6 ms·
I was denied tenure – how do I cope?
- belter 2y agoMove to Spain? Salamanca has lovely weather all year round?
- dr-detroit 2y ago[dead]
- belter 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40554394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40554394
- tgv 2y agoThe first one they ask works in India? Are those situations comparable?
- pjc50 2y agoThe castle drawbridge at the top is apt, because academics are expecting universities to still be working on a feudal/guild model (lifetime loyalty is rewarded, progression from apprentice to master) while universities have moved to the Uber model (short term contracts for interchangeable staff). I don't really know how to advise people other than "please consider working in the private sector, research is an expensive hobby".
- jltsiren 2y agoThis was about a failure mode in the old "guild model". That your career may fail due to guild politics, regardless of performance. If universities truly move to the "Uber model", this particular issue will go away.
- delichon 2y agoIf career is replace by gigs, politics wouldn't go away, it would just shift to affecting your gigs.
- Simon_ORourke 2y agoNot only that, the CS stuff they teach now is woefully behind the times apart from what you get at a few high profile colleges. Kids coming straight out of college CS courses not knowing GitHub for instance. Then again some colleges seem to think training folks for the workforce to somehow demean their efforts.
- masklinn 2y ago> Kids coming straight out of college CS courses not knowing GitHub for instance. That’s… not really surprising? Why would a CS course teach github? Hell I’d be surprised if a CS course taught git, that’s more of a CE subject, and not an amazing one either.
- zarathustreal 2y agoColleges focus on teaching things that require study to learn, things that you won’t really understand without intentionally analyzing them. Algorithms and data structures are great examples. An individual is never going to invent A* on the spot without an education, for example. Learning how to use the tools of the trade, e.g. OS, IDE, version control, etc, is not something you need to spend $50k/yr to have a Ph. D. Teach you, it’s something you pick up on your own. A lot of younger adults these days seem to think that college entitles you to a well-paying job, possibly due to the messaging from previous generation(s), but that is not (and never has been) the case.
- deleted 2y ago
- probably_wrong 2y agoI don't think the market for ecologists in the private sector is super hot right now. But even then, I know plenty of researchers who would rather earn half their salary than dealing with the private sector's BS: bad science practices, endless meetings, "Powerpoint or it didn't happen", zero freedom to experiment, having to constantly "dumb it down" to your manager's manager, draconian publication guidelines, "are you sure we can't patent it?", and the list goes on. Research is only a hobby if you don't care about the impact and quality of your work. I'm sure the scientists who drafted the 1982 Exxon Internal Report on Global Temperatures [1] got paid very well for their report to be buried for 30+ years, but I would rather take a lower salary and make sure the fruits of my work actually get out there. [1] https://xkcd.com/2500/ https://xkcd.com/2500/
- pjc50 2y ago> But even then, I know plenty of researchers who would rather earn half their salary than dealing with the private sector's BS: bad science practices, endless meetings, "Powerpoint or it didn't happen", zero freedom to experiment, having to constantly "dumb it down" to your manager's manager, draconian publication guidelines, "are you sure we can't patent it?", and the list goes on. Sure, but I suspect you could find similar complaints from a lot of academics (UK "REF", for example). The UK situation is pretty dire at the moment and is unlikely to improve without the shock of a respected university simply becoming insolvent.
- foobarian 2y agoI thought that what OP said described academic life pretty accurately as well! Except dealing with grants, PIs, deans, etc.
- xyzzy123 2y ago> I don't think the market for ecologists in the private sector is super hot right now. You might be surprised to know that there's a fairly big environmental consulting sector. It's serious stuff. Multi billion dollar construction projects can be derailed by the discovery of e.g. a particular kind of unique beetle. I don't know what it's like in the US, but I have met some people in the sector in Australia and they do real work, they're ok with it, they do it with integrity - nobody gets asked to "bury" things. Of course, they DO get asked by their customers what the absolutely cheapest possible way to (legally) solve their problems might be :)
- harimau777 2y agoUnfortunately there's lots of types of work that are only available in academics. E.g. functional programming and most CS research.
