3 ms·
This is all post-facto rationalization to avoid a more glaring truth. Women aren’t having kids - because they can avoid having kids. While still having sex and
by lazide 2y ago
This is all post-facto rationalization to avoid a more glaring truth.
Women aren’t having kids - because they can avoid having kids. While still having sex and having societal benefits, including retirement. That is a very, very new and unusual situation when looking at the span of human history.
Birth control is a pretty new invention (mid 60’s approximately), and societies globally have been steadily rolling it out/making it available more easily.
Childbirth is dangerous (especially the first time), usually ruins one’s figure (and hence ‘market value’), and is economically very expensive.
At a minimum 4-6 months of ‘non productive’ work time per pregnancy, not counting the several years of near constant caretaking for a newborn. Which kills normal careers, where taking ‘time off’ pretty much guarantees you’ll be surpassed by all your competition - and 2-2.5 years pretty much guarantees it. And that is for an office job, not labor.
Before birth control, the only way to do that would have required celibacy or constant abortions - and good luck suppressing that drive for most people!
It’s like wondering why almost everyone is fat and out of shape when there is no public transit, everyone has to drive everywhere (and gets stuck in traffic), food is terrible and junky, jobs are mostly sedentary, etc.
Of course that’s how folks will be on average when that’s the environment! And birth rates are by definition based on the average behavior.
Coupled with the fact it’s relatively easy to survive/live in society without kids now, and it’s a double whammy. At least until the consequences of having no kids for a long time come home to roost - then everyone is going to be fucked. Figuratively.
- reducesuffering 2y ago> including retirement I think social safety nets are an under-reported cause of this. 80 years ago, children were your retirement plan. Long term stable value pensions and 401ks, along with government ensured healthcare and social security, weren't a thing. If you got to 70 without kids, you would eventually not be able to work and probably die poor. Now, almost everyone thinks not having kids could be an option, because of course they'll have some savings (the rest of society's labor), and government healthcare, and the government won't let them become destitute.
- lazide 2y agoThe issue of course being that when there is a population crunch, there is no ‘rest of societies labor’ free, like there would be with a normal population age curve. If the crunch is big enough, anyway. Same with the tax base used to fund gov’t healthcare and similar programs. That said, Japan has… problems. But they aren’t apocalyptic. At least not yet.
- tivert 2y ago> The issue of course being that when there is a population crunch, there is no ‘rest of societies labor’ free, like there would be with a normal population age curve. Yeah. For that reason, old age pensions should be tied to how many kids you've had, not how much money you paid into the system during your working years. If you have no kids, you get no pension. If you want to support in old age, you need to contribute to the next generation's labor pool to provide that support. Otherwise, you need to work to support yourself.
- lazide 2y agoHah, and I thought ‘forced natalism’ was the controversial one! Or, the more subtle approach - inflation. Hmm, wait a minute….
- anonporridge 2y agoYep. This is the problem I've been zeroing in on as well. Socialized retirement destroys most of the incentive to sacrifice your youth to grow and raise new people. Why sacrifice your youth and money being a parent when you can leech off the labor of other people's kids in retirement? I think we'll need to eventually experiment with things that try to give some disproportionate benefit to people who have kids. e.g. everyone gets some minimal socialized retirement and healthcare, but your benefits increase above that baseline in proportion to how many children you raised. Maybe your benefits increase at 3+ kids and decrease with 0-1 kids.
- lazide 2y ago
- cue_the_strings 2y agoWe're in a situation where even discussing or proposing any realistic solution to this is considered too radical (how dare you propose controlling other peoples' lives). Yet societies will collapse because of it, or come close to collapse. The only "allowed" solution is importing people from poor countries into richer ones, but disguised as something humanitarian, taking in refugees of war or whatnot.
- dalyons 2y agoIf your realistic solution is some form of forced natalism, then yeah, we shouldn’t be talking about that. It’s ethically wrong and unpalatable to the vast majority of people in developed societies, it’s not a thing that we should be entertaining.
- lazide 2y agoOne way or another, most likely ideological, things will change. Probably in the ‘over correct once it’s too late, in some terribly traumatic fashion’ as is the norm. Eventually, likely in the direction of gun control - birth control being licensed or the like. Or being religious being a requirement again to be a ‘respected member of society’. Unlikely to be popular of course, but eventually society will change to protect its interests - or die.
- cue_the_strings 2y agoExactly. Either you opt for a timely, balanced, thought-out solution, or you have the traumatic over-correction forced upon you. I wish we could have real conversations about how to solve this issue, and not bury our heads in the sand. I'm not proposing any particular solution, just for our collective attention to the problem and liberty to discuss solutions.
- lazide 2y agoI also like unicorns, rainbows, and free money. :(
- jiggawatts 2y agoYou're looking at the trees but missing the forest. Birth control is available in countries where women are having over 5 kids on average each despite that. Similarly, legalisation or the illegality of abortion has no significant effect on child birth rates. Availability of birth control (or abortion) alone doesn't explain the "big picture", it just alters it a little bit. These are Catholic and conservative talking points, not scientific theories with evidence, charts, graphs, and equations. Similarly, childbirth has always been dangerous, but is less dangerous now, so that has no explanatory power either. Etc... You're also confusing something else: Women's careers being interrupted by childbirth is the much closer to the truth. Women didn't work previously on anything but raising a family! In the economy/stress phase diagram, this is a different place, where a single income is no longer sufficient. THAT is the problem. If women are forced to enter the general workforce, then that alters the game-theoretic optimum for family planning. Similarly, the mere existence of a social safety net such as a government pension substantially alters the equation. Individual families are no longer incentivised to "invest" in their future by having kids themselves, because they expect "society to take care of it" with unemployment benefits and retirement funds. In the past, people had individual incentives to have kids, because that was their retirement plan.
- lazide 2y agoNot confused at all - both have to work because both can work. Supply increases, so ‘price’ decreases per person. Forest wise. Previously, women (unless celibate or okay having abortions a lot) had no choice but to spend time at home, which forced the market in that direction. And I’m also not confused about birth control availability. You’re confusing ‘theoretically available’ vs ‘socially acceptable available’, which those societies haven’t hit yet. Ideologically, they’re very resistant - but changing. Just like the changes in the US (starting to be possible in the 60’s) didn’t become the norm until the 80’s to 90’s or later. American Catholics have been okay with birth control since then (roughly), where South American Catholics are still against it. Which, notably, is when the US started to become more heavily two-income household dependent. And when wages stopped keeping up with growth. Without birth control being possible, none of it matters - which is why it being possible is actually important. And why we’ve been seeing steady change in societies since it has become possible.