8 ms·
Google shuts down GPay app and P2P payments in the US
- xnx 2y ago6 hours ago. 55 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40644585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40644585
- more_corn 2y agoBetter get your money out. They locked mine up and refuse to settle up.
- herpderperator 2y ago> You can still tap to pay using the Google Wallet app.
- tgtweak 2y agoThat is not even a google service really, it's just a DPAN provided by the card payment networks and your bank that gets loaded into the phone's nfc... it's just a shadow copy of your credit card and the only thing google needs to "maintain" for it is the notification when a transaction is posted so they can include it in a transaction list.
- ado__dev 2y agoAre we back to Android Pay now? or is it Google Pay? Or are they stopping p2p altogether?
- mycodendral 2y agoGoogle Wallet
- mminer237 2y agoI believe this is the end of Google's P2P in the US until they rebrand everything as Google Pay again in another 3 years.
- kyrra 2y ago(googler, opinions are my own. I work in this space). There are 2 apps here, and their functionality varies by country. Google Wallet is more closely tied into the OS to handle tap-and-pay functionality. In the US (and most of the world), management of your cards happens within the Wallet app (this includes Mobile Drivers License, which works at TSA in airports). Google Pay has been through a rollcoaster in the US. We had 2 versions sort of going at once for a while. The "newer" version included management of cards for tap&pay for a while, but that all got pulled into Wallet stand along. For P2P style functionality, Google Pay in India and Singapore are much more functional/popular. But I think those are the only countries where Google Pay P2P is active. The GPay name is also used for paying online. (using your card-on-file with Google to pay that integrates with a merchants payment processor).
- skygazer 2y agoI think your employer has ADHD. Edit: perhaps, that sounded flippant to those consuming my karma, but that walk through of all the disjointed, scattered and abortive efforts really resonated with me as someone diagnosed with ADHD. It's how I would probably run a company if lacking pressure to channel my distractions into coherent plans.
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> (googler, opinions are my own. I work in this space) Not meaning to attack you personally as I'm sure you're quite good at your job to be at Google, but care to weigh in on why Google's ecosystem as a whole is such a... well, such a mess? As an Apple user I cannot fathom working with Google's offerings, they seem in an endless flux of revamps, rebrands, closings and openings.
- 2y ago
- taeric 2y agoI know the common joke is that Google made a mess of their messaging apps. I 100% am not clear what the correct app is to be able to do tap to pay from my phone. Kind of comical how hard that is to figure out.
- jeffbee 2y agoThis is not about tap to pay at terminals. This is about the ability to send money to random individuals, the Venmo use case.
- mycodendral 2y agoGoogle Wallet app
- fieryscribe 2y agoFor now anyway
- houseofzeus 2y agoSurprised they aren't moving it to Youtube too.
- ajross 2y agoNot understanding. What part is hard to figure out? The UI is literally that you tap your phone! There is no "app". You only run the "Wallet" app UI if you want to mess with payment details, and even then it's integrated with all the other account payment stuff. So if you tried to sign up for more Drive space or ad-free youtube or whatever you've already done it. And in the worst case if you tap and you don't have it set up, it pops up automatically and prompts you. Your complaint seems to be limited to the fact that they used an app name ("GPay") for something other than NFC payments. But... so what?
- datavirtue 2y agoWhat are they trying to to do? They aren't going to dominate payments in the US, no one can tame that cluster fuck. Payments have good solid revenue but no where in the range Google/Alphabet is used to. Especially when you consider the high-touch support required in payments. This product space is so confusing in the US. P2P,does that include "business?" When a person is trying to conduct even the smallest amount of commerce as a street vendor or with another person they are faced with a shrinking lack of choices that all operate in a different way. Venmo, Stripe, Square, Clover?, Zelle. And you have to have them all because one or more of them will drop you after someone rolls out a new poorly tested fraud/abuse/whatever algorithm. The regulatory landscape is a patchwork where further regulation attempting to clean up the mess generally makes it worse.
