8 ms·
Cheapest source of fossil fuel generation is double the cost of solar
- toenail 2y agoThat number seems to exclude storage.
- bee_rider 2y agoStorage requirements are workload dependent. If your load can be deferred, you don’t need batteries.
- brink 2y agoBut generally, you need batteries.
- more_corn 2y agoYou can generate daytime peak base load without batteries. Then you compare the cost of a gas peaker plant to the cost of a battery and make your decision off that.
- toenail 2y agoIs there any workload that can be deferred at will, without harming businesses or people?
- bastawhiz 2y agoIt depends on what you mean by "harming". But to answer your question, yeah, most of them. I've been preparing my home to switch to time of use energy pricing, where power is less expensive at night when there's lower demand. It's pretty painless to put things on timers or set schedules in configuration. The trivial cost of setting this up will pay for itself within about two months. Deferring workloads for when it's sunny is almost the exact opposite: using more power during the day rather than at night. That's probably better for most consumers, since people tend to use more power when they're awake by default.
- bee_rider 2y agoWe can definitely defer our air conditioners for times when it is sunny, haha.
- bastawhiz 2y agoThat's one thing that's maybe an inconvenience for me now! I'll have to run my heat pumps in the early morning to lower (or raise) the temperature of the house before the cost of power goes up. Though maybe also more efficient in the summer, since I suspect it's less energy intensive to cool the house when it's cooler outside.
- megaman821 2y agoBitcoin mining can, with little notice and any time of day. Solar is pretty predictable and there are a lot of workloads that can follow solar output. Vehicle charging, water heating, water chilling/freezing, and industrial heat batteries. Depending on the capital cost of the plant, desalination and hydrogen splitting make sense too.
- bee_rider 2y agoI don’t like Bitcoins, they seem like a ridiculous way of burning extra electricity. That said, because they can consume energy on tap, they do seem like a funny way of providing a return on extra renewable energy, promoting the over-building of renewables, which would mean that we have to turn on the wasteful peaking generators less often. Have to give them credit here.
- otherme123 2y agoFor example water heating can be done and stored for 12 hours. In some houses, this is the main energy consumption for a family. The night hours are tipically cheaper due to low demand, so water heaters are programmed to work at night. But if solar panels are the energy source, you can move the heating to the middle of the day. Same goes to electric cars, but in that case there are batteries storing, so I'm not sure it counts.
- bee_rider 2y agoWhat do you mean by harm? Appliances could be made smarter—think fridges, water heaters, pool pumps, air conditioners, dishwashers—the grid just needs to communicate price info, and the electricity needs to be priced in line with production capacity. It would be extremely easy but there’s no incentive to do it. I mean, flip it around. Those of us who can plan ahead are being harmed by the fact that we’re paying for a system that caters to those who can’t.
- pfdietz 2y agoHeating and/or cooling can be shifted by hours, depending on the thermal time constant of the building. The better the insulation, the longer it can be shifted. Texas had a problem because so many older buildings there are very poorly insulated. Thermal energy in general is very cheap to store. This is also true industrially, where thermal storage has long been used for regenerative recovery of waste heat, for example in various places in steelmaking. Thermal storage of heat derived from electrical power is now being proposed as a way to soak up zero or negative price electricity. There's a company based on work at MIT that's doing this, using moderately electrically conductive refractory ceramic bricks as combined storage and heating elements.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoThat might be true, but in places like North Texas where multiday blackouts are becoming common during the winter, it might make sense to invest in storage if you have the option. Not going to help much with heating, but at least your fridge / freezer can stay running.
- hcurtiss 2y agoIs that true? Places in America with multi-day blackouts common? That’s nuts!
- otherme123 2y agoFor what I read about Texas, the root if the problem is that they opted to disconnect from the interstate grid, IIRC to avoid Federal regulations. If anything goes bad, they can't lean on neighbor states to provide, so they blackout.
- delecti 2y agoAnd additionally, things are more likely to go bad, precisely because there are fewer regulations that would otherwise lead to stability.
- more_corn 2y agoI’m not sure if Texas qualifies, but yes. When it gets too hot or too cold the Texas grid tends to fall over. Mostly because Texas aggressively deregulated their power grid allowing producers to cheap out of weatherization. If you live in Texas rooftop solar and a battery are highly recommended.
