4 ms·
Data-fueled neurotargeting could kill democracy
- jc6 2y agoDemocracy is already dead. As in who spends more or buys more Ads wins elections. For decades now. Trump and the Brexit vote broke the traditional media-advertising complex but that got fixed fast.
- OmarShehata 2y ago> they understand, from centuries of experience, that provoking strong emotional responses is one of the most reliable ways to get people to change their behavior this is easily defeated by teaching everyone a sprinkle of meditation (it has been quite shocking to me the extent to which I'd have an emotional reaction -> rationalized argument -> action, even over things like, slack messages from coworkers/my manager. I used to think it was always rational thought -> action. But noticing this makes it very easy to alter the pattern) now I want to see a response article: "Meditation will save democracy"
- d0gbread 2y agoFollowing "easily defeated" with "teaching everyone" gave me an audible chuckle.
- aspenmayer 2y ago> emotional reaction -> rationalized argument -> action This reminds me of a trap that I myself am mindful to avoid, and to be gracious of when done by others - motivated reasoning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motivated_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motivated_reasoning Ironically/paradoxically, a graceless or haughty (over)correction can undermine our own efforts to correct this in ourselves and especially in others, so I would agree that meditation and general mindfulness practice as well as empathy are helpful in understanding and empowering us to overcome these hurdles in interpersonal dynamics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hostile_media_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hostile_media_effect
- omgJustTest 2y agoJan 6 is unlikely to have been unrelated to “data-fueled neurotargeting” (title is over dramatic imo). First impression information really sticks in people’s minds (I heard x and then you tell me y in conflict with x, I will believe x more easily). And targeting is doing this daily. Republican voters talk more about the democrats than democrats do, democratic voters talk about republicans than democrats do. Obsession with the other is what happens in the current gridlock, and the most unproductive congress in history.
- api 2y agoJan 6th was done via what as near as I can tell are cult indoctrination and mass scale rabble rousing techniques as old as civilization. If newer tech like this was used it was to boost the effect. I think it’s possible that the I AM cult was the template for some of it like Qanon. Look into the tail end of that cults saga when they tried to set up a march on DC to set up their cult leader as king. Flynn and a few others have made direct references to it such as Flynn’s weird I AM inspired prayers at Q events. As Hubbard said… want to get rich and powerful, start a religion.
- omgJustTest 2y agous vs them has an ad cross section too! … read the article? Think about the last time you used someone else’s device in your family, or watch them use it… listen to the “news” they get and ask if they get different news than you. Ask why they believe what they believe, unjudgementally and with curiosity. This fact finding mission will surprise you. It might be true certain people are less discerning than you, but I can guarantee that the small difference in discerning is not a linear effect in the distortion they see the world with.
- api 2y agoI see bullshit across the political spectrum, but the Q cult was kind of unique. I don’t see an obvious left wing analog at least today in the US. If you consider totalitarian communism left wing then you can see analogs in Maoism and Leninism. That was a long time ago in other countries though. The US seems to have a more vibrant totalitarian cult scene on the far right today than on the left.
- api 2y agoThe free will debate usually falls into two camps. One holds that we have free will, period. The other holds that it’s some kind of illusion, period. I believe that we have it but it is not some kind of context free limitless divine power. It’s constrained like all other real things. Our free will is more like the ailerons on a plane. It can steer the plane. It cannot make the plane stop instantly or make 90 degree hard turns. It cannot stop another plane from running into you, or stop a bird strike, or rescue the plane if the wing falls off. I think what I’m getting at is that as our technology for influencing each other advances we can never be sure exactly where we are in comparison to the strength of our own free will. At what point might we invent ways to influence each other that renders us mindless biological robots?
- gfody 2y agothis is pretty much what Conway says about it too. we have about as much free will as fundamental particles.
- api 2y agoThat’s an interesting way to put a floor on it but I think he’s neglecting emergence and nonlinear dynamics. Deterministic objects in a system can become computationally irreducible and manifest higher order behaviors that are not reducible or predictable. Of course then you get into the challenge of defining free will. Is it enough to be impossible to predict or is actual acausality required? If the latter you are into quantum mechanics or bust.
- ProjectArcturis 2y agoAs a neuroscientist, I can say that calling it "neurotargeting" vastly, vastly overstates the contribution of "neuro" to these ads. Advertising has had more than a century of practical experience in manipulating the human mind. fMRI studies have added approximately zero to this understanding. Really, fMRI studies are their own form of neurotargeting, though aimed at ad buyers rather than ad consumers. Pretty colorful pictures of the brain convey the idea "Gosh, we're so smart and advanced and differentiated from those other ad agencies", even if those pretty pictures provided basically no new insights into how to sell anything.
