13 ms·
Microsoft Bans Linux/Android Dual-Booting on Windows 8 ARM Devices
- danmaz74 14y agoThe article is much more complex than what it would look like from the title, but it is a good idea to keep the pressure on on Microsoft so that they might "soften their position", as is stated in the article.
- keeperofdakeys 14y agoOriginally Windows 8 x86 certification didn't mandate that a disable option must exist. They changed this because of pressure. They won't soften their position just like that, they have a policy and agenda and they will follow it. Just the fact that they will have a SecureBoot stronghold means they can easily tighten their position. The pain doesn't come from the fences being built, it's from taking them away. Also, all of this pretty much stops new linux penetration, which is a horrible thing.
- tjoff 14y agoThe windows 8 x86 certification shouldn't need to mandate that a disable option must exist. It was added because people wouldn't trust manufacturers to support anything but Windows.
- polshaw 14y agoAlong with their apparent restriction of the 'desktop' on arm, this is the reason I lost interest in windows8 on arm. So far a linux + android solution (like ubuntu have demonstrated) seems more powerful and very will also have more apps to start (way to go throw away windows' advantage #1). It seems quite short-sighted, too, as I see ARM as being a viable laptop platform in the life of windows 8, but MS are restricting it to 'device' status. Also, we've known this for a long time now.
- rbanffy 14y agoWindows already had no advantage - all programs would need to be rebuilt for the new platform. That's what killed Windows NT on everything non-x86. The only apps that will be cross-platform will be WinRT/Metro based ones.
- brudgers 14y agoMetro is a set of UI guidelines, not a set of programming tools. Applications built using the Silverlight Framework (not to be confused with the browser plugin) should be suitable for cross platform development because CLR runs on both platforms. CLR remains Microsoft's way of integrating the "write once, run anywhere" philosophy within the Windows ecosystem in order to deal with legacy issues.
- rbanffy 14y agoThanks. This whole stack is very confusing to me these days (I once was a Windows developer, one of the first MCPs in Brazil, but that was another life, a very long time ago). And Android, iOS and OSX are all waiting in line for my attention before I consider learning modern Windows development again. I sincerely hope that, if I wait long enough, I won't need to ;-)
- jack12 14y agoAre you sure you're not describing cross-platform with Windows Phone instead of Windows 8? I thought for Windows 8, Microsoft is pushing WinRT as the cross-platform solution, and that "binaries" crossing from x86/x64 to arm will work as-is for javascript, as-is (if pure) for CLR, and with no modifications but requiring recompilation for native (C/C++) WinRT apps.
- brudgers 14y agoIf you're writing in C/C++ rather than C#, then you're off the CLR ranch, so to speak. It's like saying Java isn't portable because a program links to custom libraries written in C. That said, rumor has it that the next version of Windows Phone will not be Silverlight (though XAML and Silverlight are fairly similar), but based on WinRT. That's a good thing because it will allow Windows Phone Apps to better integrate Javascript.
- givan 14y agoUnlike on x86 where windows dominates on ARM there is a different story and linux dominates on ARM, they can lose some market share because of this policy but it seems that microsoft only cares to keep their old strategies no matter what times they live in.
- wavephorm 14y agoIt only increases the subsection of hardware I won't buy. Thanks for making my choice easy.
- tjoff 14y agoWhat subsection of hardware do you buy?
- exDM69 14y agoI assume Microsoft will want to have secure booting devices that ship with Windows, because Hollywood and other content producers require a secure OS so their DRM is safer. If they would allow non-secure boot, it might be difficult or impossible to get video and music content licensed from the major producers on the platform.
- fpgeek 14y agoBecause insecure-booting OSes like Windows 7 (and earlier) and Mac OS X have so much trouble getting licensed video and music content...
- exDM69 14y agoThe situation is a bit different on mobile platforms. Mostly because the field is new and changing, so content producers see an opportunity to require secure boot. DRM/content licensing was cited by Asus as a reason to ship their Android products with locked bootloaders. I assume the same applies to Microsoft.