- publicsavant 2y agoIt isn't. Ercot keeps records, or you can check the outages section of wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Interconnection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Interconnection .
- 2y ago
- asoneth 2y agoTrue, a few workloads can be time-shifted (like filtering your pool) but the majority of grid load is at least somewhat time-dependent. Some loads are slightly time-dependent because you can shift them with minor inconvenience such as pre-cooling your home or refrigerator (using it as a thermal battery) or scheduling when your car charges (using its battery as a battery). Others are entirely time-dependent. Waiting until it's sunny to process an online order, take MRI images, run an assembly line, or use your TV to watch a sporting game incurs substantial additional cost and/or inconvenience.
- bee_rider 2y agoI don’t think we really know what percentage of loads are time-dependent because we mostly don’t have demand response pricing in the US. A hospital probably needs a backup battery (or a guaranteed slice of the grid’s battery capacity). Everything which could be shifted with minor inconvenience—we don’t have any incentive to try and automate that inconvenience away, so who knows? Perhaps we could see a resurgence in more efficient designs, like chest freezers.
- asoneth 2y ago> we mostly don’t have demand response pricing in the US What makes you say that? Do you know of a region that does not have DR (demand response) options? Every US utility I am aware of has had DR programs for commercial and industrial customers for many years. Back when I worked in electricity markets a decade ago only a few had DR programs for residential customers but since then many have added residential DR or have started pilots as they upgrade their residential infrastructure. TVP (time-variable pricing) is also very common, though moreso with commercial/industrial customers. I'm honestly not sure how many residential customers have the option to pick a provider with TVP/TOU pricing. Some crazy ISOs (looking at you ERCOT) even allow residential customers to pay rates pegged to RTP (real-time pricing) which is gloriously insane and very Texas. > A hospital probably needs a backup battery (or a guaranteed slice of the grid’s battery capacity). Yes. Hospitals often have special utility contracts and get priority when there are brownouts or blackouts. (One benefit of living next to a hospital is that you'll get power back more quickly after a blackout!) But most hospitals still have backup generators, and special circuits so that they only need to power critical equipment. > we don’t have any incentive to try and automate that inconvenience away, so who knows? Perhaps we could see a resurgence in more efficient designs, like chest freezers. This is already very common with commercial/industrial customers, but hopefully you're right that as residential customers get more exposure to things like dynamic pricing and home solar generation that more of them will alter their behavior and appliances.
- declan_roberts 2y agoYou should tell that to California which has such an excess glut of solar during the sunniest part of the day that they're sometimes _paying_ to export their energy.
- Herz 2y agoWhile the idea of deferring load to eliminate the need for batteries might seem straightforward, it raises significant practical challenges. Forcing billions of people and businesses to change their consumption habits is not only unrealistic but also fraught with potential issues. Consider the global perspective. In developing countries, where resources and infrastructure are already limited, expecting such flexibility is impractical. These regions often lack the luxury of choice and are more vulnerable to disruptions. Moreover, the goal of decarbonization isn't just about ideological preferences for renewable energy. It requires a pragmatic approach that incorporates a mix of technologies: solar, wind, hydro, nuclear, batteries, and more. Each technology has its strengths and plays a crucial role in the overall strategy. Cherry-picking preferred technologies without considering the broader context can delay our progress by decades. To effectively combat climate change, we need to embrace a comprehensive and inclusive approach that leverages all available solutions.
