4 ms·

Sorry, they just aren't. There are numerous breakdowns going into great detail why the plot is nonsensical and silly. This isn't even addressing the acting, whi

Sorry, they just aren't. There are numerous breakdowns going into great detail why the plot is nonsensical and silly. This isn't even addressing the acting, which at times is so horrible it's laugh out loud funny (reportedly lucas only allowed actors to do single takes, although I'm not sure if that's ever been confirmed). From a cinematography standpoint, it's also kind of a mess, especially when you break down the absurd amount of shit he crams into nearly every single shot of the film. The only reason they have appeared to have aged well is because they filled in a lot of the silliness and nonsense with quality content from other sources such as clone wars (which ended up being good) and comics, etc. to fill in the gaps. It also helps them age a lot when you compare them to the latest trilogy, which I'm sure I don't even need to elaborate why that is. For the record I still occasionally watch the prequels now, but when they came out, they were very poorly received and for good reason.

dasil003 2y ago
A few generations have grown up with them now, which greatly elevates their status. It's not that unlike the original trilogy in that way. I can think of any number of films that I liked as a child, some hold up better than others, but even the ones that don't, the early impression creates a lasting fondness that is stronger than many of the flaws which more mature first-time viewers might not be able to look past.
WJW 2y ago
I think quite a lot comes from teenage nostalgia from whichever era you are from. The original trilogy is not actually all that good, but some people still talk about it as if those movies are the epitome of moviemaking. I think it has a lot to do with the circumstances that people first saw them in. The prequels are also not fantastic movies, but as the people who saw them in cinemas as children grew up they came to be loved more and more. It's not so much the movies themselves that are liked, but the associated memories. I wonder if in ~10 years we'll have a new batch of people who like the latest trilogy. First ironically as they get through their edgy teenage phase, then unironically as they grow up further and point out some great scenes from between the (admittedly many) terrible ones.
- aredox 2y ago
  The very first Star Wars ("A new hope") is fairly basic in plot, but with very good moments and no mistake. The next two, especially the empire strikes back, are really good in their own right in terms of film-making artistry. They have the right tone, rhythm, imagery, scenography. The rest, though, is catastrophically bad.
  - sien 2y ago
    Rogue One is good. Interesting it doesn't fit into any trilogy.
    - billyjmc 2y ago
      The best theatrical release since the original trilogy, IMO. I think part of it is because of how much gravity it imparts to the beginning of Episode IV. (And the other part is how objectively bad the prequel and sequel trilogies were.)
    - aredox 2y ago
      Ho, yes, forgot about it! Excellent visuals save some plot gaps. Andor is also very, very good.
    - glitchc 2y ago
      I honestly got bored with Rogue One. All standard plot points, nothing new, plus you know how it ends. I fell asleep midway through. Once you know the ending, the plot needs to have some twists and turns to stay relevant and interesting. One rogue scientist having the detailed design for the entire Death Star is a ludicrous premise. That thing's as big as a planet. Heck, no single scientist could tell you the detailed architecture for CERN or even the ISS for that matter, and those are significantly smaller in scale.
- bitnasty 2y ago
  Then there should be many millennials who love the prequels but sadly I know of zero.
glitchc 2y ago
I seem to have that reaction watching the originals. It's like watching a mix between a western and a soap opera, but set in space. Maybe it's because I watched the prequels first, then the originals. At least we both agree that the Clone Wars (and associated material) is good.
- marcosdumay 2y ago
  Oh, all of the stuff on the franchise that is actually that good are series.

dasil003 2y ago

A few generations have grown up with them now, which greatly elevates their status. It's not that unlike the original trilogy in that way. I can think of any number of films that I liked as a child, some hold up better than others, but even the ones that don't, the early impression creates a lasting fondness that is stronger than many of the flaws which more mature first-time viewers might not be able to look past.

WJW 2y ago

I think quite a lot comes from teenage nostalgia from whichever era you are from. The original trilogy is not actually all that good, but some people still talk about it as if those movies are the epitome of moviemaking. I think it has a lot to do with the circumstances that people first saw them in. The prequels are also not fantastic movies, but as the people who saw them in cinemas as children grew up they came to be loved more and more. It's not so much the movies themselves that are liked, but the associated memories. I wonder if in ~10 years we'll have a new batch of people who like the latest trilogy. First ironically as they get through their edgy teenage phase, then unironically as they grow up further and point out some great scenes from between the (admittedly many) terrible ones.

aredox 2y ago
The very first Star Wars ("A new hope") is fairly basic in plot, but with very good moments and no mistake. The next two, especially the empire strikes back, are really good in their own right in terms of film-making artistry. They have the right tone, rhythm, imagery, scenography. The rest, though, is catastrophically bad.
- sien 2y ago
  Rogue One is good. Interesting it doesn't fit into any trilogy.
  - billyjmc 2y ago
    The best theatrical release since the original trilogy, IMO. I think part of it is because of how much gravity it imparts to the beginning of Episode IV. (And the other part is how objectively bad the prequel and sequel trilogies were.)
  - aredox 2y ago
    Ho, yes, forgot about it! Excellent visuals save some plot gaps. Andor is also very, very good.
  - glitchc 2y ago
    I honestly got bored with Rogue One. All standard plot points, nothing new, plus you know how it ends. I fell asleep midway through. Once you know the ending, the plot needs to have some twists and turns to stay relevant and interesting. One rogue scientist having the detailed design for the entire Death Star is a ludicrous premise. That thing's as big as a planet. Heck, no single scientist could tell you the detailed architecture for CERN or even the ISS for that matter, and those are significantly smaller in scale.
bitnasty 2y ago
Then there should be many millennials who love the prequels but sadly I know of zero.

glitchc 2y ago

I seem to have that reaction watching the originals. It's like watching a mix between a western and a soap opera, but set in space. Maybe it's because I watched the prequels first, then the originals. At least we both agree that the Clone Wars (and associated material) is good.

marcosdumay 2y ago
Oh, all of the stuff on the franchise that is actually that good are series.