- keeperofdakeys 14y agoIt should be noted Secure Boot is not a DRM device in itself, it merely allows you to enforce a chain of trust for an OS to boot. The OS still needs to provide DRM functions itself.
- slowpoke 14y agoSecure Boot (on ARM) restricts my ability to run whatever the fuck I want on my device. I do not see how this is not Digital Restrictions Mismanagement.
- keeperofdakeys 14y agoDRM usually refers to mechanisms to digitaly manage rights of content, SecureBoot merely checks that a bootloader is signed by specific keys. Just ensuring people know what's what.
- gouranga 14y agoLike iOS. Why the shock headline?
- wkz 14y agoI would love to see an open bootloader for iDevices. However, I do think that there is a difference between Apple, a company who makes their own hardware and have chosen this strategy, and Microsoft, a company who tries to impose their strategy on others (device makers).
- keeperofdakeys 14y agoIn theory, the PC makers are the ones who can choose whether to apply Windows Certification to their devices. Of course, they are in a position where they have no real choice not to, and then we are getting into antitrust territory.
- ars 14y agoBecause the iOS policy is unethical (the machine belongs to the user, not apple), and now Microsoft is (attempting) to do it too. The only way to stop unethical behavior is to punish them. The Library of Congress already ruled that this behavior is unethical, now manufacturers need to be pressured.
- gouranga 14y agoFor reference as the parent of your comment, I agree 100% I do however see disparity with general opinion and what is right, which is slightly worrying, hence the original point.
- nathan_long 14y agoBecause it's unpleasant to see an unfortunate anomaly becoming a trend.
- ivanbernat 14y agoI've said this before and I'll say it again: Microsoft isn't doing this to ban Ubuntu / Linux in general, but to prevent Android from spreading. With ICS being a great OS, many (tech) folks would simply dual-boot ICS on their WinRT devices.
- beedogs 14y agoBut those people will just figure out a way to do that anyway. I don't see the point in these decisions to expend likely a lot of time, effort, and money eliminating edge cases.
- chucknelson 14y agoYou never know, if Microsoft allowed it that could open the door to marketing and such that could lead to Win8+Android tablets being mainstream or something. Not that it would be likely, but I'm sure Microsoft would want to stave off any chance of that happening in the early days of the platform.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- silon3 14y agoVirtualization is better than dual boot anyway. MS better make it run well virtualized.
- gouranga 14y agoFor reference, it absolutely fucking sucks under virtualization.
- commandar 14y agoOn hardware that's powerful enough to handle virtualization well, sure. It looks like ARM has gotten some virtualization extensions recently, but I still have my doubts as to how pleasant the experience would be on sub 1.5GHz processors.
- tjoff 14y agoWe've yet to see any mobile device where running another OS than the bundled one have been anything but a nightmare. This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple. These devices are not multipurpose devices, they are built for a specific purpose and tailormade for that and nothing else. It is not in any sense equivalent to desktop/laptop-computers. Which is kind of apparent considering the limitations that Windows Phone, Android and iOS amount to. Since Microsoft have expressed that secure boot must be optional on x86 it is quite easy to justify this rationally without resorting to the popular "typical evil Microsoft tactics" argument.
- liquidsnake 14y agoException: HP Touchpad. ICS runs great on it.
- fpgeek 14y agoI've read that the Nokia N9 also does a good job of running ICS. Other counter examples: Boot2Gecko (runs well & generally demoed on a Samsung Galaxy S2), Ubuntu for Android, ASUS Transformers running various Linux distributions, ...
- recoiledsnake 14y agoThat is because WebOS was running a Linux kernel and the hardware was similar to a HTC phone(Sensation?).
- tmzt 14y agoBecause the touchpad had a fairly open bootloader and we built a more versatile one for it based on the same code base (moboot). The bootloader in the OMAP chip also allows booting from usb and does not require the second stage be signed.
