7 ms·
A new world of DIY medical testing
- whoomp12342 2y agothis is all fine and well until greedy people start selling snake oil remedies which will absolutely happen
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://wapo.st/45ebUg3 https://wapo.st/45ebUg3
- PaulKeeble 2y agoA lot of this is Covid Long Haulers who have been dismissed by their doctors as anxiety who are now following the research themselves and pursuing tests and treatments all away from medicine. The medical system is very slow to pick up on new research and Long Covid is so debilitating that people don't have a choice to wait the 20 years it takes it to adopt the research. Its not just happening in the USA its a worldwide phenomena. The more the world and healthcare especially ignores the Long Covid problem the more people will turn to private diagnostics and treatments away from existing healthcare.
- notjoemama 2y agoDo you know if there’s been any advancement on the cause? Last I checked, my cocktail party understanding was it trained immune cells to attack parts of the nervous system. So long Covid was (sometimes) a bit like having transitory multiple sclerosis. I probably misunderstood the explanation. I just hope there ongoing research. I miss physics Girl on YouTube.
- PaulKeeble 2y agoNo treatment or trial has yet been effective enough to suggest it points to the root of a singular disease pathology. There is evidence of viral persistence (even those without Long Covid), auto immune antibodies and dysfunction immune T and B cells and a host of metabolic and cellular adjustments as well as clotting and a host of other issues, its completely systemic and that makes it really hard to pick apart. I don't know if the research will get down to one thing or a multitude of treatments or how quickly its going to be, things are going quite slowly its a very complex disease. Nothing is in development yet directly targeting it due to a lack of accepted biomarker and true understanding. Its not that we don't know a lot we just don't know which bits matter and whether existing treatments work on them. Its pretty concerning, that there is no treatments let alone a cure, because every infection can cause Long Covid. Its about 13% chance every time you catch Covid. There is no lasting immunity to Covid or Long Covid that we know of nor genetic commonality. Current CDC projections suggests everyone will have this disease in their life and recovery is very rare. We are looking at a worldwide disabling event and not a lot of research money to get to the bottom of it from governments nor any social support for the 100s of millions already disabled by it.
- azinman2 2y agoAre there 100s of millions already disabled by it? You hear of it, but I feel like if the disabling was in hundreds of millions it would get more attention than it does.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoCommenting as a placeholder to come back to check for replies later because I'm also curious. And for a bit of comparative context (which I always find helpful), the population of California is about 40 million. So a hundred million is about two and a half Californias.
- pjc50 2y agoOn the other hand, ONS UK estimates about 3% https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/conditionsanddiseases/bulletins/prevalenceofongoingsymptomsfollowingcoronaviruscovid19infectionintheuk/30march2023 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan... , and 3% of eight billion is 240m people. We already know that disability in general tends to be rendered invisible unless it's a really widespread condition, and long covid symptoms are themselves invisible to others.
- avgDev 2y agoI think there has been some research showing long covid often causes dysautonomia, which is dysfunction of autonomic nervous system. This results in many weird symptoms affecting many different bodily functions. This is why many dysautonomia clinics are seeing long covid patients. If long covid patient shows damage to small or large nerve fibers tested by EMG, skin punch and QSART, there is some treatments in the pipeline. WinSanTor is working on a cream which uses pirenzepine. In early studies it reversed nerve damage. It is being tested on diabetic neuropathy. Also, applying dysautonomia life style changes could potentially help people cope right now. I have spoken directly to a chemist who took oral pirenzepine and cured his dysautonomia.
- 0xWTF 2y agoThe problem with lab developed tests (LDTs) is they aren't very regulated, and in a malpractice situation, a physician could be liable if they made diagnosis or treatment decisions based on unverifiable LDTs. It may well be that many LDTs are quite reproducible, but there's now oversight on that at the moment. You could set up a lab in your garage and start billing people out-of-pocket for the results of a Ouija board. If you want some policy opinions from the College of American Pathologists, feel free to lodge them here: https://www.cap.org/advocacy/laboratory-oversight-and-regulation/laboratory-developed-test-oversight https://www.cap.org/advocacy/laboratory-oversight-and-regula...
- murphyslab 2y ago> in a malpractice situation, a physician could be liable if they made diagnosis or treatment decisions based on unverifiable LDTs. That seems to be a senseless concern, since offered the evidence of a lab test, a physician should be prompted to investigate further. No physician (nor individual) should ever be making a diagnosis or treatment decision based on a single line of evidence. More importantly, such results can help offer hard evidence to pressure one's physician to investigate a particular complaint, which can be difficult to convey or to convince the physician it's real. Physicians are often dismissive of things that they do not understand, or of certain classes of patients. Consequently many patients are forced to figure out the source of the problem for themselves. With a lab based test result, you can go to a physician and say, "Hey, this isn't just my imagination nor some kind of over-reaction. It's tangible and externally verifiable." And for those without a GP, waitlisted like myself (5+ years waiting here in Canada!), such tests can help one navigate our piecemeal medical system more effectively.