- bee_rider 2y ago> While the idea of deferring load to eliminate the need for batteries might seem straightforward, it raises significant practical challenges. This is pretty vague. Practical challenges such as? > Forcing billions of people and businesses to change their consumption habits is not only unrealistic but also fraught with potential issues. Potential issues such as? > Consider the global perspective. In developing countries, where resources and infrastructure are already limited, expecting such flexibility is impractical. These regions often lack the luxury of choice and are more vulnerable to disruptions. I’m under the impression that brownouts or blackouts are a little more common in developing countries, so if we’re going to have to deal with intermittent supplies we probably should be asking them for advice. I think we’d have to look, probably case-by-case, at what the issues are in less electrified areas, to see how renewables and load shifting would affect things. If the grid is less robust and parts become disconnected from time to time, then renewables are great, because they tend to be more disperse. If there are times where there isn’t enough generation capacity (not enough power plants or fuel) then great, whatever communication scheme is used to communicate information about renewables can also be used for fossil fuel. > Moreover, the goal of decarbonization isn't just about ideological preferences for renewable energy. It requires a pragmatic approach that incorporates a mix of technologies: solar, wind, hydro, nuclear, batteries, and more. Each technology has its strengths and plays a crucial role in the overall strategy. This is true. But I don’t really see any ideology in the idea of load shifting though. It is actually a practical answer. Renewable generation capacity that isn’t backed by batteries is always cheaper than that which is, unless batteries somehow become free. So, the pragmatic answer is to combine the two. Batteries are a cost, strategies to avoid them should be taken. That doesn’t mean 0 energy storage, though. > Cherry-picking preferred technologies without considering the broader context can delay our progress by decades. To effectively combat climate change, we need to embrace a comprehensive and inclusive approach that leverages all available solutions. Accounting for the price of batteries is often brought up as an argument against renewables. We should implement dynamic pricing now. It could even provide a market incentive to build more batteries. There’s no cherry picking here. Load shifting goes in the basket of solutions.
- danaris 2y agoYes, but it's also right now. Solar costs are still decreasing. And fossil fuel costs still do not price in the catastrophic side effects of using them.
- itslennysfault 2y agoSeems like "peak oil" is happening, but not at all like we originally thought.
- datadrivenangel 2y ago"Peak Carbon" is a phrase that's been in use for quite a while now, because we're out of atmosphere to dump extra burnt fossil fuels into if we want to keep climate change relatively mitigated.
- ben_w 2y agoIt depends who the "we" is; many of the people who dismissed the fear of Peak Oil, did so on the grounds that low supply would drive the price up high enough to encourage the development of alternatives — phrases such as "the stone age didn't end because we ran out of stones" and similar. My main worry in 2010 was that it is very difficult to balance an exponential increase in demand for a thing that is a big employer (such as oil) with some convenient replacement that employs a similar number of people at a similar cost. The economics of the transition to PV and wind are much smoother than I expected, because I am not an economist and did not have a remotely realistic model for how any of this would work in practice. (Hopefully my similar concern about the upcoming economic transition due to AI automation is misplaced for exactly the same reasons).
- maxerickson 2y agoIf AI is so effective that it annihilates jobs, productivity will go up and we will have abundance. How to deal with that is a political problem, not particularly an economic one.
- ben_w 2y agoAutomation has been annihilating jobs since before my grandmother was born, and many social upheavals resulting from them. Even narrow AI is more of the same — one that can drive, would rapidly put millions of drivers out of work, but not much else. That's a huge one-off transition to manage, but not inherently radical. General-purpose AI? Depends on the details. Let's say it's got the all the capabilities and limitations of an exactly average human, with a 24/7 equivalent power requirement of 17.2 kW — that will cost around $15.1k/year to run: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=17.2+kW+*+1+year+*+%240.1%2FkWh https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=17.2+kW+*+1+year+*+%240... I picked that power requirement to get an annual cost comparable to the USA federal minimum wage: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%247.25+per+hour+*+40+hours+%2F+week+*+52+weeks https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%247.25+per+hour+*+40+h... This means it's economically neutral to pick an average human or a machine for those roles and with that assumption about electricity cost… provided that humans are willing to accept minimum wages for that role. This lowers the wages for the average human to minimum wages. But! The USA's electricity supply is about 1.3 TW: https://www.publicpower.org/resource/americas-electricity-generating-capacity#:~:text=As%20of%20January%202024%2C%20America,than%20one%2Dthird%20of%20capacity https://www.publicpower.org/resource/americas-electricity-ge.... This is only 3.8 kW/capita: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=1.3TW%2Fusa+population+in+watts+per+capita https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=1.3TW%2Fusa+population+... This suggests that prices may rise rapidly, at least before the AI can be put to work guiding robots to install solar power systems (there's a startup on Y Combinator dedicated to exactly this). How much might prices rise? To whatever level where the AI can still be a neutral replacement for human labour. If the median capacity human earns $45k, then that assumption for power requirement would raise electricity prices to $0.30/kWh. If the AI is as energy efficient as a human brain, and uses 30 watts, then it doesn't have any impact on prices because the US doesn't run out of power in the first place; if the AI needs megawatts, then the effect is also reduced, because 1 MW * 1 y * $0.1/kWh = $876,000 and therefore it isn't economically sensible to displace even one worker. So what I'm worried about is the transition, the time between now and the steady-state long-term future where the robots can put in as much PV as they need. Do we have a risky period where robots could use all the available electrical power and might be able to out-bid the average human on both sides of the equation, the income side by being as cheap as it's legally possible for a human to be, and the expenses because now the human isn't earning any money and can't pay for electricity? Or does this dynamically fix itself because I'm doing an over-simplified toy model in my head and I've missed a critical part? (Probably).
