4 ms·
Article lists a bunch of interesting details, and even is very careful to make sure the term 'muppets' gets incorporated twice, but doesn't quite connect the do
by tedunangst 14y ago
Article lists a bunch of interesting details, and even is very careful to make sure the term 'muppets' gets incorporated twice, but doesn't quite connect the dots and explain just exactly how the naked shorting fucked the muppets. For example:
More damning is an email from a Goldman, Sachs hedge fund client,
who remarked that when wanting to “short an impossible name and
fully expecting not to receive it” he would then be “shocked to
learn that [Goldman’s representative] could get it for us.”
I mean, there are all sorts of reasons why naked shorting is bad, but the most damning thing we can say is "Goldman offered to make their customer happy"? That's what passes for screwing the 'muppets'?
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI'm lost on the mechanics here, but doesn't this mean that any profit on the part of a short-selling customer was actually coming out of the pockets of GS? I mean...where does the money to cover the customer's profit on a naked short come from?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- asmithmd1 14y agoCome on, you know it was not coming out of GS pockets. It was a heads I win tales you lose situation. Evidently there is some amount of time between when a stock transaction is booked and when it clears - like a purchase made with a check. They were essentially writing bad checks by selling stock they didn't own. If the price of the stock went down, they would actually go out and buy the stock at the new lower price. If the stock went up they would say, sorry that stock transaction "failed" - darnedest thing, just happens sometimes. "Instead, he preferred to just sell stock he didn’t actually possess. That is what is meant by, “We want to fail them.” Trafaglia was talking about creating “fails” or “failed trades,” which is what happens when you don’t actually locate and borrow the stock within the time the law allows for trades to be settled."
- joe_the_user 14y agoAnd moreover, creating an apparent supply of the stock which didn't exist before would exert downward pressure on the stock (by supply-and-demand), hurting the holders of the company's shares. So he made the profit scenario more likely for himself.
- quantgenius 14y agoWe want to fail them means we are going to issue a failure to deliver because it turns out that the stock we thought was available is not. If you fail on a trade, you don't cancel the trade, a trade is binding, it means you require the customer to buy the stock back to cover the short sale since the stock wasn't actually available. Since in this case the Goldman rep had told the client they could get the stock even though the client thought the stock was likely to be available, issuing a fail to deliver and requiring the client to buy the stock back would lead to egg on the face for whoever the client spoke to at Goldman. The other option for Goldman of course was to buy the stock to lend the customer and hedge out their risk maybe with a put option or to keep looking somewhere else for stock to borrow.
- paperwork 14y agoNo, the profit doesn't come from GS. Say you think XYZ, currently priced at $100 is going to go down in price. You tell your broker (GS in this case) to short 1 share in the market. GS sells XYZ (someone else buys it) and you get $100 in your account while the quantity of XYZ shows up as -1. Later, the price does drop to $90. You tell GS to buy 1 share, and you pay $90 for that share. You now have $10 in your account ($100-$90) and the quantity of XYZ in your account it zero (-1 +1). Someone else in the market lost this money, you gained it. GS was supposed to have borrowed this 1 share from someone, but they didn't. In other words, for a short time, this 1 share was created out of this air. If there was a system to make sure that every single transaction was backed by an actual share, then this would not have been possible. However, transactions are not actually reconciled on a real-time basis. Someone with more knowledge of the back office will have to explain how such naked shorts can exist in books for longer than 3 days (perhaps GS was rolling over these shorts?)
- waterlesscloud 14y agoBut if it's a naked short, the only transactions are between me and GS. I sell short at $100, GS gives me that $100. If there's no share behind that to sell, then they just gave me that $100 out of their own pocket, right? So then the stock drops to $90 and I cover my short by sending GS $90. There's still no real share to deal with. So GS gave me $100, had no source for that money other than their pockets, and I gave them back $90. They're down $10 of their own money. This can't be how it works or they wouldn't do it, and if they did, no one would be complaining. So how does it actually work?
- refurb 14y agoI think the difference is that no money changes hands. Normal shorting is when you "borrow" a share from someone else with the promise of giving it back at a given date. You sell it and pocket the current price, then try and buy back the share in the future at a lower price, pocketing the difference. In reality, money never changes hands during a short (other than the cost of setting up the short). The short is only due at the end of the borrowing period (or before if a margin call happens). So in the case of a naked short, it's more of a bet on GS part. They don't located a share to "lend" you, they just say "ok, pay us a few dollars and you have a short". If the stock goes down, GS gives you the difference, if it goes up, you pay up. It's basically a bet and GS is the counterparty.
- jblow 14y agoI think you didn't understand that paragraph. The implication is that Goldman couldn't get the stock, and in fact did not bother, and just lied and said they did.
- tedunangst 14y agoI get that. But there's no explanation as to why that's bad for the client, as is implied by the article.
- p0ckets 14y agoIt's not bad for the client. They wanted to short, and they did. Also, there are now non-existent shares being traded which artificially depresses the price, which is good if you shorted the stock.
- quantgenius 14y agoI think the paragraph means that the client THOUGHT Goldman couldn't get the stock and did not expect them to be able to get it but Goldman was able to get the stock.
- lmkg 14y agoI'm not 100% up to speed on this particular topic, but I think that the damage is diffuse, i.e. it distorts the market but doesn't affect any particular involved party. Therefore, it doesn't make a good story, and doesn't show up in the news. Basically, you're increasing the amount of good for sale, without the corresponding purchases that would normally balance that out. It's the converse situation of buying things even when you don't have the money (not even in the form of credit or loans), and distorts the market in corresponding ways. The market is robust to a certain amount of shenanigans like this, but when a player the size of GS is doing it willy-nilly, the distortions can become measurable. According to econ 101, naked-shorting is observationally equivalent to a sudden inflation of supply, which should drive the price down. Lowering the price benefits those in a short position, at the cost of people who are taking a long position, like value investors, or the companies themselves. If you have weight to naked-short enough volume that it actually effects the market, you would in theory be pushing the stock market down and pocketing the difference. Again, I'm not an expert and this is a pretty naive analysis. I am willing to be corrected. Eventually you have to cover your short, which in theory should un-do all the market effects you've done, but my gut says that in practice the sudden drop has lasting damage to intangibles like "investor confidence" and "market volatility."
- pppttt 14y agoIt's actually quite clear. Much like printing money takes value away from savers, naked short selling takes value from existing stock holders. The lawsuit between Overstock and the banks concerned a phenomenon called naked short-selling, a kind of high-finance counterfeiting that, especially prior to the introduction of new regulations in 2008, short-sellers could use to artificially depress the value of the stocks they’ve bet against.
- tedunangst 14y agoOverstock's shareholders were not Goldman's clients. I want to know how the 'muppets' were harmed, as the article claims. There is a story here, but this is not the author who's going to write it.
- quantgenius 14y agoNo, it just means the Goldman salesman was able to find someone who owned OSTK stock and was willing to lend it out at the rate the hedge fund client was willing to pay to borrow it. It's called good customer service.