- giantg2 2y agoExactly, the unofficial test is basically a check engine light that you need to get checked out. The doctor is like a mechanic and should then run additional diagnostics to confirm any issues.
- creer 2y agoOf course, right? And then the article quotes a doctor proud to "put “zero stock” in the tests because she cannot verify their accuracy". I guess she prefers to have her patients go through the massive hassle of finding another physician.
- banish-m4 2y agoA signal of a health system that doesn't meet the needs of the population and is unconcerned with containing absurd profits when the chems are cheap. If a person elects to get more tests than medically necessary, then they should be charged nominal fees. The crux of the problem is whether the latter should be allowed to be less accurate or less precise, and/or calibrated, but then disclosed as such for equal comparison.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- duffpkg 2y agoHealth executive, author of Hacking Healthcare... At the start of the pandemic, the general unavailability of mainstream supply chain covid testing apparatus combined with an absolute torrent of cash, somewhere around 900 billion in total overall, created a cottage industry in covid testing startups. At the time the institutional thinking was that this was "a good thing" because existing infrastructure had a 0% of meeting covid testing demand. The FDA and other regulators more or less abandoned what little oversight of lab developed tests (LDT) there was during this period. They remain lightly regulated. Fast forward to today, a large number of the covid testing startups still exist and are sitting on mountains of cash, having come up in the age of LDTs they are going to continue to min/max that shaky regulatory framework. People in the startup sphere of influence constantly complain about the FDA being too involved in regulation. LDTs will lead to innovations as well as a abuses, I predict many people will complain their regulation is too lax. Such is the way of trying to regulate anything in healthcare.
- 0xWTF 2y ago> many people will complain their regulation is too lax Oh, definitely. No matter how tight or lax the regulation is, people will complain any existing regulations are too lax, and too harsh. The more interesting bit how different populations will respond. The do you own research folks will complain about both sides: both that the regulations are too tight and too loose. "Be better" will be thrown about. Underrepresented minorities will hear all the noise, not hear many people of their own group, and inherently distrust the whole thing. The people who actually own the problem will try to ignore the noise and focus on doing their jobs, keeping their own comments to themselves, thus depriving the conversation of the voices that would be most helpful. The silent majority (or at least largest minority) will quietly make decisions based on un-admitted allegiances and biases.
- RecycledEle 2y agoDIY medical testing is only a part of the DIY testing boom. Just one small example is the amazing array of test strips we have for liquids: Pool test strips, drinking water test strips, urine test strips, blood test strips, drug (urine) test strips, pregnancy (urine) test strips, and much more. Back during the COVID-19 pandemic, I set up 2 air particle checkers that returned the number of particles they found in each of (maybe 8) sizes. I put them in 2 clear tubes, and duct taped a COVID-19 mask between the tubes. A pair of fans moved air over the first checker, then through the mask, then through the second checker. I proved that below 2.5 microns, none of the COVID-19 masks people were wearing at work did anything. That was when I started laughing at the whole thing. This is the kind of tester I used: https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Quality-Detector-Tester-Monitor/dp/B07DL1M46J/ https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Quality-Detector-Tester-Monit... Checking if the testers read the same without a mask was a simple as taping the tubes together without a mask between them. The electronic meters we have today is astounding. Digital meters that do not use test strips can measure dozens of gasses, from any explosive gas to O2, CO2, CO, LP (I know it's not a liquid when it's a gas, but they call it LP) and dozens more such gasses. The MQ series is really cool: https://robocraze.com/blogs/post/mq-series-gas-sensor https://robocraze.com/blogs/post/mq-series-gas-sensor Note: The web links are not things I put up, and I do not make money off them. I only found them through web searches while knowing what subject matter I wanted to find.
- RecycledEle 2y agoA search on Amazon for "blood test" also returns an array of cool results.
- RecycledEle 2y agoI wanted to build a product a few years ago that would hang on the back of an aquarium like a hang-on-back filter, but instead of being a filter it would test dozens of parameters and send the results to a phone app. You could fill up an aquarium, wait a week, then ask your phone what fish would like it. It might tell you to dechlorinate it and start it cycling before asking again. It might know what fish you later put in it, and suggest things that would make the water better suited to those fish. If you need to raise the PH for African Cichlids, it might suggest crushed coral and show a paid advertisement for just such a product.
