3 ms·
On approach. I think that’s an important detail missing from the headline. Still a shocking near-miss, but it’s not like it dropped from 35,000 feet to 400 feet
by adastra22 2y ago
On approach. I think that’s an important detail missing from the headline. Still a shocking near-miss, but it’s not like it dropped from 35,000 feet to 400 feet before correcting.
- nscalf 2y agoOn approach, and dropped from 600 feet to 400 feet at a rate of 4000 feet per minute. So a 3 second drop. I don’t know much about what is normal here, but that seems like important framing.
- pbhjpbhj 2y ago60-180 fpm (foot per minute) is a typical vertical speed at touchdown for an airliner. I think the glide slope is 600fpm (?). Eg. https://aviation.stackexchange.com/a/47430 https://aviation.stackexchange.com/a/47430
- MadnessASAP 2y ago1000-2000 fpm would be a typical climb/descent in most situations. 4000 fpm would raise an eyebrow or two but is not generally alarming (that is, it's well within the performance envelope of most aircraft). However, at 600' any loss of altitude without a suitable runway beneath you and an aircraft ready to greet it is a very alarming prospect. As for this incident, it sounds like a junior pilot accidentally hit the control column while going for another control. It's only notable for having occurred at the very moment you don't want such things to occur. I suggest a corrective action of briefing pilots not too hit the control column.
- sofixa 2y agoTo be fair, most aircraft accidents are on or just after takeoff, or just before, during or after landing. Those are the most critical minutes when the most things can go wrong.