6 ms·

Serious question, why would a person spend that kind of money on an ebike? An entry-level motorcycle is less than half that. What benefit does the bike get yo

Serious question, why would a person spend that kind of money on an ebike? An entry-level motorcycle is less than half that. What benefit does the bike get you that a motorcycle doesn't? One example among many: https://powersports.honda.com/motorcycle/cruiser/rebel-500 https://powersports.honda.com/motorcycle/cruiser/rebel-500

elbasti 2y ago
Serious answer: they are lighter, quieter, go slower, handle differently, and have access to different infrastructure. The lighter and slower bit may sound glib, but it makes a huge difference to what it feels like to ride them and to have them ridden around you.
- nox101 2y ago
  a Riese and Muller is not a light bike
  - fatrat 2y ago
    It's a heavy bike, but a very light motorcycle, which is the point
petre 2y ago
> What benefit does the bike get you that a motorcycle doesn't? Exercise and silence.
- nox101 2y ago
  Most bikes are not silent. Worse, it's getting popular to make them loud. I was looking for an e-mtb recently. Tried a Trek ($4.5k down from $7.5k), ridiculously loud hub. Sales person claimed (falsely) that the more pro the hub the louder. Talked to another dealer who gave me the same story.
  - cujo 2y ago
    > Sales person claimed (falsely) that the more pro the hub the louder. What's false about it? Pros tend to ride wheels with loud hubs. It's kind of a known thing.
  - petre 2y ago
    Even loud hubs are more silent than most motorbikes.
  - fireflash38 2y ago
    MTB hubs are noisy as hell anyway, and yes, the more expensive the MTB the noisier the hub. For pedal bikes it's about being able to pedal without doing a full rotation and not losing power or wasting energy
  - scheme271 2y ago
    It's kind of true. If you want the hub to engage right away when you pedal, you'll need the rachet mechanism to have more points of potential contact and those points will all make clicking sounds when you're coasting.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y ago
  What about EV motorcycles? That at least solves noise.
daliusd 2y ago
You can attach trailer to bicycle and use it to transport your kids to nursery/school during winter. There I live both things would be illegal with motorcycle.
- abdulhaq 2y ago
  Sounds very dangerous to me
  - saagarjha 2y ago
    Why would attaching a trailer to your bike be very dangerous?
    - tejtm 2y ago
      Total bike and trailer builder and believer of yore here. One can fail to appreciate the additional breaking forces and shifts in balance a loaded trailer introduces to the bicycle. Where the trailer attaches should be as close to the center of gravity of the bike & rider as possible so the trailer's resultant forces have the least leverage. The trailer hitch should be rotationaly neutral which is a gentler way of saying if the trailer flips over it should not take the bike down with it. If the trailer has its own breaks they should slightly and lightly lead the bikes rear break. Being careful helps, I never wrecked, but do see how the addition of electrical assist does up the concern as it could result in more mass moving fast.
    - abdulhaq 2y ago
      I've been rear-ended by other drivers a couple of times, once in the centre of town. If a child in a trailer been between the two vehicles they would have been killed. The reason for one of the rear-endings was that the brake rubber came of the pedal. I don't trust other drivers to not be on their phone or to properly maintain attention at all times. The OP also said that he did this in winter time. Here in the UK there can be black ice on the road at that time of the year.
Too 2y ago
Convenience and sense of freedom. No license required, can lend it to friends or kids. Can be parked anywhere. Can be loaded on a car, ferry and some places even the metro. Can ride them on bike lanes, the forest and the sidewalk. More approachable diy maintenance. Don't need full leather protection, just a helmet and t-shirt and you are good to go. If you are only traveling max 30km within the town, you don't need anything faster. Bigger isn't always better.
- IshKebab 2y ago
  > Can be parked anywhere Jesus I wouldn't park a $15k bike anywhere...
  - nox101 2y ago
    This is hard to believe but if true it's insane. The claim is, 2 million bikes are stolen in the USA every year. https://cyclingindustry.news/bicycle-theft-surpasses-2-million-a-year-in-the-usa/ https://cyclingindustry.news/bicycle-theft-surpasses-2-milli...
  - Too 2y ago
