3 ms·
It's all unraveling at OpenAI (again)
- textninja 2y agoMy tin foil hat is telling me that no publicity is bad publicity and LLMs are great at spinning dramatic yarns.
- haolez 2y agoAlso, most of the signers in that letter probably still have OpenAI equity. They are incentivized to pump it. I'm not saying that they are doing this in bad faith. I'm just saying that the incentive is perverse in this case.
- cjk2 2y agoI dunno. Quite frankly I’m bored of it and don’t care any more. I suspect it’s just attrition. I have better things to do than deal with some transient technology provider’s existence. Other than to bitch about this meta point of course :) Really the metric is: if they died tomorrow would my life be materially impacted. Apple yes, OpenAI nope!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- andsoitis 2y agohttps://archive.is/2024.06.04-234256/https://www.businessinsider.com/openai-mess-concerns-over-nda-safety-sam-altman-2024-6 https://archive.is/2024.06.04-234256/https://www.businessins...
- tptacek 2y agoHalf of this story seems to be about the ScarJo "Her" voice story, which was more or less debunked by the Washington Post --- OpenAI hired several voice actors, months before reaching out to ScarJo, and the voice suspected to be a clone or performance of ScarJo's own voice was the natural speaking voice of one of those actors, who was not instructed to mimic ScarJo or given any reference to "Her". † The rest of it is about "safety" whistleblowers. That's something that seems like it could be a real problem for OpenAI, if you believe that transformer models are something that raise genuine safety issues, or if you take seriously OpenAI's founding commitments to be something more like a monastic society than a company. For some time now, I've mentally bucketed OpenAI in with all the other tech companies, and I find that perspective pretty refreshing; there's just not much to think about here, apart from the technology, because, to my eyes, it's not reasonable to expect a lot more of OpenAI than I would from Apple or Google. Is OpenAI becoming less and less like a religion and more like a hyper-rational technology business? To me: that's a good thing. It is fine that we disagree. † I anticipate many responses about the subtle angles of this silly voice actor story that I am not capturing, like Altman's professed love for the movie "Her", and to all that I'll preemptively respond: you do you, we (again) can simply disagree, I would have delighted in a news cycle where a giant tech company actually gets shredded by Rebecca from Ghost World, but I found the WaPo story dispositive.
- minimaxir 2y agoThe issue with the ScarJo case, irrespective of the facts behind the development of OpenAI's voices, is that a) ScarJo's team indicated an intent to sue and b) legal precedent exists that can give the performer ownership if it's uncannily similar. It's not as clear cut as non-lawyer tech people say it is even if it will be an uphill battle for ScarJo, which is what makes it more interesting. She did fight Disney and won, after all.
- tptacek 2y agoAs far as I can tell, all of that precedent involves the "copier" of the voice giving specific instruction to the "mimic", which didn't happen here.
- bdcrazy 2y agoIf the series of events was: They wanted Scar Jo, she said no. They found someone similar. That would be the end of the story. The question then was, why did they reach out to her again immediately before putting it out there? That seems pretty strange to me.
- tptacek 2y agoI don't have more to say here other that I'm aware of the legal precedent being discussed here, read 2 cases, and in both the fact pattern cited in the decision involved specific instruction for the performer to mimic someone else's performance. That's all.
- pseudalopex 2y agoThey made a voice model from Scarlett Johansson recordings and hoped she would change her mind maybe.
- tptacek 2y agoThey did no such thing. The Washington Post found the voice actor they used, it's her natural speaking voice, she was not asked to perform ScarJo, and the movie "Her" wasn't mentioned.
- Anon1096 2y agoNo new information in this article, just spamming all the recent newsworthy events for OpenAI.
- andy_ppp 2y agoI’m not convinced there isn’t a pretty defined ceiling on how clever LLMs can get using current algorithms and hardware.. this isn’t how we think and they all still fall apart on most reasoning tasks. If they haven’t seen lots of examples of something in the training they can’t generalise anything let alone comprehend a book on aerodynamics and design a formula one car. They are more like a parrot than a doctor right now.
- marvinkennis 2y agoA lot of the hype around LLMs and the unfounded promises of them solving complex tasks autonomously seem to stem from a lack of understanding on how these models actually work. The tech is impressive and has its uses, but we shouldn’t pretend like a token predictor can somehow reason and plan.
- smegger001 2y agoSure the current generation, but what happens if we expand its scope, so instead of predicting the next token one at a time, it was allowed greater scope? What happens when you feed it summaries of its work as training data so it has long a short term memory, what happens when you feed several networks together creating a dialogue similar to the theories of a bicameral mind, what if we instead of having the llm halt after every prompt it was put in a loop? Its own output along with outside information used as the prompts for fallowing loop
- textninja 2y agoThey absolutely can reason and plan; how do you suppose they predict the next token? That they’re not autonomously solving complex tasks is a bit of a straw man though, and with a bit of creativity we can easily imagine them being combined with models and modalities that do provide executive function and autonomy.
- marvinkennis 2y agoThis is one of those things I’d love to be wrong on. I think your point on combining them with other models is interesting. Do you think that Markov chains can reason and plan? Dijkstra’s algorithm? Curious where you draw the line
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Some more discussion earlier in the week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40579104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40579104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40576018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40576018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40574355 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40574355 The letter site: https://righttowarn.ai/ https://righttowarn.ai/
- Legend2440 2y agoTheir idea of AI safety is pretty heavy-handed anyway, so I’m glad they’re focusing on it less. LLMs aren’t gonna take over the world, the worst they could do is tell you something you could find with Google. I just want them to make a useful, reliable product and sell it to me for a reasonable price.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Aeroi 2y agoI know Sam Altman is revered as a tech god in this forum and and I will likely get downvoted, but there's something deep within his character that doesn't seem genuine or sit well with me. It's almost a tinge of elizabeth holmes (the aspirational part) and likely stems from his desire from a young age to emulate a bill gates, elon musk, or the cohort of silicon valley VC and founders that came before him. I believe this deeply drives his speech and motivation. He pulls certain levers that he knows will shape his persona and plays the tech visionary role. As an outsider, it seems manufactured and disingenuous.
- textninja 2y ago> Sam Altman is revered as a tech god in this forum I don’t think that’s true. > I will likely get downvoted, but there's something deep within his character that doesn't seem genuine or sit well with me That’s actually an extremely popular opinion; see for example just about every recent article that’s been posted about him.
- andsoitis 2y agoAI safety, like banning AIs from pretending to be humans, require government action, regulations. There is naturally an arms race for AI organizations and companies and open source groups to be “the best”, and it is impractical and naive to expect individual organizations to act in humanity’s best interest.
- whateverevetahw 2y agoMy immediate reaction is that the media just needs something to talk about.