- parpfish 2y agoAgreed. They may as well start calling the persuasive five paragraph essays we learned in school “brainwashing”. I think people just get freaked out when they remember that the psychological processes that make up their inner life have biophysical correlates
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 2y agoThis whole article is an example of emotionally manipulative media, starting with the headline.
- nostrademons 2y agoThe types of "neurotargeting" describes in the article - using data from emojis, personality tests, OCEAN models, fMRI studies - are all very noisy compared to what actually does work in advertising. You perturb the ad shown, measure conversions, and then just directly optimize for conversions. It's a variant of A/B testing described in the article, but you aren't comparing just two variants and having a human decide based on metrics, you're comparing thousands of variants and then training a machine learning model to predict conversion events. All of the major online ad networks - Google, Facebook, etc - actually function like this, and have for the past 15 years. And it is effective to the tune of about $300B/year, looking at Google's ad revenue.
- ethbr1 2y ago> And it is effective to the tune of about $300B/year, looking at Google's ad revenue. That's conflating total market with specific benefit though. If Google ran the dumbest, most basic ad-targeting, their ad revenue would still be >0.
- readyman 2y ago>Enfranchisement for women and racial minorities in the United States took centuries to codify, and these citizens are still disproportionately excluded from participating in elections No acknowledgement whatsoever of poor people. Clearly this is a trash article.
- selimthegrim 2y agoHave you been charged a poll tax lately?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 2y agoA critical property of active neurodefense is denial of emotion sensing to the adversary. This means no iris sub-second response data, facial expressions, or heart rate via cameras and wifi radar sensing via local AI/ML inference. Use an OS which keeps sensor data on-device, via some kind of security enclave.
- ethbr1 2y agoYou’re in a desert walking along in the sand when all of the sudden you look down, and you see a tortoise. It’s crawling toward you. You reach down, you flip the tortoise over on its back. The tortoise lays on its back, its belly baking in the hot sun, beating its legs trying to turn itself over, but it can’t, not without your help. But you’re not helping. Why is that?
- relaxing 2y agoI’ll tell you about my mother-
- walterbell 2y ago“Someone had told them that they must punctuate, but nobody would ever be able to tell them how.”
- relaxing 2y agoI’ll admit I don’t understand this reference.
- sneak 2y agoAs captured in the classic Neal Stephenson and George Jewsbury novel (released under the pen name Stephen Bury) “Interface”. Democracy hasn’t functioned as it was “intended” for, well, ever. It was never alive to be killed, which makes this useless handwringing.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoThis is what Harari and others have been warning for a while. Once you build profiles for everyone, you can craft stimuli that controls their behavior and in that way rule them.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 2y ago> To better understand neurotargeting and its ongoing threats to democracy, we spoke with one of the foremost experts on the subject: Emma Briant, a journalism professor at Monash University and a leading scholar of propaganda studies. Actually, this sounds instead of the best way to understand the subject, the best way to get a very narrow and biased view and fear mongering view. Basically, this is someone whose whole career is dependent on convincing people that there is a problem whether or not there is.
- rootusrootus 2y agoWho would you propose as a better source of expertise?
- TheBlight 2y agoIt's been nearly 8 years now and the elite class still seems reluctant to come to grips with the fact that they lost an election to a boorish gameshow host not because of foreign adversaries or clever marketing but because many people not in their social circle decided they preferred him to another political dynasty that didn't appear to represent their interests -- and in fact made it a point to openly despise these voters publicly by calling them deplorable. It isn't rocket science.
- ethbr1 2y agoGranted, Trump made it easy to point the finger at him, but agreed that the lack of Democrat self reflection over how the uglier impacts of globalism on the middle class drove the 2016 election result was ridiculous. And similarly, how the taken-for-granted poor rural and evangelical vote upended the Republican party in the primaries. Political parties ignore blocks of constituents at their peril -- and that's always been the strength of democracy.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- krapp 2y ago>and in fact made it a point to openly despise these voters publicly by calling them deplorable. Nope. Hillary Clinton was specifically calling out the racists and bigots within the Trump camp, not all Trump supporters. Which is obvious to anyone who bothers to read the actual quote. It isn't complex or nuanced, or even that long. And I don't know why Trump supporters still insist on believing otherwise, since one would expect that they would want to distance themselves from the bad elements within their party. I can only assume they find solidarity with such elements to be more important than conceding that a Democrat might actually have a point. Ah well. You sleep with the pigs, you wake up smelling like shit.
- TheBlight 2y agoThat part of my comment was probably the least interesting but for the record, her exact words were that half of his supporters were deplorable.