- dimask 2y agoTo be fair people in the private sector typically make more money at least and have better work-related perks. Academia advertises mostly 1. you research stuff you find interesting and 2. you will get job security some point after a couple of postdocs. Currently neither 1 nor 2 apply for the vast majority of academic work.
- ghaff 2y agoFrom a somewhat outside perspective, I used to think that being a tenured professor at one of a relative handful of top institutions would be a pretty nice gig overall with at least decent pay and benefits. Over time, I came to think I probably wouldn't have liked it a lot even given that very optimistic hypothetical situation.
- throw0101c 2y ago> Academia advertises mostly 1. you research stuff you find interesting and 2. you will get job security some point after a couple of postdocs. Also pensions. Often, if you start early, you can retire with a full pension at 55 or so.
- HenryBemis 2y ago> I had never considered what I would do if this happened. Apologies but I stopped reading after that sentence in the very-very top of the article. What does she mean "I had never considered"? What kind of immature and juvenile mindset is that? You plan for the success, and you also plan for the failure. It's sad that this happened (I take no joy on someone else's pain), and at the same time I am surprised this happened. To the positive outlook, you have built a team and have some equipment? Where/how else can you use that? As I know very little about your space, can you start doing blood-lab-work collaborating with clinics? Can you do a 23-and-me-like service? Can you sell all the hardware, cash-out at a loss, chillax for a few months, re-group and figure out what to do next? Perhaps go work for a big pharma or similar? It's never the end, it's always one hurdle and perhaps a change of direction. Hang in there, all will be well. In 2-3 years you will be looking back at this moment and think "huh.. why was I even worried???" EDIT: I read the full thing halfway through my note, but didn't go back up to change it.. still.. that phrase is a facepalm moment. I propose to many the "The Daily Stoic: 366 Meditations on Wisdom, Perseverance, and the Art of Living". I've gone through it twice, read/think/journal daily. It asks some very good questions, and it would have prepared the author of that post for such outcome.
- KingMob 2y agoI assumed it was just hyperbole meant to indicate they thought they had a strong likelihood of getting tenure.
- reportgunner 2y agoThe article lost my interest when I couldn't find any reason why they were denied tenure.
- gaws 2y ago> I couldn't find any reason why they were denied tenure. The subjects are happy to share their experience of getting denied, but they're probably too embarrassed to share why that happened.
- 2y ago
- low_key 2y agoAs an outsider, the thing I've noticed is that it appears the only way to nearly guarantee tenure is to bring in money. The author mentions applying for grants, but does not mention getting any. Not to say it's fair or anything, but it seems like this is the way it is at least at some institutions.
- neilv 2y agoBonus: If news reports are to be believed, bringing in money makes some university officials look the other way on a lot of misconduct.
- cephaslr 2y agoIts hard to relate to a lifetime employment 'tenure' when us in the private sector have to deal with leet code interviews and other countless indignities in the knife fight employment cycle every 1-3 years for the rest of our careers.. if we are lucky
- firesteelrain 2y agoSkip the LeetCode interviews/stop doing them and eventually they will go away But they will probably come up with something else sadly
- gaws 2y ago> Skip the LeetCode interviews/stop doing them and eventually they will go away That is not an option in this environment; too many companies use that as the gatekeeper. From a company's point of view, if someone refuses to take the test, that's okay because there are hundreds of other applications who will gladly do it.
- firesteelrain 2y agoI have managed to avoid them in my 20 years in industry. I once interviewed and they wanted me to do a take home coding exercise to build a CI/CD system in Python (with a scheduler). No one does that - we use GitLab, Bamboo, Jenkins, etc. Not a LeetCode example but my point is the coding exercises are silly. (Plus Activision was apparently using Perforce at the time and not git)
- gaws 2y ago> I once interviewed for Activision How long ago was that?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 2y ago
- analog31 2y agoThink about the grad students. They're in an even shittier situation. At least the prof gets to keep their PhD and publications. Focus on getting the students transferred into decent situations. Remember to give them glowing recommendations.