- datadrivenangel 2y agoIt is important to note that utility scale Solar+Storage is still more expensive than combined cycle gas, at $60/MWh versus $45/MWh. This is close enough on a purely economic aspect that a carbon tax to allocate costs for the externalities of carbon or more stringent emissions requirements may make it cheaper overall for Solar + Storage!
- zdragnar 2y agoI'm curious how those numbers are calculated. My brother works for a company that installs and supports operations for microgrids and renewable power generation. At the moment, solar is slowing down, because private equity is turning to cobbling together quotes from residential installers as a bargaining tactic to get lower quotes from my brothers company. It's a profoundly bad idea, but if they can get something together and flip it to naive buyers in a few years, they can get away with it. All of that is to say, there's lots of bad cost estimation out there for commercial solar, and I know it'll happen sooner or later, but I'm still skeptical that solar+storage is going to beat carbon in the "sooner" range.
- jkic47 2y agoI am not familiar enough with the topic to comment on the numbers, but do the costs you quoted for renewables factor in externalities associated with reaponsibly recycling dead solar panels?
- mattmaroon 2y agoThat’s an unnecessary task because the externality is near 0. Modern landfills are cheap, plentiful, and relatively benign to the environment. CO2 emissions are a real problem, landfills are largely an imaginary one. If solar panels are dumpstered at the end of their life cycle but save CO2 emissions, it’s a non-factor. And in any case, they’re made largely of aluminum which is profitable to recycle (which means it will actually happen if its own accord) and a solved problem. Any real negative externalities come in manufacture or installation.
- dalyons 2y agothis is such a strange talking point. Do we factor in recycling all the materials a gas plant is made out of? Who cares about panel recycling? bury them if we have to, they're non toxic, and would be an infinitesimally small % of total annual landfill. Such an irrelevant "gotcha" i wonder why people keep repeating it?
- slackerIII 2y agoWe are headed towards a world where my robotic coding assistants are smarter when it is sunny.
- daemonologist 2y agoMade me think of Factorio (game in which you bootstrap automated factories on an alien planet) where all the robot arms run at reduced speed when power demand exceeds supply.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AndrewOMartin 2y agoThis game also comes with a decent lesson about the importance of energy storage when it comes to solar power generation.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoKlara and the Sun
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Herz 2y agoThe article presents a misleading analysis of renewable energy costs, which needs correction for a rational discussion on energy and decarbonization. The LCOE measures overall production costs but overlooks availability and reliability. This is problematic for intermittent sources like solar and wind, which can't ensure continuous production. For instance, solar energy isn't feasible at night, necessitating backup sources like gas, coal, or nuclear. It's worth considering the immense lithium required for a 100% solar-powered country. If renewables were the most cost-effective, private investors would already favor them. Yet, investments continue in gas and coal due to their reliability and continuous output, essential for economic stability. Countries like Germany have replaced nuclear reactors with coal plants, despite their decarbonization goals, and India relies on fossil fuels for economic growth. Misleading articles hinder decarbonization efforts. It's crucial that energy discussions are grounded in concrete data and rational analysis to advance towards a sustainable future.
- barfbagginus 2y agoThe capital heavy industries are still set to destroy the planet, because we have not forcibly destroyed their capital investments. The capital light industries won't help us if the mega capital still exists and needs to be leveraged. Lucky, things are stark enough to catalyze action. Namely, if we remain too wimpy to implement revolutionary climate justice and destroy the mega capital, then we are all going to die.