6 ms·
Waves are just a description of the behavior that’s been observed, right? It is a mathematical model. Physicists cleverly foist the question of what is and why
by bee_rider 2y ago
Waves are just a description of the behavior that’s been observed, right? It is a mathematical model.
Physicists cleverly foist the question of what is and why on philosophers (who are happy to ponder endlessly), it turns out “can we model how it works” is much more profitable to follow.
- Koshkin 2y agoAny physical theory is "just a description of the behavior that’s been observed, right? It is a mathematical model." (Saying that 'cat' is just a word describing what's been observed completely misses the point of what science actually is. Philosophy of thought and science has gone much farther than that.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Aloisius 2y agoIt does seem that many physicists confuse mathematical models with reality or at least do so when communicating to laymen. At the very least, it sells more books.
- whatshisface 2y agoIn the sense that, - You don't know your partner, you know what you remember of what you've understood from what you've seen them say and do. - You don't know the text, you know what was printed. - You don't know which grains of rice you will scoop out from a bag. "Reality" as held above theories (models) and the evidence for and against them is an unreachable standard of truth.
- mistermann 2y agoNon-truth, and the unknown (both realized as such, or not) are also fundamentally important components of aggregate reality. Reality is very complex, but it typically seems very simple.
- Gooblebrai 2y agoIn what way does it seem simple?
- mistermann 2y agoListen to people describe extremely complex social systems and problems (poverty, war, etc) and how to fix them. They appear simple because people are describing their cognitive representation of them (which is derived from simplistic, incorrect representations broadcast on the media), rather than the things themselves. The problem exists at both the individual and the collective level. It's a big problem.
- samatman 2y agoPhysicists are not in the book-selling business to at least three significant figures.
- Aloisius 2y agoI'm unsure what you mean by three significant figures. 99.8%? 1.57% 1,240? Physicists aren't generally in the book selling business, but authors generally want their books to be popular and presenting mathematical abstractions as physical reality certainly seems like it would make it more appealing to the general public (and of course, publishers).
- samatman 2y agoIt was meant to be witty more than informative, but it only has one meaning: to one significant figure would mean no more than 4.9% of physicists sell books. To three, it's 00.049%. I think less than 1 in two thousand physicists being book authors is accurate.
- criddell 2y agoSome, like Max Tegmark in his Mathematical Universe Hypothesis, suggest that mathematics may be all there is.
- mistermann 2y agoPhysicists, like all humans, often confuse their theories and models of reality for reality itself. And when they are called on it, they are far less likely to simply admit the mistake/shortcoming than their stellar reputation would exist. Also, like most (but not all) humans, they tend to not enjoy criticism.
- mannykannot 2y agoMathematical models answer all sorts of 'why' questions: why is the sky blue? why do the planets move the way they do? Why does biological altruism exist in a Darwinian world?
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThey are answering ‘how is the sky blue’ not ‘why’ the universe has a mind (in the form of human) to experience the blueness :)
- mannykannot 2y agoAny toddler can ask "why" ad nauseam (at least it seems that way to adults in the vicinity) - and that is a good thing - but answering is the clever part. Strangely, some philosophers seem to shy away from answering. Philip Goff, for example, whose forays into popularizing include "Galileo's Error", merely declares that consciousness is fundamental, without explaining the second thing about what that means, and he is not, apparently, at all interested in following through; in fact, he seems to think that is a job for scientists - the same scientists who have made the error of adopting mathematical models, apparently - who should gratefully accept his insights and do something (what?) with them. https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/599229/galileos-error-by-philip-goff/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/599229/galileos-err...
- amelius 2y agoEven Feynman didn't like to answer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36GT2zI8lVA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36GT2zI8lVA
- mannykannot 2y agoThere are some apposite comments here: @matthewsawczyn6592:If this man ever talks to toddlers, the conversation will be infinite. @thisismonitor4099: He actually did. He talked to me when I was a toddler at a physics conference in Greece and i remember it well. However, at the time I thought my father (another physicist) was smarter than him:)... Well he asked me if I knew my numbers (I did) and then talked a bit about them, and I told him my father taught me and that he was the smartest man in the world - lol he agreed:) He was a very kind man to children indeed and he certainly had no airs about him given that this guy was a 1 on the Landau scale and that probably no one else at the conference was better than a 3 so he would have been 100 times more influential than anyone else ...
- abdullahkhalids 2y agoFirst, the dominant philosophy of physics/science is that of falsification. Which roughly says that it is impossible to know the "true" laws. All of physics is just models, nothing else, and you can't do better than that. Second, physicists also do not foist this question onto philosophers. There is plenty of work done on this by physicists. Particularly, on the question of whether the wavefunction is simply a calculational tool or more, there are many many papers written by physicists. Two samples [1, 2]. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/nphys3233 https://www.nature.com/articles/nphys3233 [2] https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.1570 https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.1570