- neilv 2y agoThe professors who'd look after students' development and welfare, even after the professor themself got scrod... are the people a university should most want to have as professors.
- Beijinger 2y ago"I was denied tenure – how do I cope?" Easy. Just understand that most things in life resemble "Trip to Jerusalem" game.
- jackspawn 2y ago"denied" tenure is weird phrasing: I assume you don't have the right to tenure, similarly to us not having a right to a promotion or a job. I am for fighting/hustling this if this is doable
- bglazer 2y agoDenied is just the inverse of “granted” which is the standard way to say a tenure application was accepted
- doctorwho42 2y agoIt's the common vernacular in academia and has been for centuries
- bradley13 2y agoSomewhat related: generally, teaching professors are considered "second class citizens" compared to research professors. This person was all about their research and their lab, and getting tenure on that basis. Yet the bread and butter of universities are their undergraduate students, and you don't need a research lab to teach at that level. I would like to see universities prioritize undergraduate teaching. Stop abusing adjuncts and hire professors with a long-term interest in the success of the university's undergraduate programs.
- svara 2y agoThere's a long-standing academic tradition of teaching researchers, and frankly that makes a lot of sense and is a really important part of scientific education. Otherwise scientific education becomes like school teaching, and you end up learning that science is the things that your book says are true. Rather, science is the living of body of knowledge based on experiment and logical thinking. It's a very subtle difference that I don't think can be taught if you're not an active researcher, it's not sufficient to state that in the abstract.
- ghaff 2y ago>Yet the bread and butter of universities are their undergraduate students, I'm not sure that's actually true. It's not financially--at least in the short term. There are more smallish teaching-oriented liberal arts colleges/universities but most of the big engineering/science schools probably regard undergrads as largely necessary annoyances if the powers that be were being honest. For better or worse, the overall trend is for a lot of the smaller liberal arts colleges to be going out of business as home economics/finishing schools really aren't especially useful any longer.
- s_dev 2y ago>big engineering/science schools probably regard undergrads as largely necessary annoyances I recall one definition of a school including elementary right up to University being an institution that passed knowledge from one generation to the next. The suggestion that students are considered an 'annoyance' really is quite galling in itself. It defeats the entire purpose of the institutions and questions why we justify giving them tax money.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoEasy. I didn't even get an academic position. I quit trying in academia and became a wildlife photographer. That's not because making it in academia wasn't theoretically possible, but because sometimes it's just not worth it. If you're smart enough to do research at an academic level, go off the beaten track: start some courses on your subject on Udemy, save up some money while you're still IN academia, and when get out the first chance you get and do something else. Every time you feel like the system burns you to the ground, rise like the phoenix and remake yourself. If something isn't working for you, discard it and push hard to fight against it.
- hiAndrewQuinn 2y agoMy condolences, but it is in fact entirely normal in a modern market economy that you don't get offered a minimum-responsibility cushy sinecure for life. https://www.betonit.ai/p/tenure-is-a-total-scam https://www.betonit.ai/p/tenure-is-a-total-scam
- pech0rin 2y agoGod the entitlement of academia is insane. Living life in an environment where every next step is somehow a given breeds such a strange culture of childishness. Almost spent my whole life in it, so glad I got out. People hate on the private sector but at least it feels connected to reality on a much more basic level.
- gaws 2y agoIf the end goal is a lifetime job with excellent pay and benefits, why not go through the struggle?
- gaws 2y ago> How do I cope? Don't be like Amy Bishop.[1] She was a neurobiologist at the University of Alabama in Huntsville who didn't get tenure and, during the middle of a meeting, pulled out a gun and shot dead several of her colleagues, some of whom were on the committee that denied application. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/02/11/a-loaded-gun https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2013/02/11/a-loaded-gun