    Anywhere, including indoors :)
  - 7bit 2y ago
    You took the Most expensive example to make your Point. Who even owns a 15k bike? 0.0001 % of the population?
    - IshKebab 2y ago
      Did you actually read this thread? We're specifically talking about a $15k ebike.
  - macrolime 2y ago
    If you're afraid of it getting stolen you can buy insurance.
nox101 2y ago
I'm curious too when bikes became that expensive. I just recently started looking for a new bike. Every major bike brand (Specialized, Trek, Cannondale, Orbea, Canyon, Santa Cruz, etc...) all sell bikes between $4000 an $18000! That's regardless of whether they are e-bikes or non-e-bikes. When did bikes get that expensive? I bought a "brand name bike" just like 6 years ago for $900 and thought I was going way out of a normal budget.
- cujo 2y ago
  Yes they all very sell expensive bikes. They also sell less expensive bikes. At a quick glance for road bikes: * Canyon starts at $1899 * Specialized starts at $1200 * Trek starts at $999 If you want a more upright hybrid, they can be found at lower prices. > I bought a "brand name bike" just like 6 years ago for $900 and thought I was going way out of a normal budget. I'm curious what you got for $900. I doubt the current iteration of that $900 bike is now being sold for many thousands.
- acdha 2y ago
  Even 20 years ago, $900 was on the lower side for a serious bike but the big thing to remember is that e-bikes are transformative: they make daily commuting practical for many people who are not avid cyclists and especially so for parents. That means you should compare them to cars: I bought a cargo e-bike for just under $3k when I needed to take my son and all of his stuff to daycare near my office ~6 miles away. I certainly used to bike that distance before but the weather, workday timing, etc. meant I never did it more than 3 days a week before, but the speed & cargo capacity of the e-bike made it my preferred option every day. The other people who didn’t live within walking distance all drove, so their trips took longer door to door (congestion around the school alone was 20 minutes) and my expensive e-bike was the equivalent of a couple months of what they spent on SUV payments, parking, gas, and insurance. Plus my son _loved_ going on the bike every day (it helped that we went by the train yard) while most of his classmates protested going in the car because they’re so isolated with nothing to see.
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y ago
  E-bikes imported to the US from Europe for sale to Americans who have essentially unlimited funds and little concern for what things actually cost. For mechanical bikes, they've always been (relatively) expensive. Here's one for $16k: https://www.cannondale.com/en-us/bikes/road/race/supersix-evo/supersix-evo-lab71 https://www.cannondale.com/en-us/bikes/road/race/supersix-ev...
macrolime 2y ago
With an ebike you can ride in bike lanes, sidewalks and many other places motorcycles are not allowed. They can also park loads of places motorcycles aren't allowed plus you get exercise.
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y ago
  Yep. Ebikes can do a lot of things motorcycles aren't allowed to do. For example, it's customary (while illegal) for ebikes to not stop at stop signs in the US because there's little-to-no enforcement of it compared to the enforcement of traffic laws against motorcyclists.
rjh29 2y ago
or a escooter or one of those things you just stand on and it moves? The main reason to ride a bike nowadays is for pleasure or exercise and a ebike defeats both.
- sswezey 2y ago
  An ebike can be for both pleasure and exercise. Most ebikes are pedelecs - you're still cycling, you're just getting a boost. They aren't loud, you just either get somewhere faster or with less effort. I find an ebike to be more pleasurable than a regular bike 90% of the time. Just because you're doing less work, doesn't mean you're doing no work. An ebike can provide mobility for people who aren't in perfect shape. Ebikes can also allow you to use your bike for more errands, like getting groceries that people would otherwise not do on a regular bike.
  - rjh29 2y ago
    That's fair. I can see how an ebike might encourage people to ride them more compared to owning a regular bike and never using it!
hi-v-rocknroll 2y ago
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ It's a stupid amount of money for what it is. KTM makes an 18 kW e-motorcycle for $12k USD. https://www.ktm.com/en-us/models/e-ride/freeride/2023-ktm-freerideexc.html https://www.ktm.com/en-us/models/e-ride/freeride/2023-ktm-fr...

