to write any kind of paper without the internet.
- pezezin 2y agoSeriously? What kind of textbook are you going to read on a tiny cellphone screen?
- KingMachiavelli 2y agoIt's actually quite convenient, school desks are quite small so trying to fit a textbook and your homework notebook is quite cramped. You can just put your phone directly next to the HW problem. High schoolers and college students still have good eyes lol.
- freilanzer 2y agoWhat? Textbooks on a phone? This must be satire.
- Zenzero 2y ago> Almost impossible to write any kind of paper without the internet. Did we all forget about books?
- KingMachiavelli 2y agoSure but why would you want to? I can lookup 10x the number of sources just using LibGen and Google Scholar than I can in a real library.
- exabrial 2y ago72% seems kind of low
- Fezzik 2y agoThe big problem is smartphones with internet access, not cellphones. I was in high-school when cellphones really took off and while the occasional errant phone ring in class wasn’t uncommon nobody was compelled to be doom scrolling on social media during class, because we didn’t have internet access. A lot of people, especially kids, are not skilled at moderating bad habits. On a related tangent, my drive to work takes me past multiple middle-school bus-stops and every. single. kid. Has their face glued to their phone every. single. day. It’s depressing.
- hulitu 2y ago> every. single. kid. Has their face glued to their phone every. single. day. It’s depressing. Maybe for you. Sincerely, Meta, Apple, Microsoft and Google. /s
- qwery 2y agoI don't have any deep insight into the American education system. So I'm making a bit of a guess and assuming that, like other capitalist-oriented western democracies, the current state is the result of decades of underfunding, overzealous application of standardised testing, industry and other lobbying, poor working conditions, etc. With that out of the way... Carrot or stick. School is already all stick all the time. Right now, some students feel that some of their time is better spent on their phones than paying attention to the teacher. Why that is doesn't seem to be a significant part of the conversation. Properly fund public, free for everyone education. Pay teachers more. Make school good for kids instead of trying to force kids to be good for school.
- asdajksah2123 2y ago> some students feel that some of their time is better spent on their phones than paying attention to the teacher And kids feel that eating donuts is better than vegetables. Or that drinking soda is better than water. The fact that students feel something easy (not just easy, but something that is designed by tens of thousands of the smartest people in the world to be addictive) is more attractive than something hard says almost nothing that isn't a tautology.
- beretguy 2y agoCover walls of your classroom in copper mesh.
- john_the_writer 2y agoWhat I wonder all the time is why jamming isn't a think in schools. Have it on a fire-alarm system. Fire alarm on.. jammer off
- samgranieri 2y agoI graduated HS in 1999. If I were a teacher, I'd require the students turn off their phones and put them in a clear bag with their name on it on a box on my desk. Then they get their phones back at the end of class. Simple solution, no?