- PerryCox 14y ago>This is done everywhere, android manufacturers constantly try to lock users in their own android shell, not to mention apple. And people still jailbreak/root their devices for numerous reasons. If you buy something, you should be able to do what you want with it. Just because it's designed for one thing doesn't mean it can't do others.
- bni 14y agoFrom the article: "Apple has long prevented dual booting to Linux" This is not true, I have Ubuntu on my MacBook Pro.
- pimeys 14y agoMe too. You just need the refit to enable multiboot, that's it. I wonder how's it going to be in the future.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- brudgers 14y agoThe article is about ARM devices, not x86.
- rbanffy 14y agoApple makes their own devices. Microsoft is forcing OEMs who would allow dual booting to restrict user choice because they'd rather not compete.
- brudgers 14y agoApple's devices are ARM (that's how ARM works, by licensing designs rather than fabricating chips like Intel).
- DrJokepu 14y agoImplementation detail. Apple sells iPhones, not ARM-based phones. They don't mention "ARM" anywhere in iPhone marketing materials.
- Allaun 14y agoThey don't have to. It is what it is. The Droid isn't stated as being a Arm Cortex A8 phone. But that's exactly what it is and it's related to what they are stating in the article.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tzs 14y agoMy speculation is that they are doing this so that they can offer subsidies on the hardware.
- fpgeek 14y agoIf that's the problem, why can't end users "buy off" the bootloader lock if they want to?
- brudgers 14y agoMy speculation is so that ARM devices which take advantage of the Microsoft stack are suitable for a wider range of enterprise customers. Think HIPAA rather than "hip."
- Nelson69 14y agoSeems possible that there could be 2 options, a Windows option and an unlocked option. You'd think the Windows option would be more expensive. How many vendors are really set up for that? Windows really took off because of this practice. Vendors would license it based upon total PCs sold, regardless of if they even had windows installed or the customers wanted it. It was so effective that the competition dried up and died in a remarkably short time. This was competition from IBM, you could lump some others in with it BeOS and maybe some early Linux but Big Blue had their ass handed to them which was remarkable. At the time there are a lot more (maybe, maybe not, it seemed like there were a lot more) tier 2 type vendors: name companies with support and such. I'd argue MS doesn't know how to build market share other than with subsidies or lock-ins and that's what this is. If devs don't pick up Win8 pretty quickly, that ARM tablet isn't going to look so great, why wouldn't you want to try Android with its piles of apps? Then it puts the vendors in a very interesting bind, you have to pick which platform to support, a market leader (Android) or a product from a market leader in a different market. I don't remember the results of the anti-trust but I could see how this is designed to do the same thing but is different enough. A handful of motherboards now come with 2 BIOS, I think I have an Asus mb with one that you can "tweak" and overclock and then like a failsafe backup. Something like that, maybe with a hardware jumper setting seems like the real solution for your vendors, but that adds some cost. Either that or Win8 just flops, industry wide, that seems like it might be the better solution. There will be win8 tablets at Walmart and Target and such though and million of less technical folks will buy them. I suspect dual boot is dead forever unless someone certifies some sort of kexec like application.
- zokier 14y agoDoes anyone have statistics about how many Android devices require signed systems?
- brudgers 14y ago[edit] The article is from January[/edit] Topic discussed previously on Hacker News: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3458679 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3458679 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3567448 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3567448 Upshot: If you don't care that your hardware is certified, you don't have to implement secure boot in the way Microsoft requires for certification. You will probably have a few technical challenges, however.
- air 14y ago"Upshot: If you don't care that your hardware is certified, you don't have to implement secure boot in the way Microsoft requires for certification." No, upshot is that for ARM you can't get Windows at all (certified or not) if you allow other operating systems to boot.
- brudgers 14y agoWindows certification is not necessarily the same as Windows licensing, and given the history, that is likely to remain the case. The article conflates the two: "a document that regulates licensing (certification) (pg. 116): " But Microsoft is clear: "The new Windows Hardware Certification Program (formerly known as the Windows Logo program) makes it easier to certify your hardware for Windows 8. Use the requirements to build and certify your Windows-compatible devices, systems, and filter drivers across all Windows platforms." http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/hh748200.aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/hh7...