- treprinum 2y agoCould or did it already and we are living the aftermath nowadays?
- HyulianGrader 2y ago[dead]
- seydor 2y ago"neurotargetting" is just advertising. I think the authors overlook a more serious turn of politics in the past 50 years: politicians have monotonically been hoarding powers in the name of safety , technocracy or simply "trust us bro". This leaves the voting population unaccountable for their own choices, since none of their bad choices was allowed to affect them negatively. This made people vote increasingly with Pathos, aware that there will be no real consequences, or they will become a burden for the next generation.
- aspenmayer 2y ago> people vote increasingly with Pathos, aware that there will be no real consequences Isn’t this the same as it ever was? In this view, voters deserve what they get, yet are unlikely to get what they deserve, but should we will it different? Ought not a tyranny of the majority set the stage a for tragedy of the commons? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_theory
- hprotagonist 2y agohttps://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/ scissor sentences, you say.
- Slava_Propanei 2y ago[dead]
- jandrewrogers 2y agoThe term "neurotargeting" is the kind of manipulative framing they notionally abhor, there is nothing "neuro" about it. This is just classic computational propaganda but I guess that term isn't edgy enough. They greatly underestimate the difficulty of the computational problems surrounding automated production of effective and highly granular propaganda at scale. Targeting is crude and coarse because that is a technical limit of off-the-shelf analytical processing platforms.
- mrangle 2y agoSets out to write an article on the dangers of Neurotargeting. Immediately employs Neurotargeting in the article.
- unglowin 2y agoAmerican democracy is already all but dead. The reason being that lies fuel the decision making process: from campaigning to lobbying. They claim it’s democracy when elected officials vote on bills that are largely against the interests and desires of even the people that elected those voting representatives. I think we can recover though. What we need to do is extend the powers of our justice by jury system. Bills in congress should be voted on by a panel of jurors conducted by a judge. The elected officials are there to litigate either for or against, but it is the jury’s ultimate decision. I rarely think I have anything to offer the word of civics as it seems to me to be motivated in ways antithetical to my own desires in governance, but I truly think this is an idea that will have a very positive effect on the current failures of the American system of democracy.
- ethbr1 2y agoMy personal twist, if I were building a system in a first-world country, would be to have a bicameral legislature. Upper house has 4 year terms with term limits (say, 20 years max) and has professional politicians. Lower house is elected for 4 year terms by lottery, a portion turning over every year, in the same way as jury duty. Then support them with a strong research civil service (e.g. the CBO).
- unglowin 2y agoI’m into term limit reform, though I think complexity for the sake of complexity just allows more dark corners for corruption to fester. But how do term limits solve the misinformation and cult of personality that is currently plaguing contemporary American democracy? The interesting part, for me, of the introduction of juries in bill voting is having to plead the case to the jury rather than their ephemeral status. This would immediately remove all of the “carve out diplomacy” that is currently used to get bills passed. Politicians lie by a matter of course, courts have consequences and checks and balances for lies; imperfect, but at least they are there.
- ethbr1 2y agoJuries are terrible at offering specialized knowledge, which is becoming increasingly critical in the world. That's why their primary use in the US (trials) offloads all the specialty requirements onto other parties (adversarial prosecution and defense teams, judges, court staff). Consequently, in using juries you gain some measure of protection from corruption and responsiveness. But you lose expert knowledge. How would that work in your system?
- daft_pink 2y agoI don’t understand why this partisan hit piece is allowed on hacker news.
- Kamq 2y agoI find myself noticing some confusion while reading this article (and several previous articles along the same line). This seems like "neurotargeting" could be a danger to a very specific conception of democracy, but not a danger to democracy in the way that people, in my experience, generally use the word. And certainly not a danger to democracy in the way that people such as Edward Bernays would have thought about it. For complete clarity, the way I've generally heard people use the word "democracy" is (roughly) regarding a system of governance where the will of the people is used to decide legitimacy, either by voting directly on laws or by voting on representatives to govern for them. It's not automatically clear that changing the will of the people is actually a danger to that system or makes it any less legitimate (assuming the will of the people itself is what you value). And it seems weird that this would be a danger. Is this just a different definition of democracy (possibly a regional variation?), or is it actually being used in a non-standard way here, because it seems like this would be a much bigger threat to liberalism than democracy (is democracy a short-hand for liberalism in some circles?).
- smitty1e 2y agoMaybe we just stop viewing the internet as the ultimate human end and return to the culture that existed for millennia before: local interactions; live performances; physical media; in-person elections on a single day with physical ballots. Ideas so kooky that they could succeed?