- Bluestein 2y ago> This product space is so confusing in the US This. The proliferation is insane. Makes you yearn for the good 'ol (bad) days when Paypal was king. At least you knew what service to complain about back then. Particularly if you were a vendor, Paypal abuse was rampant.-
- shadowgovt 2y agoI suspect (without hard evidence) the sticking point is regulatory. Being in the business of allowing private individuals to move money around opens a company to massive scrutiny. Scrutiny Google probably doesn't want, especially if it gives the government an excuse to snoop around in Google's related enterprises. At the revenue point of the service, let somebody else be Uncle Sam's punching bag.
- xyst 2y ago[flagged]
- shadowgovt 2y agoIn the US. Apparently it's doing great in India?
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoThat's confusing. If it's doing really well in at least one large country, surely the effort of keeping the lights on in other countries is reduced?
- shadowgovt 2y agoMy best guess is that it's a lot more costly than "keeping the lights on," probably in liability exposure. You can eff around a lot in the tech space (in the US) on AI, privacy, data protection and preservation, reliability, etc., but when you get into the financial sector the rules change. The US's monetary system only works because it's audited out to hell and back to avoid people cheating. And the government is quite empowered to enforce scrutiny on that auditing. Even having a toe in the water in the US market probably opens up Google to massive investigative potential they'd prefer to just avoid. "A strange game. The only winning move is not to play."
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40644585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40644585
- kmeisthax 2y agoIronically, Apple just announced P2P payments. Which means this is almost certainly a temporary closure. Google will almost certainly relaunch with a new name, branding, and UX that rides on the coattails of Apple's marketing efforts, but P2P will be coming back. If you're competing with Apple, you can't just not do a thing Apple is doing.
- square_usual 2y agoApple has had P2P payments for a while. Yesterday's announcement was that now you can tap to pay for those. Before, you'd have to send money via iMessage.
- lxgr 2y agoI think it's most likely still going to be sending money "via iMessage" (or more precisely: via a book transfer between two Green Dot Visa prepaid card accounts, addressed by an iCloud address and initiated over iMessage in UX terms).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jp57 2y agoWhat is new here exactly? This is AppleCash, which has been around for years.
- giancarlostoro 2y agoIf I'm understanding correctly, the difference is that it's going through VISA directly. Kind of like how you can send someone a Starbucks gift card through iMessage / Messages app, without it ever going through Apple Cash technically.
- lxgr 2y agoHow so? It only works between two Apple Cash accounts, so it can just be a book transfer within the bank maintaining these (Green Dot), no Visa required. Or do they now allow it between two non-Apple-Cash debit cards? That would indeed require some network to work across banks.
- tacocataco 2y agoI am exhausted switching services. please can we pick one and be done with it? How about adversarial integration? Why can't I send money from cashapp to venmo? Is the technology not there yet? I wish the post office was a bank and they hosted their own pay apps.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoBecause every app needs to be the dominant one or it can't possibly make enough money to make a VC happy, which is the answer to all three of your questions. You want infrastructure, not private networks, and there is no infrastructure, just private networks trying to be infrastructure for rent-seeking purposes.
- sa-code 2y agoIn Europe people can send money from any bank to any bank through IBAN numbers (your bank account number) Not sure what's taking so long in the states
- smartician 2y agoIIUC the EU basically had to force banks to implement this via a mandate. I don't see "business friendly" US lawmakers doing the same anytime soon. The joys of the Free market™!
- Cu3PO42 2y agoI mean, yes, it was mandated, but I am decently confident a usable system would have emerged one way or the other. In Germany we had a standardized API for online banking (HBCI) just because banks agreed it would be reasonable to do that.
- ozim 2y agoBut no one wants that, bank numbers are too much hassle and typing out 34 digits is error prone. Everyone in Europe also uses Tikkie, Blik whatever else service in other countries.