- air 14y agoConsidering that WOA will not be sold separately and how MS touts tight integration with hardware, I'd be willing to make a bet that consumers won't be able to buy an ARM device with WOA that can boot to Linux (without exploits). http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/02/09/building-windows-for-the-arm-processor-architecture.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/02/09/building-windo... "Partners will provide WOA PCs as integrated, end-to-end products that include hardware, firmware, and Windows on ARM software. Windows on ARM software will not be sold or distributed independent of a new WOA PC, just as you would expect from a consumer electronics device that relies on unique and integrated pairings of hardware and software"
- mtgx 14y agoI think the real issue with this is that it stops manufacturers from bundling Windows RT with Android. Take Asus for example. They've just made their "big" announcement which everyone thought it would be a dual-booting Windows RT/Android machine, and it turns out it's just Windows with the Bluestacks program that can make it run Android apps inside Windows. I find that pretty silly, and I don't see a real reason why they didn't just make the machine dual-boot both Windows and Android. If users want Android apps inside Windows, they can download Bluestacks themselves. So the only explanation is that Microsoft is coercing manufacturers into not allowing Android or other OS's alongside Windows. If they are doing this now, and more Linux vendors start asking for Microsoft's "permission" to boot their OS on the Windows machines with UEFI, what's to stop Microsoft from denying a UEFI license to someone who's starting to become a "real" competitor to Windows (like Android is, in some cases)? What if Ubuntu gets to 10% market share in the next 5 years, and keeps growing? Will they keep giving Canonical the UEFI license? What's guaranteeing that they will, if they are already banning Android from the Windows RT machines?
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>I think the real issue with this is that it stops manufacturers from bundling Windows RT with Android. Take Asus for example. They've just made their "big" announcement which everyone thought it would be a dual-booting Windows RT/Android machine, and it turns out it's just Windows with the Bluestacks program that can make it run Android apps inside Windows. Everyone thought something that everyone else knew wouldn't happen from about 6 months? That article you submitted is from January. Also, do you have any references to everyone thinking Asus's big announcement will be an Windows RT/Android hybrid?
- yajoe 14y agoYou're absolutely right. This announcement is all about money more than OS religion. The expectation and Microsoft's fear was that manufacturers would take the marketing money (i.e. the Win8 subsidy) that Microsoft is paying out the wazoo and hedge OS bets by also including Android. Acer and Asus don't care what OS they run so long as it keeps them in the race against Apple. They're happy to let Microsoft pay them money to market their devices if it means they have to include "apps" (and in this case app := OS). Microsoft wasn't willing to subsidize devices that run Android because it views Android as a competitor rather than an enemy-of-my-enemy. Given Apple's clear cost advantage, it would have been interesting to see such a Android+Win8+subsidy bet play out. Microsoft might have been able to dislodge marketshare enough during the year that Microsoft comes out ahead next year with SP1. Alas, the business case will slightly less interesting.
- c0un7d0wn 14y agoJust when we hear chromeos and android about to become one
- novalis 14y agoThe really troubling part of this is UEFI being used as a strong arm scam that depends on MS good will... how did things get to this point. On another point, they can "ban" whatever they want. They also didn't support Windows Phone 7 or allow Android and Ubuntu on my old trusty HTC HD2 and look at it go. Plus, it is just like saying to a child that she cannot have the piece of cake in front of her, if it looks tasty it's going to be munched. Meaning, if the hardware will be good someone somewhere is going to shoe horn it independent of what MS wants.
- protomyth 14y agoI really don't care about the restrictions on tablets. I figure every OS will have a tablet or two available. What really bothers me is that ARM-based laptops come under this crud. I have really wanted a modern day replacement for the Psion. Something that gets great battery life and has a decent keyboard. I also want to run a BSD (probably Open), so that is really going to make it a pain.