elbasti 2y ago

Serious answer: they are lighter, quieter, go slower, handle differently, and have access to different infrastructure. The lighter and slower bit may sound glib, but it makes a huge difference to what it feels like to ride them and to have them ridden around you.

nox101 2y ago
a Riese and Muller is not a light bike
- fatrat 2y ago
  It's a heavy bike, but a very light motorcycle, which is the point

petre 2y ago

> What benefit does the bike get you that a motorcycle doesn't? Exercise and silence.

nox101 2y ago
Most bikes are not silent. Worse, it's getting popular to make them loud. I was looking for an e-mtb recently. Tried a Trek ($4.5k down from $7.5k), ridiculously loud hub. Sales person claimed (falsely) that the more pro the hub the louder. Talked to another dealer who gave me the same story.
- cujo 2y ago
  > Sales person claimed (falsely) that the more pro the hub the louder. What's false about it? Pros tend to ride wheels with loud hubs. It's kind of a known thing.
- petre 2y ago
  Even loud hubs are more silent than most motorbikes.
- fireflash38 2y ago
  MTB hubs are noisy as hell anyway, and yes, the more expensive the MTB the noisier the hub. For pedal bikes it's about being able to pedal without doing a full rotation and not losing power or wasting energy
- scheme271 2y ago
  It's kind of true. If you want the hub to engage right away when you pedal, you'll need the rachet mechanism to have more points of potential contact and those points will all make clicking sounds when you're coasting.
HeatrayEnjoyer 2y ago
What about EV motorcycles? That at least solves noise.

daliusd 2y ago

You can attach trailer to bicycle and use it to transport your kids to nursery/school during winter. There I live both things would be illegal with motorcycle.

abdulhaq 2y ago
Sounds very dangerous to me
- saagarjha 2y ago
  Why would attaching a trailer to your bike be very dangerous?
  - tejtm 2y ago
    Total bike and trailer builder and believer of yore here. One can fail to appreciate the additional breaking forces and shifts in balance a loaded trailer introduces to the bicycle. Where the trailer attaches should be as close to the center of gravity of the bike & rider as possible so the trailer's resultant forces have the least leverage. The trailer hitch should be rotationaly neutral which is a gentler way of saying if the trailer flips over it should not take the bike down with it. If the trailer has its own breaks they should slightly and lightly lead the bikes rear break. Being careful helps, I never wrecked, but do see how the addition of electrical assist does up the concern as it could result in more mass moving fast.
  - abdulhaq 2y ago
    I've been rear-ended by other drivers a couple of times, once in the centre of town. If a child in a trailer been between the two vehicles they would have been killed. The reason for one of the rear-endings was that the brake rubber came of the pedal. I don't trust other drivers to not be on their phone or to properly maintain attention at all times. The OP also said that he did this in winter time. Here in the UK there can be black ice on the road at that time of the year.

Too 2y ago

Convenience and sense of freedom. No license required, can lend it to friends or kids. Can be parked anywhere. Can be loaded on a car, ferry and some places even the metro. Can ride them on bike lanes, the forest and the sidewalk. More approachable diy maintenance. Don't need full leather protection, just a helmet and t-shirt and you are good to go. If you are only traveling max 30km within the town, you don't need anything faster. Bigger isn't always better.