- ck2 2y ago[flagged]
- Beijinger 2y agoUngoogle yourself. I once, under unfortunate circumstances, lost access to a very valuable phone number (Google project fi). Lost the number, consequently lost acccess to my Gmail account, lost software licenses, Android apps, my emails etc. I have a random gmail account for Android. Don't even know it out of my head. Some Android apps have register codes (pleco). insync was so kind to grant me a new free license for their software. I still have (new) google project fi phone since I travel a lot. But google sucks. No accountability, you are the product and expect everything to be gone tomorrow.
- mariasykk 2y agoSomeone mentioned that in Europe you can send via IBAN to anyone. Well in Ukraine you can just use card number and send money to any bank. There is virtually no bank in Ukraine that doesn’t support this. Obviously IBAN also works for that, but nobody uses it for P2P, only to pay companies for provided services. It’s a big surprise for me that people actually need third party apps for P2P money transfers.
- _zoltan_ 2y agoIn Hungary you can use email or phone number as well for instant transfer via standard banks (provided you add your email and phone number as a secondary ID besides your IBAN) I'm always amazed to see how much some other banking systems are waaaay behind.
- averageRoyalty 2y agoIn Australia we've been able to do BSB (simpler domestic version of IBAN) for decades, and we introduced NPP 6 years ago. All banks now have instant transfer between each other via the BSB method or via your own unique identifier you can pick and give out (your phone number, email, etc). The focus on P2P pay makes me think that despite how profitable Google and Apple are, their mindset is still US centric which is surely not the country the majority of their profit comes from, given their global reach. Surely they leave money on the table constantly with this focus?
- thisisauserid 2y agoDue to a series of silly events, my balance is negative $900 for the last six years. I assume they'll just eat it. Thanks, Google!
- upmind 2y agoLmk what happens to this, that's hilarious!
- wbkang 2y agoI feel like the typical Google answer to this would just be to shut down your account D: fingers-crossed that it doesn't happen
- balozi 2y agoWell...they will just sell your $900 debt to a brass-knuckled debt collector for $19. That's what I would do.
- Jimmc414 2y ago[flagged]
- wg0 2y agoI am pretty sure that Firebase would be sunset by 2026 at max. Google Cloud, not so sure.
- mountainofdeath 2y agoTo add even more noise, there is a similar service from Samsung called Samsung Cash which lets you transfer cash between other Samsung Cash users using a prepaid Visa debit card on the backend. It
- sealthedeal 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tgtweak 2y agoGoogle really needs to start publishing LTS commitments on their new services - or put "beta" tags with disclosures on them - so at least you know how long they're guaranteeing support on a service you are getting committed to. The reputation they're accruing by killing all of these services is really affecting the consideration for new services. That is a very hard to measure and consider data point, but I can say first hand for my own services and those of companies I advise - this point comes up every time someone mentions electing for a google service. Imagine considering building gemeni into your product knowing full well they will likely sunset it in a year or two or force you into the newest version (or replacement service entirely) vs OpenAI who are supporting and reducing cost on legacy models and service as they release new ones. The other ugly side of this is the sunsetting of free tiers and plans on many products they do choose to keep. Gsuite free edition is a very good example - early adopters of gsuite for businesses were promised it would remain free, only to find that last year google walked back on that and sunset nearly all the free gsuite accounts, forcing early adopters (and supporters) to pay or get off. Google One is another example - they removed the ability for gsuite accounts to subscribe to Google One individually, and the aftermath of that was "take your data out or upgrade your entire organization to a premium storage tier per user". Zero intention to accommodate or support those users that had been happily paying for that service for years. Icing on the cake: they kept billing for it even after removing access to the service.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoYes. I'm actually worried about Golang too. Moved to it from Common Lisp but I am worried about the long term liability of it. They also started doing telemetry and other things in the language because it is being treated as a product and then what happens if Google loses interest in it? Would have gone all in on Rust if it just was aesthetically pleasing.
- mrastro 2y agoGolang is 14 years old, used by Google in production projects, and still in active development so it has a good track record. It's also open-source so worst case scenario it would get forked and community-maintained without Google backing. I wouldn't be concerned about Golang being deprecated.