- cryptoz 14y agoWhat's the difference between tablets and laptops? I don't see any differences when it comes to the ability to dual boot. The ASUS Transformer line has been around for a while now, showing that the line between tablet and laptop is blurring. Also, Canonical/Ubuntu seems to be gunning for tablet market share in the future. Do you think they'll have their own hardware? I don't see any reason to separate out tablets and laptops when talking about dual booting, OS concerns, etc. A tablet is just a laptop with a touch screen and optional rather than mandatory keyboard.
- protomyth 14y agoBecause I see tablets as a device that really needs software that's been design for it. It a package that I buy to have it work out of the box. Tablets aren't laptops without a keyboard, they are their own thing. Laptops have a long tradition of multiple OSes giving a pretty good experience and being open to multiple OSes.
- mhurron 14y ago> What's the difference between tablets and laptops? Usage patterns. A laptop is just a mobile general purpose computer, to restrict it by restricting say it's OS, you have removed the general purpose nature of the device and this is a loss of functionality. A tablet on the other hand is an appliance. It has more in common with your toaster, microwave, refrigerator or your DVD player. It is intended to basically do one thing and hopefully do it well. Just like no one really complains that you can't toast bread with a refrigerator, having a tablet sort of locked to one OS isn't exactly that strange of a proposal.
- tomrod 14y agoI'm not familiar with the specifics of ARM devices. Why couldn't one come later and install Linux+variant of Grub to detect the MBR after the Windows install?
- esolyt 14y agoSimply because UEFI will refuse to boot to anything other than Windows
- esolyt 14y agoGreat. If ARM starts dominating laptops as well, nobody will be able to boot Ubuntu or any other Linux distribution on them.
- mjg59 14y agoThe quotations say nothing of the sort. A vendor could provide a dual-boot device providing they have an Android bootloader signed with Microsoft's signing key, which is a service that Microsoft will be providing. A more open question is whether any of the existing Linux vendors will be doing this. Fedora is willing to use Microsoft's signing service for x86 because users will be able to disable the feature or enrol their own keys. We're not willing to do that for ARM because users won't have that freedom and so wouldn't be able to replace components like the kernel.
- brudgers 14y ago>"A more open question is whether any of the existing Linux vendors will be doing this." The Market Economics Fairy predicts that they will not given the limited number of people who are interested in dual booting a tablet and the diversity of device configurations likely to be manufactured.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoLimited number? Quite a few enthusiasts will buy x86 tablets JUST for this purpose. Sure, enthusiasts, but enthusiasts also drive Linux to some extent.
- brudgers 14y agoThe enthusiast market + the small business market for Linux is so small that no significant manufacturer builds Linux laptops for the consumer segment. The enthusiast Linux tablet market will probably be rather smaller.
- derrida 14y ago"...a service that Microsoft will be providing." It's now a 'service' to unlock the 'universal' in the 'universal Turing Machine' in my hand?!
- gringomorcego 14y ago
- ck2 14y agoApparently as consumers we don't own anything anymore, we are just renting it from our corporate overlords.
- pooriaazimi 14y agoYou don't have to buy these machines. If you choose to buy it, you've bought a Windows 8 machine and have paid for it. It's not like MS promised you a dual-bootable machine and sold you a single-bootable machine. You know what you're getting, and you can choose whether or not it fits your needs.
- Havoc 14y ago> you can choose Microsoft isn't known for playing nice & allowing competitors to compete fairly. So yes there will be choice, but relying on that as a justification is pretty risky imo. Esp considering MS's standard MO and history.
- pooriaazimi 14y agoI hate MS just as the next guy. But Open Thinking (tm) people should no seek freedom (as in speech) through restricting other's (namely, MS) freedom. They have the right to do what they feel like, and we have the choice whether or not to buy them. (I'm not being snarky)
- sounds 14y agoWell said. We also have the right to make waves and be loud about the abusive, monopolistic behavior of Microsoft and Apple. http://jailbreakingisnotacrime.org http://jailbreakingisnotacrime.org In this sense the political fight is for our freedom, not a restriction of their sales. If they do sell crippled devices, we'll just do everything we can to make that crippling public, including jailbreaking the devices to show that the emperor(s) have no clothes: DRM is a logical impossibility except through security by obscurity which is no security at all when the person trying to get in (jailbreak the device) has complete physical control over it. No one has a guaranteed right to profit (the economic kind of profits).