- teeray 2y ago> But the boom angers some doctors, who argue that circumventing their offices can lead to questionable remedies, misdiagnosis or delayed medical care. Yes, we’ll get you scheduled for that initial consult in a couple weeks, then a few weeks after that we can probably get you a test appointment, then a follow-up consultation a few weeks later. We might have to repeat that cycle a few times to get all the tests. The epitome of speedy treatment (/s)—but only if you’re an existing patient. If you’re a new patient, then bump that up a few months.
- azinman2 2y agoThere aren’t enough doctors or specialists. So what to do? The answer for most shouldn’t be “alternative medicine” where any whacko “treatment” is an appropriate stand in.
- teeray 2y agoBut the answer is also not “the traditional system is perfect, just under-provisioned.” The additional doctors aren’t coming. They’re too expensive to train and they don’t want to be primary care doctors when they can finally practice. We need self-service means to augment the few doctors we have so that the system can continue to function.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoThe primary care doctor role is in the process of being supplanted by nurse practitioners and physician assistants.
- bobmcnamara 2y agoAh yes, the perpetual margin chasing enshitification of healthcare.
- ghaff 2y agoAnd while we're at it, companies should probably only hire PhDs from elite schools as developers because you never know when that sort of (supposed) expertise might be needed.
- Havoc 2y agoAs long as they’re seen as hints that should be subsequently confirmed. I’d say it’s a net positive They can certainly be quite misleading though. Eg food intolerance tests are pretty directly linked to things you ate recently.
- kkfx 2y agoAllow me to rephrase a bit: a new world where Doctors are very scarce and busy, because they work in an assembly lines of meat-based robot force people with some conditions to act autonomously and others to do for curiosity, "wellness" and so on. This is a new market: on one side expensive and assembly-line improperly called medicine just because of legacy and marketing reasons, on the other side the opportunity to allow people badly injuring themselves not knowing biology enough to understand. The sole positive aspect I see is the mere fact that some devices used to be very expensive so only present in some labs, while today almost anyone can own one, allowing for "home testing" of many thing or doctor's cabinet tested without much traveling and bureaucracy. That's good, but can't replace the destruction of Medicine for the sake of commerce.
- rqtwteye 2y agoI am all for it. More stuff in medicine needs to be commoditized and get cheaper. Why pay tons of money to a system that marks up everything by 10x, makes you wait for weeks and months and then you get maybe 5 minutes of attention from the doctor? I want the freedom to make my own decisions based on as much data as I can get. I am sure some people will make bad decisions but that's not worse than the current situation where people do nothing because they can't afford it.
- neongodzilla 2y agoYou want the freedom to make your own uninformed decisions based on data that you don't understand. That's fine. It's when this inevitably leads to uninformed people making bad decisions for others based on easily available that they don't understand -- that is the problem. We've already seen this with shitty Covid tests. We see it all the time when insurance companies use the cheapest routes to "resolve" specific maladies. If something can be exploited, it will be exploited in a capitalist economy. And everyone needs healthcare eventually. This is going to simply accelerate the shit show.
- everforward 2y agoThere is a reasonable argument to be made that it would be cheaper and better to educate the population about some of this rather than enforcing a requirement to go through someone who is frankly far too educated to be doing this variety of thing. There's definitely a line; non-medical professionals probably shouldn't be checking their own X-rays for fractures or CAT scans for cancer. On the other hand, I do very much think people could do things like perform and read their own tests for non-life-threatening infections. Joe Schmoe can swab their own throat, and tell whether there's 1 line or 2. If you want to be super cautious, require a Bluetooth app to read the results and force the user to run through the typical "annoying but not lethal infection" questionnaire doctors give (Is your fever over 102F? Shortness of breath? etc). The app can give warnings that regardless of results, they should seek a doctor. It would also free up doctors and nurses to do something more valuable than administering tests a child could do. Again, this doesn't apply universally, many medical things require far too much knowledge for Joe Schmoe to do, but I do think there are a lot of things that could be the equivalent of a home blood pressure monitor.
- kemmishtree 2y agoWe need to build utility-scale solid-state molecular sensing, it's a threat to civilization not to build it, and only Molecular Reality Corporation is explicitly pursuing it with a specific technical vision.
- OutOfHere 2y agoBe warned that certain doctors, especially endocrinologists, have been losing business, and they will do all they can to disempower people from self-testing and also from effective supplements or other basic self-administered treatments. They will lie, publish hogwash in journals that is not actually backed by data, and they will even believe their lies, all so they can get more steady patients and business.
- beryilma 2y agoAs an extension, I have three good examples of DIY medicine that makes a huge difference. 1. Urinary tract infection testing: 4 tests at home for $10, or same test at the hospital for $300 (nominally as reported to insurance). 2. Night dental guards: $100 for good quality custom mold versus $800 at the dentist. 3. Eyeglasses: $36 at Zenni versus $400 at the eye doctor. I wish there is more of this available... Some kind of home cholesterol test would be awesome.