IshKebab 2y ago
> Can be parked anywhere Jesus I wouldn't park a $15k bike anywhere...
- nox101 2y ago
  This is hard to believe but if true it's insane. The claim is, 2 million bikes are stolen in the USA every year. https://cyclingindustry.news/bicycle-theft-surpasses-2-million-a-year-in-the-usa/ https://cyclingindustry.news/bicycle-theft-surpasses-2-milli...
- Too 2y ago
  Anywhere, including indoors :)
- 7bit 2y ago
  You took the Most expensive example to make your Point. Who even owns a 15k bike? 0.0001 % of the population?
  - IshKebab 2y ago
    Did you actually read this thread? We're specifically talking about a $15k ebike.
- macrolime 2y ago
  If you're afraid of it getting stolen you can buy insurance.

nox101 2y ago

I'm curious too when bikes became that expensive. I just recently started looking for a new bike. Every major bike brand (Specialized, Trek, Cannondale, Orbea, Canyon, Santa Cruz, etc...) all sell bikes between $4000 an $18000! That's regardless of whether they are e-bikes or non-e-bikes. When did bikes get that expensive? I bought a "brand name bike" just like 6 years ago for $900 and thought I was going way out of a normal budget.

cujo 2y ago
Yes they all very sell expensive bikes. They also sell less expensive bikes. At a quick glance for road bikes: * Canyon starts at $1899 * Specialized starts at $1200 * Trek starts at $999 If you want a more upright hybrid, they can be found at lower prices. > I bought a "brand name bike" just like 6 years ago for $900 and thought I was going way out of a normal budget. I'm curious what you got for $900. I doubt the current iteration of that $900 bike is now being sold for many thousands.
acdha 2y ago
Even 20 years ago, $900 was on the lower side for a serious bike but the big thing to remember is that e-bikes are transformative: they make daily commuting practical for many people who are not avid cyclists and especially so for parents. That means you should compare them to cars: I bought a cargo e-bike for just under $3k when I needed to take my son and all of his stuff to daycare near my office ~6 miles away. I certainly used to bike that distance before but the weather, workday timing, etc. meant I never did it more than 3 days a week before, but the speed & cargo capacity of the e-bike made it my preferred option every day. The other people who didn’t live within walking distance all drove, so their trips took longer door to door (congestion around the school alone was 20 minutes) and my expensive e-bike was the equivalent of a couple months of what they spent on SUV payments, parking, gas, and insurance. Plus my son _loved_ going on the bike every day (it helped that we went by the train yard) while most of his classmates protested going in the car because they’re so isolated with nothing to see.
hi-v-rocknroll 2y ago
E-bikes imported to the US from Europe for sale to Americans who have essentially unlimited funds and little concern for what things actually cost. For mechanical bikes, they've always been (relatively) expensive. Here's one for $16k: https://www.cannondale.com/en-us/bikes/road/race/supersix-evo/supersix-evo-lab71 https://www.cannondale.com/en-us/bikes/road/race/supersix-ev...

macrolime 2y ago

With an ebike you can ride in bike lanes, sidewalks and many other places motorcycles are not allowed. They can also park loads of places motorcycles aren't allowed plus you get exercise.

hi-v-rocknroll 2y ago
Yep. Ebikes can do a lot of things motorcycles aren't allowed to do. For example, it's customary (while illegal) for ebikes to not stop at stop signs in the US because there's little-to-no enforcement of it compared to the enforcement of traffic laws against motorcyclists.

rjh29 2y ago

or a escooter or one of those things you just stand on and it moves? The main reason to ride a bike nowadays is for pleasure or exercise and a ebike defeats both.

sswezey 2y ago
An ebike can be for both pleasure and exercise. Most ebikes are pedelecs - you're still cycling, you're just getting a boost. They aren't loud, you just either get somewhere faster or with less effort. I find an ebike to be more pleasurable than a regular bike 90% of the time. Just because you're doing less work, doesn't mean you're doing no work. An ebike can provide mobility for people who aren't in perfect shape. Ebikes can also allow you to use your bike for more errands, like getting groceries that people would otherwise not do on a regular bike.
- rjh29 2y ago
  That's fair. I can see how an ebike might encourage people to ride them more compared to owning a regular bike and never using it!

hi-v-rocknroll 2y ago

¯\_(ツ)_/¯ It's a stupid amount of money for what it is. KTM makes an 18 kW e-motorcycle for $12k USD. https://www.ktm.com/en-us/models/e-ride/freeride/2023-ktm-freerideexc.html https://www.ktm.com/en-us/models/e-ride/freeride/2023-ktm-fr...