- Hoff 14y agoPlease take a moment to reflect on the current situation before launching the "corporate overlord" and related snark. Many existing customers effectively do not own what they already have; their systems have been infested with malware and crapplications. Locked-down bootstraps are the least-bad of a very bad lot of approaches available for dealing with the changes in the user base, and with the increasingly less-experienced and less-DIY users for modern systems. Security attacks are only getting more subtle, complex and sophisticated. The Microsoft Terminal Server-derived Microsoft code-signing digital certificates is a recent example of the complexity of the environment. How do you deal with these changes in attacks and with the changes in the user base otherwise, given the numbers of systems out there, and the changes in the knowledge and experience of the user base? Do any of us like these locked-down bootstraps? Emphatically, no. So figure out another way to ensure this security, get yourself patent or three (and yes, software patents are issued for far too many years) and get yourself rich by solving this problem.
- keeperofdakeys 14y agoI personally don't see many bootloader attacks these days. Consider that SecureBoot only protects from attacks like this, after bootstraping it is upto the OS to ensure security. So purely from this, I don't think the tradeoffs are worth it. Once you have infastructure like this, it isn't hard for it to be misused (even with good intentions).
- darkarmani 14y agoWhat proportion of attacks are stopped by securing the boot loader like 2%? Does anyone really think this will stop most malware?
- gioele 14y agoMaybe it is the right time to make all this rage converge into contributions to coreboot [1]. A free working alternative is the only practical way out of this future kind of subjection. Google has already contributed core for some current Ivy Bridge chipsets. It would be nice if coreboot received more testing and development from a broader audience. [1] http://coreboot.org http://coreboot.org
- McGlockenshire 14y agoCoreboot is a good thing, but it's going to be hard to succeed without hardware vendor support, and that will be hard to build unless people actually want the product. I work for a VAR. Our preferred vendor was one of the first to market with motherboards that expressly supported Coreboot. We're supporters of OSS, and so are our customers, so we figured that they'd be popular. We sold only a handful over about two years. Our competitors didn't seem to have much more success, as our vendor didn't continue the experiment into the following motherboard generations.
- dattaway 14y agoShopping for coreboot devices is frustrating. Google returns products containing pictures of legs.
- mjg59 14y agoThe problem is not the availability of a free alternative. Hardware vendors could already simply choose not to implement secure boot - the default policy is a single configurable switch during the build. The problem is that vendors believe they can make more money by selling hardware that meets Microsoft's requirements. Coreboot doesn't do anything to help there.
- gioele 14y ago> Hardware vendors could already simply choose not to implement secure boot You are right, but if we had an easily installable coreboot we could just ignore whatever comes with the computer and just flash coreboot over the existing firmware. This is basically what Linux people have been doing with Windows in the past twenty years: see that Windows is preinstalled, boot a CD, overwrite the partition table, install distro. But this was possible because in most cases the distro you chose was ready to be installed on a whatever computer you had; the same cannot be said of coreboot.
- showwayer 14y agoIt gives me great excuse not to use Microsoft Windows then!
- CUR10US 14y agoAnything that cannot boot from USB, SD card, or some externally connected media, should be approached with caution. If you can boot from external media, then generally you can dual boot. Someone may have to show you how to prepare media for booting, but it's quite easy once you have been shown. Today's PC's all seem to have good support for booting from external media. Are we going to see this removed in ARM devices? You do not have to shop for devices that have an "open" bootloader. You have to shop for devices that can boot from external media. (For today's PC's, that's quite easy.) If you have a device that can boot from external media, we can show how to do the rest.